Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To see a psychic

167 replies

TwentysixV · 23/01/2023 23:18

I’ve never believed in anything supernatural, am a scientist. I recently read a book where the main character went to see a psychic and it got me thinking. I read some reviews of a local one online and most of them were positive saying she was extremely accurate, mentioning specific names etc. she charges £40 which I can easily afford. I want to go partly out of curiosity and partly because I’ve been single all my life and want some reassurance that everything will be ok/I’ll meet someone in the future.
interested to know if anyone has any experience with going to see a psychic and if they were accurate or a total waste of time. And also what “reading” am I after-is it tarot cards or is there another name for where they basically tell you about your situation and what they think the future has in store for you.
I’m not that interested in replies saying it’s all a load of rubbish from people who have never been to a psychic though!
any insight would be interesting

OP posts:
EmmaEmerald · 24/01/2023 18:54

Loq · 24/01/2023 18:43

I was at a country fair with my mum at the age of 14. We went and had a reading as a bit of a laugh. As we left her room, my mum stepped outside first. She discreetly held me back a second and whispered “stop seeing the man”. I just froze! She then said, “find a boy your own age”.
I had got in to a weird secret relationship with a 21 yro, that my mum knew nothing about. It freaked me out so much, I completely ghosted the man and never saw him again.

Was this in yours or his local area?

Snapdragon123 · 24/01/2023 18:52

@ReneBumsWombats

Thanks I will definitely read his books.

@EmmaEmerald i am pleased that your experience was positive and didn’t have a negative impact.

Unfortunately my experience influenced a negative impact.

EmmaEmerald · 24/01/2023 18:52

Rene "although I'd like to know what a professional stage magician noticed that you didn't."

sorry, not sure what you mean by that?

It happened because I was in a part of the US where walk-in psychics just seemed to be everywhere, so I thought I'd go. I did have some leftover dollars...in days of yore, it was the amount you wouldn't spend (and I didn't know I'd go back so often).

I suppose because that was my first experience, that may be why I am so puzzled when I hear about cold readings etc. she was more like "siddown, shaddup, Imma tell you stuff, you gonna listen".

ReneBumsWombats · 24/01/2023 18:45

EmmaEmerald · 24/01/2023 18:41

Rene Maybe my experience was very different. I was commanded to keep quiet while she told me my future and "maybe there'll be time for questions at the end". I think of her fondly though I reckon she's probably dead by now.

I cannot tell you exactly what happened at your experience, although I'd like to know what a professional stage magician noticed that you didn't. But if she was legitimate, she would have been the only person ever to have been able to replicate it under lab conditions...and I have to wonder why she wasn't working on a murder investigation squad, etc etc.

I also think that if you saw the late Paul Daniels and he successfully guessed your card without any apparent way of knowing, you'd be impressed...but you wouldn't think it was actually magic.

BloodAndFire · 24/01/2023 18:43

EmmaEmerald · 24/01/2023 18:41

Rene Maybe my experience was very different. I was commanded to keep quiet while she told me my future and "maybe there'll be time for questions at the end". I think of her fondly though I reckon she's probably dead by now.

Anyone who goes to see a 'psychic' is already by definition open to believing them. 'Sceptics' don't waste their time and/or money propping up the delusions and/or con tricks of professional scammers.

Loq · 24/01/2023 18:43

I was at a country fair with my mum at the age of 14. We went and had a reading as a bit of a laugh. As we left her room, my mum stepped outside first. She discreetly held me back a second and whispered “stop seeing the man”. I just froze! She then said, “find a boy your own age”.
I had got in to a weird secret relationship with a 21 yro, that my mum knew nothing about. It freaked me out so much, I completely ghosted the man and never saw him again.

EmmaEmerald · 24/01/2023 18:43

PS sorry, I should be clear

I'd take a recommendation, but not get into a "Dave at 2 is going to book an appointment" scenario.

EmmaEmerald · 24/01/2023 18:41

Rene Maybe my experience was very different. I was commanded to keep quiet while she told me my future and "maybe there'll be time for questions at the end". I think of her fondly though I reckon she's probably dead by now.

ReneBumsWombats · 24/01/2023 18:37

EmmaEmerald · 24/01/2023 18:34

This made me lol because I'm pretty humourless.

so you're talking about pulling in audiences for shows? Never seen one.

I thought there'd always be obvious rules for people visiting psychics

  • don't pay in advance
  • don't tell them your real name
  • don't go via anyone who knows you
  • don't go local (if possible).

If you're going to see a psychic, then in all likelihood, whatever you tell yourself, you're hoping for a hit and you'll be primed for it. Everyone says they give nothing away and they were totally poker faced the whole time. But most people who want a good result will take a recommendation, and I hear you often have to wait a while for the good ones...

It's just stage magic. Although weirdly, we always accept there's a rational explanation behind sawing a woman in half.

EmmaEmerald · 24/01/2023 18:34

ReneBumsWombats · 24/01/2023 18:30

They can gather it from people who know the mark (existing customers who recommended them and have already let stuff slip), they can check public records and do research from those, they can send spies to talk to people beforehand, they've been known to look up local news stories in certain areas and call people in with free tickets for a guaranteed hit.

But most of all, they can know how a good cold reading works and take cues from the mark to make it sound even more specific and personalised, brushing over what they got wrong and playing up what they got right. I'm not saying they aren't talented. The psychology is real. There are also a few known stats to go with. A woman in her 40s or younger is most likely to be looking for the spirit of her father, for example.

Much of it works on people truly not realising how universal and common certain experiences and feelings are. According to some research, 80% of people think they have an "above average sense of humour". Apart from that obviously not being possible, how do you gauge the level of someone's sense of humour?

This made me lol because I'm pretty humourless.

so you're talking about pulling in audiences for shows? Never seen one.

I thought there'd always be obvious rules for people visiting psychics

  • don't pay in advance
  • don't tell them your real name
  • don't go via anyone who knows you
  • don't go local (if possible).
ReneBumsWombats · 24/01/2023 18:33

Snapdragon123 · 24/01/2023 18:25

@ReneBumsWombats

I had been reading them many years ago before the internet and I believed everything I saw. However with the discovery of the internet. It has been proven to be not as it seems.

Please enlighten me regarding Derren Brown?

It would take far too long to type it out here, but if you read Tricks of the Mind, there's a lot in there. Including a full cold reading that creeped out many people in different countries for its eerie accuracy. (He got it translated into Spanish for a Spanish audience and the translator thought he was playing a joke on her because it read as of it were for her. One person withdrew from the event because she found the reading too personal.) It described me too.

EmmaEmerald · 24/01/2023 18:31

donttellmehesalive · 24/01/2023 18:22

"The thing is, OP explicitly didn't want to hear those opinions. That's why it's arrogant. It's like being an atheist who has to bang on about it regardless of the fact no-one else cares."

What would you say to someone who had received a convincing email from a Sudanese prince and was about to transfer £5000 so that he could release funds and send her a million pounds? Would you respectfully back off if she said 'I'd like opinions on this but not criticism I don't want any negativity?'

But OP has said she doesn't mind spending out of curiosity.

I see it as like canvassing opinion on whether it's worth forking out to see a particular show.

ReneBumsWombats · 24/01/2023 18:30

EmmaEmerald · 24/01/2023 18:20

What other ways do you think they get info?

They can gather it from people who know the mark (existing customers who recommended them and have already let stuff slip), they can check public records and do research from those, they can send spies to talk to people beforehand, they've been known to look up local news stories in certain areas and call people in with free tickets for a guaranteed hit.

But most of all, they can know how a good cold reading works and take cues from the mark to make it sound even more specific and personalised, brushing over what they got wrong and playing up what they got right. I'm not saying they aren't talented. The psychology is real. There are also a few known stats to go with. A woman in her 40s or younger is most likely to be looking for the spirit of her father, for example.

Much of it works on people truly not realising how universal and common certain experiences and feelings are. According to some research, 80% of people think they have an "above average sense of humour". Apart from that obviously not being possible, how do you gauge the level of someone's sense of humour?

donttellmehesalive · 24/01/2023 18:30

Plenty of ex psychics online revealing how they do it.

Seem to remember a really interesting study by Liverpool University, or Liverpool John Moored maybe, that introduced a group of sceptics to a talented psychic. After the performance, they were no longer sceptics. Their belief in psychic ability increased by something like 40%. Then he showed them how he did it.

Snapdragon123 · 24/01/2023 18:25

@ReneBumsWombats

I had been reading them many years ago before the internet and I believed everything I saw. However with the discovery of the internet. It has been proven to be not as it seems.

Please enlighten me regarding Derren Brown?

donttellmehesalive · 24/01/2023 18:22

"The thing is, OP explicitly didn't want to hear those opinions. That's why it's arrogant. It's like being an atheist who has to bang on about it regardless of the fact no-one else cares."

What would you say to someone who had received a convincing email from a Sudanese prince and was about to transfer £5000 so that he could release funds and send her a million pounds? Would you respectfully back off if she said 'I'd like opinions on this but not criticism I don't want any negativity?'

EmmaEmerald · 24/01/2023 18:20

ReneBumsWombats · 24/01/2023 18:06

This shit long predates social media and there's all manner of ways they can get personal info.

If they can talk to the dead, they should be on murder investigation squads.

What other ways do you think they get info?

donttellmehesalive · 24/01/2023 18:19

AFAIK the million dollars offered to any genuine psychic in the 1960s by the James Randi Foundation is still safe. Anyone who you find convincing should be directed that way.

ReneBumsWombats · 24/01/2023 18:18

Snapdragon123 · 24/01/2023 18:11

@ReneBumsWombats

have you been reading the Doris Stokes books?

No, but I've read some Derren Brown ones and others.

Should I?

donttellmehesalive · 24/01/2023 18:17

WeeOrcadian · 24/01/2023 17:02

Go, but wear a wedding / engagement ring (or one that could pass) and see what she says.

But you have to come back and update us.

This made me laugh. I saw a psychic about five years ago and gave a fake name - well, the name of another friend who couldn't go. He gave me a load of accurate information about 'my' life that had presumably been lifted directly from the Internet.

Another friend on that same visit was told 'when you meet a man whose name begins with k you must trust him with all your heart.' For ages she prioritised dating men whose names started with k. Positively dangerous to give someone information like that.

PP ask why some people feel the need to mock it all. It's because it's obviously, demonstrably untrue whilst preying on vulnerable and gullible people. I'm not sure if it's theft exactly, but a scam that sucks people in and takes their money.

Snapdragon123 · 24/01/2023 18:11

@ReneBumsWombats

have you been reading the Doris Stokes books?

BloodAndFire · 24/01/2023 18:10

@Allthegoodnamesarechosen there is one person who has mentioned 'sky fairies' on this thread. You.

Oh, now there's two. Me also.

And no, it's not 'fear of the unknown'. Alison from Bromley telling me my son will one day own a pair of black shoes and that a kettle will feature in my future isn't a terrifying prospect.

BloodAndFire · 24/01/2023 18:07

Shame that the tall glass building amazing magic foresight lady didn't bother to warn any of the several thousand people who went to work in the World Trade Center on 11 September 2001.

Or any of those who took the tube to work on 7 July 2005.

Or any of the women murdered and abducted by strangers on their way home.

You'd think you'd want to use that sort of amazing special magic gift to make the world a better place, rather than scamming credulous/desperate people out of a few quid.

ReneBumsWombats · 24/01/2023 18:06

This shit long predates social media and there's all manner of ways they can get personal info.

If they can talk to the dead, they should be on murder investigation squads.

ThreeLittleDots · 24/01/2023 18:01

But I’ve been to two that spoke specifically about someone who had died, with names, dates and details that they could not have known. This was pre social media and they only had my first name

I think your friend would have told the psychic this info. Or they knew of you some other way.