Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Copywriters, content writers, journalists etc, do you worry about Chat GPT?

40 replies

WeAreAllLionesses · 23/01/2023 23:12

If you write for a living or are freelance, are you concerned about your potential loss of income?

I am a freelance copywriter and wonder how much we will be affected.

YABU - nothing can replace writing by a proper human being
YABU - not long until the robots take over...

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WeAreAllLionesses · 15/02/2023 22:37

@ScienceDragon how much, would you say, you use the original AI content in your submission to clients?

OP posts:
ScienceDragon · 14/02/2023 11:32

I use a (paid for) AI program as a tool in producing information for my clients, and also to provide outlines for my blog. Basically, it saves time for me in generating rough drafts, but I still need to rewrite to put the words into my "voice". I also need to do the underlying research to evidence what I am saying. There are issues with critical reasoning, and it is very poor with creative reasoning. An AI would struggle to produce, for example, a quality scientific report, without being spoonfed every step of the way.

These AIs are trained on existing internet content. They aren't trained on (for example) all the course content and additional reading required to earn a degree in any discipline. They lack the capacity to differentiate between fact and theory/opinion (they can define the difference if asked, but not demonstrate it in practice). They are simply a tool, and like any tool the final quality of their output will depend on the person wielding the tool.

To summarise, it halves the time I put into producing content (which makes paying for it, worth it), but couldn't possibly replace me, in terms of my knowledge and experience.

krustykittens · 24/01/2023 16:52

FuckabethFuckor · 24/01/2023 15:53

For anyone interested, Nick Cave has some interesting thoughts about AI for songwriting (and creativity more broadly).

www.theredhandfiles.com/chat-gpt-what-do-you-think/

Worth a read.

I agree with him. Replication does not mean good art. I remember, years ago, when CGI first came out and people talked about being able to recreate performances from dead actors and programme them with new lines. But it hasn't been done because I think it would leave an audience cold. Or perhaps their estates have blocked it? But I want to watch, gaze upon, read and listen to art produced by human beings who have something to say. AI has nothing to say that has not already been said.

EffortlessDesmond · 24/01/2023 16:32

I was a copywriter back in the day, and I don't think it would have had much impact on my work (mostly annual reports and financial statements) because by definition my output was based on personal one-to-one interviews that were confidential until publication. But for standard consumer stuff...

FuckabethFuckor · 24/01/2023 15:53

For anyone interested, Nick Cave has some interesting thoughts about AI for songwriting (and creativity more broadly).

www.theredhandfiles.com/chat-gpt-what-do-you-think/

Worth a read.

YukoandHiro · 24/01/2023 12:45

I'd be a convert if so...

YukoandHiro · 24/01/2023 12:45

@pinkfluffycushion could it pitch for me? 🤣

pinkfluffycushion · 24/01/2023 12:44

@YukoandHiro

Hey journalist I pulled out the info into an email, tweaked the bits I needed to, added in a direct quote and sent it to my press contacts. Yes I did get responses from it and I'd do it again.

Ideally yes I'd be able to pay someone to do every task I need doing but as a small business, I simply can't! Don't hate on the AI - I'm sure it can help you in some way too!

YukoandHiro · 24/01/2023 12:06

@pinkfluffycushion Did that press release get any bites? Or did you generate it to hit your own random KPIs?

Journalist here. Can't remember the last time I used a press release. Would be years ago. Pay someone to pitch directly by email to the right journalist. Don't waste budget generating shite that gets you no visibility.

Jimboscott0115 · 24/01/2023 11:27

NextPrimeMinister · 23/01/2023 23:44

I don't think it's all or nothing.

There's a place for both.

Bottom feeder blogs written for £10 a pop are likely to be hit hardest.

Exactly this, clickbait articles and the like are going to be worst hit. While these do clearly employ people to write them, it's had it's time and offers little value so hard to argue with this type of role being replaced.

EmmaEmerald · 24/01/2023 11:02

I saw an early version of similar software, years ago. At the time, I didn't think much of it...now, about 7 years on, I think - it's a problem. Someone mentioned it being unable to cross-reference law - I thought that was on the test it just passed?

I am so glad I'm reaching the end of my career. There's no end point in terms of what tech will destroy - or "people using tech" if you prefer.

FuckabethFuckor · 24/01/2023 10:36

kegofcoffee · 24/01/2023 10:20

The v2 Beta about to become $45 a month, but is going to have significantly more data points. When it's fully released the cost is likely to increase, which will make it not worth it for some companies.

Either way, it'll hugely impact industry. The people writing £10-20 articles through Fivver & PPH will loose the most business. They'll be replaced by people selling ChatGPT generated articles for £2-3.

I suspect the copyrighters that work with large companies charging higher fees will be expect to reduce their prices to compete with ChatGPT. The work will still be their, but unfortunately valued less.

Any copywriter will common sense will accept the reduced prices and then try to increase their turn over by using CharGPT to create first drafts that they can edit from.

I suspect the copyrighters that work with large companies charging higher fees will be expect to reduce their prices to compete with ChatGPT. The work will still be their, but unfortunately valued less.

I'm not sure about that. A few years ago, the marketing copywriting market suddenly became awash with journalists, because the press had let a lot of people go. The journos were willing to write for £150 a day, because that was the going rate in the press industry, whereas copywriters in the marketing sector usually charge double that or more.

At the time, some people were saying that the copywriters would have to reduce their fees because the £150/day journos would drop the bottom out of the market.

It hasn't really happened; mainly because journalists and copywriters still do different things, even within the marketing and advertising sector. But also because the ad industry is used to paying £400 a day for a good copywriter, so the journalists who were any good tended to get that day rate without anyone blinking.

I do think AI will scalp some work but it won't be the creative work.

krustykittens · 24/01/2023 10:35

thebellagio · 24/01/2023 10:13

It will be jumped on by people who don't value content anyway.

Sadly, that is a pretty big market.

kegofcoffee · 24/01/2023 10:35

I should add, I work in Conversational AI.

I think the people saying it lacks warmth, compassion, personality, and a 'human touch'. Haven't played about enough with it yet.

It's only as good as the request you put in. Ask for 'a blog post about top breads of dogs' and you'll get a very different output from if you asked for 'a blog post about top dog breads of 2023, for a website that's aimed at retired women living in Scotland. Written in the style of friends talking to each other.'

It's also going from 175billion data points to 100 trillion. So that'll make a huge difference.

krustykittens · 24/01/2023 10:31

BigCheeseSandwich · 24/01/2023 09:10

I’m in a FB page for romance novelists and there was a thread on this last week. One author is already self publishing using AI, she says she is producing a book every week. I bet it’s bland as fuck but a lot of self published romance is quite samey yet sells so maybe it works for her.

Do you think readers will spot the difference and be turned off by it? I always thought romance writing was actually very hard. The audience is meant to be quite demanding in what it wants?

WeAreAllLionesses · 24/01/2023 10:26

I'd rather not do it than charge less. And I'm not a Fiverr rates of pay person either.

Someone was saying to me last week they think it's artists that will really suffer, they'd produced visuals using one of the art related AI programmes and said it was really good.

OP posts:
kegofcoffee · 24/01/2023 10:20

The v2 Beta about to become $45 a month, but is going to have significantly more data points. When it's fully released the cost is likely to increase, which will make it not worth it for some companies.

Either way, it'll hugely impact industry. The people writing £10-20 articles through Fivver & PPH will loose the most business. They'll be replaced by people selling ChatGPT generated articles for £2-3.

I suspect the copyrighters that work with large companies charging higher fees will be expect to reduce their prices to compete with ChatGPT. The work will still be their, but unfortunately valued less.

Any copywriter will common sense will accept the reduced prices and then try to increase their turn over by using CharGPT to create first drafts that they can edit from.

TrickorTreacle · 24/01/2023 10:19

AI art is more of a threat imo e.g. Stable Diffusion and Dream.ai

thebellagio · 24/01/2023 10:13

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 24/01/2023 10:10

I'm a writer. My boss, a scientist, was banging on about the glories of ChatGTP yesterday n a meeting. I didn't say anything.

It will be jumped on by people who don't value content anyway.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 24/01/2023 10:10

I'm a writer. My boss, a scientist, was banging on about the glories of ChatGTP yesterday n a meeting. I didn't say anything.

thebellagio · 24/01/2023 10:03

@FuckabethFuckor I agree. I also think these days, people want to see warmth and compassion within content and an AI generator can't do that.

I think good copywriters shouldn't be worried. As a PP said, it's the copywriters who claim to offer a researched/written, and SEO-optimized blog for £10 that should worry.

My clients don't just pay me to write for them. They pay me to come up with the ideas, to find new ways of matching business priorities with customer service, to help them raise their profile and increase their reputation. They want me to update their websites for them so they can concentrate on their daily tasks. I personally think being a copywriter is about so much more than just writing.

FuckabethFuckor · 24/01/2023 09:46

Copywriter here (some of the time).

You know the old saw about how work can be good, quick, or cheap, but you can only pick two? AI is the definition of that in copywriting terms. It can do quick and cheap. It can't (in my view) do good. Yet.

All the AI-generated copy I've seen has been very... ploddy. It's grammatically correct, appropriately spelled and makes sense. But AI only seems to have one rhythm. It's dull to read. It can't seem to do wit, playfulness or that wilful bending of linguistic rules to create earworm wording.

Nevertheless, I've been slowly losing a segment of work to AI for about four years now. The sort of work I've been losing has tended to be the copy editing work — smoothing out Ts&Cs, policy wording, that kind of thing. Or writing functional stuff like nav for apps and websites, customer service comms and staff handbooks. Half-spammy social media posts that are more SEO and hashtags than meaningful content.

For some clients, who don't care if their site's modern slavery statement is crafted to within a gnat's fart of Hemingway, AI can do a 75% good enough job in a few seconds. Quick and cheap.

Overall, though, I'm not worried; more wary.

What AI can't do (for now, anyway) is pair up with an art director to toss around ideas for a campaign. It can't do jokes, plays-on-words or duality.

When AI writes the next VW 'Lemon' ad, I'll worry. Until then, nah.

thebellagio · 24/01/2023 09:13

I'm not worried. I think that it should be used as a tool to assist, rather than replace. A bit like spellcheck/Grammarly.

I've used a few AI tools when I've got a bit of writers block and it can help with inspiration. But ultimately, a robot can't write like a human for a human. I personally think Google may penalise sites that are overly AI-content, especially with the new helpful content guidance.

My view is that people buy people. Therefore, you want to read and consume content that is written by someone you can relate to. A lot of my clients are in the financial services sector which is heavily regulated in terms of what you can/can't say. An AI generator wouldn't be able to correlate with rules/legislation so there will always be a need for human content writers.

BigCheeseSandwich · 24/01/2023 09:10

I’m in a FB page for romance novelists and there was a thread on this last week. One author is already self publishing using AI, she says she is producing a book every week. I bet it’s bland as fuck but a lot of self published romance is quite samey yet sells so maybe it works for her.

housemaus · 24/01/2023 09:01

Not overly worried for my day job (journalism).

But I do a lot of (too!) cheap low end copy freelance and I assume that'll disappear. It's not that I think that the stuff AI produces is better - more that it's not so significantly worse as to make the comparative cost of a human worth it for what amounts to website filler for SEO purposes.