Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want other people using our caravan?

333 replies

Serialcatmum · 23/01/2023 22:19

Ok, by other people I mean my sister in law.

We recently purchased a caravan, we were going to go for a smaller one but decided to treat ourselves to a bigger one to give us more space. When I told SIL she said “oh I had my fingers crossed you’d go for the bigger one as then we can maybe use it some weekends too?!” It was sort of a question, sort of a statement. I laughed and said “oh we’ve not even planned our first trip yet”. She just said “ha ha. I don’t mean next weekend, I mean in the summer”. I laughed and changed the topic.

Since then DBIL has messaged my DH saying that SIL mentioned we might we able to borrow the caravan sometime.. (DH didn’t reply)

They don’t even have a towing vehicle. So are they planning on taking our car too?! Or are we expected to drive to their holiday place of choice and set up / collect for them?!

ANBH - they should get their own caravan and stop being cheeky fs.

ABU- they are family, of course you should let them take your caravan (and car) for a jolly.

OP posts:
Calphurnia88 · 24/01/2023 10:36

YANBU at all.

It's entirely up to you if you want to let family members make use of the caravan you have paid for, and there are a lot of very valid reasons why you might not.

It's incredibly cheeky of SIL to assume.

bellswithwhistles · 24/01/2023 10:35

I can't believe anyone would just assume that! You wouldn't assume if someone got a new car you could just hop in it and drive off whenever you fancy!

A firm NO before this all gets out of hand!

ItsNotReallyChaos · 24/01/2023 10:32

IME caravans have tons of foibles and things just waiting to go wrong, especially at the hands of anyone who doesn't realise this and doesn't treat everything with care and respect.

We've had the same in our extended family with someone constantly hinting to borrow another's caravan. In the end the owners just said 'no, because there's so much that can go wrong with it. It's our pride and joy and we can't bear for things to be damaged by anyone except us'.

I think it's really bloody cheeky for them to have assumed you'd lend this out and to not realise the value/cost to you.

TollgateDebs · 24/01/2023 10:31

Straight no here, the insurance implications would put me off for a start.

magratvonlipwig · 24/01/2023 10:28

I would say something like
Maybe we might rent it out in a few years but for now we just want to keep it for ourselves to enjoy
Which tells her its not available, and also it wont be free !

BMrs · 24/01/2023 10:27

We had a tourer and I wouldn't have let family use it. Issues around sage towing, insurance, how to use the damn thing as it's complicated! I think she was rude to outright say that without you hinting it would be ok.

FanFckingTastic · 24/01/2023 10:25

Putting aside the cheeky nature of the assumption it doesn't sound like they have they considered the logistics at all. They don't have a car that tows - which then suggests that they don't have the correct insurance or a driver that can safely tow either - it's not just the same as driving (and parking) a car. Presumably they also have no idea what they are doing with regards to setting up and putting away the caravan.

OP - I would just tell them that at this point they can't use the caravan as it just won't work from a practical point of view.

MGMidget · 24/01/2023 10:25

I would say no because all your stuff will be as you want it in the caravan and it will be disrupted by their use. Also, there is a risk of damage - whose insurance will be covering it? From experience, when lending things to other people they often don't take the same care as I would with my own things so 'borrowed' things come back worn, torn or damaged. Then its really awkward discussing any damage with a friend/relative so better to just say you aren't letting anyone else stay in it and not planning to let it out as ABNB! And I think SIL has been quite cheeky to ask to use it the way she has so a firm 'no' asap should reduce the likelihood she will keep asking. If you put it off with a 'maybe in the future' type of answer she will keep pestering you in the hope you will give in!

katmarie · 24/01/2023 10:25

Whatafustercluck · 24/01/2023 08:08

Do they have a licence to tow? That’s an easy get out if not.

You don't need a special licence. Anyone with a full driving licence is allowed to tow.

I was about to argue with you about this, but you are right, the rules have changed, you don't need a trailer test any more to tow if you have a full licence. Every day's a school day.

beAsensible1 · 24/01/2023 10:25

Fimofriend · 24/01/2023 08:50

Practically every one of our friends and family members reacted like that when we bought a cottage. We nipped that in the bud immediately.

you wouldn't let any of your family or friends stay in your holiday cottage if you're not using it?

ExtraJalapenos · 24/01/2023 10:23

Cover it in black studded leather and stick a sex swing in

That'll ward off most of them...(it'll also attract a different new crowd)

euff · 24/01/2023 10:21

My BIL doesn't live in the country but is lucky enough to own a flat outright in London near a tube station. He has service charges etc to pay when not here and general upkeep so we suggested renting it out to cover those costs. My DH and another SIL already had keys in case of any issues. When we were visiting SIL I mentioned something about the first tenant moving in soon and she said 'why didn't they tell me, I had plans to use it in a couple of weeks.' She hadn't told them of her plans, she had a key and was using it as her holiday pad to take friends to London to stay.

beAsensible1 · 24/01/2023 10:21

just going against the grain that unless they're known not look after peoples things i'd probably let my immediate family use my caravan. and let them now they'd be liable for any damage.

DanseAvecLesLoups · 24/01/2023 10:20

Buy a mouldy £50 heap of shit caravan on ebay that has been sat in a field for twenty years and offer that to them when they rock up to collect.

ajandjjmum · 24/01/2023 10:19

Surely having others using and towing is going to increase the insurance premium hugely. Haven't read the full thread, but I would use that excuse.

LightDrizzle · 24/01/2023 10:15

Keep your “No” simple, as if she’s pushy or very keen, giving reasons gives her removable obstacles.

“Sorry, we’ve thought it over and won’t be renting it out or lending it out to anyone.”

If she pushes then revert to something like what ZaphodDent’s sister told her when she asked.

Otherwise referring to its newness - Oh! She wasn’t thinking about THIS year, but in the future, when the newness has worn off; wanting flexibility yourself, - just let her know anytime you definitely won’t be using it, and/ or you’ll be getting a weekly message in summer asking if you are using it that weekend…; cost implications? - she might agree offer £100 etc.

YANBU. We have a camper van and luckily nobody has asked to borrow it but it would have been a no.

Highfivemum · 24/01/2023 10:09

Make a point before you get it that you are not renting it out to anyone . If you start like that then you have made yourself clear. I have had same problem and did y make it clear. It then became a right of one friend that she would use it two weeks a year. I don’t mind helping people but I found myself working around her schedule to use my own van.
also meant I had to then remove all my stuff that I kept in it. Since we bought a new one I have never let it be used. Funnily enough the friend isn’t quite a friendly anymore.
set your rules from the start

StClare101 · 24/01/2023 10:05

”Err we’ll use it a few times ourselves first before even considering loaning it out!”

FeelingwearyFeeelingsmall · 24/01/2023 10:03

I'm torn on this one. I can understand that the OP wants to keep it pristine but on the other hand sharing could bring so much joy.

We are lucky enough to own a small holiday flat in a very popular seaside town. We are fully aware of what a privilege this is and so are delighted to be able to share it with friends and family. We give ourselves first priority for dates, then our adult D.C. but if none of us are using it we are more than happy for other people to use it. So far very few people have been cheeky about it (and when one person was, we just said no). Most people are very appreciative and take good care of the place.

That being said, a flat is much harder to damage than a caravan - and it does drive me mad when people leave their unwanted food supplies behind.

Misunderstoodagain · 24/01/2023 10:02

Also what about insurance? Not sure how it works with caravans but would you only be 3rd party if someone else is using it? That alone would mean I wouldn't lend it out, what if they got into an accident and then then it's gone.
Really cheeky. I don't even lend my tent out!

Puppers · 24/01/2023 09:57

It's the way they've "asked" that would get my back up. You haven't even used the damn thing yet and SIL is letting you know she expects to use it. She hasn't even demonstrated any manners and asked you. She just assumes that she will be borrowing it and has deliberately not really given you a fair opportunity to say no (because there wasn't actually a question; only a statement). The text from BIL also implies that she's told him you've already given the green light and it's just a case of working out details. Cheeky fuckers the pair of them. So entitled and rude, trying to strong arm you.

FWIW it's always always people like this who end up carelessly damaging things and they are the last people who will put their hands in their pockets to replace or fix anything they've broken.

There is only one couple on earth I would lend my caravan to and that's my DB and SIL. They would never in a million years be so forceful or presumptuous but they may take us up on our open offer one day. They would be very respectful and careful and I wouldn't be upset about any wear and tear incurred because I know that they would have been careful. If they broke something they'd fix it. Also - very crucially - we are exceptionally close with them. Caravans are small and fragile and full of soft furnishings and personal belongings. They're a very personal, intimate space. The idea of other people sleeping in my bed, using the tiny bathroom etc makes me very uncomfortable. I would not be happy to allow anyone else use of that space.

TicTac80 · 24/01/2023 09:56

I hope you manage to speak to your DH and nip this in the bud with you BIL/SIL soon. I have friends with caravans and camper vans - there's no way I'd ask to "borrow" theirs for trips away. I know how much work goes into to towing, setting up correctly etc (I've seen them do it) and I'd not want to have the responsibility of something so costly (plus my car isn't suitable for towing), and whilst my DC are sensible/we're seasoned campers, I'd be so worried about something getting damaged. I also only have limited experience of driving with a trailer (road trailer for my boat, when I had one - and that boat was smaller/shorter/lighter than a caravan!). I also don't have the experience of driving large camper vans/long wheel base vehicles etc. IT would be asking for trouble.

For the PP saying that OP is selfish, I think OP is being prudent and not selfish. If the BIL/SIL had an accident or something got damaged on the caravan, then they may then plead that they can't afford to pay to get things sorted. Or plead ignorance etc. Declining to lend it out will just stop all of this, and prevent any possible arguments/fall outs.

Justalittlebitduckling · 24/01/2023 09:52

SleepingStandingUp · 23/01/2023 23:21

Honestly I think you're pretty selfish. Unless there's some massive drop feed about their 7 unruly brats and their 6 dogs and how she's always leaving a trail of crumbs behind her, I don't see why you'd rather it sat empty on your driveway than be used by family.

If you're worried about wearing the tyres our or the mattress, ask for a small contribution.

I wouldn't have asked, in her shoes. I would have offered, in yours.

They might well have been planning to offer it to family eventually, but IMO the issue is the way the SIL has been so pushy right as they’ve bought it and assumed.

Badger1970 · 24/01/2023 09:52

Say that the insurance doesn't cover other people towing/using it as it was too expensive to have a cover all policy.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 24/01/2023 09:50

I think it’s really rude if you’ve got something new and someone else has already got their eye on it