Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is the WHOLE POINT of tax?

361 replies

wheresmymojo · 23/01/2023 09:41

Daily Fail are frothing today that higher earners pay more tax, and lower earners get more out in various benefits than they pay in.

I thought even the DF understood that the entire point of tax, it's whole reason for existing, is to re-distribute wealth to some extent with the wealthier paying more so that the less wealthy can benefit from a better standard of living?

Have I missed something - are there people who don't know this is what tax is fundamentally supposed to do?

I mean, I'm being fairly genuine...are there actually people who think it's like a bank account and you 'pay in' to 'get out'?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
roselune · 23/01/2023 12:17

The worst part is that some people get more on benefits (not working) than others who are working on a lower income earn but the workers are not entitled to any help. I'm in that group and losing so much of my income to taxes and NI when my bills are going up is very frustrating.

edwinbear · 23/01/2023 12:09

At @Slowingdownagain I completely respect people with that view and understand it. And if it was that in isolation and DC are in the middle of exam years, I guess we'd suck it up until they are through them. But, it feels we're being asked to potentially also pay one off wealth taxes/higher income taxes on top.

I think the marginal rate of tax when people lose their child benefit is even high, someone will know the figures better than me but I think it worked out at about 70-80% or something for going over that 50% threshold.

MrsSkylerWhite · 23/01/2023 12:09

Please note: we do not swing our cats 😁

MrsSkylerWhite · 23/01/2023 12:09

socialmedia23

can I add flats that aren’t rabbit hutches for older people needing to downsize from family homes but who would still like the much reduced in number rooms to be large enough to swing their cats.
developers seem to think all retirees just want to sit in a chair looking out of a window all day.

MarshaBradyo · 23/01/2023 12:09

edwinbear · 23/01/2023 11:57

@Slowingdownagain I understand the argument and why people feel that way re the ethics. But the net result to me and fellow private school users is the same - we hand over more of our income in tax, after already handing over up to 60% of it. And the suggestions are that on top of that, we should also pay wealth taxes on our homes/pensions. I'm well paid and grateful for it, but I don't have an unlimited pot of money and there comes a tipping point where you have to question whether it wouldn't be better to go PT, take a lower paying job and get better 'value' for the contribution you make.

There is a point where you can’t extract ever more. I know on many threads the answer is ‘tax them more’ but it’s usually not the person suggesting it paying.

Tax burden falls mostly to top centiles I’m ok with that and wouldn’t change much - more or less

QuertyGirl · 23/01/2023 12:08

Do people know what happens when you cut the incomes of the lower paid?

To society?

I do. You won't like it

socialmedia23 · 23/01/2023 12:06

Badbadbunny · 23/01/2023 12:03

The main thing is to control house prices and rents.

They'll just rise if benefits or minimum wage rises, so people would end up no better off. That's just basic economics of supply and demand. It's where Gordon Brown went wrong with his tax credits - it fuelled house price and rent inflation as people could afford to pay more!

So, before we even start to think about increasing wages or benefits, we need to have rent and house price controls so that people can actually benefit from their increased income, and for it not just to be eaten up in housing costs.

house price and rent controls don't work as they would just restrict supply for newcomers. Existing tenants would benefit from rent controls but very difficult for new people finding a property as existing tenants would cling onto their new property. Few developers would build if there was a cap on housing price.

What is needed is to increase supply and to ensure that new properties are going to people who need them rather the sons and daughters of the rich, the state should build housing. lots of them. For the poor and middle income who find it difficult to buy on the private market.

Slowingdownagain · 23/01/2023 12:05

edwinbear · 23/01/2023 11:57

@Slowingdownagain I understand the argument and why people feel that way re the ethics. But the net result to me and fellow private school users is the same - we hand over more of our income in tax, after already handing over up to 60% of it. And the suggestions are that on top of that, we should also pay wealth taxes on our homes/pensions. I'm well paid and grateful for it, but I don't have an unlimited pot of money and there comes a tipping point where you have to question whether it wouldn't be better to go PT, take a lower paying job and get better 'value' for the contribution you make.

I can kind of see where you are coming from - I am a higher rate tax payer too, and although comfortable we are not rolling in money that we are dying to give away, and comment after comment about how rich we must be and therefore how much more we ought to contirbute without complaint is frustrating sometimes because although I am accutely aware of my privilege, that's just not the reality of it. However, the VAT of school fees I agree with because it's a policu question. They are businesses enjoying an, in my view, inaccurate classification as a charity. If Government want to ring fence them with their own tax exclusion then they ought to do that, not chuck them in with charities.

Badbadbunny · 23/01/2023 12:03

The main thing is to control house prices and rents.

They'll just rise if benefits or minimum wage rises, so people would end up no better off. That's just basic economics of supply and demand. It's where Gordon Brown went wrong with his tax credits - it fuelled house price and rent inflation as people could afford to pay more!

So, before we even start to think about increasing wages or benefits, we need to have rent and house price controls so that people can actually benefit from their increased income, and for it not just to be eaten up in housing costs.

PartyHelp · 23/01/2023 11:59

wheresmymojo · 23/01/2023 09:41

Daily Fail are frothing today that higher earners pay more tax, and lower earners get more out in various benefits than they pay in.

I thought even the DF understood that the entire point of tax, it's whole reason for existing, is to re-distribute wealth to some extent with the wealthier paying more so that the less wealthy can benefit from a better standard of living?

Have I missed something - are there people who don't know this is what tax is fundamentally supposed to do?

I mean, I'm being fairly genuine...are there actually people who think it's like a bank account and you 'pay in' to 'get out'?

I don't think most people, even higher tax payers, have a problem with this. I suppose maybe the higher tax payers, the businesses and the evil multinational corporations who pay all the tax to subsidise the majority of the population are pretty sick of the constant inference that the are evil and greedy and should be paying more taxes.

edwinbear · 23/01/2023 11:57

@Slowingdownagain I understand the argument and why people feel that way re the ethics. But the net result to me and fellow private school users is the same - we hand over more of our income in tax, after already handing over up to 60% of it. And the suggestions are that on top of that, we should also pay wealth taxes on our homes/pensions. I'm well paid and grateful for it, but I don't have an unlimited pot of money and there comes a tipping point where you have to question whether it wouldn't be better to go PT, take a lower paying job and get better 'value' for the contribution you make.

MrsSkylerWhite · 23/01/2023 11:57

Underhisi

“You do not get a free annual holiday for having an autistic child. My child has been diagnosed for 12 years and we have never had one.
There are charities that offer funding towards holidays for disabled children but you do not need to be on a very low income to qualify.”

Ah, but why let fact get in the way of a good anecdote?

socialmedia23 · 23/01/2023 11:54

Cormick · 23/01/2023 11:48

Many posters on here seem to expect the government to intervene in every aspect of their lives like they’re small children. They also expect everything to be free and if it isn’t ‘we’re not taxing the rich enough’.

Absolutely.

The problem is that now we are living in a country where a PA in a hedge fund (£90k) can earn more than a NHS doctor (£80k). The amount of money out there is stupendous. And few would share in it, as not everyone can work in a hedge fund! The rich would earn millions extra every year (there are people who believe that £300k is the break even income in London when the median salary in London is £41k); and the middle income would get a 5% rise so they would become poorer every year.

If the government does not intervene, no one can and this would mean everyone except the top 3% become poorer. It has gotten to the stage where it is more lucrative to be the door polisher for a hedge fund or bank than to work as a doctor, or civil servant, let alone carer or nurse.

Autumn54 · 23/01/2023 11:54

@purpledalmation it might be just my experience but I have found I see less people who just "don't work", than day 10 years ago. Everyone I know who doesn't work has either retired, has disability, or is a stay at home parent but the other partner works. It feels like we are working, harder and harder, doing more overtime, working second jobs, just to keep afloat. But like I say this could just be from my own personal experience and the people I have encountered.

MrsSkylerWhite · 23/01/2023 11:53

Wookiebowl · Today 11:39
MrsSkylerWhite · Today 11:32
The idea that only higher rate tax payers “work their arses off” is very blinkered.

We are higher rate tax payers. Lots of lower rate/non-tax paying employees work considerably harder than we do. We relied upon them during the pandemic too, as we worked from home.

“The poster said they worked their arse off to get where they are, the vast majority of higher rate tax payers will have indeed worked hard to get a well paid job- more so than someone who works at an entry level job.”

No. we’re in our late 50s and mid-60s. Both born into families in social housing. Free further education and living grants, an abundance of choice when we left and cheap housing, comparative to earnings and an awful lot of people fell into pretty cushy jobs because they were in the right place at the right time. I suppose we worked “hard” - including in the wine bar with clients at lunchtime - to the extent that our abilities made our employers a great deal of money (for which we were well rewarded) but there was nothing terribly taxing (pun not intended) about it.

Working life for our kids is considerably more demanding now. The opportunities that existed when we were young simply don’t any more, regulation in our industry (much needed) put paid to those. Fed up with hearing how lazy and feckless young people are today (not from you, from others). Working life for us when we started out was a blast, as it was for many of our generation. Sadly, lots seem to have forgotten that in the mists of time and remember it as “working their arses off”.

(I think the scenario is different, then and now, for the self-employed high rate tax payers, most of whom did/do indeed work their arses off).

RenegadeMrs · 23/01/2023 11:53

It’s been an interesting thread.

Benefits = bad, but pension = good, so pensions are not a benefit (except they are, and included in the figures as a benefit).

Wealth redistribution = bad, but provision of public services = good. Except public services, provided via taking wealth off person A to provide a service to the benefit of person B, are by their nature a redistribution of wealth?

dollymixtured · 23/01/2023 11:51

wheresmymojo · 23/01/2023 09:41

Daily Fail are frothing today that higher earners pay more tax, and lower earners get more out in various benefits than they pay in.

I thought even the DF understood that the entire point of tax, it's whole reason for existing, is to re-distribute wealth to some extent with the wealthier paying more so that the less wealthy can benefit from a better standard of living?

Have I missed something - are there people who don't know this is what tax is fundamentally supposed to do?

I mean, I'm being fairly genuine...are there actually people who think it's like a bank account and you 'pay in' to 'get out'?

I would fundamentally disagree with you regarding the purpose of tax. I believe that tax should be gathered to allow governments to provide services that could not easily or practically be financed on an individual basis, such as defence, road building etc I certainly don’t think they should be a means to redistribute money from one group in society to another other than to provide a safety net and support for those unable to support themselves.

Slowingdownagain · 23/01/2023 11:50

Cuppasoupmonster · 23/01/2023 11:47

The focus should be on improving wages, education, health and living standards so that less people need quite so much propping up and so everyone can enjoy better services.

The problem is though the bigger the state, the more people come to rely on it and the more propping up they need.

Many posters on here seem to expect the government to intervene in every aspect of their lives like they’re small children. They also expect everything to be free and if it isn’t ‘we’re not taxing the rich enough’.

I think it's likely an evil cycle though. People feel disenfranchised. They expect the government to help because they can't get help elsewhere, and they can't get the money to help themselves. I agree that taxing more isn't necessarily the answe,r which is why I said we should focus on improving the situation for those who can't earn a wage they can live on. People want help feeding their kids, because their kids are starving in one of the richest economies in the world. Pay them better so they can feed their own kids and they don't have taht issue.

Lozzybear · 23/01/2023 11:50

I’m in the same scenario as Edwinbear…I know from my DC’s school that there are a lot of other families in the same position. I’m also getting to the point where I am tempted to throw the towel in and become a net beneficiary rather than a net contributor. Even more so after reading this thread where apparently other people in the company I work for are propping up my salary. There’s only one person in my company that does my job - ME!! I have no support whatsoever apart from the very occasional IT help desk. I save my company huge sums of money my reducing risk for them. With that comes massive responsibility.

Blossomtoes · 23/01/2023 11:50

Make me pay a one off tax on the value of my pension

Really? When did that start? Of course all your pension contributions are tax free or had you forgotten that?

Cormick · 23/01/2023 11:48

Many posters on here seem to expect the government to intervene in every aspect of their lives like they’re small children. They also expect everything to be free and if it isn’t ‘we’re not taxing the rich enough’.

Absolutely.

Overthebow · 23/01/2023 11:48

Throwncrumbs · 23/01/2023 10:16

I did work extra hours to earn more money as when my kids were younger there was no UC, as a single mum in the 80’s there was no childcare element, I worked and got no help from the government whatsoever, if I wanted or needed it I worked, it was bloody hard but I had to house, clothe and feed my child by myself. It’s what you had to do. I bettered myself, and eventually bought a house, no one was going to give me one! People nowadays expect everything given to them instead of working long hours for it, then playing the blame game!

I agree with this. I see this attitude on here a lot, not wanting to work more as they will only be marginally better off. This attitude needs to change, people should be working and paying for their lives themselves with UC when they really need it, not sitting in UC not taking extra hours. The system really needs to change to stop this being able to happen.

Cuppasoupmonster · 23/01/2023 11:47

The focus should be on improving wages, education, health and living standards so that less people need quite so much propping up and so everyone can enjoy better services.

The problem is though the bigger the state, the more people come to rely on it and the more propping up they need.

Many posters on here seem to expect the government to intervene in every aspect of their lives like they’re small children. They also expect everything to be free and if it isn’t ‘we’re not taxing the rich enough’.

Slowingdownagain · 23/01/2023 11:46

edwinbear · 23/01/2023 11:25

@hamstersarse I agree with you completely. I pay 45% tax, in fact I pay 60% tax on part of my income. That's OK, I understand why and happy to pay. But, on top of what I already pay, suggestions being thrown about to get more out of me are:

Pay 20% VAT on DC's school fees (as well as continue paying for state education I don't use)
Cap my ISA allowance to £100k
Make me pay a one off tax on the value of my house
Make me pay a one off tax on the value of my pension
Increase my income tax to over 50% (some suggestions I should pay 80%)
Pay for any NHS healthcare (I already have private healthcare for major issues but do use my GP)

There comes a point where I might as well just hand over 100% of my earnings to the Government. Although I think even taxing the top 10% of earners at 100% still wouldn't be sufficient to fund everything everyone wants the state to pay.

The private school thing is different though. They get the exemption because they qualify as a charity. Despite not really doing anything charitable (except maybe lending out their pool to the local comp 2 hrs a week at a reduced rate, and a couple of bursarys) and are in fact a business. It's not a VAT discount because you save the state in school costs. I have private health insurance, should I get a discount on my NI contributions?

Cormick · 23/01/2023 11:46

Bumpitybumper. Good post.