Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to want to know about DP finances?

56 replies

purplepencilcase · 23/01/2023 10:10

But if perspective please ladies!

We've been together for 16 years, three children, I'm completely financially independent in that I ask absolutely nothing of him, I pay for myself and the children, all school fees and childcare, sports, clubs, family car, family food etc he pays the modest mortgage and most (again modest) bills.

He is self employed and about 2 months ago I went on his phone (in an attempt to help him!) and totted up his debts as he has a lot on credit cards. I was shocked to find that he owes about £40k on credit cards.

He has locked me out of his phone since.

I've never seen a bank statement of his after 16 years together. I have no idea really what his finances look like.

We are not married and I have no plans to.

AIBU to think it's normal to share financial information between long term partners?

I'm just sad really that he doesn't think it's important that I have some reassurance that he's ok financially.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Hillarious · 23/01/2023 16:00

A misalignment of your finances isn't a problem, if you're both open about where you are financially and work together as a team to raise your family. Sounds like you have enough money together to do that. He just needs to be more open and trusting with you, and not feel affronted if you're in the fortunate position of earning enough to be the main breadwinner and can afford to buy the family a home.

Overthebow · 23/01/2023 15:56

I pay for myself and the children, all school fees and childcare, sports, clubs, family car, family food etc he pays the modest mortgage and most (again modest) bills.

Your DP is a low earner, why is he paying the lions share of the essentials?

From your OP, DH pays rent and bills, all essential. You pay for childcare, car and food which are essential. The rest is your lifestyle choice. It sounds like as a family you can't actually afford the lifestyle choices you are making, if he is running up debt to pay for rent and bills.

You need to sit down together and work out the costs of the essentials, and split it proportionately to what you earn. What's left can be spent on the luxuries, and if there isn't enough then you need to cut back.

Paq · 23/01/2023 15:36

@FloydPepper in this case it's the opposite, the lower earner driving the secrecy. It's probably better to focus on supporting the OP than checking on any equity across various mumsnet threads.

FloydPepper · 23/01/2023 15:09

Paq · 23/01/2023 12:10

@FloydPepper but he has been incredibly secretive from OP, she only knows about the debt because she saw it on his phone and now he won't talk about it.

I have every sympathy for farmers but OP should not be using her income, savings and the future financial security of her and their children to prop up a failing business. Where does it end? When they are both penniless?

But there have been posts on here from women who have run up secret debts due to their higher earning partner not sharing money with them. They are always told it was not their fault, it was their partners.

i though higher earning partners should “prop up” lower earning ones? Why is that not the case here. It sounds like the partner works very hard, does not spend on themselves, and is in debt due to “paying their share”

GabriellaMontez · 23/01/2023 12:51

He's not your partner. Thank god he's not your husband.

Your plans and lives don't seem to align.

Do you actually even like him? Do you want to spend you life with him?

MRex · 23/01/2023 12:48

It sounds very frustrating, running up debt is the sort of thing that needs discussion because it becomes a household matter. I'd sit down and explain that you two need a long-term plan, and you're there to help not criticise, but there may be compromises so that as a family you have security.

Is he claiming all the subsidies available to him? Basic Payment Scheme, Farming Investment Scheme, Countryside Stewardship etc? Can he change the type of farming to something with higher income or subsidies? What if you bought a farm so you own the house and land but he can farm it, getting income at least from Countryside Stewardship etc?

yousmellnice · 23/01/2023 12:36

I would genuinely leave and buy a house for you and the kids. You've done well to afford that without him

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 23/01/2023 12:35

Obviously you can post as much as you want! I just thought, this one sounds familiar.

And with the added context, my view is that while yes I'd expect my partner to be open with me about finances, him doing that would still be something of a sticking plaster here. The problems go way deeper. He's never shown any indication that he's willing to put farming lower on the priority list than you, providing for his kids or purchasing a home. You knowing exactly what his cash situation is wouldn't change that.

Quiettiger · 23/01/2023 12:34

purplepencilcase · 23/01/2023 10:44

His point of view is that our lifestyle is MY choice, and if I want it, I need to pay for it. We'd be on the breadline otherwise and I genuinely think he'd be ok with that, his parents were quite poor.

I'm guessing from the way you describe things, you're living with a farmer on an AHA tenancy. I'm not in the least surprised that he has that level of debt, given the state of farming and also the way banks behave with tenant farmers. I'm also not surprised at his attitude if he inherited the tenancy from his parents.

I know of what I speak, I'm married to a 3rd generation tenant farmer. The difference is, I run the business and the finances so I'm aware of everything regarding our farm business and I manage it. My income, like yours, pays for most stuff. Our farm business is sketchy at best because of costs and margins. Having said that, that state of play is also the case for many farmers who own their ground. But that's a whole different discussion.

My personal feeling is that if you want to stay with your DP, you let him just run the farm. Keep his finances as far as possible away from yours and keep an escape fund in case it all goes tits up and you have to move/split up. In the meantime, you're going to have to reconcile with the fact that it's your money paying for the "luxuries".

Is it right? No. But unless you're going to leave him, you're not going to be able to change very much because the situation with him won't change. Should he give you access to his finances? Yes, but it sounds like he's not going to. And the mindset is entrenched. It won't be just him. I know of several farmers in their 40's and 50's who still aren't allowed to make financial business decisions because their father or mother (who is by now utterly geriatric) won't relinquish the cheque book. They also hate spending money.

And farmers can be some of the most stubborn people on the planet. If the farm business is failing, don't get mired into bailing the business out, make sure your money/finances are secure and you can get out relatively unscathed if you need to.

ProudToBeANorthener · 23/01/2023 12:33

If he’s a tenant farmer anywhere it’s hard to make a decent living. If you buy from supermarkets you are the primary reason for this as their buying power scr*ws farmers for every last drop
Misses point of thread completely 🫣🤷‍♀️

purplepencilcase · 23/01/2023 12:31

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 23/01/2023 12:07

OP have you posted about this before?

Yes I have. It's a recurring issue for us. I'm sorry.

OP posts:
purplepencilcase · 23/01/2023 12:30

Bobshhh · 23/01/2023 12:18

Haven't you posted about him before and buying a house and he wouldn't agree to one?

Yes I have. Still all unresolved!!

OP posts:
Bobshhh · 23/01/2023 12:18

Haven't you posted about him before and buying a house and he wouldn't agree to one?

Paq · 23/01/2023 12:10

@FloydPepper but he has been incredibly secretive from OP, she only knows about the debt because she saw it on his phone and now he won't talk about it.

I have every sympathy for farmers but OP should not be using her income, savings and the future financial security of her and their children to prop up a failing business. Where does it end? When they are both penniless?

GirlsNightOut33 · 23/01/2023 12:08

what's his plan longer term?

he can't farm forever.

and in the meantime he's basically been living on subsistence wages, while not paying a fair share towards FAMILY costs (e.g. DC costs etc).

what happens if he has an acccident?
ill?
old?

One or more of them WILL happen.

What's his backup plan for WHEN it happens?

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 23/01/2023 12:07

OP have you posted about this before?

Irishfarmer · 23/01/2023 11:51

@mrsm43s I don't know their situation but if they are tenants on the farm it is possible the rent for the farm house is very low. It's the huge debt with on credit cards I'd be concerned about. What will they have to show for it.

purplepencilcase · 23/01/2023 11:40

FloydPepper · 23/01/2023 11:25

I do wonder if this thread would feel a bit different if he posted. He works hard and doent earn much. He pays (his fair share) all the rent and has so little left over he’s now in debt from making ends meet. He can’t spend on himself, clothes etc.

you pay (your fair share) and have enough left over to have saved enough for a house. However his finances are his problem (he won’t talk out of shame). You won’t share.

I think if he posted as a woman he’d get some interesting advice

Thanks for this perspective- I'm very aware of the complexities of being the female breadwinner. It's very complex!

OP posts:
Snoken · 23/01/2023 11:28

I don't see the point of renting a farm that leaves you dept each month. It would be one thing if he owned it and there is at least something there for your kids to inherit. As it stands it's just a money pit and once he gets too old to run it he will be asked to leave one way or another.

FloydPepper · 23/01/2023 11:25

I do wonder if this thread would feel a bit different if he posted. He works hard and doent earn much. He pays (his fair share) all the rent and has so little left over he’s now in debt from making ends meet. He can’t spend on himself, clothes etc.

you pay (your fair share) and have enough left over to have saved enough for a house. However his finances are his problem (he won’t talk out of shame). You won’t share.

I think if he posted as a woman he’d get some interesting advice

mrsm43s · 23/01/2023 11:23

Why is everyone saying he's not contributing?

He pays the rent in full and the bills in full. OP doesn't pay at all towards rent or household bills. She has all her money available for extras and nice to haves. If she's choosing stuff like private education, then it's not unreasonable for her to pay for it, as her DP is fully covering the household rent and bills.

He's contributing well.

I agree the secrecy and lack of transparency isn't good, and they don't seem to be working as a team.

Calmdown14 · 23/01/2023 11:22

Would he open up more if you presented it as 'do you want me to help make sure you are paying it off in the best way to help you reduce interest rates, do you know about snowballing etc'? Or I want to help you secure the future of the farm.

I think your set up is different to most but your circumstances are also quite unique.

In this scenario not being married is to your advantage . He probably wants to pretend it's not there more than he wants to cut you out

SnackyOnassis · 23/01/2023 11:14

OP, this must make you feel awful. Not least the secrecy and the shutting you down when you try to fix the family financial situation, but the fact that he thinks the breadline is good enough for your children, and for you.
While he might accept that for himself, I'd struggle to find patience to build a life with someone who thinks my children should have a shit life, or at least one without the advantages of the little bit of cushioning a safe income can bring.

Lcb123 · 23/01/2023 11:13

That seems very strange to me. I don’t know about every transaction DH makes (and I don’t care) but I know an overview of his savings and credit card. Same for me. Definitely don’t buy a house with his name on the deeds as well

KettrickenSmiled · 23/01/2023 11:10

purplepencilcase · 23/01/2023 10:44

His point of view is that our lifestyle is MY choice, and if I want it, I need to pay for it. We'd be on the breadline otherwise and I genuinely think he'd be ok with that, his parents were quite poor.

What?

He reckons he had nothing to do with creating 3 DC?

Why are you still with the selfish, secretive arse?