Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is the WHOLE POINT of tax?

361 replies

wheresmymojo · 23/01/2023 09:41

Daily Fail are frothing today that higher earners pay more tax, and lower earners get more out in various benefits than they pay in.

I thought even the DF understood that the entire point of tax, it's whole reason for existing, is to re-distribute wealth to some extent with the wealthier paying more so that the less wealthy can benefit from a better standard of living?

Have I missed something - are there people who don't know this is what tax is fundamentally supposed to do?

I mean, I'm being fairly genuine...are there actually people who think it's like a bank account and you 'pay in' to 'get out'?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
madamovaries · 23/01/2023 10:59

Totally agree! Also the social contract exists partly as a form of insurance - in case you are one of the unlucky ones who falls on hard times - BUT I would also far rather live in a society that genuinely cared well for its elderly/ vulnerable etc (at which we regularly fail unfortunately).

One thing that has struck me though is that there is a real problem that it feels like there's an attitude from eg Tory chair Nadhim Zahawi that tax is for the little people (ie the working and middle classes, small businesses etc) and not for either people like him or giant businesses like Amazon.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 23/01/2023 10:59

Absolutely agree. It’s scaremongering at best.

I think we all need to remember that literally today something can happen that changes the course of our lives and we could be reliant on benefits for the next six decades. So perhaps expecting only what you’ve put in isn’t the wisest stance.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 23/01/2023 10:59

There always will be a small proportion of free loaders. I don't really care, if tolerating them means that all the children are fed.

This is the perfect way of putting it! I'm going to be stealing that phrasing.

Blossomtoes · 23/01/2023 10:58

ThreeFeetTall · 23/01/2023 10:13

And surely nearly all pensioners get more from the state than the pay in tax?

I’m pretty sure that’s the case. My state pension is definitely more than I pay in tax. Having said that, I was a higher rate tax payer for over 20 years and my deductions paid for the two previous generations’ pensions so I don’t feel too guilty. I’d happily pay more tax for better public services.

nc1013 · 23/01/2023 10:57

@horseyhorsey17

You don't think people on low wages work long hours and have job stress?! Have you MET a nurse?

@Scottishgirl85 said OFTEN....she's not saying no-one on low wages has stressful jobs. The majority of people referenced in the article will either not be working at all or be on low hours with min. wage.

A full time nurse working long hours isn't likely to get more in benefits than what they pay in income tax.

DifferenceEngines · 23/01/2023 10:55

purpledalmation · 23/01/2023 10:01

Giving extra to low earners who struggle is perfectly acceptable. Disabled, elderly, sick people all deserve help. However it is disingenuous to not admit there is a small proportion of the population who won't work. These infuriate taxpayers and genuine people in need alike. The focussing on them directs away from genuine claimants Overall taxation works

There always will be a small proportion of free loaders. I don't really care, if tolerating them means that all the children are fed.

edwinbear · 23/01/2023 10:55

But they don't in fact receive more than they pay. That would only be true if you add the disclaimer "with regard to income tax". Once you add in consumption taxes, the pictures changes since those are by their very nature regressive: poor households spend a much higher proportion of their income on consumption (no spare cash to save and invest), hence pay out a higher proportion in VAT than high earners

In absolute terms though, they do receive more than they pay. I agree, the proportion they pay in VAT is higher. But in absolute terms, if you earn £20k pa and spend 100% of it on goods and services, attracting VAT at 20%, you pay £4k in tax. Which if you have a school aged child, doesn't cover the £7k the state pays for your child's education. So they do receive more than they pay.

MrsSkylerWhite · 23/01/2023 10:53

GrumpyPanda

But they don't in fact receive more than they pay. That would only be true if you add the disclaimer "with regard to income tax". Once you add in consumption taxes, the pictures changes since those are by their very nature regressive: poor households spend a much higher proportion of their income on consumption (no spare cash to save and invest), hence pay out a higher proportion in VAT than high earners

Oh, I don’t disagree. Bottom line is that when working people have to claim top ups simply to survive, something is very badly wrong.
Some employers have been getting away with too much, for too long.

LemonSwan · 23/01/2023 10:52

It is shocking. And not because people are receiving benefits. It’s that half the country are.

We ourselves would be eligible, but as a director it’s very confusing and no one can agree whether dividends are earned income or unearned. So we won’t claim as don’t want to risk having to pay back and be more in the shit.

Minimum wage is clearly not high enough.

Taxes should be paid to pay for public spending; and to support those who have fallen on tough times.

If half the country have fallen on tough times that’s not good.

Parentandteacher · 23/01/2023 10:51

I also want to add if you are a higher rate tax payer and are feeling the pinch, it’s because the ultra wealthy (not usually by income but very large inherited wealth and businesses that profit whilst paying low tax and low wages) are not paying enough. The middle classes should feel a bit hard done by at the moment, but the people to be looking to are not those with even less than yourself (some muddling along with self medicated childhood trauma, ill health and poor housing) but the ultra wealthy who are taking us all for mugs.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 23/01/2023 10:49

But it does sometimes bother me that we both work 12 hour days to maintain the high responsibility jobs we have, whereas lower earners often don't have the same levels of stress and crazy relentless hours. But we choose to do the jobs we have.

You could always suggest that your job is cut in half. So two people could earn half your salary and do a reasonable amount of work each.

horseyhorsey17 · 23/01/2023 10:49

Scottishgirl85 · 23/01/2023 10:40

My husband and I are in the highest tax bracket, and we are happy to contribute to those less fortunate. But it does sometimes bother me that we both work 12 hour days to maintain the high responsibility jobs we have, whereas lower earners often don't have the same levels of stress and crazy relentless hours. But we choose to do the jobs we have.

You don't think people on low wages work long hours and have job stress?! Have you MET a nurse?

GrumpyPanda · 23/01/2023 10:49

MrsSkylerWhite · 23/01/2023 09:43

You’re not wrong.

I do find it alarming though that 36 million people are receiving more from the state than they’re paying in contributions. That, clearly, can’t continue, just can’t be sustained.

Wages need to be set at a realistic level, so people don’t need state top ups just to survive.

But they don't in fact receive more than they pay. That would only be true if you add the disclaimer "with regard to income tax". Once you add in consumption taxes, the pictures changes since those are by their very nature regressive: poor households spend a much higher proportion of their income on consumption (no spare cash to save and invest), hence pay out a higher proportion in VAT than high earners.

JarByTheDoor · 23/01/2023 10:48

Why do people have an objection to pensions being called benefits?

When I'm a member of an insurance scheme, one of the words that can be used for the payouts I'm entitled to if the right circumstances apply is "benefits". There are long-term sickness insurance policies you can buy which refer to the regular payout you'll receive if you become ill as a "benefit".

Pensions are benefits as much as ESA payouts are benefits. They're both connected to the National Insurance system so they use that bit of insurance lingo.

People are only reluctant to call pensions benefits because we've succeeded in demonising working-age benefits and their recipients to the point that the word itself has somehow come to take on an unofficial meaning that excludes all those respectable, hard-working pensioners getting their well-earned reward for a life's graft.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 23/01/2023 10:48

The top 10% are largely in that bracket because they are taking a cut of the work done by lower paid people. They can either pay a fair chunk of their wage in tax, which is then given to the lower paid through the government, or reduce their salary to give the lower paid workers sufficient pay rises that they don't need redistribution by the government.

It isn't possible to have a low wage economy and low taxes for high earners. Unless you want to live in Victorian times, of course.

PhillyJoe · 23/01/2023 10:47

Isn’t the education of children included in that calculation? So my household which receives no benefits (I am higher rate tax payer so don’t claim CB) is not a net contributor because I have two school aged children. I would be most interested to know if over my lifetime I am a net contributor or not. These gross figures really need pulling apart.

MrsSkylerWhite · 23/01/2023 10:47

Scottishgirl85 · Today 10:40
My husband and I are in the highest tax bracket, and we are happy to contribute to those less fortunate. But it does sometimes bother me that we both work 12 hour days to maintain the high responsibility jobs we have, whereas lower earners often don't have the same levels of stress and crazy relentless hours. But we choose to do the jobs we have.“

well quite, you’ve answered your own dilemma there. Work in high responsibility jobs and earn more or work in less responsible jobs and earn less.

I’m just glad we had/have the ability to do the former. Not everyone does, however much they may wish they could improve their lives through work. With high earnings come high taxes. Never bothered me🤷‍♀️

horseyhorsey17 · 23/01/2023 10:47

We have some of the highest taxes in Europe - and under the Tories, who the Daily Mail keeps trying to prop up even while the tax-dodging cabal of crooks smash up the economy around us. I always find it hugely ironic that the Tories claim to be the party of low-tax when in fact taxes are high and they're destroying public services so people have to pay for private services instead - effectively another tax. Meanwhile nobody's had a pay rise since they came into power (apart from politicians and financiers, of course) and the cost of living has massively overtaken wage growth.

The country is screwed until we can kick them out of power.

bowlingalleyblues · 23/01/2023 10:47

Taking out more than they’re putting in…is USING public services that they’ve paid the majority towards, subsidised by the rich.

viques · 23/01/2023 10:43

Well many of them will be pensioners. As am I . My state pension, which of course I contributed to along with my work pension, is applied to my tax free allowance before any other income, I then pay tax on the rest of my pensions according to the criteria laid down by the Treasury. I am not sure what the DM wants me to do , offer to pay more ? Like most other people I also pay council tax, road fund tax, VAT, petrol tax, tax on wine, airport tax and probably a few more that they have sneaked in.

Perhaps I should take up smoking, or just buy a packet of cigarettes a day to make up my shortfall. Or just say thanks to Government ministers who have the wherewithal to pay £5m of tax they forgot to pay due to an oversight, or to the wives of Prime ministers who have graciously waived their non dom status to pay tax in the country where they have lived for a great many years.

Bumpitybumper · 23/01/2023 10:43

Bumpitybumper · 23/01/2023 10:41

Of course the whole point of taxation is to redistribute wealth. We don't live in a communist country!

We pay tax to fund public services. This spans health, education, transport, defence and the welfare state. As the welfare state and the demands on the health service have grown then it becomes harder to fund the other services without increasing taxes. I know MN loves to pretend that taxation of the wealthy is the answer to everything but we already live in a high tax economy where the highest payers receive very little for the amount they put in. The fact that the number of net contributors is reducing is bad news for everyone but the answer isn't to tax that minority even more heavily.

Instead we need to look at the structure of our economy. At things like productivity, innovation and enterprise. High taxation promotes none of these things, but these are the things we need to kickstart our economy. We need to look at Brexit again and the impact this has had on our GDP and labour market. We need to revisit how the welfare system and NHS are structured in the context of our population demographic, the cost of new treatments and our decline as a population into poor health and obesity. We cannot put our head in the sand anymore and hope to tax ourselves out of these problems.

I meant the whole point of taxations isn't to redistribute wealth

countrygirl99 · 23/01/2023 10:42

It's hardly surprising given the gross inequality in incomes in the UK.

nc1013 · 23/01/2023 10:42

wheresmymojo · 23/01/2023 09:41

Daily Fail are frothing today that higher earners pay more tax, and lower earners get more out in various benefits than they pay in.

I thought even the DF understood that the entire point of tax, it's whole reason for existing, is to re-distribute wealth to some extent with the wealthier paying more so that the less wealthy can benefit from a better standard of living?

Have I missed something - are there people who don't know this is what tax is fundamentally supposed to do?

I mean, I'm being fairly genuine...are there actually people who think it's like a bank account and you 'pay in' to 'get out'?

Also I don't believe the WHOLE point in tax is for the higher earners to re-distribute their benefits to the lower/non-earners by way of benefits.

I thought it was also to pay for:
NHS
Police
Fire
Education.....

FailingMotherhood · 23/01/2023 10:42

MrsSkylerWhite · 23/01/2023 09:43

You’re not wrong.

I do find it alarming though that 36 million people are receiving more from the state than they’re paying in contributions. That, clearly, can’t continue, just can’t be sustained.

Wages need to be set at a realistic level, so people don’t need state top ups just to survive.

I think that's the main thing - there's a huge number of people in employment who need top ups to survive, because wages aren't keeping up with the cost of living.

If we want fewer people claiming from the state, we need to increase the minimum wage, and put limits on rent costs, etc. But that involves putting people above profits, so that's unlikely to happen any time soon.

Also the amount of money lost through tax avoidance and evasion far exceeds the amount lost to benefit fraud, so maybe crack down on that, maybe? Or alternatively, just let tax dodgers continue to hold high ranking positions in government. Whatevs.

Bumpitybumper · 23/01/2023 10:41

Of course the whole point of taxation is to redistribute wealth. We don't live in a communist country!

We pay tax to fund public services. This spans health, education, transport, defence and the welfare state. As the welfare state and the demands on the health service have grown then it becomes harder to fund the other services without increasing taxes. I know MN loves to pretend that taxation of the wealthy is the answer to everything but we already live in a high tax economy where the highest payers receive very little for the amount they put in. The fact that the number of net contributors is reducing is bad news for everyone but the answer isn't to tax that minority even more heavily.

Instead we need to look at the structure of our economy. At things like productivity, innovation and enterprise. High taxation promotes none of these things, but these are the things we need to kickstart our economy. We need to look at Brexit again and the impact this has had on our GDP and labour market. We need to revisit how the welfare system and NHS are structured in the context of our population demographic, the cost of new treatments and our decline as a population into poor health and obesity. We cannot put our head in the sand anymore and hope to tax ourselves out of these problems.