Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is the WHOLE POINT of tax?

361 replies

wheresmymojo · 23/01/2023 09:41

Daily Fail are frothing today that higher earners pay more tax, and lower earners get more out in various benefits than they pay in.

I thought even the DF understood that the entire point of tax, it's whole reason for existing, is to re-distribute wealth to some extent with the wealthier paying more so that the less wealthy can benefit from a better standard of living?

Have I missed something - are there people who don't know this is what tax is fundamentally supposed to do?

I mean, I'm being fairly genuine...are there actually people who think it's like a bank account and you 'pay in' to 'get out'?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
socialmedia23 · 23/01/2023 15:02

Lozzybear · 23/01/2023 14:56

The top 10 per cent of workers earn an average of £62,583. We’re not talking super rich.

www.statista.com/statistics/416102/average-annual-gross-pay-percentiles-united-kingdom/

exactly and this is why I am saying the salaried population in general is underpaid. £62k isn't crazy money so how can they be the top 10%?

SnackSizeRaisin · 23/01/2023 15:02

orangeoyster · 23/01/2023 12:36

You don't have to earn much in this country to pay the higher rate. I certainly don't rely on low-paid people to do my job. As one of the 10% who is paying more than their share, I get no better services or pension than anybody else. In fact, in many cases I get less back.

How is that fair?

Also, nobody should be campaigning for Increasing the minimum wage and capping rents, as they both lead to undesirable effects.

If you increase the minimum wage, then the higher wages also generally have to increase. Certain jobs (like carers) become less desirable because you can get paid the same for doing ANYTHING else. Everything gets more expensive, prices go up to compensate, and then we're back where we started except the money has inflated.

If you cap rents then you will eliminate the supply because people stop moving. As a result, prices rise due to S&D and people end up paying more for the same, except the money has inflated and there is less choice.

The government does not control house prices. That is a market matter, and nothing is overpriced in a free market.

Of course you rely onlow paid workers. Do you drive a car, use public transport, eat food, buy anything, get your bins emptied,put your children in childcare? Unless you live entirely off grid and are self sufficient then you rely on an army of low paid workers to keep the country running.

The only way to make low paid people contribute more is to pay them more. As there's a finite amount of money, that would mean paying some other people less.

SleeplessInEngland · 23/01/2023 15:00

If I was the government I would not be highlighting - via a tufton street think tank - that the benefit piece of pie is now bigger than it was under labour. It might make people think the guys who have been in charge for 12 years fucked up a bit.

Lozzybear · 23/01/2023 14:56

The top 10 per cent of workers earn an average of £62,583. We’re not talking super rich.

www.statista.com/statistics/416102/average-annual-gross-pay-percentiles-united-kingdom/

Slowingdownagain · 23/01/2023 14:55

I actually think it's services that are key. If people experience that they (and others) receive good services they are happier to pay tax. In Denmark for example taxes are much higher than here and peopl are, generally, ok with it. There is pride in the welfare state and the services it produces. In the UK public services are being degraded so people feel they are getting bad value for their money (personally and from a wider public benefit perspective). It feels like a rip off to pay £x thousands in tax and not only can't I get a doctor's appoitnment but also I see that children near me are living in poverty. What benefit exactly am I paying for here? It's a value for money perception as much as anything I'd say.

socialmedia23 · 23/01/2023 14:50

MarshaBradyo · 23/01/2023 14:40

I live in London in a mixed area of SE and don’t see this at all.

But I’m guessing I’m older than you at near 50 and what tends to happen is we move to an area that is up and coming early on which has people who have been here for decades, and then after about ten years City couples move here.

I think the pp is right you’re in a bubble where people say they couldn’t survive on less.

I am 30. Age is key. What constitutes a good wage cannot be based on property prices from 20 years ago, they should be based on market rent/mortgage based on 10% deposit in the local area (in London this can be a wider geographic area due to good commuter links). If people are having to rely on parents to beef up their deposits to buy an average home, they are not earning a living wage.

jcyclops · 23/01/2023 14:50

Also mentioned by the Daily Fail and commented on higher up this thread is that 53% of income tax is paid by the top 10% of earners. It is actually higher than that at 62.3%. Data from HMRC is shown in the the table attached.

Note that this is just income tax. Points to note are that the top 50% of earners pay 91.7% of income tax, and that this has increased by 3 percentage points since 2010/2011 matched by a corresponding decrease for the bottom 50%. The top 10% of earners share of income tax has increased from 53.5% to 62.3% over the same period.

To think this is the WHOLE POINT of tax?
socialmedia23 · 23/01/2023 14:44

dollymixtured · 23/01/2023 14:33

I am sorry but the idea that unless you are in finance, tech or corporate law you are not earning a living wage is absolutely laughable. I have certainly found that those earning 100k plus have a pretty skewed idea of what amounts to essential and I can only guess that @socialmedia23 ia living in some kind of bubble because there are millions of people not working in those sectors and doing just fine.

Would you be able to buy your current house on your salary? Could you manage 20% increase in groceries/childcare costs? A lot of people manage fine because they bought years ago or their kids no longer need full time childcare. my MIL 'manages' fine on less than 20k per annum in London but thats because she boguht her house at 100k. However, it is not possible for a low wage earner to buy her house for 100k anymore. in finance, corporate law and tech, it is possible for young people to buy their parents' houses or at least a flat even in London. And many people in finance don't earn 100k or more esp in the operations side at analyst level. But 2 40k salaries can at least buy a flat in London (esp if they lived at parents' house) or a small house in commuter territory (in their 20s). We were on combined £75k when we bought our flat in our late 20s, i believe.

I am not saying no one is earning an ok wage in other industries but a lot of people aren't . If they were, the median salary in London would not be 41k. And its lower outside London. The average rent in the whole of UK is £1000. Many many houses outside London are now £300k-£350k. When you do the math, you realize how poorly paid British people relative to housing (and lets not even mention childcare).

But how many other industries can two 20+ year olds earn 40k?

MarshaBradyo · 23/01/2023 14:40

socialmedia23 · 23/01/2023 14:35

We are in the top 8% of households only because we live in London and work in financial services. we are a small percentage of the overall UK population because not everyone can live in london/work in financial services.

£30k is not enough to survive when the average rent in the UK is £1000. Worse if there are children. Its not so easy to 'couple up', are you suggesting women should just randomly pick men up on the street as long as they earn a decent wage? £1000 is my mortgage in London and our combined income is well over £100k. I actually think our household income is the break even income in London and anything less is low wage.

I live in London in a mixed area of SE and don’t see this at all.

But I’m guessing I’m older than you at near 50 and what tends to happen is we move to an area that is up and coming early on which has people who have been here for decades, and then after about ten years City couples move here.

I think the pp is right you’re in a bubble where people say they couldn’t survive on less.

SleeplessInEngland · 23/01/2023 14:39

Just seen that walking-PR-disaster Lee Anderson MP has been promoting the Mail's front-page on twitter today and it's gone about as well as you would expect. "Feel free to crawl back under your socialist rock & chat bollocks there. Have you ever done an honest days graft? Thought not!" etc etc

HelloJan · 23/01/2023 14:39

caringcarer · 23/01/2023 14:03

@Badbadbunny, where did you get idea that tax exists to redistribute wealth? It is to pay for public services like hospitals, schools and roads.

This.
It's to pay for services/infrastructure/etc that everyone can use.

The fact that some people think that taxes exist so that "lower earners could benefit from a higher standard of living" is laughable.

Genevieva · 23/01/2023 14:38

It means there is something fundamentally wrong in our society when so many people who work hard in good jobs need handouts from the state to survive. Wages should reflect the cost of living, but are massively below where they should be. A different interpretation from the DM article you posted, but the same fundamental problem. It is unsustainable to have a society in which so many people rely on handouts provided by so few. Remember the mega tax payers are not the superrich either. They are the people earning in the low six figures who don't earn enough to make use of all the off shore loopholes that our politicians seem to get away with using. Nadhim Zahawi was in the press this weekend for that.

lightand · 23/01/2023 14:38

edwinbear · 23/01/2023 14:31

@VivX I was designated a key worker. I work in a bank. Make of that what you will, but we certainly shifted a lot of pandemic loans out the door quickly enough to stop small businesses going bust.

Of course you are a key worker.
Imagine if all banks closed their doors?

lightand · 23/01/2023 14:36

MarshaBradyo · 23/01/2023 14:07

Oh gawd at posters not realising you need tax receipts to run state services

Just have a think for a bit

This is a thread that will stick in my memory for years to come.

The sheer number of posters who dont realise, or have forgotten, or who never even knew in the first place.
Or perhaps worse, taught wrongly at school?

madamovaries · 23/01/2023 14:36

RenegadeMrs · 23/01/2023 11:23

'To be honest inheritance tax should exist the money has already been taxed once'

Assuming that this should read 'shouldn't exist'?

Inheritance tax absolutly should exist. Wealth in accumulated property and pensions is one of the biggest reasons we have such a huge disparity in wealth between the top 10% and the rest in this country .

Also, you get to the end of your life and you have savings. Hurrah. But ultimatly that means you have accoumulated more than you needed to use over your lifetime. Why shouldn't some (not all) of this excess go back to the state that will have played some part in facilitating the accumulation of this excess?

I agree! Contrary to popular opinion, I think Inheritance tax is one of the fairer taxes: it’s tax on accumulated wealth you have done nothing to earn. A friend who comes from a v wealthy family actually argues it should be 100% (I don’t agree with that though). His (slightly bonkers?) theory is that inheritance makes rich kids lazy.

also most people won’t pay it - one of the things that’s fascinating is a lot of people who oppose it will never pay it.

There’s a decent argument that inheritance tax should be reformed though. The first problem being that too many ultra rich people find ways to avoid paying it, and the second being that as it’s taxed on estates and not the recipients, there’s the issue that it doesn’t take into account how many recipients there are.

full disclosure: v likely we’ll have to pay it on my parents’ estate one day (since they own a house in London), though I’m one of 3 kids so the sum we receive - while significant - will be split 3 ways. Care costs, of course, might mean the estate is too small for us to pay it all, though

socialmedia23 · 23/01/2023 14:35

orangeoyster · 23/01/2023 14:26

@socialmedia23

There would always be 'poorer people', but there is a big difference between 'poor people' who cannot afford food or heating and 'poor people' who live in subsidized government housing or who own their own houses , who have access to quality education and healthcare so that they have the tools to access better jobs if they wish to.

I'd suggest that those people who cannot afford food get a full time job and take a look at their lifestyle choices. A minimum wage job gets you about £16.5k after taxes (almost £18k after April 2023) Couple up and all of a sudden you're bringing in over £30k easily.

the state of society is such that there is a dwindling middle class. People earn very low incomes and they don't realize it.

Those higher rate taxpayers are the middle class and everybody wants their money because they feel entitled to it.

We are in the top 8% of households only because we live in London and work in financial services. we are a small percentage of the overall UK population because not everyone can live in london/work in financial services.

£30k is not enough to survive when the average rent in the UK is £1000. Worse if there are children. Its not so easy to 'couple up', are you suggesting women should just randomly pick men up on the street as long as they earn a decent wage? £1000 is my mortgage in London and our combined income is well over £100k. I actually think our household income is the break even income in London and anything less is low wage.

dollymixtured · 23/01/2023 14:33

socialmedia23 · 23/01/2023 13:40

There is an earnings crisis. Outside of finance, tech and corporate law, no one is being paid a living wage (unless they are senior). I had this realization when i was discussing budgeting for a baby with a friend that I thought would be above my income level (cambridge educated civil servant). She recently bought a house in my area (with her older husband who is an academic) so I incorrectly assumed she was doing ok. She thought our household income was very high (DH and I are on the lower end of incomes in our industry). It was embarrassing.

Its no surprise the very poorest need handouts from the government to survive. I do the math AND THEY CANNOT SURVIVE WITHOUT IT! Even when working fulltime.

Its why Martin Lewis has switched from advising on credit cards switches and mortgages to waging war on the government. There is nothing left to cut. there is only one thing for low wage workers (predominantly in the public sector) to do and that is to strike.

I am sorry but the idea that unless you are in finance, tech or corporate law you are not earning a living wage is absolutely laughable. I have certainly found that those earning 100k plus have a pretty skewed idea of what amounts to essential and I can only guess that @socialmedia23 ia living in some kind of bubble because there are millions of people not working in those sectors and doing just fine.

edwinbear · 23/01/2023 14:31

@VivX I was designated a key worker. I work in a bank. Make of that what you will, but we certainly shifted a lot of pandemic loans out the door quickly enough to stop small businesses going bust.

jcyclops · 23/01/2023 14:30

This statistic that the Daily Fail has just discovered has been around since July 22 and has been raised on previous mumsnet threads eg.
www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4681152-median-household-income-higher-rather-than-lower-after-taxes-benefits

The data is not just Income Tax - it includes NI and indirect taxes. The data INCLUDES pensioners and their state pension and pension credit, but excludes children (I think, but am not sure that it includes students). You can ignore the Fail's own derived figure of 36m.

For those that are interested, the data set shows:

Percentage of individuals receiving more in benefits than they pay in taxes:
2021 - ALL 54.2% - Retired 87.6% - Non Retired 47.2% (inc Covid)
2019 - ALL 50.5% - Retired 88.6% - Non Retired 42.6% (pre Covid)
2011 - ALL 52.5% - Retired 88.2% - Non Retired 45.0%
1998 - ALL 41.6% - Retired 84.4% - Non Retired 33.4%

For those commenting on workers needing benefits due to low wages under the tories, note that the "non retired" figure is fairly constant since 2010/11. The massive increase in workers needing benefits occurred under the Blair/Brown Labour administration.

orangeoyster · 23/01/2023 14:26

@socialmedia23

There would always be 'poorer people', but there is a big difference between 'poor people' who cannot afford food or heating and 'poor people' who live in subsidized government housing or who own their own houses , who have access to quality education and healthcare so that they have the tools to access better jobs if they wish to.

I'd suggest that those people who cannot afford food get a full time job and take a look at their lifestyle choices. A minimum wage job gets you about £16.5k after taxes (almost £18k after April 2023) Couple up and all of a sudden you're bringing in over £30k easily.

the state of society is such that there is a dwindling middle class. People earn very low incomes and they don't realize it.

Those higher rate taxpayers are the middle class and everybody wants their money because they feel entitled to it.

SnackSizeRaisin · 23/01/2023 14:17

Have they forgotten about national insurance, energy, Vat, tax on fuel, cigarettes, alcohol? The poor actually pay a higher proportion of their income in tax than the better off because of all these unavoidable taxes.

MavisMcMinty · 23/01/2023 14:13

where did you get idea that tax exists to redistribute wealth? It is to pay for public services like hospitals, schools and roads.

@caringcarer

Wealth is more than money. A healthy nation with excellent public services is wealthy.

orangeoyster · 23/01/2023 14:10

QuertyGirl · 23/01/2023 13:28

@orangeoyster

Richer people generally already pay less in those circumstances.

You certainly have easier and cheaper credit and, you can buy better stuff which lasts.

Commander Vimes school of economics!

Also, you are paying for the society which enabled you to earn what you do.

You haven't answered my question. Would it be fair?

Credit and lending is based on risk. Risk is based on history and ability to make payments. I had a high credit rating even when I was on barely more than min wage. I know high earners with awful credit. Your point is moot.

I don't know who Commander Vimes is but they sound cool.

You're making a lot of assumptions about what has enabled me to do anything.
Equally, I'm paying for the society that allows people do nothing at all, so I don't see how that helps your argument.

MarshaBradyo · 23/01/2023 14:07

Oh gawd at posters not realising you need tax receipts to run state services

Just have a think for a bit

VivX · 23/01/2023 14:05

Agree, @Blossomtoes. It's amazing how quickly everyone has forgotten who the essential and key workers are.

The country would not grind to a halt if the hedge fund managers stopped working but if the bin men stopped working, it would quickly become very unpleasant for everyone.