Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is the WHOLE POINT of tax?

361 replies

wheresmymojo · 23/01/2023 09:41

Daily Fail are frothing today that higher earners pay more tax, and lower earners get more out in various benefits than they pay in.

I thought even the DF understood that the entire point of tax, it's whole reason for existing, is to re-distribute wealth to some extent with the wealthier paying more so that the less wealthy can benefit from a better standard of living?

Have I missed something - are there people who don't know this is what tax is fundamentally supposed to do?

I mean, I'm being fairly genuine...are there actually people who think it's like a bank account and you 'pay in' to 'get out'?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
5
Badbadbunny · 26/01/2023 10:17

@orangeoyster

Living in London (or any city) is not mandatory, and I would actively recommend that people live elsewhere.

Don't you realise that most decent jobs are in London and other major cities? If you want a good job, then basically, you have to work in a city and live near one.

It's one of the reason why the majority of graduates don't return to their home towns - there's no jobs for them there, except for low paid jobs like hospitality and retail.

Twillow · 25/01/2023 21:47

TinyTinyHamsterBalls · 23/01/2023 10:18

Agreed! @Throwncrumbs But won't be popular amongst the socialists, who will blame: the system, politics, companies, high earners for being so greedy for working hard for their money, everyone else but themselves.

Again, I ask the question that @Throwncrumbs didn't answer either - would you work extra hours in a minimum wage job where the system ensured that effectively you got paid £2 an hour for those hours?
Don't be so quick to blame people for this - the system is all wrong, it actively discourages them to work more.

MrsSkylerWhite · 24/01/2023 11:15

Throwncrumbs

Back in the 80s a woman who lived next door to me on benefits with two kids told me she had an annual holiday paid for to visit her family in Trinidad and Tobago, she came back once pregnant with a 3rd child she started to get benefits for… explain this!”

Its 2023. Any more recent anecdotes.

I remember the 80s very well. Unemployment figures were shocking, there were few jobs to be had.

MrsSkylerWhite · 24/01/2023 11:12

Throwncrumbs

Young working people who can’t come here isn’t the problem. It’s the young people already here who dont want to work because they can claim benefits!“

We don’t know any such young people. Our adult children are both studying, o e for BA one for MA, work when they’re not in classes and one is bringing up a young child at the same time (with her FT working husband).
Their peers are all doing similar (18-28 age range).
Do you know lots of young people who don’t want to work?

Oldsu · 24/01/2023 10:07

EsmeSusanOgg · 23/01/2023 20:47

Doesn't welfare also cover pensions?

No actually it does not it's separate from welfare but welfare covers a lot more things.www.gov.uk/government/publications/how-public-spending-was-calculated-in-your-tax-summary/how-public-spending-was-calculated-in-your-tax-summary

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 24/01/2023 09:56

Yanbu. I'm a net contributor, and I think this is perfectly fine. The redistribution of wealth and the funding of public services is the whole point of paying tax in the first place. I would like to live in a society which does this more effectively than we do at the moment, but the basic concept is perfectly reasonable as far as I'm concerned.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 24/01/2023 09:47

MrsSkylerWhite · 23/01/2023 09:43

You’re not wrong.

I do find it alarming though that 36 million people are receiving more from the state than they’re paying in contributions. That, clearly, can’t continue, just can’t be sustained.

Wages need to be set at a realistic level, so people don’t need state top ups just to survive.

It's not unsustainable as long as the top 1-10% own the majority of wealth. There's no point in increasing wages if the end result is increased prices, all that does is keep everyone in-situ.

The only way to improve things for the majority is to decrease the amount of wealth held by those at the top. Sounds harsh on paper until you realise that, even if you drastically reduced the wealth of the elite they'd still have more than the average person ever will.

I've lost count of how many times I've said this but, as an example you could take £2.5 trillion (enough to wipe out the UK national debt) from the top 1% (around 65,000 people) and they'd still have £15,000,000 each (which would take and average earned around 430 years to earn).

Unfortunately, far too many people ignore this level of wealth disparity at the very top and chose to focus their anger on those at the bottom. You see it all the time (this thread included) where people are genuinely angry that someone receiving benefits/top-ups can afford a big TV, decent car, or god forbid a holiday. Yet point out that Jim Ratcliffe has more money than a top surgeon would earn in over a thousand lifetimes and they just shrug their shoulders and go "meh".

hamstersarse · 24/01/2023 09:21

I'm not complaining, but just highlighting. The effective rate when people jump above £50k and lose their child benefit is even higher than 60% I believe

That is me. Single parent house. I work from January to June full time just to pay the tax for the year. I am the definition of 'taxed to the hilt'

I also have a dispute with HMRC at the moment about HICB and they go after me like you would not believe because I am not rich enough to get a lawyer and just easy picking for them. It is like dealing with the mafia. They arbitrarily apply charges with no warning, apply deadlines that are just made up, make it impossible to contact them (no email, letters never registered, a minimum of 1 hour holding to speak to someone only to be told they are not the right person).

This dispute with HMRC is connected to this case here and the gall of it is that the guy won the case, but in between the first win and the appeal, Rishi literally changed the law to say that anyone else with the same issue cannot use this as case law, even if HMRC lose the appeal.

Genuinely like the mafia.

KnittedCardi · 24/01/2023 09:17

Parentandteacher · 23/01/2023 22:29

Based on national living wage (minimum wage’s new name) from April, someone working full time at 37.5 hours per week would be paid £20,319
That’s the absolute minimum.

You can see why junior police, teaching assistants, teachers, nurses etc don’t think the relatively small extra pay is worth it.

Apples and pears. The T&C's, pensions and benefits, job security, will generally, be way better in public service, than someone on minimum wage.

C8H10N4O2 · 24/01/2023 09:01

Blossomtoes · 24/01/2023 08:50

Yes, NI was 6%. That still meant that very poorly paid people had 40% of their wages deducted at source. While rents were lower, inflation was running at double the current rate, it was completely out of control.

Incidentally, I don’t think tax relied on pension contributions is ridiculous. It’s an incentive to people who perhaps wouldn’t otherwise make their own provision and of course the money is taxed when it comes out.

Tax relief on pension contributions isn't my issue - its the fact that I get substantially more tax relief on my pension contributions than someone earning much less because its given at your top rate of tax.

I'd restrict tax relief on pensions to basic rate. The income derived from the pension income may be taxable but that is likely to be a much lower rate than a top rate tax payer receives on contributions and will benefit from the personal allowance.

Habber · 24/01/2023 08:52

I cannot understand how you would think you pay in 50% tax and then expect to get it back? It’s not a service we pay the government all your tax in order to reap back exactly all the money you paid in, how would that ever work? How would you know how much you took back out? It’s not a post office savings account

Blossomtoes · 24/01/2023 08:51

Relief, not relied!

Blossomtoes · 24/01/2023 08:50

C8H10N4O2 · 24/01/2023 08:14

If you mean the mid late 70s then NI was less than half the current rate (5-6%?), as was VAT plus rents and purchase prices were lower compared to average incomes.

Taxes rarely drop they just move around. In general tax on consumption is assumed to be harder to avoid and whatever the regime tax has always been largely optional for the ultra wealthy.

Yes, NI was 6%. That still meant that very poorly paid people had 40% of their wages deducted at source. While rents were lower, inflation was running at double the current rate, it was completely out of control.

Incidentally, I don’t think tax relied on pension contributions is ridiculous. It’s an incentive to people who perhaps wouldn’t otherwise make their own provision and of course the money is taxed when it comes out.

MrKlaw · 24/01/2023 08:49

sst1234 · 24/01/2023 08:08

Keeping more of the money you earnt is not a giveaway.

but whats the effective difference?

Case 1 - you get 4k a year in tax relief from the government. yes this is money you’ve earned but the government is taking 4k less tax from you. Thats 4k less they have to spend on things

Case 2 - you get 4k a year universal credit. Thats 4k less the government has to spend on things.

In both cases the government has the same amount less in their tax pot for things they need to do.

I don’t mind tax relief, but by the same token I don’t begrudge universal credit

BigBoysDontCry · 24/01/2023 08:36

Putting money in the hands of people at the bottom means that money is spent on goods and services which (mostly) raises more tax and keeps society running. It is the don't work/could work people that drives this anger and yet there are clearly bigger fish to fry in terms of lost taxation.

I was brought up in poverty with two working parents pre benefits and now have a decent income. I'm happy to pay tax and indeed happy to pay more if it gets spent on the right things and if corporations and the rich also play fair and if people don't take the piss.

C8H10N4O2 · 24/01/2023 08:17

edwinbear · 23/01/2023 18:37

@Dymaxion yep, that's correct. So it goes:

0-£50k 20% tax
£50k-100k 40% tax
£100k-£125K 60% tax (taking into account that you lose the personal allowance
£150k+ 45% tax

I'm not complaining, but just highlighting. The effective rate when people jump above £50k and lose their child benefit is even higher than 60% I believe.

Whilst this is more or less true and its an anomaly which really should be fixed, I've yet to have someone turn down a promotion because their salary tips into that £100-125 bracket. And of course we get a lot more tax relief on pension contributions (which is frankly ridiculous).

C8H10N4O2 · 24/01/2023 08:14

Blossomtoes · 23/01/2023 18:24

However did we cope when I started work and the basic rate was 33%?

If you mean the mid late 70s then NI was less than half the current rate (5-6%?), as was VAT plus rents and purchase prices were lower compared to average incomes.

Taxes rarely drop they just move around. In general tax on consumption is assumed to be harder to avoid and whatever the regime tax has always been largely optional for the ultra wealthy.

Sugarfree23 · 24/01/2023 08:14

@MrKlaw I've read that post about 3 times, the bit you are forgetting is the pension will be taxed when it's paid out.

sst1234 · 24/01/2023 08:08

MrKlaw · 23/01/2023 17:25

I had a fun argument on twitter the other day - someone complaining about the money you get on universal credit and how its a giveaway from the government.

But the same person was a high rate taxpayer and claiming 40% tax relief on his pension contributions. I argued that - depending on his contributions - the government is also handing him about the same amount by not deducting income tax from that amount of his earnings. le you pay £10k into your pension but you're only paying £6k from net salary the government covers the rest.

But apparantly thats 'good' tax policy because it benefits him. I suggestd he should be taxed on it as its income but he didnt like it.

Keeping more of the money you earnt is not a giveaway.

banjaxxed · 24/01/2023 07:37

@Parentandteacher and after 2 years it's nearly £28K
It's lower because they are in the Apprenticeship now

A PC after 7 years service is on £43K. Whilst it might be low to start it's still a good career with a good salary even in the medium term

Sugarfree23 · 23/01/2023 23:14

@Parentandteacher so many public sector workers are so underpaid.
A real kick in the teeth benefits are going up 10% yet their pay isn't. That 10% should be across the board.

Parentandteacher · 23/01/2023 22:29

banjaxxed · 23/01/2023 20:29

Police officers start on £23,500 and it increases rapidly. It's disingenuous to compare it to someone working in Aldi

Based on national living wage (minimum wage’s new name) from April, someone working full time at 37.5 hours per week would be paid £20,319
That’s the absolute minimum.

You can see why junior police, teaching assistants, teachers, nurses etc don’t think the relatively small extra pay is worth it.

EsmeSusanOgg · 23/01/2023 20:47

MrsSkylerWhite · 23/01/2023 09:43

You’re not wrong.

I do find it alarming though that 36 million people are receiving more from the state than they’re paying in contributions. That, clearly, can’t continue, just can’t be sustained.

Wages need to be set at a realistic level, so people don’t need state top ups just to survive.

Doesn't welfare also cover pensions?

banjaxxed · 23/01/2023 20:29

Police officers start on £23,500 and it increases rapidly. It's disingenuous to compare it to someone working in Aldi

Bodybarnet · 23/01/2023 19:54

orangeoyster · 23/01/2023 19:33

That's all there is to it then!

I'm not really sure what your point is. Most of those jobs feature within the most dangerous 10 jobs in the UK and yet you get paid far higher for less difficult or dangerous jobs. A police officer starts on 21k. You get more working in Aldi.