Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

3 year old member of Mensa.

268 replies

Toddlerteaplease · 23/01/2023 17:38

Article in todays Times, (don't know how to link)
AIBU to think this is ridiculous, let him be a toddler, nurture his interests of course. But this is OTT, and asking for trouble. Apparently he wants to go to university and be a doctor. Confused

OP posts:
Jellycats4life · 24/01/2023 10:26

It’s the pushy parents that are the worst (and the parents of Teddy, all over the TV and radio, count as pushy in my opinion - they are revelling in the kudos of having a “gifted” child).

I see them on FB groups refusing to acknowledge their child’s autistic traits (they don’t have friends because they’re too gifted to socialise with their peers, apparently) and push and push to have them moved up one or even two years at school… like sitting their GCSEs when they should really be in Year 9 is actually a good idea. I find it really sad. If only they’d spend as much time nurturing their social and emotional well-being as their intellect.

BellatrixLestrangesHeatedCurlers · 24/01/2023 10:22

I always feel a bit of a pang for gifted children. The world isn't made for NT people. They often end up burned out and depressed. I hope his future is different.

PennyRa · 24/01/2023 10:19

AssignedNorthern · 23/01/2023 20:17

Hyperlexia is when a child starts reading early and surprisingly beyond their expected ability.

Beyond their comprehension

AtomicBlondeRose · 24/01/2023 09:57

My DS could read at 2 and it wasn't rote learning at all - he definitely understood what he was reading and could chat to you about it. I know people don't really believe this unless you've seen it but he could have long conversations with adults at that age and had a very good level of comprehension. As with PPs it was sometimes hard to find the right things to give him to read - he was "stuck" on a low reading book level for a long time as although he could read the higher ones he wasn't emotionally ready for them (eg books about WW2 with details a 9-10 year old would be fine with but a yo definitely couldn't handle! Also books about school that assumed the reader was a junior school child and dealt with friendship or family issues a reception child couldn't get their head around).

dustydewdrop · 24/01/2023 09:45

VioletLemon · 24/01/2023 09:00

Love this. The 'taught himself to read at 2' stuff is rote learning, decoding that's all. Give the same 2 year old written questions they can 'read' using common 2, 3,4 or 5 letter words and it quickly becomes obvious the child cannot 'read' but they can decode, spot patterns, solve simple problems very easily.

To a lesser extent it’s the same when people say my two year old can count to 20, isn’t that amazing. Yes it is but it’s memory really isn’t it? Same with learning the alphabet. My toddler knew if we were going into a Morrisons supermarket that wasn’t our regular one not because she could read the sign but because she recognised it.

WandaWonder · 24/01/2023 09:39

How on earth do you know this child's entire life?

SlaveToTheVibe · 24/01/2023 09:38

We had to give my 4yo son nursery books and fairy tales, the sort you read to a child at bed time because he could read books for 8-9 year old but was not emotionally able for the content. And while he’s extremely bright, his “worst” topic is probably English comprehension.

The problem with autism is it gives with one hand but takes with the other. My son is 9, intellectually he’s like a 14 year old but emotionally more like a six year old. It’s hard to reconcile that type of age gap! The gap become more evident as he goes through the school and I’m convinced there will be some sort of crisis when puberty hits. Yeah nice to have a clever child but it brings a load of worry.

Jellycats4life · 24/01/2023 09:13

KnittedCardi · 24/01/2023 09:04

I have a question. Is it a case of just learning patterns though? Do these children understand meaning, context, and nuance. I am assuming not.

Like I said in a previous post, it’s not rote learning. Hyperlexic/autistic kids are gestalt language processors, meaning they process words as a whole rather than in parts (as in phonics - phonics was pointless for my child!)

Whether they understand meaning and context depends whether they’re being given Peppa Pig or Harry Potter at 3 😄 Hyperlexia does go hand in hand with comprehension issues, because their ability to read words far exceeds their knowledge of what words mean. And this issue persists as they get older and the texts and comprehension exercises they’re given at school get more complex. You can imagine a literal thinker of an autistic kid finding it baffling to be given a question about subtext or something that isn’t explicitly written in the text.

Jellycats4life · 24/01/2023 09:08

VioletLemon · 24/01/2023 09:00

Love this. The 'taught himself to read at 2' stuff is rote learning, decoding that's all. Give the same 2 year old written questions they can 'read' using common 2, 3,4 or 5 letter words and it quickly becomes obvious the child cannot 'read' but they can decode, spot patterns, solve simple problems very easily.

It’s not rote learning. Well, hyperlexia isn’t. I don’t think anyone fully understands how these children learn to read at 2 or 3 (sometimes younger) but they do. But they are neurodivergent, and I always explain my son’s hyperlexia as a facet of his autistic brain.

My son was speech delayed and I didn’t know he could read until he started properly talking at 3.5+

I first thought that his “reading” was recognising letters and guessing, or recognising logos, but he once sat in the back of the car and read the name of the radio station from
the display. We would go to the supermarket and he’d be walking around reading the signs: “meat, fish, white bread” and street signs “why’s it London Road?”

He started school able to read all of the tricky words like where, were, there etc. What he never did was learn to count in six languages because I didn’t hothouse him.

KnittedCardi · 24/01/2023 09:04

I have a question. Is it a case of just learning patterns though? Do these children understand meaning, context, and nuance. I am assuming not.

TwoLeftSocksWithHoles · 24/01/2023 09:03

Sounds like a potential candidate for the next parliamentary election in two years. We could do with some brains in Government, and I'm pretty certain a five year could do it better.

Thepeopleversuswork · 24/01/2023 09:02

drummin · 24/01/2023 08:57

I think that if the story is on the back of a Mensa press release it is naive of the family to agree to it. Mensa is only intererested in promoting Mensa, to ensure self-preservation for an out-dated concept. Their entire ethos is based on the idea that clever people are somehow isolated and need help to find each other. They are very pre-internet (and their admin is very dated). One of my kids was a member for a year and it was a complete waste of money. He was sent some very niche and uninteresting newsletters and signed up for a Chess tournament that I had to withdraw him from because it would have involved us taking him (age 12) to the homes of adult strangers to play (which seemed daft when he can play chess online with people all over the world or in person with his friends at school).

Exactly. Mensa has its own reasons for wanting to promote its members and they have to do what they have to do but anyone allowing their (tiny) kid to be used as a promotional tool like this is either very vain or astonishingly naive.

That poor kid is now regarded as public property by the media (see also Ruth Laurence, James Harries) and his progress will be relentlessly monitored. And he can't really win. If he is successful he is likely to become very arrogant and distanced from his peers and struggle to maintain normal relationships. If he fails an exam or gets bullied at school or screws up, like most kids do at some point, the papers will pillory him for not being quite so clever as he was at two.

Poor little thing.

VioletLemon · 24/01/2023 09:00

ClareBlue · 23/01/2023 20:09

I mean all children are pretty much guiniuses. They learn highly complex manuvors to pivot a centre of gravity within a couple of centimeters whilst propelling forward backwards and sideway within a year or so of birth (walking) , learn a language in a couple of years, learn seriously complex mechanics like using a fork to move unfixed items to a set target, which it took years to invent a machine that could do similar, build up a huge database of sound, smell, face and taste recognition, developed understanding of complex social interactions, dangerous situations and fun situations. It's never ending their capacity. This lad has just done a couple of other things that are no more remarkable than what his peers have achieved at his age.

Love this. The 'taught himself to read at 2' stuff is rote learning, decoding that's all. Give the same 2 year old written questions they can 'read' using common 2, 3,4 or 5 letter words and it quickly becomes obvious the child cannot 'read' but they can decode, spot patterns, solve simple problems very easily.

drummin · 24/01/2023 08:57

I think that if the story is on the back of a Mensa press release it is naive of the family to agree to it. Mensa is only intererested in promoting Mensa, to ensure self-preservation for an out-dated concept. Their entire ethos is based on the idea that clever people are somehow isolated and need help to find each other. They are very pre-internet (and their admin is very dated). One of my kids was a member for a year and it was a complete waste of money. He was sent some very niche and uninteresting newsletters and signed up for a Chess tournament that I had to withdraw him from because it would have involved us taking him (age 12) to the homes of adult strangers to play (which seemed daft when he can play chess online with people all over the world or in person with his friends at school).

Thehop · 24/01/2023 08:52

Jellycats4life · 23/01/2023 17:52

I would be going for an autism assessment, not a Mensa assessment, but hey ho.

Self-taught precocious reading is hyperlexia and most hyperlexics are autistic, just before anyone jumps on me.

This, 100%

VioletLemon · 24/01/2023 08:50

Jellycats4life · 23/01/2023 17:52

I would be going for an autism assessment, not a Mensa assessment, but hey ho.

Self-taught precocious reading is hyperlexia and most hyperlexics are autistic, just before anyone jumps on me.

Hyperlexia commonly found in ASD. Can't understand how this is MENSA membership is in any way helpful for this child. This child will likely need significant support with social aspects in life in order to happily manage relationships and school.

nolongersurprised · 24/01/2023 08:48

AreOttersJustWetCats · 24/01/2023 08:20

Precisely. No sensible parent wants their child splashed over the front pages at such a young age, imo. That's not "down to earth" or caring behaviour, and the child can't consent to it.

It never seems to end well when a child is publicly celebrated for being precocious in a particular area, whether it be sport, academic prowess, any random hobby.

The media loves precocious children but no one cares when they’re adults. Unfortunately, their identity is formed around their early talent.

Nurturing your child’s talent as a family/parent is one thing, splashing it over the media is another

Squamata · 24/01/2023 08:46

He needs a challenge and counting, learning languages is obviously something he enjoys so I don't see the harm.

Quite how mensa membership or a press release to the national newspapers benefits him, I don't know!

HRTQueen · 24/01/2023 08:46

Fizbosshoes · 24/01/2023 07:50

He's probably quite average compared to the typical MN child! 😄

😆

drummin · 24/01/2023 08:44

^ And, I should have made clear, it's a comprehensive school!

drummin · 24/01/2023 08:40

Mensa is a joke. To qualify for membership you need to score in the top 2% in their self-defined IQ tests. My children's school enables students to do the test each year if they want to, and more than 10% of the school population score in the "top 2%". Most don't bother to join because it's expensive, geeky and doesn't give you much for your money other than opportunities to network with other people in the "top 2%". They can do that every day at school!

FatGirlSwim · 24/01/2023 08:35

Jellycats4life · 23/01/2023 17:52

I would be going for an autism assessment, not a Mensa assessment, but hey ho.

Self-taught precocious reading is hyperlexia and most hyperlexics are autistic, just before anyone jumps on me.

I was going to say this. My dc could read at two. Autistic. They are fairly bright now at 16 but not a genius.

I think hyperlexia implies lack of understanding and my dc did understand the content. Remember them reading Stig of the Dump begore they started reception. But they are by no means a genius. Apparently I was the same (also autistic).

BigMadAdrian · 24/01/2023 08:31

Legrandetraitor · 23/01/2023 20:21

There is an overlap between genius and autistic traits, the reasoning is different. Doesn’t make someone autistic.

Where is that from, out of interest?

Two of my dc are diagnosed with autism and would be better described by the right hand column (although some stuff from the left applies too). They are definitely autistic, but are also intelligent.

I was hyperlexic and am almost certainly autistic too.

AreOttersJustWetCats · 24/01/2023 08:20

Thepeopleversuswork · 24/01/2023 08:17

I think you are getting the wrong end of the stick: I don’t think people have a problem with the parents seeking help from Mensa. What some people think is very foolish is to have this little boy splashed all over the newspapers.

Precisely. No sensible parent wants their child splashed over the front pages at such a young age, imo. That's not "down to earth" or caring behaviour, and the child can't consent to it.

Thepeopleversuswork · 24/01/2023 08:17

ClearRunning · 23/01/2023 20:16

Yes, the mum sounds nice. Another judgy OP, she doesn’t know this family. 🙄
I imagine it’s very difficult to know what to do for the best if your child is this intelligent and is very different from others their age. Best not to judge.

I think you are getting the wrong end of the stick: I don’t think people have a problem with the parents seeking help from Mensa. What some people think is very foolish is to have this little boy splashed all over the newspapers.

Swipe left for the next trending thread