Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is the WHOLE POINT of tax?

361 replies

wheresmymojo · 23/01/2023 09:41

Daily Fail are frothing today that higher earners pay more tax, and lower earners get more out in various benefits than they pay in.

I thought even the DF understood that the entire point of tax, it's whole reason for existing, is to re-distribute wealth to some extent with the wealthier paying more so that the less wealthy can benefit from a better standard of living?

Have I missed something - are there people who don't know this is what tax is fundamentally supposed to do?

I mean, I'm being fairly genuine...are there actually people who think it's like a bank account and you 'pay in' to 'get out'?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
MarshaBradyo · 23/01/2023 14:04

Mavis you do need the tax receipts from the private sector don’t you?

How would you survive funding the public sector if you didn’t get back to normal?

MarshaBradyo · 23/01/2023 14:03

JemimaTiggywinkles · 23/01/2023 13:48

Society runs on many people contributing.

Exactly. Some people are paid very little to do absolutely essential jobs. Some are paid very well to do jobs that are inessential but create wealth. Most are somewhere in between. The vast majority contribute to society in one way or another.

My problem is with people who earn a lot and pay a lot of tax but think that they don't rely on lower paid workers. We all do.

That is true we depend on each other.

But as most learnt from pandemic you can’t hammer the private sector and expect the public sector to be ok.

Whoever is funding what we need is crucial. Without it very low state funding.

The U.K. can easily lose tax competitiveness for individuals and companies as other countries vie to become attractive.

It’s a balance. No one who is contributing is not needed but look where the tax burden is being paid and don’t reduce that group. Then think about how to use it.

caringcarer · 23/01/2023 14:03

@Badbadbunny, where did you get idea that tax exists to redistribute wealth? It is to pay for public services like hospitals, schools and roads.

MavisMcMinty · 23/01/2023 14:01

It was a lesson writ large during lockdown. It’s astonishing how quickly people have forgotten.

Oh I know, @Blossomtoes - I had an almost euphoric hope during that first lockdown that we (society) would finally appreciate the lowest status, lowest paid workers are the people keeping the country going, not their billionaire/millionaire employers, sorry, I mean “wealth creators”. No wonder those bastards wanted us to “get back to normal” as quickly as possible.

caringcarer · 23/01/2023 13:58

The amount the state is having to pay to support so many is simply too high to be sustainable. As population is ago g this will get worse. Something has to give. Employers should pay higher wages so people need less top ups. UC is not fit for purpose. If you are single you don't get enough to pay bills, a care leaver gets £61 to pay for gas, electricity, water rates, food, clothing, SIM. Nothing left at all. If you have children you are given more than generous payments. A single parent only working 16 hours a week gets a full weeks pay. It needs to be fairer. People need to be more self sufficient as in the past. There needs to be more social housing.

Blossomtoes · 23/01/2023 13:57

My problem is with people who earn a lot and pay a lot of tax but think that they don't rely on lower paid workers. We all do.

It was a lesson writ large during lockdown. It’s astonishing how quickly people have forgotten.

horseyhorsey17 · 23/01/2023 13:52

Elsiebear90 · 23/01/2023 12:39

I think it is concerning that half the country take more back than they give, surely this is only going to get worse with inflation and an ever growing elderly population? It’s not sustainable, you can’t keep taking more and more of those who already contribute way more than their fair share, it’s not a race to the bottom, soon there will be no incentive to earn more as most of it will be taken off you.

That's not how taxes work. The people contributing the most are still vastly more wealthy than those who are largely out of taxation because they don't earn enough to get by. There's plenty of incentive for them to go on making tons of money and being massively rich - not least that they can simply set up shell companies and avoid taxes altogether, like most of this Conservative government.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 23/01/2023 13:48

Society runs on many people contributing.

Exactly. Some people are paid very little to do absolutely essential jobs. Some are paid very well to do jobs that are inessential but create wealth. Most are somewhere in between. The vast majority contribute to society in one way or another.

My problem is with people who earn a lot and pay a lot of tax but think that they don't rely on lower paid workers. We all do.

JarByTheDoor · 23/01/2023 13:47

Blossomtoes · 23/01/2023 13:37

Benefits is a loaded term. “Benefit scroungers” and “Benefit Street” anyone?

Yes, it's been loaded and loaded and loaded by those who'd like to divide and conquer, and by people who just want to make money by infuriating a certain section of the population.

But the denotative meaning of the word in this context is a payout from a scheme we all pay into. I've screenshotted the relevant OED entry, which mentions the friendly societies/benefit societies that people paid into for this kind of cover before the welfare state.

There's no reason to exclude pensions from this term other than people's reluctance to put pensioners in the same category as those receiving other benefits. Making it clear, again and again, that pensions are a benefit and part of the benefits system might go some way to removing some of the loading that the press have heaped on to the word "benefit".

To think this is the WHOLE POINT of tax?
Endlesssummer2022 · 23/01/2023 13:47

user982548025 · 23/01/2023 10:00

Well no. The point of tax is to fund public services. Not to redistribute money to poor people.

I also thought taxes were to pay for public services. One of those services involves providing a safety net for poorer people but taxes aren’t simply to transfer money from wealthier people to poorer people.

VivX · 23/01/2023 13:45

I am in agreement that the purpose of tax was not actually to redistribute wealth - as in, that was not its original purpose, centuries ago.

But now, in the 2023, I think it is absolutely right to use as a form of wealth distribution. (I say this as someone who is probably a net-payer-in to the "system")

But then I'm also a strong believer in things like having a welfare state, a social safety net, excellent public services and infrastructure - and that all of these things should be funded by the taxpayer.
Also, I'm not, nor ever have been a Conservative voter or a DM reader.

MarshaBradyo · 23/01/2023 13:44

socialmedia23 · 23/01/2023 13:40

There is an earnings crisis. Outside of finance, tech and corporate law, no one is being paid a living wage (unless they are senior). I had this realization when i was discussing budgeting for a baby with a friend that I thought would be above my income level (cambridge educated civil servant). She recently bought a house in my area (with her older husband who is an academic) so I incorrectly assumed she was doing ok. She thought our household income was very high (DH and I are on the lower end of incomes in our industry). It was embarrassing.

Its no surprise the very poorest need handouts from the government to survive. I do the math AND THEY CANNOT SURVIVE WITHOUT IT! Even when working fulltime.

Its why Martin Lewis has switched from advising on credit cards switches and mortgages to waging war on the government. There is nothing left to cut. there is only one thing for low wage workers (predominantly in the public sector) to do and that is to strike.

The trick is to extract the tax from those earners without turning U.K. to a poorer right across the board for all economy because like it or not that tax burden won’t reduce.

You have many other countries quite happy to have tax payers - individuals and companies

SleeplessInEngland · 23/01/2023 13:41

socialmedia23 · 23/01/2023 13:40

There is an earnings crisis. Outside of finance, tech and corporate law, no one is being paid a living wage (unless they are senior). I had this realization when i was discussing budgeting for a baby with a friend that I thought would be above my income level (cambridge educated civil servant). She recently bought a house in my area (with her older husband who is an academic) so I incorrectly assumed she was doing ok. She thought our household income was very high (DH and I are on the lower end of incomes in our industry). It was embarrassing.

Its no surprise the very poorest need handouts from the government to survive. I do the math AND THEY CANNOT SURVIVE WITHOUT IT! Even when working fulltime.

Its why Martin Lewis has switched from advising on credit cards switches and mortgages to waging war on the government. There is nothing left to cut. there is only one thing for low wage workers (predominantly in the public sector) to do and that is to strike.

I agree. You're preaching to the choir.

MarshaBradyo · 23/01/2023 13:41

People need to spend more time with better quality information and ONS using the term benefits in their analysis won’t upset them.

‘Reductions in indirect taxes and increased benefits-in-kind, largely in response to the coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic, drove the proportion of individuals receiving more in benefits than they paid in taxes increased from 47.5% to 54.2% in FYE 2021’

If only more people learnt economics and were better at avoiding tabloid terminology.

socialmedia23 · 23/01/2023 13:40

SleeplessInEngland · 23/01/2023 13:29

Yes, because there's a housing crisis and childcare is ridiculously expensive. But the peole who tend to use terms like 'politics of envy' also tend not to give a shit about those two issues, and the government certainly doesn't.

There is an earnings crisis. Outside of finance, tech and corporate law, no one is being paid a living wage (unless they are senior). I had this realization when i was discussing budgeting for a baby with a friend that I thought would be above my income level (cambridge educated civil servant). She recently bought a house in my area (with her older husband who is an academic) so I incorrectly assumed she was doing ok. She thought our household income was very high (DH and I are on the lower end of incomes in our industry). It was embarrassing.

Its no surprise the very poorest need handouts from the government to survive. I do the math AND THEY CANNOT SURVIVE WITHOUT IT! Even when working fulltime.

Its why Martin Lewis has switched from advising on credit cards switches and mortgages to waging war on the government. There is nothing left to cut. there is only one thing for low wage workers (predominantly in the public sector) to do and that is to strike.

Blossomtoes · 23/01/2023 13:37

Benefits is a loaded term. “Benefit scroungers” and “Benefit Street” anyone?

MarshaBradyo · 23/01/2023 13:34

JarByTheDoor · 23/01/2023 13:32

That makes the exact opposite of sense.

The reason these things were called benefits in the first place is that they're things you get from being part of the National Insurance scheme (not that you get a choice, obviously). That language is used because a payout you get from insurance — like, from an insurance company — is often called a benefit. True, National Insurance isn't really like being signed up with a private insurance company, but the word "benefits" (rather than something like "welfare") is chosen because we're meant to think of it as being a bit like insurance — we all pay in, so that if we're unlucky enough to get ill or be out of work, or if we live long into old age, we can claim for the benefits we're entitled to as part of our membership. The whole point of that language is that it's something you get because you paid in, or would've been required to pay in if you were in a position to do so. The name itself implies that this is not charity or a handout, it's a payout from a scheme you are entitled to make a claim on, that you can request and receive without loss of dignity.

You've been conditioned by years of tabloid crap to think of "benefits" differently, but the intent of the word is for people to think of it as the flipside of paying in.

Exactly. People see ‘benefits’ and treat it as a loaded term.

Using it as part of statistics is not an issue (unless easily affronted by facts)

socialmedia23 · 23/01/2023 13:33

orangeoyster · 23/01/2023 13:24

You will never not have 'the poor' as a section of society.
Even if you gave everyone £1m tomorrow, you would still have a class of 'poor' people after a year.

Taxing the rich is pointless as an endeavour. You could confiscate the assets of the entire Times rich list and it wouldn't change anything in the long run - the sums of money p*ssed up the wall every year by governments are just too massive.

There would always be 'poorer people', but there is a big difference between 'poor people' who cannot afford food or heating and 'poor people' who live in subsidized government housing or who own their own houses , who have access to quality education and healthcare so that they have the tools to access better jobs if they wish to.

the state of society is such that there is a dwindling middle class. People earn very low incomes and they don't realize it.

JarByTheDoor · 23/01/2023 13:32

Throwncrumbs · 23/01/2023 13:18

State pension is not a benefit, unless you have never worked in your life and at pension age you swap your UC for a pension, which is what is going to happen in the future!

That makes the exact opposite of sense.

The reason these things were called benefits in the first place is that they're things you get from being part of the National Insurance scheme (not that you get a choice, obviously). That language is used because a payout you get from insurance — like, from an insurance company — is often called a benefit. True, National Insurance isn't really like being signed up with a private insurance company, but the word "benefits" (rather than something like "welfare") is chosen because we're meant to think of it as being a bit like insurance — we all pay in, so that if we're unlucky enough to get ill or be out of work, or if we live long into old age, we can claim for the benefits we're entitled to as part of our membership. The whole point of that language is that it's something you get because you paid in, or would've been required to pay in if you were in a position to do so. The name itself implies that this is not charity or a handout, it's a payout from a scheme you are entitled to make a claim on, that you can request and receive without loss of dignity.

You've been conditioned by years of tabloid crap to think of "benefits" differently, but the intent of the word is for people to think of it as the flipside of paying in.

Hollowgast · 23/01/2023 13:31

Badbadbunny · 23/01/2023 12:03

The main thing is to control house prices and rents.

They'll just rise if benefits or minimum wage rises, so people would end up no better off. That's just basic economics of supply and demand. It's where Gordon Brown went wrong with his tax credits - it fuelled house price and rent inflation as people could afford to pay more!

So, before we even start to think about increasing wages or benefits, we need to have rent and house price controls so that people can actually benefit from their increased income, and for it not just to be eaten up in housing costs.

True. I also think a massive thing he did was changing the official rate of inflation from RPI to CPI. RPI includes house prices so because prices in shops weren't soaring the interest rates were kept low. Guaranteed huge house price inflation.

SleeplessInEngland · 23/01/2023 13:29

socialmedia23 · 23/01/2023 13:26

sadly its the middle earners who pay the most tax, not the rich. £65k is not a high income, its a middle income in London where it buys you a 2/3 bed flat (with a partner). If your partner earns a similar amount, you can afford childcare for 1 kid.

Yes, because there's a housing crisis and childcare is ridiculously expensive. But the peole who tend to use terms like 'politics of envy' also tend not to give a shit about those two issues, and the government certainly doesn't.

QuertyGirl · 23/01/2023 13:28

@orangeoyster

Richer people generally already pay less in those circumstances.

You certainly have easier and cheaper credit and, you can buy better stuff which lasts.

Commander Vimes school of economics!

Also, you are paying for the society which enabled you to earn what you do.

MarshaBradyo · 23/01/2023 13:28

Throwncrumbs · 23/01/2023 13:18

State pension is not a benefit, unless you have never worked in your life and at pension age you swap your UC for a pension, which is what is going to happen in the future!

Here you go. Information here

www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/personalandhouseholdfinances/incomeandwealth/bulletins/theeffectsoftaxesandbenefitsonhouseholdincome/financialyearending2021

socialmedia23 · 23/01/2023 13:26

SleeplessInEngland · 23/01/2023 13:21

You're right, those poor fabulously wealthy rich people. I bet they'd trade places with the benefit scroungers in a hartbeat if they could.

sadly its the middle earners who pay the most tax, not the rich. £65k is not a high income, its a middle income in London where it buys you a 2/3 bed flat (with a partner). If your partner earns a similar amount, you can afford childcare for 1 kid.

MarshaBradyo · 23/01/2023 13:25

JemimaTiggywinkles · 23/01/2023 13:01

I certainly don't rely on low-paid people to do my job.

The majority of higher rate tax payers do. Whether that be directly (employees below them), indirectly (cleaners, admin support), or via the fact that the companies they are selling their services to do employ people on low wages. As do the utility providers.

Let me put it this way - if everyone working for minimum / low wage downed tools, how long would it be before you were unable to work? Within my organisation it would be about a week or so before I'd absolutely have to do their job on top of my own. But we probably wouldn't get that far because I can't do my job without heating, lighting and running water, and I don't think those things would last long without the low wage maintenance staff. Plus the fact that a fair number of colleagues rely on low paid childcare workers, so we'd be running on skeleton staff if they wouldn't work due to lack of childcare.

I'm not having a go at net contributors or higher rate tax payers (I'm already a net contributor and next tax year I'll be in the 40% bracket). I'm just pointing out that the idea that you can earn lots of money in this country without lower paid workers is nonsense.

Society runs on many people contributing.

It’s stupid to try to make being a higher payer unattractive enough to go though.

Really basic - the tax burden needs payers. People happy when they go are really shooting themselves in the foot as pp put it.