Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is the WHOLE POINT of tax?

361 replies

wheresmymojo · 23/01/2023 09:41

Daily Fail are frothing today that higher earners pay more tax, and lower earners get more out in various benefits than they pay in.

I thought even the DF understood that the entire point of tax, it's whole reason for existing, is to re-distribute wealth to some extent with the wealthier paying more so that the less wealthy can benefit from a better standard of living?

Have I missed something - are there people who don't know this is what tax is fundamentally supposed to do?

I mean, I'm being fairly genuine...are there actually people who think it's like a bank account and you 'pay in' to 'get out'?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
orangeoyster · 23/01/2023 13:24

Slowingdownagain · 23/01/2023 12:38

So what's the solution if you don't want to increase taxes on the higher earners and you don't want the lower earners to earn more or be able to have more affordable lifestyles? Just let the poor be poor? Sod them and grabbiness?

You will never not have 'the poor' as a section of society.
Even if you gave everyone £1m tomorrow, you would still have a class of 'poor' people after a year.

Taxing the rich is pointless as an endeavour. You could confiscate the assets of the entire Times rich list and it wouldn't change anything in the long run - the sums of money p*ssed up the wall every year by governments are just too massive.

Blossomtoes · 23/01/2023 13:24

Throwncrumbs · 23/01/2023 13:21

Back in the 80s a woman who lived next door to me on benefits with two kids told me she had an annual holiday paid for to visit her family in Trinidad and Tobago, she came back once pregnant with a 3rd child she started to get benefits for… explain this!

The explanation is that it never happened.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 23/01/2023 13:22

I've done minimum wage jobs when I was 19/20 and doing my degree, I had a room in a shared halls then lived at home. I didn't expect that minimum wage job to support a family which is what is happening with universal credit top ups etc.

Yes, but there are too many minimum wage / low paid jobs that need doing. There isn't enough young people to do them all - particularly care work. So either those jobs become higher paid or the people doing them get government top ups.

MarshaBradyo · 23/01/2023 13:22

Here is link for those upset benefits is looking high due to inclusion and it doesn’t fit their view.

If it’s an issue they’ll have to set up own source as ONS has a good reputation.

www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/personalandhouseholdfinances/incomeandwealth/bulletins/theeffectsoftaxesandbenefitsonhouseholdincome/financialyearending2021

MooseBreath · 23/01/2023 13:22

Until a standard full-time wage doesn't require top-up benefits or a food bank, people will be taking far more from taxes than they put in. The issue here is a low-wage economy where the average person cannot be a net contributor.

Throwncrumbs · 23/01/2023 13:21

Underhisi · 23/01/2023 11:45

"I was talking to a man the o week who was determined to stay below a certain income so he could retain the benefits he gets for his (dubiously diagnosed) autistic child, which included an annual holiday.

You do not get a free annual holiday for having an autistic child. My child has been diagnosed for 12 years and we have never had one.
There are charities that offer funding towards holidays for disabled children but you do not need to be on a very low income to qualify.

Back in the 80s a woman who lived next door to me on benefits with two kids told me she had an annual holiday paid for to visit her family in Trinidad and Tobago, she came back once pregnant with a 3rd child she started to get benefits for… explain this!

SleeplessInEngland · 23/01/2023 13:21

roarfeckingroarr · 23/01/2023 12:36

I mean, it's a bit nuts that so many posters talk about us being a "low tax country" when over half the country may as well not bother. There's such a culture of envy in this country and yet the richest pay such a huge percentage of everything in the public purse.

You're right, those poor fabulously wealthy rich people. I bet they'd trade places with the benefit scroungers in a hartbeat if they could.

Blossomtoes · 23/01/2023 13:19

Throwncrumbs · 23/01/2023 13:18

State pension is not a benefit, unless you have never worked in your life and at pension age you swap your UC for a pension, which is what is going to happen in the future!

It’s only comparatively recently that state pensions became labelled “benefits”. It’s political rhetoric.

Throwncrumbs · 23/01/2023 13:18

Squamata · 23/01/2023 11:44

Do they include pensions in that? The state pension is a benefit, and by far the biggest chunk of the benefits budget.

People who are on benefits are very often in work as well. It's not like they're sitting around.

State pension is not a benefit, unless you have never worked in your life and at pension age you swap your UC for a pension, which is what is going to happen in the future!

Slowingdownagain · 23/01/2023 13:17

Throwncrumbs · 23/01/2023 13:11

Young working people who can’t come here isn’t the problem. It’s the young people already here who dont want to work because they can claim benefits! There was someone on here the other day saying about their partner who doesn’t live with them because it suits them better, despite having children, the suits them better is a way of claiming benefits, in the next sentence he he 3 kids with 3 different mothers ffs…people need to get off their backsides and pay for their kids, not someone working long hours paying tax!!

Migrant labour is great for this equation. Most come only to earn money (and therefore pay taxes), the state hasn't paid to educate them when they were children and leave when they when they are done doing so (so no long term costs for pension and healthcare). I would think the loss of EU labour will have an impact.

orangeoyster · 23/01/2023 13:16

QuertyGirl · 23/01/2023 12:38

@orangeoyster

Of course it's fair.

You get an orderly society in which you have the opportunity to earn that money

Would you call it fair if you had to pay higher mortgage rates or prices in shops because you earn more than their average customers?
I suspect not.

Grumpybutfunny · 23/01/2023 13:13

JemimaTiggywinkles · 23/01/2023 13:01

I certainly don't rely on low-paid people to do my job.

The majority of higher rate tax payers do. Whether that be directly (employees below them), indirectly (cleaners, admin support), or via the fact that the companies they are selling their services to do employ people on low wages. As do the utility providers.

Let me put it this way - if everyone working for minimum / low wage downed tools, how long would it be before you were unable to work? Within my organisation it would be about a week or so before I'd absolutely have to do their job on top of my own. But we probably wouldn't get that far because I can't do my job without heating, lighting and running water, and I don't think those things would last long without the low wage maintenance staff. Plus the fact that a fair number of colleagues rely on low paid childcare workers, so we'd be running on skeleton staff if they wouldn't work due to lack of childcare.

I'm not having a go at net contributors or higher rate tax payers (I'm already a net contributor and next tax year I'll be in the 40% bracket). I'm just pointing out that the idea that you can earn lots of money in this country without lower paid workers is nonsense.

But you can redraw societies views so those lower paid jobs become an option for school leavers, Saturday/evening jobs and university students (for who it is no longer easy to get an entry level job). I've done minimum wage jobs when I was 19/20 and doing my degree, I had a room in a shared halls then lived at home. I didn't expect that minimum wage job to support a family which is what is happening with universal credit top ups etc. Our son was a surprise and one of our first thoughts was about how we could make it affordable with our life plan at the time, for me that meant working until my due date and going back at 4 months as we didn't have enough in savings for when I went onto half pay, 9 years later it honestly didn't make a difference to him.

It also about what you want to spend money on, so could you cut the bill by say giving everyone free childcare from X age so mam has to go back to work and contribute?

Throwncrumbs · 23/01/2023 13:11

MrsSkylerWhite · 23/01/2023 10:32

Knew someone would state this. A pension isn’t a benefit, a lot of people never collect a pension because they die before collecting it, but pay tax all their life, my own father died a few months before he was due to retire and worked all his life. His pension died with him. My sister on the other hand has always lived on benefits, she’s looking forward to collecting her pension in the next couple of years, something she has never paid into but is still ‘entitled’ too. Her own kids are playing the system now, minimum hours for maximum benefits!“

Our taxes don’t pay for our own pensions. They cover the services we use during our working lives and the pensions/benefits of others.

The biggest time bomb in the UK is the lack of young, working people coming into the country. Brexit. Bloody disaster. Thankfully, people are finally realising. Latest polling showing that 72% believe we should rejoin.

Sadly, don’t think the EU would take us back now. Don’t suppose we meet the criteria.

Young working people who can’t come here isn’t the problem. It’s the young people already here who dont want to work because they can claim benefits! There was someone on here the other day saying about their partner who doesn’t live with them because it suits them better, despite having children, the suits them better is a way of claiming benefits, in the next sentence he he 3 kids with 3 different mothers ffs…people need to get off their backsides and pay for their kids, not someone working long hours paying tax!!

Blossomtoes · 23/01/2023 13:10

MrsSkylerWhite · 23/01/2023 12:09

socialmedia23

can I add flats that aren’t rabbit hutches for older people needing to downsize from family homes but who would still like the much reduced in number rooms to be large enough to swing their cats.
developers seem to think all retirees just want to sit in a chair looking out of a window all day.

Make that bungalows with a decent garden and you’re on the money. Won’t happen though because they take up more space.

edwinbear · 23/01/2023 13:05

Perhaps what we need is some sort of tax breaks on employers/companies who agree to pay higher wage? I'm thinking aloud here, but perhaps they pay a lower employer NI rate if they agree to pay higher salaries? I have no idea how the numbers would work out mind. Lower NI receipts from employers but higher income tax and fewer receiving in work benefits - would that work?

QuertyGirl · 23/01/2023 13:04

JemimaTiggywinkles · 23/01/2023 13:01

I certainly don't rely on low-paid people to do my job.

The majority of higher rate tax payers do. Whether that be directly (employees below them), indirectly (cleaners, admin support), or via the fact that the companies they are selling their services to do employ people on low wages. As do the utility providers.

Let me put it this way - if everyone working for minimum / low wage downed tools, how long would it be before you were unable to work? Within my organisation it would be about a week or so before I'd absolutely have to do their job on top of my own. But we probably wouldn't get that far because I can't do my job without heating, lighting and running water, and I don't think those things would last long without the low wage maintenance staff. Plus the fact that a fair number of colleagues rely on low paid childcare workers, so we'd be running on skeleton staff if they wouldn't work due to lack of childcare.

I'm not having a go at net contributors or higher rate tax payers (I'm already a net contributor and next tax year I'll be in the 40% bracket). I'm just pointing out that the idea that you can earn lots of money in this country without lower paid workers is nonsense.

And if you don't pay those workers enough, they won't work eventually. Though that's after they work so much they become ill, can't parent their kids or run their homes properly- with all of the resulting mess that the tax payer has to pay to clean up

JemimaTiggywinkles · 23/01/2023 13:01

I certainly don't rely on low-paid people to do my job.

The majority of higher rate tax payers do. Whether that be directly (employees below them), indirectly (cleaners, admin support), or via the fact that the companies they are selling their services to do employ people on low wages. As do the utility providers.

Let me put it this way - if everyone working for minimum / low wage downed tools, how long would it be before you were unable to work? Within my organisation it would be about a week or so before I'd absolutely have to do their job on top of my own. But we probably wouldn't get that far because I can't do my job without heating, lighting and running water, and I don't think those things would last long without the low wage maintenance staff. Plus the fact that a fair number of colleagues rely on low paid childcare workers, so we'd be running on skeleton staff if they wouldn't work due to lack of childcare.

I'm not having a go at net contributors or higher rate tax payers (I'm already a net contributor and next tax year I'll be in the 40% bracket). I'm just pointing out that the idea that you can earn lots of money in this country without lower paid workers is nonsense.

SleeplessInEngland · 23/01/2023 12:56

hamstersarse · 23/01/2023 12:49

An example of the 'tax the nasty landlords' rhetoric in the past few years were the changes that the govt made to mortgage interest relief, the scrapping of the ‘wear and tear’ allowance and introduction of a 3% stamp duty surcharge.

Yay, let's tax the rich some more.

Result is fewer privately let properties available and rents rising.

Which would be far less of a problem if we built more houses but that tends not to happen with a cabinet of ideological NIMBYs.

QuertyGirl · 23/01/2023 12:54

JobSearchStress · 23/01/2023 12:51

I think we may be looking at this the wrong way.

I have lived in 2 places where I paid 12-15% tax, and 3-7% sales tax (VAT), and no other taxes. The quality of life was better there. In both places the population was under 7m.

Here in the UK I think taxes are massive. My household pays max rate tax, max council tax, road tax, massive fuel tax, inheritance tax, etc.etc. Even on a high income, it’s difficult to save.

We have relatives who live in Spain who earn a lot less, but have holiday homes and a better quality of life.

We are over populated, with many people claiming benefits. If it wasn’t so expensive to live here, if our govt. didn’t piss money up the wall, these people wouldn’t need in work benefits.

Smaller house, cheaper car and walk/bike where possible.

MarshaBradyo · 23/01/2023 12:53

QuertyGirl · 23/01/2023 12:51

@MarshaBradyo

Public sector pensions are not benefits though- but the gov has used them to paint a picture of a high benefit bill.

They're part of the remuneration that public sector employees get

I’m going by ONS figures

They know their statistics. Others might want to order things differently but it helps to use a consistent verifiable source such as ONS.

SleeplessInEngland · 23/01/2023 12:53

The "think-tank" that came up with this report is based in 55 Tufton Street. If you know about that building's reputation you can draw your own conclusions.

JobSearchStress · 23/01/2023 12:51

I think we may be looking at this the wrong way.

I have lived in 2 places where I paid 12-15% tax, and 3-7% sales tax (VAT), and no other taxes. The quality of life was better there. In both places the population was under 7m.

Here in the UK I think taxes are massive. My household pays max rate tax, max council tax, road tax, massive fuel tax, inheritance tax, etc.etc. Even on a high income, it’s difficult to save.

We have relatives who live in Spain who earn a lot less, but have holiday homes and a better quality of life.

We are over populated, with many people claiming benefits. If it wasn’t so expensive to live here, if our govt. didn’t piss money up the wall, these people wouldn’t need in work benefits.

QuertyGirl · 23/01/2023 12:51

@MarshaBradyo

Public sector pensions are not benefits though- but the gov has used them to paint a picture of a high benefit bill.

They're part of the remuneration that public sector employees get

hamstersarse · 23/01/2023 12:49

An example of the 'tax the nasty landlords' rhetoric in the past few years were the changes that the govt made to mortgage interest relief, the scrapping of the ‘wear and tear’ allowance and introduction of a 3% stamp duty surcharge.

Yay, let's tax the rich some more.

Result is fewer privately let properties available and rents rising.

MarshaBradyo · 23/01/2023 12:47

QuertyGirl · 23/01/2023 12:44

Depends what you class as a benefit.

I've seen calculations which include public sector pensions.

All benefits yes. But we’re aging so it doesn’t make it easier to deal with. It will get higher.

imo check you can keep higher tax payers as much as people get annoyed the tax burden is huge and can’t afford loss of input at top end.