Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is the WHOLE POINT of tax?

361 replies

wheresmymojo · 23/01/2023 09:41

Daily Fail are frothing today that higher earners pay more tax, and lower earners get more out in various benefits than they pay in.

I thought even the DF understood that the entire point of tax, it's whole reason for existing, is to re-distribute wealth to some extent with the wealthier paying more so that the less wealthy can benefit from a better standard of living?

Have I missed something - are there people who don't know this is what tax is fundamentally supposed to do?

I mean, I'm being fairly genuine...are there actually people who think it's like a bank account and you 'pay in' to 'get out'?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
socialmedia23 · 23/01/2023 17:20

orangeoyster · 23/01/2023 16:59

Where does the city go when it wants to expand and build the 300k+ new houses we apparently need every year (despite a sub-replacement birth rate)? The countryside.

Anyway, you're not hearing me.

What the Pret guy earns has everything to do with you. For one because he's just an example, and for another because wages are relative to jobs, which are relative to people's appetite and capacity to fulfil them.

£15/hr is about £30k/yr. How much do the people who currently earn £30k then have to be paid to make it worth their while to do what they're doing?

Another example: My job is quite stressful and demands many hours. If I could earn the same money stacking trollies at Tesco 9-5, then why would I do this job? Why would anybody?

So I ask again: if the Pret guy earned what you earn now, how much would you want to be paid to keep doing what you're doing?

A lot of properties in the city lie empty because they are built for a luxury market and developers would rather wait years for a suitable buyer than sell it at a lower price. There should be a tax for developers that you have to pay if you don't sell the properties you build within two years. A carmelite monastry just down the road just got converted to 2,3 and 4 bedroom townhouses starting at £825k. They are not going to sell all the houses in a hurry because for that price, you can get a 2 bedroom mansion apartment in Kensington (and which would be bigger than the cheapest 2 bedroom house in that development). And I am in surburban London. THey already have 4 3 bed £1.5 million houses a few streets away and those are still rented out several yeaers on even though they were built to sell. They could have used the land to build key worker housing. So we don't necessarily need to build in the countryside as the problem is inefficient allocation of housing. Lots of older people in 5 bedroom properties because there is nothing suitable to downsize to. Apparently even in London, there are more bedrooms than people.

I assume your job is either a vocation or has progression opportunities or at least the chance to jump to another job and get 20% more pay? It isn't just stressful and take up your energy with no hope of a six figure salary at the end of it? What is the point of it for your personally unless its a vocation or calling ? Jobs can be many things- it can be a way of gaining entry into a high earning or prestigious sector,getting trained up, a way of providing purpose, a calling but if it is none of these things and doesn't even pay you well enough (to make up for the long hours and the stress), then it is a dead end job.

And you deserve to earn more just like the Pret baristas. In fact you should be protected just as much as the Pret baristas. Do you know why people in banking or corporate law don't strike even when their jobs are beyond awful? Its because they are being well paid and they know it and this makes up for whatever indignities they have experienced. And it is not worth ditching that job even for a £15 per hour job in the supermarket. Even if it was £20 or £25, its not worth it.
Same with trainee lawyers (many of whom earn very low salaries as paralegals for many years); they know that it would probably work out eventually.

MeridaBrave · 23/01/2023 17:16

Yes it’s what tax is supposed to do but I think the question is over the contribution rate eg too much dependence on the rich and too many not contributing….

Blossomtoes · 23/01/2023 17:14

My job is quite stressful and demands many hours. If I could earn the same money stacking trollies at Tesco 9-5, then why would I do this job? Why would anybody?

I can only speak for myself but I’d find stacking trolleys at Tesco incredibly stressful. I’d be bored out of my mind, pissed off at having to deal with people all the time and detest having to be out in all weathers. I’d also find working as a barista just as stressful, they actually have to be nice to customers all the time.

I find the concept of having to be paid more than people whose jobs you perceive as inferior really interesting. If you’re being paid enough to have the lifestyle you want why would you be bothered if a care assistant or a checkout operator was paid the same as you?

orangeoyster · 23/01/2023 16:59

socialmedia23 · 23/01/2023 16:07

well the vast majority of immigrants don't live in the countryside.

Minimum wage should be £15 per hour. The cost of the coffee would also depend on rent in addition to how many cups of coffee can be sold. If people had more disposable income, they may buy more coffee and this would generate economies of scale.

What pret servers earn has nothing to do with what I earn. I am probably not going to be a Pret server even if they paid £60k as i believe that there is not much means of progression. I want to be in a job where pay would increase as I increase my seniority and where i can increase my pay by 20-40% whenever I move. Which is quite normal in my industry. No matter how high the minimum wage is, this isn't possible in the hospitality industry as the nature of the job would mean that it is less difficult to train up people to make coffee and also coffee has far lower margins. On the other hand, other industries are more lucrative and can afford to pay even junior employees more.

Where does the city go when it wants to expand and build the 300k+ new houses we apparently need every year (despite a sub-replacement birth rate)? The countryside.

Anyway, you're not hearing me.

What the Pret guy earns has everything to do with you. For one because he's just an example, and for another because wages are relative to jobs, which are relative to people's appetite and capacity to fulfil them.

£15/hr is about £30k/yr. How much do the people who currently earn £30k then have to be paid to make it worth their while to do what they're doing?

Another example: My job is quite stressful and demands many hours. If I could earn the same money stacking trollies at Tesco 9-5, then why would I do this job? Why would anybody?

So I ask again: if the Pret guy earned what you earn now, how much would you want to be paid to keep doing what you're doing?

horseyhorsey17 · 23/01/2023 16:35

Elsiebear90 · 23/01/2023 16:07

Not everyone who pays a high amount of tax is able to do that, if you’re paid via PAYE you have no choice but to pay your tax because your employer pays it
for you. I see a lot of people saying to increase tax rates for the “rich” because they “can afford it”, but you can only do that for so long before there’s no incentive for people (employees) to earn more.

The threshold for being a higher rate tax payer is £50,000, that’s comfortable (unless you’re the only one in the family working), but by no means rich. They need to tackle tax avoidance rather than just keep freezing tax thresholds despite inflation (which is a covert way of increasing tax).

I agree with this - it's the top 0.0001% (or similar) who hoard most of the world's wealth, and the disparity in the top 1% is quite big. Obvs there's a big gap between people on £100K a year and people with millions/billions. Even so, though, it's a huge exaggeration to paint higher-rate tax payers as struggling as much as people paying less tax. They might not actively be rich but unless they're overspending in some way, they are certainly comfortable enough not to think an 'easy' life on the dole is in any way comparable.

SnackSizeRaisin · 23/01/2023 16:22

orangeoyster · 23/01/2023 15:56

From a quick Google, junior doctors earn about $70k AUS, which is about £39k...

You make a very good anti-immigration argument there, with the countryside being for animals. Applause for that!

Of course it's the government's fault.
However, you can't expect an income of an amount, because it's based on what people are willing to pay, relative to other things.

I have 3 questions:

1.How much should the person who makes your coffee at Pret be paid, in your opinion?

  1. How much would they have to be paid until it became too expensive for you to buy coffee from Pret?
  2. How much would you want to be paid if your Pret barista earned as much as you do?

One of the effects of a more equal society is that luxuries are more expensive, but also within reach of more of the population. Cafes are relatively more expensive in more equal countries such as Norway. In less equal countries they are cheaper (to the better off) but more people are too poor to afford them.

Buying coffee at pret is something that's probably too expensive for someone who earns minimum wage to do. Therefore increasing the wage of a pret barista doesn't have any negative effect on poorer people

socialmedia23 · 23/01/2023 16:07

orangeoyster · 23/01/2023 15:56

From a quick Google, junior doctors earn about $70k AUS, which is about £39k...

You make a very good anti-immigration argument there, with the countryside being for animals. Applause for that!

Of course it's the government's fault.
However, you can't expect an income of an amount, because it's based on what people are willing to pay, relative to other things.

I have 3 questions:

1.How much should the person who makes your coffee at Pret be paid, in your opinion?

  1. How much would they have to be paid until it became too expensive for you to buy coffee from Pret?
  2. How much would you want to be paid if your Pret barista earned as much as you do?

well the vast majority of immigrants don't live in the countryside.

Minimum wage should be £15 per hour. The cost of the coffee would also depend on rent in addition to how many cups of coffee can be sold. If people had more disposable income, they may buy more coffee and this would generate economies of scale.

What pret servers earn has nothing to do with what I earn. I am probably not going to be a Pret server even if they paid £60k as i believe that there is not much means of progression. I want to be in a job where pay would increase as I increase my seniority and where i can increase my pay by 20-40% whenever I move. Which is quite normal in my industry. No matter how high the minimum wage is, this isn't possible in the hospitality industry as the nature of the job would mean that it is less difficult to train up people to make coffee and also coffee has far lower margins. On the other hand, other industries are more lucrative and can afford to pay even junior employees more.

Elsiebear90 · 23/01/2023 16:07

horseyhorsey17 · 23/01/2023 13:52

That's not how taxes work. The people contributing the most are still vastly more wealthy than those who are largely out of taxation because they don't earn enough to get by. There's plenty of incentive for them to go on making tons of money and being massively rich - not least that they can simply set up shell companies and avoid taxes altogether, like most of this Conservative government.

Not everyone who pays a high amount of tax is able to do that, if you’re paid via PAYE you have no choice but to pay your tax because your employer pays it
for you. I see a lot of people saying to increase tax rates for the “rich” because they “can afford it”, but you can only do that for so long before there’s no incentive for people (employees) to earn more.

The threshold for being a higher rate tax payer is £50,000, that’s comfortable (unless you’re the only one in the family working), but by no means rich. They need to tackle tax avoidance rather than just keep freezing tax thresholds despite inflation (which is a covert way of increasing tax).

SnackSizeRaisin · 23/01/2023 16:04

socialmedia23 · 23/01/2023 15:02

exactly and this is why I am saying the salaried population in general is underpaid. £62k isn't crazy money so how can they be the top 10%?

I agree that 62k isn't crazy money. But it's a good wage beyond the reach of most people.

The problem is more the distribution of those at the lower and middle. If full time annual earnings varied between say 25k and 65k (with 10% earning more) and the median full time salary was 40k, there'd be much less need for in work benefits and higher tax revenues. As it is, many full time workers earn only 16 or 17 k, which means they are paying very little tax (although they still pay a good whack of national insurance). The median is about 26 k.

orangeoyster · 23/01/2023 15:56

socialmedia23 · 23/01/2023 15:23

Living in the city is much cheaper if you have to commute (as most jobs are in the city). Less necessary to have a car too. Much kinder to the environment as countryside should be for the animals rather than humans!

I despair of low expectations in this country. I met an Australian lady when on a weekend break in Norway and they were aghast junior doctors were paid £33k in the UK.in their words, Australians would not work for that kind of money..not just doctors but anyone..sure their cost of living is higher but at the same time, it's not like our cost of living is super low either. We should expect higher salaries on par with other high income countries. Of course higher salaries without higher productivity would just lead to high inflation so we have to increase our productivity as well. However the fact we are a low wage economy isn't the fault of the people, it's the fault of the government. Even Liz Truss recognized this- outside of London/SE, the UK economy was low productivity/low wage. hence why jobs that are linked to the local UK economy (rather than London the financial hub/fintech capital) are low wage.

From a quick Google, junior doctors earn about $70k AUS, which is about £39k...

You make a very good anti-immigration argument there, with the countryside being for animals. Applause for that!

Of course it's the government's fault.
However, you can't expect an income of an amount, because it's based on what people are willing to pay, relative to other things.

I have 3 questions:

1.How much should the person who makes your coffee at Pret be paid, in your opinion?

  1. How much would they have to be paid until it became too expensive for you to buy coffee from Pret?
  2. How much would you want to be paid if your Pret barista earned as much as you do?
Blossomtoes · 23/01/2023 15:54

SleeplessInEngland · 23/01/2023 14:39

Just seen that walking-PR-disaster Lee Anderson MP has been promoting the Mail's front-page on twitter today and it's gone about as well as you would expect. "Feel free to crawl back under your socialist rock & chat bollocks there. Have you ever done an honest days graft? Thought not!" etc etc

He was whinging about food banks in The Telegraph. Nasty, nasty piece of work.

SnackSizeRaisin · 23/01/2023 15:53

orangeoyster · 23/01/2023 15:16

@SnackSizeRaisin

I was taking about relying on them for my job, since the poster I was replying to seems to think that all 'high earners ' have staff.

Of course your life relies on people who are paid less than you. You also rely on people who are paid more than you. This is a redundant point.

What you're missing is that you don't have to pay people more - you have to make the government and its machinations cost LESS. However, no government would willingly advocate for making itself smaller, hence the lack of conversation on the matter.

The only way for the government to cost less will be further cuts to the NHS, education, policing, social care, public transport, welfare etc. That would not, in my opinion, improve quality of life for the vast majority of people. Most people are much better off in a more equal society with good public services than in a society where there is poverty with all its associated criminality and decay.

vivainsomnia · 23/01/2023 15:47

despair of low expectations in this country. I met an Australian lady when on a weekend break in Norway and they were aghast junior doctors were paid £33k in the UK.in their words, Australians would not work for that kind of money
Of course not when costs of living there is much higher. Its not comparable.

Taxes are to pay for public services and an element of redistribution. What is mot right is families that work PT expecting a similar financial comfort as those who work FT.

SleeplessInEngland · 23/01/2023 15:25

orangeoyster · 23/01/2023 15:16

@SnackSizeRaisin

I was taking about relying on them for my job, since the poster I was replying to seems to think that all 'high earners ' have staff.

Of course your life relies on people who are paid less than you. You also rely on people who are paid more than you. This is a redundant point.

What you're missing is that you don't have to pay people more - you have to make the government and its machinations cost LESS. However, no government would willingly advocate for making itself smaller, hence the lack of conversation on the matter.

They're not talking about that because they know Britian isn't America. "Reasonable taxes to pay for good public services" remains a popular political tenet of most voters, and if people are angry right now is because they're clearly not getting the second part of the deal. Maybe that will change and libertarianism will one day get a foothold, but for now it's a minority ideology.

socialmedia23 · 23/01/2023 15:23

orangeoyster · 23/01/2023 15:08

See, this falls under 'lifestyle choices'.
Living in London (or any city) is not mandatory, and I would actively recommend that people live elsewhere. Life is better when you're surrounded by cows and/or oxygen.

Median monthly rent is actually £725 outside of London. £30k is plenty for a couple - as demonstrated by my own outgoings, which includes the mortgage on an above average house, 2x cars, holidays, meals out etc.

You don't necessarily have to sleep with the people you share a house/flat with either.

Living in the city is much cheaper if you have to commute (as most jobs are in the city). Less necessary to have a car too. Much kinder to the environment as countryside should be for the animals rather than humans!

I despair of low expectations in this country. I met an Australian lady when on a weekend break in Norway and they were aghast junior doctors were paid £33k in the UK.in their words, Australians would not work for that kind of money..not just doctors but anyone..sure their cost of living is higher but at the same time, it's not like our cost of living is super low either. We should expect higher salaries on par with other high income countries. Of course higher salaries without higher productivity would just lead to high inflation so we have to increase our productivity as well. However the fact we are a low wage economy isn't the fault of the people, it's the fault of the government. Even Liz Truss recognized this- outside of London/SE, the UK economy was low productivity/low wage. hence why jobs that are linked to the local UK economy (rather than London the financial hub/fintech capital) are low wage.

orangeoyster · 23/01/2023 15:16

@SnackSizeRaisin

I was taking about relying on them for my job, since the poster I was replying to seems to think that all 'high earners ' have staff.

Of course your life relies on people who are paid less than you. You also rely on people who are paid more than you. This is a redundant point.

What you're missing is that you don't have to pay people more - you have to make the government and its machinations cost LESS. However, no government would willingly advocate for making itself smaller, hence the lack of conversation on the matter.

Isitsixoclockalready · 23/01/2023 15:15

wheresmymojo · 23/01/2023 09:42

Sorry, front page of the Fail here

Ha ha that's such a clichéd Daily Mail front page. Exactly the kind of thing that one would expect.

MarshaBradyo · 23/01/2023 15:13

SleeplessInEngland · 23/01/2023 15:09

We're agreed it's a deliberate narrative that goes beyond black and white numbers, then. We just disagree on what the resulting consensus will be from it.

I knew this due to ONS figures already and haven’t bothered to read the DM version.

I don’t have an issue with raw numbers and find ONS reputable as do many statisticians.

But both parties, and unions, use figures to prompt the public I don’t think that’s unusual. I haven’t reacted to the DM article as it’s not of interest to me.

but yes I recommend stats / info programmes over press releases anyway

SleeplessInEngland · 23/01/2023 15:09

MarshaBradyo · 23/01/2023 15:06

Because of the second line in that post people associate higher benefits with the left so wouldn’t want to vote for them to be higher

We're agreed it's a deliberate narrative that goes beyond black and white numbers, then. We just disagree on what the resulting consensus will be from it.

SueVineer · 23/01/2023 15:09

the point of the article is the percentage of net contributors has fallen significantly. We do need a balance between givers and takers or the system doesn’t work.

orangeoyster · 23/01/2023 15:08

socialmedia23 · 23/01/2023 14:35

We are in the top 8% of households only because we live in London and work in financial services. we are a small percentage of the overall UK population because not everyone can live in london/work in financial services.

£30k is not enough to survive when the average rent in the UK is £1000. Worse if there are children. Its not so easy to 'couple up', are you suggesting women should just randomly pick men up on the street as long as they earn a decent wage? £1000 is my mortgage in London and our combined income is well over £100k. I actually think our household income is the break even income in London and anything less is low wage.

See, this falls under 'lifestyle choices'.
Living in London (or any city) is not mandatory, and I would actively recommend that people live elsewhere. Life is better when you're surrounded by cows and/or oxygen.

Median monthly rent is actually £725 outside of London. £30k is plenty for a couple - as demonstrated by my own outgoings, which includes the mortgage on an above average house, 2x cars, holidays, meals out etc.

You don't necessarily have to sleep with the people you share a house/flat with either.

MarshaBradyo · 23/01/2023 15:06

SleeplessInEngland · 23/01/2023 15:04

Yes, and Civitas decided to make that those numbers into a nice shiny report for the Mail. As you say, why?

Because of the second line in that post people associate higher benefits with the left so wouldn’t want to vote for them to be higher

SleeplessInEngland · 23/01/2023 15:04

MarshaBradyo · 23/01/2023 15:03

Why is it a think tank ONS already had the information.

I’m guessing it’s the left who tend to push higher benefits so people think no thanks to more.

Yes, and Civitas decided to make that those numbers into a nice shiny report for the Mail. As you say, why?

MarshaBradyo · 23/01/2023 15:03

Why is it a think tank ONS already had the information.

I’m guessing it’s the left who tend to push higher benefits so people think no thanks to more.

Neededanewuserhandle · 23/01/2023 15:03

SleeplessInEngland · 23/01/2023 12:56

Which would be far less of a problem if we built more houses but that tends not to happen with a cabinet of ideological NIMBYs.

Thousands of houses built on formerly productive farmland are swamping our small town - there are no GP appointments of school places, the roads are choked and there's almost no public transport of viable cycle routes.