Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be surprised at £18 per hour for gardening?

217 replies

Spagnolia · 23/01/2023 18:25

We are struggling to keep the weeds and brambles at bay and started to think we might get someone to help.

A guy was recommended by neighbour but I almost fell off my chair when I found out he charges £18 per hour for general weeding, grass cutting etc using our tools and equipment.

My junior doctor child gets £14 per hour!

We are far from the South East.

Do you have gardening help?
What is the going rate at the moment?

OP posts:
mumsneedwine · 25/01/2023 08:11

Drs pay for insurance (about £2,000 a year I believe), parking at their place of work unless v lucky (13 hour shifts can cost over £30 in parking every day), exams every year which cost £000s (even though they have to do them as part of their job), and all the other usual things that people pay for. They also have accrued a minimum of over £80,000 debt to qualify, a sum that will only increase every year due to the 6% interest. As a first year qualified doctor they will be given the hospital bleep overnight and be in charge of the patients on several wards. They have no say in where they live, no say in their shifts or days off and never leave on time. For £14 an hour.

Many say, well leave if you don't like it. So they do, and the NHS suffers even more from lack of staff.

C8H10N4O2 · 25/01/2023 07:51

BungleandGeorge · 24/01/2023 22:50

Drs pay tax, NI, pension, indemnity insurance, the costs of running a car (which will be the same class of business use) and equipment (eg stethoscope) too.

They don't pay employers NI and most people in work where there isn't convenient public transport use a car to get to and from work. It will only be classed as business use if they use it to travel from patient to patient during the working day and typically insurance for a professional moving between jobs is a lot less than for a tradesman who may not even be able to get insurance for kit in the van.

C8H10N4O2 · 25/01/2023 07:47

Spagnolia · 23/01/2023 19:44

Thank you to those of you who’ve shared their knowledge of the going rate for similar work, it’s certainly much higher than I’d expected. I guess on reflection a lot of mumsnet posters may also be South East and London-based where wages are much higher.
To some on here, as my granny would say ‘if you can’t say anything nice, don’t say anything at all ;) ‘

Don't be ridiculous - you would pay a lot more than £18 per hour in most of the SE (where charging is often by the half or whole day). If you don't want to pay do your own gardening. As for the poster upthread boasting about paying less than minimum wage for what is often hard physical work.

As for being "nice" - what hypocrisy. You rubbish your gardener's skills because he doesn't have a lot of paper qualifications in an industry where its common for people to learn over years on the job.

Your precious boy also has massive potential earnings in both public and private sectors, compared to most workers along with signficant kudos and social status. Not to mention the pension scheme which is pretty golden even by public sector standards and all the insurance benefits which come with that, the guaranteed work without lengthy annual gap periods, six months full sick pay in the NHS and a range of other "big public employer" benefits. He doesn't have to pay the costs of running a business.

There is a case to be made over pay for some groups and levels working in care and health care. You don't need to punch down on the nobodies you consider beneath you to make that case.

Doing so by comparing salaried employee rates per hour with business charges per hour simply makes you sound ignorant.

Alighttouchonthetiller · 25/01/2023 06:32

I've just paid £19 to the window cleaner who was here for approximately 5 minutes dribbling a bit of water down the windows and giving them a quick wipe over with a brush, so I think £18 for the garden sounds OK. You don't want to do it, just as I don't want to clean my windows, so throw money at it and move on.

snowlolo · 25/01/2023 05:23

Spagnolia · 23/01/2023 19:44

Thank you to those of you who’ve shared their knowledge of the going rate for similar work, it’s certainly much higher than I’d expected. I guess on reflection a lot of mumsnet posters may also be South East and London-based where wages are much higher.
To some on here, as my granny would say ‘if you can’t say anything nice, don’t say anything at all ;) ‘

I'm assuming the gardener is self-employed. £18 an hour also includes their time to travel to you, any tools they need, sick pay, NI, tax. How on earth would you expect them to survive on less than this? They have to make a living.

countrygirl99 · 25/01/2023 05:22

Spagnolia · 23/01/2023 19:44

Thank you to those of you who’ve shared their knowledge of the going rate for similar work, it’s certainly much higher than I’d expected. I guess on reflection a lot of mumsnet posters may also be South East and London-based where wages are much higher.
To some on here, as my granny would say ‘if you can’t say anything nice, don’t say anything at all ;) ‘

Well you came on to moan about a tradesman wanting to earn a living wage so that's a bit pot calling the kettle black. If it's such easy, low skilled work and you don't want to pay a reasonable wage do it yourself .

Orangetapemeasure · 25/01/2023 05:07

@BungleandGeorge its no acres! It’s a larger than average garden, but it’s by no means huge. I think when we bought the house it was described as being on a 0.2 acre plot- so that included the house and large parking area.

AnotherRandomMale · 25/01/2023 00:05

Seasonal job
Own transport
Own tools
YABU

SeasonFinale · 24/01/2023 23:11

So I am massively overpaying mine and will be looking for a new one!

SoShallINever · 24/01/2023 23:10

I have several Dr friends, one has quit to run a personal training class and one has moved into finance. Dr's (and nurses) aren't stupid, why would they stay in a massively stressful job, risking making themselves ill, when they can earn more doing something easier?
I don't begrudge gardeners and hairdressers their pay but I think we are deluded if we think the NHS will survive much longer unless staff pay rises.

BungleandGeorge · 24/01/2023 23:09

Orangetapemeasure · 24/01/2023 22:52

South west. £20-25/hr for general gardening. Flat rate of £40 for mowing the lawn which took less than 40 minutes.

How many acres is the lawn?!

LemonSwan · 24/01/2023 23:09

I really don’t understand this doctor comparison, or comparison to any other profession tbh.

Your literally saying you or someone you know doesnt earn xyz and so why should a gardener.

Do you know how that sounds?

Besides all the complexities of self employment. Even if it was more - your saying they shouldn’t earn that. Because your worth more?

Well garden yourself then.

Oh no but you can’t because you don’t know how. But it’s unskilled?

Or is it just you couldn’t possibly get your nails dirty. And the person that will well how dare they charge a living wage. Absolute paupers they should be. Scrapping around in the mud.

Bigweekend · 24/01/2023 23:04

UsingChangeofName · 24/01/2023 23:03

but I must correct the idea that you can compare doctors and gardeners in terms of pay for going between jobs. My GP spends hours extra travelling between jobs and patients after 6, all unpaid.

Yes, but that isn't really what we are talking about - a GP is on a salary, a very good salary at that (very quick google says around £82 000 on 'average' - which I know is rarely what 'most people are paid', but they start on £40K ish). They are paid a whole salary so the role, not an hourly rate.
The point about someone being hourly paid is that they can't actually earn 8 lots of their hourly rate. Whereas a GP - or me, traveling from one place to another - still gets their salary for the day / week / month / year, even if some of the working day is spent traveling.

I'm going to guess the GP.probably claims mileage too

UsingChangeofName · 24/01/2023 23:03

but I must correct the idea that you can compare doctors and gardeners in terms of pay for going between jobs. My GP spends hours extra travelling between jobs and patients after 6, all unpaid.

Yes, but that isn't really what we are talking about - a GP is on a salary, a very good salary at that (very quick google says around £82 000 on 'average' - which I know is rarely what 'most people are paid', but they start on £40K ish). They are paid a whole salary so the role, not an hourly rate.
The point about someone being hourly paid is that they can't actually earn 8 lots of their hourly rate. Whereas a GP - or me, traveling from one place to another - still gets their salary for the day / week / month / year, even if some of the working day is spent traveling.

Orangetapemeasure · 24/01/2023 22:52

South west. £20-25/hr for general gardening. Flat rate of £40 for mowing the lawn which took less than 40 minutes.

BungleandGeorge · 24/01/2023 22:50

Drs pay tax, NI, pension, indemnity insurance, the costs of running a car (which will be the same class of business use) and equipment (eg stethoscope) too.

Hadtochangeforthisone · 24/01/2023 22:43

The market will pay for 'demand' . I am from the south east. House maintenance jobs are extremely well paid here because they are in such high demand and short supply.

Cleaners £15-20
Gardeners £18-22
Handyman/general maintenance £15-20

They do jobs that people with the money to pay can't or don't want to do.

paintitallover · 24/01/2023 22:13

Plus, the gardener’s salary won’t go up at the same rate as a doctor’s. Plus a gardener’s working time includes going between different jobs. Plus paternity/maternity/sick leave etc

This is t my argument (or thread) but I must correct the idea that you can compare doctors and gardeners in terms of pay for going between jobs. My GP spends hours extra travelling between jobs and patients after 6, all unpaid.

OoooohMatron · 24/01/2023 22:08

Spagnolia · 23/01/2023 19:44

Thank you to those of you who’ve shared their knowledge of the going rate for similar work, it’s certainly much higher than I’d expected. I guess on reflection a lot of mumsnet posters may also be South East and London-based where wages are much higher.
To some on here, as my granny would say ‘if you can’t say anything nice, don’t say anything at all ;) ‘

Your granny was talking out of her arse. Is everybody supposed to 'be kind' in the face of a snob who doesn't think that people doing manual labour should earn a decent wage? Get over yourself.

OoooohMatron · 24/01/2023 22:03

BungleandGeorge · 23/01/2023 23:21

Yes people are odd they’ll happily pay their Gardner/dog walker/ cleaner etc a good hourly rate plus tips but grumble about HCP/ teacher etc pay.
self employed pay less to the taxman. Those who don’t require a degree can start earning at 18 and avoid thousands of pounds student loan.

What bollocks

BumpySkull · 24/01/2023 10:59

Beneficialchampion2 · 23/01/2023 18:26

Does your junior doctor buy all their own tools, pay their own NI, tax and Pension contributions. Pay for their own insurance plus everything else required to do their job safely?

YABU

This.

Plus, the gardener’s salary won’t go up at the same rate as a doctor’s. Plus a gardener’s working time includes going between different jobs. Plus paternity/maternity/sick leave etc.

Allmyarseandpeggymartin · 24/01/2023 10:42

I think that’s pretty good, my cleaner is £15 an hour now

Thoughtful2355 · 24/01/2023 10:41

South West here, £25 ph is going rate for gardening

WisherWood · 24/01/2023 08:12

self employed pay less to the taxman.

Nope. We pay exactly the same. There isn't some 'it's OK we'll let you off' clause. It's just that your class 4 NICS and everything else come out of your hourly rate. Check the rates for regular employment vs being self employed. They are the same.

Comewithmefriday · 24/01/2023 01:20

Spagnolia · 23/01/2023 19:00

The gardener is not qualified, brings no tools or removes any of the garden waste. I have no idea about his insurance (our home insurance covers people working around our house and garden though.

I mentioned my DC as they did 5 years at medical school and currently does night shifts as the only doctor on duty covering several wards, so a lot of responsibility looking after someone’s child, partner, parent.

I was surprised that an unqualified unskilled wage was higher than a junior doctor wage. Nothing to do with snobbery.

Though it does go some way to explain why many new doctors are leaving for Aus/NZ sadly. And are currently voting to take strike action. There are no market conditions for doctors. The NHS has a monopoly unfortunately. And awful working conditions.

But getting back to the subject, I won’t be paying that much so it looks like we will be embracing rewilding!

It nothing to do with snobbery 🤣

your feudal system is going rogue.

that serf is getting above his station, ma'am,
he is so BU, demanding a fair wage for a day toiling on your land when your poor junior doctor son is pointlessly training for a position with no prospects in a profession that's notoriously underpaid.

nip this in the bud before all your peasants start revolting, the consequences of this will affect us all.

before you know it they'll be talking about having rights and then where will we be