Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

3 year old member of Mensa.

268 replies

Toddlerteaplease · 23/01/2023 17:38

Article in todays Times, (don't know how to link)
AIBU to think this is ridiculous, let him be a toddler, nurture his interests of course. But this is OTT, and asking for trouble. Apparently he wants to go to university and be a doctor. Confused

OP posts:
tornadoinsideoutfig · 23/01/2023 19:44

Legrandetraitor · 23/01/2023 19:36

But for example my son is in the top 0.5%. There’s no test for higher than that. That’s not 1 in 50 it’s 1 in 200 but there’s literally no test to filter any higher than that. Which is incredibly obvious when you spend time with him (I have 2 other children who are normally bright btw it’s a huge difference I can’t even begin to explain but the attitudes on here and the lack of understanding are WHY Mensa helps).

they speak directly to the school and provide all sorts of advice for how to handle students and how to keep them interested. It’s not a matter of extension work it’s very hard to explain

They do test higher. DS got 99.8th% on the SB-5.

JaneJeffer · 23/01/2023 19:42

*affect Grin

JaneJeffer · 23/01/2023 19:42

SpentDandelion · 23/01/2023 19:40

Judging by the mean spirited attitudes on here, l feel sorry for him.
My youngest is very intelligent, but what I've noticed over the years is that no one else had ever really clapped for him, preferring to mock him instead in an underhanded way.
Shame this little boy cannot be celebrated for his achievements.

People are worried about the effect being famous at such a young age will have.

SpentDandelion · 23/01/2023 19:40

Judging by the mean spirited attitudes on here, l feel sorry for him.
My youngest is very intelligent, but what I've noticed over the years is that no one else had ever really clapped for him, preferring to mock him instead in an underhanded way.
Shame this little boy cannot be celebrated for his achievements.

Legrandetraitor · 23/01/2023 19:37

Legrandetraitor · 23/01/2023 19:36

But for example my son is in the top 0.5%. There’s no test for higher than that. That’s not 1 in 50 it’s 1 in 200 but there’s literally no test to filter any higher than that. Which is incredibly obvious when you spend time with him (I have 2 other children who are normally bright btw it’s a huge difference I can’t even begin to explain but the attitudes on here and the lack of understanding are WHY Mensa helps).

they speak directly to the school and provide all sorts of advice for how to handle students and how to keep them interested. It’s not a matter of extension work it’s very hard to explain

Name change fail sorry

Legrandetraitor · 23/01/2023 19:36

user143677433 · 23/01/2023 19:27

So they do actually do support these days then? What does that support look like?

And is it really so hard (and important) for play dates with children “on the same level”. Mensa membership is open to anyone with an IQ above 98th percentile. So one in 50. Surely taking into account the school year plus any clubs, that means your kid already hangs about with at least 3-4 other kids “on the same level”.

But for example my son is in the top 0.5%. There’s no test for higher than that. That’s not 1 in 50 it’s 1 in 200 but there’s literally no test to filter any higher than that. Which is incredibly obvious when you spend time with him (I have 2 other children who are normally bright btw it’s a huge difference I can’t even begin to explain but the attitudes on here and the lack of understanding are WHY Mensa helps).

they speak directly to the school and provide all sorts of advice for how to handle students and how to keep them interested. It’s not a matter of extension work it’s very hard to explain

Athenen0ctua · 23/01/2023 19:36

user143677433 · 23/01/2023 19:27

So they do actually do support these days then? What does that support look like?

And is it really so hard (and important) for play dates with children “on the same level”. Mensa membership is open to anyone with an IQ above 98th percentile. So one in 50. Surely taking into account the school year plus any clubs, that means your kid already hangs about with at least 3-4 other kids “on the same level”.

Some would be the 1 in 50 kids, these are usually the kids who do well, top of the class but not disengaged, fit in easily with peers. It's the 1 in 500 kids who are more in need of kids on their level.

JaneJeffer · 23/01/2023 19:33

That's right @TaRaDeBumDeAy

TaRaDeBumDeAy · 23/01/2023 19:29

JaneJeffer · 23/01/2023 18:12

Remember James Harries?

Is that the antiques boy girl?

user143677433 · 23/01/2023 19:27

Oneeyedreindeer · 23/01/2023 19:17

Because Mensa are fantastic and work with schools etc to ensure these children are supported. And you can do play dates with other children etc of the same level. And it means you’re taken seriously

So they do actually do support these days then? What does that support look like?

And is it really so hard (and important) for play dates with children “on the same level”. Mensa membership is open to anyone with an IQ above 98th percentile. So one in 50. Surely taking into account the school year plus any clubs, that means your kid already hangs about with at least 3-4 other kids “on the same level”.

Oneeyedreindeer · 23/01/2023 19:24

Thesonglastslonger · 23/01/2023 19:21

I know a guy who tells everyone he was diagnosed a ‘genius’ age 3 and was sent to a special school for geniuses 🤔

He’s a wanker with zero social skills. Shame his parents didn’t send him to a normal preschool so he could learn the virtues of not being annoying and obnoxious. 🤷‍♀️

My eldest brother is also a genius - it tends to run in families (sadly skipped me 😆🤦🏻‍♀️) and it doesn’t stop him from being a fucking arsehole. Like good for you. you can unbelievable maths and science but you have 1 friend because you’re a wanker. Shame because he’s the only one who would really be able to understand my son!

Thesonglastslonger · 23/01/2023 19:21

I know a guy who tells everyone he was diagnosed a ‘genius’ age 3 and was sent to a special school for geniuses 🤔

He’s a wanker with zero social skills. Shame his parents didn’t send him to a normal preschool so he could learn the virtues of not being annoying and obnoxious. 🤷‍♀️

MargaretThursday · 23/01/2023 19:18

PlaitBilledDuckyPuss · 23/01/2023 17:53

The BBC article said he'd learned to read and count in different languages of his own accord. It seems reasonable for his parents to find out his IQ - I'd be curious in the same position! I wish him well for the future.

I'm always interested in what "of his own accord" means. Because my dc would have found it very hard to learn to read and count in different languages because they would have had limited access to them. I mean, I think somewhere I have Usborne's "First 1000 words in French" and I have a German dictionary, but other than that I don't think they would have had access to any other languages.

I remember discovering with dd1 that it was quite easy to teach her things. We taught her that in order to have a proper temper tantrum, she had to say "woe, woe and thrice woe" or we didn't know she was upset. Then if really cross she had to say "humph" three times.
It worked a treat as by the time she'd done that she'd forgotten what was annoying her. I think we only told her once and then the next time when she started getting upset said "are you going to say 'woe...' first".

But she also learnt things which I could say was her own accord. She learnt her letters at 22 months because she decided she wanted to play on the computer. we had no children's games so she typed. So I spent a day with her giving words she wanted to write and me spelling them out and pointing to the letters. By the end of the day she knew them all. Numbers was because we caught the bus and we have numbers 1-9 go through town, and she'd ask if it was our bus and I'd say "no that's a number 4" or whatever.
Was that her own accord? Well, I never set out to teach her the letters or numbers. However it was my actions that taught her, and I'll maintain that any other child who'd found it interesting would have learnt as easily. As far as she was concerned it was a fun game. She wouldn't have learnt them without my input at that age.

So I suspect there's some parent teaching.

And I'd also suspect that the sort of parent who goes to the press about it is going to play down the teaching they've done. I may be doing them an injustice there though.

Oneeyedreindeer · 23/01/2023 19:18

Sucessinthenewyear · 23/01/2023 18:50

This was my concern too.

This

Oneeyedreindeer · 23/01/2023 19:17

user143677433 · 23/01/2023 18:46

What is the benefit to the child though? I don’t really “get” Mensa. I was a member briefly as a teen and it just seemed to be a bunch of people doing puzzles and being a bit smug. A exclusive club to go in the CV. Maybe they are more based around support these days?

Because Mensa are fantastic and work with schools etc to ensure these children are supported. And you can do play dates with other children etc of the same level. And it means you’re taken seriously

JaneJeffer · 23/01/2023 19:17

How do children teach themselves to read?
From watching Sesame Street in my case.

PeachDelany · 23/01/2023 19:16

Bunnycat101 · 23/01/2023 18:07

It’s all bollocks really. My parents had me tested by Mensa as a child out of curiosity and I came out with a genius level iq. I was bright but nothing special. I had membership for a year and everyone knew it was rubbish so my parents didn’t renew.

This. My child was saying the alphabet forwards and backwards before their 2nd birthday.

Oneeyedreindeer · 23/01/2023 19:15

My son is a member of Mensa (and not autistic) and I think it’s a very valuable thing to have as 1) a support base 2) a tool to be taken seriously at school - everyone goes in and says their children are so smart etc and it’s a way of explaining you’re not exaggerating and your child will need special need level extra support because it’s off the scale and these children always end up with problems as adults as a result of depression /many other reasons. It’s not fair for my child to sit when people are learning how to count to 20 and he wants to do cube numbers and to the power of. Just like it wouldn’t be appropriate to give a child struggling the same work and expect them to complete it.

What I really, really don’t understand is why she contacted the papers. It’s utterly bizarre and doesn’t benefit her son at all! To make money? To show off? Why?

Athenen0ctua · 23/01/2023 19:13

Reindear · 23/01/2023 19:09

How do children teach themselves to read? Surely someone needs to tell them what sound each letter/digraph etc makes- they don’t just know that for example oo makes an ooh and a uh sound surely? Or even the sound that A makes- how do they know unless someone has told them? They’re not psychic?

And as for speaking other languages- his parents must have introduced him to them for him to know they exist or has he randomly googled how to count to 100 in welsh? And then magically learnt how to pronounce/ mutate accordingly?

Im not saying he’s not a genius- he’s obviously incredibly bright but I think the parents have had more involvement than they’re making out and also are very keen for the world to know about him, hence going to the media about him.

I learnt from book and tape sets and being read to. Initially by sight then worked out phonics backwards from that. I was three.

AssignedNorthern · 23/01/2023 19:13

Reindear · 23/01/2023 19:09

How do children teach themselves to read? Surely someone needs to tell them what sound each letter/digraph etc makes- they don’t just know that for example oo makes an ooh and a uh sound surely? Or even the sound that A makes- how do they know unless someone has told them? They’re not psychic?

And as for speaking other languages- his parents must have introduced him to them for him to know they exist or has he randomly googled how to count to 100 in welsh? And then magically learnt how to pronounce/ mutate accordingly?

Im not saying he’s not a genius- he’s obviously incredibly bright but I think the parents have had more involvement than they’re making out and also are very keen for the world to know about him, hence going to the media about him.

There are so many toys cartoons and such that say that alphabet sounds I think that's how they learn the phonetic sounds and then can visually match them to the alphabet symbol. Look up hyperlexia if you are actually interested.

user143677433 · 23/01/2023 19:11

Reindear · 23/01/2023 19:09

How do children teach themselves to read? Surely someone needs to tell them what sound each letter/digraph etc makes- they don’t just know that for example oo makes an ooh and a uh sound surely? Or even the sound that A makes- how do they know unless someone has told them? They’re not psychic?

And as for speaking other languages- his parents must have introduced him to them for him to know they exist or has he randomly googled how to count to 100 in welsh? And then magically learnt how to pronounce/ mutate accordingly?

Im not saying he’s not a genius- he’s obviously incredibly bright but I think the parents have had more involvement than they’re making out and also are very keen for the world to know about him, hence going to the media about him.

Plenty of children teach themselves to read by identifying the words on the page as their parents read to them, or by subtitles etc.

Thepeopleversuswork · 23/01/2023 19:10

I have no problem with kids being entered for Mensa (although I think it’s a bit dubious).

But offering it exclusively to papers is shortsighted and potentially cruel.

That poor kid is now a moving target for the newspapers. First time he gets a detention or flunks and exam or is found lying in a pool of his own sick At kicking out time it will be front-page news.

Vanity over common sense and very foolish on the part of the parents.

Reindear · 23/01/2023 19:09

How do children teach themselves to read? Surely someone needs to tell them what sound each letter/digraph etc makes- they don’t just know that for example oo makes an ooh and a uh sound surely? Or even the sound that A makes- how do they know unless someone has told them? They’re not psychic?

And as for speaking other languages- his parents must have introduced him to them for him to know they exist or has he randomly googled how to count to 100 in welsh? And then magically learnt how to pronounce/ mutate accordingly?

Im not saying he’s not a genius- he’s obviously incredibly bright but I think the parents have had more involvement than they’re making out and also are very keen for the world to know about him, hence going to the media about him.

PennyRa · 23/01/2023 19:07

Of course it's not ridiculous this child exists. Special children have just as much right to exist in this world as everyone else. 🙄

Thereisnolight · 23/01/2023 19:03

Is Mensa even a thing now?