Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

3 year old member of Mensa.

268 replies

Toddlerteaplease · 23/01/2023 17:38

Article in todays Times, (don't know how to link)
AIBU to think this is ridiculous, let him be a toddler, nurture his interests of course. But this is OTT, and asking for trouble. Apparently he wants to go to university and be a doctor. Confused

OP posts:
Fizbosshoes · 24/01/2023 07:50

He's probably quite average compared to the typical MN child! 😄

HRTQueen · 24/01/2023 07:37

He was on the evening news yesterday happily playing with play doh

At one point he was reading a book he was very cute, giggly and seemed completely unaware of his advanced abilities

my friends son appeared to be able to read at a very young age but was reciting quite a number of books word for word we thought he was a little genius

SweetSakura · 24/01/2023 07:27

@RobertaFirmino do you not realise that for a toddler with a high IQ the learning will be a pleasure too? And that spending time learning doesn't prevent him enjoying all the other parts of being a toddler?

My son loved puddle jumping and playing with his friends and all the other simple toddler pleasures. But he also absorbed information like a sponge and made me set him maths sums in the car because that's how he enjoyed passing the time. It wasn't me hot housing, he (and I am sure many other high IQ toddlers are the same) really wanted to do maths, to read, to learn about the world.

tornadoinsideoutfig · 24/01/2023 07:26

ProbablyRomanticised · 23/01/2023 23:46

Counting is a rote skill, denoting excellent verbal memory. Doing it in other languages isn't indicative of "fluency" in those languages. I can count to 10 in Japanese, Latin, Italian, French, German, Swahili, Spanish and English. I am absolutely not fluent in any language other than English.

The sums on the board in a picture in the newspaper article are laid out so an algorithm can be followed; again, this can be learned by rote with an understanding of English numbers to 20. Does he know what the answer would be if he had 5 people coming to play and each wanted 15 marshmallows?

I mean he's obviously got exceptional categorisation and rote skills. Can he apply that knowledge?

Rote learning is the knowledge (eg from reading or watching a video) that salt dissolves and sand does not. Application of this is the ability to design an experiment to prove this and separate salt from sand. The latter is more sophisticated.

Good luck to him; but I do think IQ testing in this very early age range is particularly inaccurate as a predictor of life success as it so emphasises rote skills and exposure knowledge (eg the names of the oceans, the points of the compass, days of the week in order etc).

DS could do the same problem quicker when presented as a word problem, and did maths in his head preferentially. He just understood numbers inside out and back to front. He had to be taught written methods at school and still forgets the months of the year in order or how many days they have now and he is doing further maths at A level!

Coffeecreme · 24/01/2023 07:08

i thought he was cute

Legrandetraitor · 24/01/2023 07:05

RobertaFirmino · 24/01/2023 01:15

What does "let him be a toddler" even mean.

It means mandarin segments, not Mandarin textbooks. The simple joys of childhood - I'm sure you can recall them yourself. Making a rocket out of an old washing up liquid bottle and playing 'space'. Uncontrollable laughter at the word 'poo'. Questionable (yet cute) drawings of Mummy with a yellow circle in the top corner for a sun. Humpty Dumpty.

I hope he gets to experience all these things.

But the point will be that for him, learning IS like those things. He will still laugh at the word poo and will still have fun and run around but he will also WANT to learn. It will be inherently part of what he wants to do.

Legrandetraitor · 24/01/2023 07:04

SweetSakura · 23/01/2023 23:43

Would you let me know the book that's from? I'd be interested to read it. I think DS and I fit into the "high IQ" whereas DH and DSD are both diagnosed (high functioning) autistic- with high IQs. And yes I can see the overlaps but I identify with those key differences

The book is “a brilliant IQ: gift or challenge” by Lyn Kendall. I highly recommend it for anyone who has a gifted child.

to the PP above speaking about rote learning - it’s very clear when your child isn’t rote learning but has a deep understanding. Again I think so many people on this thread, because they haven’t seen it, just don’t understand. It’s sad because it results in so many negative comments and so much misconception

RobertaFirmino · 24/01/2023 01:15

What does "let him be a toddler" even mean.

It means mandarin segments, not Mandarin textbooks. The simple joys of childhood - I'm sure you can recall them yourself. Making a rocket out of an old washing up liquid bottle and playing 'space'. Uncontrollable laughter at the word 'poo'. Questionable (yet cute) drawings of Mummy with a yellow circle in the top corner for a sun. Humpty Dumpty.

I hope he gets to experience all these things.

Mahanii · 24/01/2023 01:01

@Jellycats4life I was hyperlexic but not autistic! I can also read other scripts and probably seemed like a prodigy child. Now distinctly average (possibly below!)

TheMarzipanDildo · 24/01/2023 00:22

Florenz · 23/01/2023 23:48

What does "let him be a toddler" even mean. The whole idea of childhood is a social construct. It doesn't actually exist in reality.

Why are people so afraid of an intelligent 3 year old? Why must we celebrate mediocrity and ordinariness?

I think “childhood is a social construct” is a pretty dangerous line.

Of course children are allowed to be intelligent and an interest in learning should be encouraged, but children do not have the emotional intelligence or physical strength of adults. Which is why in most countries there are certain things that children cannot do, be held responsible for or consent to that adults can. I would much rather live in a world where children are seen as clearly distinct from adults than a world in which children are thought of as able to consent to sex or be exploited in a factory.

I would argue that this child cannot consent to having their face plastered all over the media, nice as the mother seems.

Florenz · 23/01/2023 23:48

What does "let him be a toddler" even mean. The whole idea of childhood is a social construct. It doesn't actually exist in reality.

Why are people so afraid of an intelligent 3 year old? Why must we celebrate mediocrity and ordinariness?

ProbablyRomanticised · 23/01/2023 23:46

Counting is a rote skill, denoting excellent verbal memory. Doing it in other languages isn't indicative of "fluency" in those languages. I can count to 10 in Japanese, Latin, Italian, French, German, Swahili, Spanish and English. I am absolutely not fluent in any language other than English.

The sums on the board in a picture in the newspaper article are laid out so an algorithm can be followed; again, this can be learned by rote with an understanding of English numbers to 20. Does he know what the answer would be if he had 5 people coming to play and each wanted 15 marshmallows?

I mean he's obviously got exceptional categorisation and rote skills. Can he apply that knowledge?

Rote learning is the knowledge (eg from reading or watching a video) that salt dissolves and sand does not. Application of this is the ability to design an experiment to prove this and separate salt from sand. The latter is more sophisticated.

Good luck to him; but I do think IQ testing in this very early age range is particularly inaccurate as a predictor of life success as it so emphasises rote skills and exposure knowledge (eg the names of the oceans, the points of the compass, days of the week in order etc).

SweetSakura · 23/01/2023 23:43

Legrandetraitor · 23/01/2023 20:21

There is an overlap between genius and autistic traits, the reasoning is different. Doesn’t make someone autistic.

Would you let me know the book that's from? I'd be interested to read it. I think DS and I fit into the "high IQ" whereas DH and DSD are both diagnosed (high functioning) autistic- with high IQs. And yes I can see the overlaps but I identify with those key differences

SweetSakura · 23/01/2023 23:34

SlaveToTheVibe · 23/01/2023 18:06

Try having a child who has an insatiable thirst for knowledge. You’d soon see that this “let a child be a child” thing is impossible sometimes.

My son is autistic and could also read at this age. Taking a book off him would have been like taking a phone off a teenager, sometimes you have to run with it when they’re obsessed with learning . He’s incredibly well informed in all areas. He watches PMQs every Wednesday after school and doesn’t bother with kids telly ever.

I’m not boasting, he’s just passionate about learning. Endless questions from
morning to night for me and his dad. It’s intense and sometimes draining.

its not always pushy parents - we’re laid back to the point of laziness in this house - or we would be if given a chance.

Exactly . The pandemic was tough to begin with as my son was so gutted school was closed because he wanted to keep learning. We paid a load in the end for tutors and online classes and lots more books for him! (We were both working very full time,).

SweetSakura · 23/01/2023 23:31

I'm in two minds. I have never bothered with mensa even though I am sure all our family could pass the tests. It seems like a vanity thing really. And I don't approve of him being in the press really

But at 2 my son already wanted to go to university and become a professor of physics (we drove past the university on our way to regular hospital appointments so we chatted about that it was and he knew his uncle had a PhD in physics and wanted to go one better Grin ). And yes, he was having proper conversations before he was two. It was glorious to get such an insight into the mind of a toddler. He was dinky and had hardly any teeth so looked even younger.

And it's not unusual for very bright children to have an insatiable thirst for learning. I taught myself to read long before I started school -because I wanted to. My parents didn't have time to hothouse me.

Blackbird2020 · 23/01/2023 23:25

“Well, he doesn’t know, which is quite nice,” she told Today. “And we will keep it that way for as long as we can.“

Hmm… haven’t really thought that through then….

Fizbosshoes · 23/01/2023 23:21

I'm always interested in what "of his own accord" means. Because my dc would have found it very hard to learn to read and count in different languages because they would have had limited access to them. I mean, I think somewhere I have Usborne's "First 1000 words in French" and I have a German dictionary, but other than that I don't think they would have had access to any other languages

I was also wondering about how he knew or accessed all the languages....? (I mean even on YouTube a parent is monitoring or choosing what a 2 or 3 year old can watch?) To be honest if either of my DC (they're teenage non geniuses) said they could count to 100 in anything other than English, French or German I would have to take their word for it!

I thought the mum seemed pretty laid back and Teddy was very cute

Ontheperiphery79 · 23/01/2023 23:17

He seems to have a loving, supportive family network (we are from the same area of the same county, so seen comments/responses from his extended family.

I really don't think I could ever discuss my DC with the media and do wonder why the parents have done so.

Remaker · 23/01/2023 23:16

My DS taught himself to read - we think - just by working out the connection between what we were saying and the word on the page when we read to him. He wanted everything read to him - instruction manuals, recipes, inserts from CD cases. My Mum would be sat with him reading things like ‘Executive Producer Garry Jones, Mixing by Serena Smith’ for hours on end. We just thought it was hilarious. I don’t know when he actually learned to read exactly, definitely before the age of 4 as this is when he picked up one of DD’s books she’d brought home from school and just read the whole thing aloud and we were gobsmacked. By that stage he could read any word you showed him pretty much.

When he’d just turned 2 I took him to a playgroup run by trainee early childhood teachers. He sat down to do some art and the teacher asked him can you write your name, I assume just seeing if he picked up the pencil the right way round and maybe made a mark on the page. He wrote his name correctly. He’d never done it before, had never been taught by anyone (he was at home with me FT). The teacher was young, she just accepted it, I was a bit taken aback but thought ok he’s picked that up somewhere.

It was school that eventually destroyed his love of learning. He’s not autistic, just a regular kid who happens to be super bright (his IQ was tested at 99.9%). But unfortunately he got some awful teachers early on who just lived to tear down anyone they felt was a tall poppy. Or they ignored him because he could already do what they were teaching and he was quiet and well behaved so he was one less kid to worry about. We switched schools to one with a G&T program and he did get some lovely teachers there but a lot of the damage had been done.

I do feel the parent on the news will live to regret publicising their child. They will find out just how awful parents can be when they are jealous of a child. They’ll be accused of robbing him of a childhood, forcing him to read and count instead of “being a normal child” as if being intelligent is not normal. My DS always did both - loved learning AND playing. Now as a teenager he learns about things he is interested in and tries to ignore the rest. Fortunately for him he absolutely loves sport, so he fits in with his peers and that makes him happy. The IQ is still there and I suspect, much like my DH, that he will thrive more when he’s out of school and can learn about the things he loves. In my family there are several people with very high IQs. Some have lived happy fulfilled lives and others have suffered terribly. Our main focus for DS is for him to be in the first group, not the second.

ThisGirlNever · 23/01/2023 22:59

DS1 (3 years old) was introduced to Mariocart by some family friends. He stunned the room by shouting 'that one, that one, pick Bell'. He was referring to the band of one of the race tracks and there were no visual clues on the screen, just text. He did a similar thing with some Aldi honey nut cornflakes (but there was a picture of honeycomb on the box, so we weren't sure).

We've never tried to teach him to read, but do read to him most days and always have the subtitles enabled on the TV. He's watched a bit of Alphablocks, but not regularly.

He certainly can't read a book, but appears to have picked up a fair bit.

I guess it just clicks for some kids.

bridgetreilly · 23/01/2023 22:43

His mum said he was playing a Thomas the Tank Engine game when she heard him counting in Mandarin. I assumed that he’d worked out how to change the language settings on the game. These days it would be very easy for a child to access all kinds of things in other languages.

AreOttersJustWetCats · 23/01/2023 22:41

The content of the interview doesn't change the fact that the parents actively sought this publicity. It was a choice they made, and it's not unreasonable for others to question that choice. The child isn't old enough to have consented to it.

ZombieKettle · 23/01/2023 22:35

AreOttersJustWetCats · 23/01/2023 22:26

Yes, so down to earth that they're publicising their child in the national media.... 🤔

Maybe have a listen. It's on BBC Sounds and interview starts at 2:47:30. It's the 23/1/23 episode.

Greyhave · 23/01/2023 22:34

Obviously I’m not a member of Mensa, however I’m just wondering at that age how does he learn to count or read or whatever in different languages? Did he figure out how to load this up on the internet himself with no prompting or did mum and dad provide him with the learning materials?

Imo toddlers should be toddlers….running around outside, having fun, getting messy, playing with other kids. Not sitting at home preparing for a Mensa test.

This will just be the beginning for this poor child especially now the media are involved. Why would any parent want this life for their child? To be pursued by the media ….presumably just to make money for themselves and appear in some channel 4 style documentary about smart kids?! They could have just kept quiet and let him get about pursuing his dream of becoming a doctor…aged three 🙄

AreOttersJustWetCats · 23/01/2023 22:26

ZombieKettle · 23/01/2023 18:19

His mum was on Radio 4's Today programme this morning. She was down to earth and good humoured about it all. They sound like a lovely family.

Yes, so down to earth that they're publicising their child in the national media.... 🤔

Swipe left for the next trending thread