Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is the WHOLE POINT of tax?

361 replies

wheresmymojo · 23/01/2023 09:41

Daily Fail are frothing today that higher earners pay more tax, and lower earners get more out in various benefits than they pay in.

I thought even the DF understood that the entire point of tax, it's whole reason for existing, is to re-distribute wealth to some extent with the wealthier paying more so that the less wealthy can benefit from a better standard of living?

Have I missed something - are there people who don't know this is what tax is fundamentally supposed to do?

I mean, I'm being fairly genuine...are there actually people who think it's like a bank account and you 'pay in' to 'get out'?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
MelroseGrainger · 23/01/2023 11:45

MrsSkylerWhite · 23/01/2023 09:43

You’re not wrong.

I do find it alarming though that 36 million people are receiving more from the state than they’re paying in contributions. That, clearly, can’t continue, just can’t be sustained.

Wages need to be set at a realistic level, so people don’t need state top ups just to survive.

See, this is why no-one should rely on the awful writers at the Daily Mail for facts. It isn’t half of the whole population, it’s half of the people who receive money from the state, surely?

Underhisi · 23/01/2023 11:45

"I was talking to a man the o week who was determined to stay below a certain income so he could retain the benefits he gets for his (dubiously diagnosed) autistic child, which included an annual holiday.

You do not get a free annual holiday for having an autistic child. My child has been diagnosed for 12 years and we have never had one.
There are charities that offer funding towards holidays for disabled children but you do not need to be on a very low income to qualify.

Blossomtoes · 23/01/2023 11:45

I think I’m worse because I’ve been in poverty myself, and I felt a duty to not be and so made the changes I needed to make.

Me too. That made me more empathetic towards people worse off than me. It’s a shame it didn’t work that way for you.

edwinbear · 23/01/2023 11:44

You can't be handing a huge amount of your earnings over to the government if you can afford private school for multiple dc. Just saying

I can, because I work in a well paid job, pay the tax it attracts and have enough left over to pay school fees. DH's salary covers the rest of the bills. However, it's getting to the point where it's not worth doing that anymore. If the 20% VAT come in for example, at that point I would question whether DC's school is worth it. I suspect not, so we may well move them to state, I can then quit my job as we won't have to pay fees anymore and we can live off DH's income. And the state both loses my tax contribution and has to pay £14k pa to educate my DC.

Regardless of the ethics around state/private school, the state will be in a net loss position in the above scenario as a direct result of over taxing.

Cuppasoupmonster · 23/01/2023 11:44

I think British people have been insulated from the realities of global competition and the need to achieve economic growth for so long that it is now seen as the enemy. Business and profit are seen as the enemy of the people when infact it is our best hope of increasing the prosperity of our country and therefore population.

This!

Slowingdownagain · 23/01/2023 11:44

wow, 36m. That's a lot of people.

I actually don't think it's a very fair system. Yes, people who earn more should pay more, but given the scale of the issue it seems like they are just propping up a poorly functioning economy. The focus should be on improving wages, education, health and living standards so that less people need quite so much propping up and so everyone can enjoy better services.

I am a net contributor, paying far more tax than what I get in return. I am ok with that generally because I believe in the concept of a welfare state (btw, it's not redstribution of wealth, which is something else). However when I look at my tax bill and then the state of the public economy I sometimes get annoyed. Not at the users of public services, but rather the systemic mismanagement of public finances and resulting awful services. I pay £10s of thousands a year in tax but can't see a GP for example, it's hard not to feel like the cost benefit analysis isn't a good one, and you have to remind yourself of the "wider public good" argument. The issue is when that wider public good doesn't seem to be very good either - I can't get a GP appointment, and children are literally starving down the road. Where is the money going?

Squamata · 23/01/2023 11:44

Do they include pensions in that? The state pension is a benefit, and by far the biggest chunk of the benefits budget.

People who are on benefits are very often in work as well. It's not like they're sitting around.

Bumpitybumper · 23/01/2023 11:42

QuertyGirl · 23/01/2023 11:26

If our taxes are so burdensome on high earners, you have to wonder why they stay here.

Is it because you like having a (previously at least) well run, stable society, reasonable infrastructure etc?

How do you think we achieve that?

This has been achieved through investing in public services through a combination of taxation and economic growth, not through taxation alone.

If the economy grows then there is more money around so taxation levels can stay the same but the government will raise more money as GDP has increased. When the economy is stagnant (or worse contracting) then it is much harder to increase tax revenue. Add to this that more people will be in need of state assistance and you have a pretty terrible situation.

I think British people have been insulated from the realities of global competition and the need to achieve economic growth for so long that it is now seen as the enemy. Business and profit are seen as the enemy of the people when infact it is our best hope of increasing the prosperity of our country and therefore population. We need a strong economy with enterprise and entrepreneurial spirit. We need to incentivise people to start businesses, innovate and be more productive. There has to be some kind of reward for hard work and taking risks, otherwise it just pushes people towards working the minimum and topping up on state benefits.

You rarely see anyone on MN suggest that someone working minimum hours in a job below their capability and topping up on state benefits has any responsibility to further themselves. Instead, it's the system's fault for being set up wrong and encouraging such behaviour. Yet when reform of the system is suggested then it is viewed as an attack on the poor who are dependent on the state through no fault of their own.

Riu · 23/01/2023 11:42

Lots of people don’t have a clue about tax. Many seem to think money comes from the government (don’t know where they think the government gets it from) and that lots of stuff, like health care and education, is actually free. They feel sorry for people in other countries because operations, drugs and doctors etc. actually cost money abroad. No wonder they worship the nhs for its miraculous free treatment.

Cormick · 23/01/2023 11:42

There’s a name for that too…..communism

Yes.

WillTimeCome · 23/01/2023 11:42

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Oh dear someone is feeling bitter and unloved. The "for his (dubiously diagnosed) autistic child" comment is totally uncalled for and out of order.

Wheretheskyisblue · 23/01/2023 11:41

MrsSkylerWhite · 23/01/2023 09:43

You’re not wrong.

I do find it alarming though that 36 million people are receiving more from the state than they’re paying in contributions. That, clearly, can’t continue, just can’t be sustained.

Wages need to be set at a realistic level, so people don’t need state top ups just to survive.

Given that 11m people are retired, 14m are aged under 18 and 15m have a disability the figure of 36m taking out more than they are putting in is not surprising at all.

The aging population coupled with AI and resultant changes to the labour market will mean we will reach a stage where the proportion taking out more than they put in climbs even higher. I expect at some point we will need more wealth taxes and a universal basic income.

hamstersarse · 23/01/2023 11:41

Since 2019 there have been 24 tax rises. They can’t keep doing this, especially when you see how many people are not paying tax.

I’m truly done with ‘being empathetic’ to people less well off. I think I’m worse because I’ve been in poverty myself, and I felt a duty to not be and so made the changes I needed to make. The ‘old rich’ I know are still much nicer about it than I am.

What I resent most is this constant cry of ‘tax the rich’ as if it’s a solution to this. Sure, just basically steal/force more money off people and then piss it up the wall. It’ll never be enough tax for some people until there is no such thing as a rich person. There’s a name for that too…..communism

Wookiebowl · 23/01/2023 11:39

MrsSkylerWhite · 23/01/2023 11:32

The idea that only higher rate tax payers “work their arses off” is very blinkered.

We are higher rate tax payers. Lots of lower rate/non-tax paying employees work considerably harder than we do. We relied upon them during the pandemic too, as we worked from home.

The poster said they worked their arse off to get where they are, the vast majority of higher rate tax payers will have indeed worked hard to get a well paid job- more so than someone who works at an entry level job. Unless we are seriously saying that highly skilled jobs that require extensive education and/or experience are as easy to get a job in as an entry level role, does anyone believe this?

This isn't to say in any way, shape or form that those in these lower paid roles don't work hard, nor is it a commentary on their value as a human, but how have we reached the point where logic is considered controversial?

Blossomtoes · 23/01/2023 11:39

MrsSkylerWhite · 23/01/2023 11:16

No, it isn’t nonsense. Our ageing population is a time bomb.

Our young people work, hard, as do their peer groups.

It’s a time bomb that’s been coming for 70 years and for which successive governments of both parties have failed to prepare. That’s one of the main problems with our politics, everything is short term.

QuertyGirl · 23/01/2023 11:37

ThighMistress · 23/01/2023 11:34

@QuertyGirl - you illustrate my point. “High earners” is who? Those on £60k +? Do you honestly believe that all those people could up sticks and move abroad? Where on earth to? Who is going to employ them? Ridiculous!

Why not? People do it on far less.

MrsSkylerWhite · 23/01/2023 11:35

Take away the 12.4 million people who are in receipt of the state pension which is classed as a benefit by DWP, then that number reduces quite a bit ?“

The state pension is a benefit, though?

I have no issue whatsoever with paying higher rate taxes. What I do take issue with is people in full time work having to seek state top ups because they can’t survive to a basic level on their wages.
Employers, including the Government, in the Uk have gotten away with shoddy practice for far too long.

RenegadeMrs · 23/01/2023 11:34

KnittedCardi · 23/01/2023 11:30

Inheritance tax absolutly should exist. Wealth in accumulated property and pensions is one of the biggest reasons we have such a huge disparity in wealth between the top 10% and the rest in this country

But most people who accumulate large pensions and property use it to fund elderly care these days. Not that many people pass on great wealth, and as the years go by, and more and more people live longer, that wealth will gradually disappear.

Well if it's spent inheritance tax wouldn't apply.

We are in this situation with my grandmother. Any savings she had are gone to care home fees, but the fact is that the wealthiest are not. And so they should pay inheritance tax.

Dymaxion · 23/01/2023 11:34

Add onto that another 3 million who might also be recieving carers allowance and pension credit and that brings the figure closer to 15 million people.

ThighMistress · 23/01/2023 11:34

@QuertyGirl - you illustrate my point. “High earners” is who? Those on £60k +? Do you honestly believe that all those people could up sticks and move abroad? Where on earth to? Who is going to employ them? Ridiculous!

Dymaxion · 23/01/2023 11:32

I do find it alarming though that 36 million people are receiving more from the state than they’re paying in contributions. That, clearly, can’t continue, just can’t be sustained.

Take away the 12.4 million people who are in receipt of the state pension which is classed as a benefit by DWP, then that number reduces quite a bit ?

MrsSkylerWhite · 23/01/2023 11:32

The idea that only higher rate tax payers “work their arses off” is very blinkered.

We are higher rate tax payers. Lots of lower rate/non-tax paying employees work considerably harder than we do. We relied upon them during the pandemic too, as we worked from home.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 23/01/2023 11:32

i worked my arse off to be a higher tax payer, but I am now at the point of total resentment for the con of it all.

So quit and take a minimum wage job. There is a desperate shortage of carers.

Every single higher rate tax payer relies on low paid staff to do their job. If you want to pay less tax, campaign for higher minimum wage, lower house prices and rent caps so that the government doesn't need to top up so much.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 23/01/2023 11:32

Daily Fail is ridiculous

But I agree with a pp that another way to do it is make wages higher through minimum wage requirements, so that people do need “top ups” so much, and the wealthiest few wouldn’t be making so much more than the average person.

Thats actually the more honest way to do to too, with fewer get outs and loopholes, so the Fail would like it even less

Cuppasoupmonster · 23/01/2023 11:31

But most people who accumulate large pensions and property use it to fund elderly care these days. Not that many people pass on great wealth, and as the years go by, and more and more people live longer, that wealth will gradually disappear.

Some do, a lot don’t - they just stay put and rely on A&E as an emergency carer’s service then end up bed blocking.