Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I despise this woman

60 replies

Hiimblahblah · 23/01/2023 08:52

DP’s best friend since childhood has been with a woman that we both truly despise for several years now, and they’re due to be married.

The reason we feel this way toward her is because she’s, in our options, quite abusive.

She demands to check his phone to see what he’s been saying to his family about her, as he’s confided in them before about arguments that they’ve had.

She wants to know clothes that he was wearing in the nights he was with previous sexual partners, and will ask him again several months later to see if he was telling the truth in his original answer.

She gets angry at the mention of any of his previous sexual partners names, even if someone just has the same name as them, and they’re not actually talking about said previous partner. (Hope that makes sense?)

One night, before I realised what type of person she was, she told me that she could easily “kick the fuck out of” her DPs sister over something that his sister said about her in a text message, that she obviously went through his phone and read.

He’s afraid to spend time with his friends without her incase she accuses him of something, or has taken offence to something he has done before he met her in his absence, and he has to go home to her being a twat. She even joined his on his staff Christmas party, because she “missed hers” 🙄

She will ignore him for days after an argument. She’s previously proudly told me (no idea why a person would admit to this) that she has done the same with her family after arguments with them.

In my shoes, how would you handle this person? We used to always ask them round for drinks and plan to meet up with them. However, ever since I realised what type of person she was I’ve stopped bothering and started keeping my distance from her.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ButterBastardBeans · 23/01/2023 13:37

You have described perfectly my step sons wife. We have had to detach completely as we were getting drawn into situations where we were made to look like the villains when it's all background manipulation by her.

I have been in a similar relationship, many years ago. Eventually there was a 'straw that broke the camels back' moment and I left him. I was aware of his abusive nature but felt unable to leave. Hopefully your DH's best friend will have an eye opening moment too but I suspect she will get pregnant ASAP and he will be tied to her forever then.

BubziOwl · 23/01/2023 13:18

She sounds like my brother's girlfriend. She's truly the nastiest person I've ever come across, and is incredibly manipulative and abusive.

Unfortunately all I feel you can do is be supportive, don't sink to her level, and point out when she's being abusive. That's what we do with my brother. It's not really working if I'm honest, but there's nothing else we can do Sad

1Dream · 23/01/2023 11:50

My sister is emotionally abusive -sometimes physically abusive by throwing objects- to her husband. I have had to cut contact with them unfortunately because I was getting fed up with her behaviour.

I feel sorry for her husband he was a nice man and wasn't allowed any friends and only spoke to me and my husband, but I'm sure my sister was reading all of his messages about what he said to us.

He went to a friends bucks party on a boat with friends that came over from his home country to Australia (along with other strangers also on bucks parties of their own) which had topless waitresses as one would imagine might be seen at that kind of party and she got upset and wrote publicly on her Facebook how disgusting he and his friends were and they should he ashamed of themselves for being in the presence of half naked females.

Meanwhile she was a lesbian (and probably still is attracted to females) and said she enjoyed going to strip clubs.

It caused a massive row between them and his friends and he no longer has any friends.

She has totally broken him and he isn't allowed to spend his own money even on a chocolate bar but she could spend his money and her money on whatever she wants calls him horrible names saying he's fat and useless etc.

I so wish I could reach out to him but it's been 4 years and I don't want to cause a fight between them so I have had to let him deal with her on his own. He is just a shell of himself.

If you're in the position to, reach out he may come to a sudden realisation of her behaviour.

BobDear · 23/01/2023 11:45

Most people in abusive relationships are frozen - unable to move backwards or forwards. You lose your ability to think for yourself because all of your decisions are based around making choices that will avoid conflict. You forget how to choose what is right and best for you. When I was in a vaguely similar situation, all I wanted was for the decision to be taken away from me - for someone to ride in on a white horse and shout "Enough is enough!". I am not saying that this is how it is for your friend but he probably feels an element of 'no turning back now' and also, sunk costs (worth googling).

I think it would be really helpful for your DH to resume their friendship, but I also feel strongly that you should try to sit him down once - before he makes any commitment - and show him that there is a way out if he wants it. Tell him that nobody will judge him for leaving her, that you are fairly confident that marriage and kids will only make things worse and that his BEST chance to leave is pre-marraige and pre-kids.

If he is defensive and insists it's what he wants and that he is happy, you just remind him that you care and will always be there.

But please - don't be afraid to have one straight conversation with him and urge him to rethink before it's too late. He may just be waiting for someone to 'okay' his gut feeling. That's how it was for me.

Calphurnia88 · 23/01/2023 11:40

Hiimblahblah · 23/01/2023 11:24

Thank you for this ❤️

May I ask how you would recommend I approach it?

Depending on the dynamic, I think you and/or your partner should arrange to meet your friend alone. Preferably at home, as its not a conversation to have in public.

Then I would just be really honest about how you see the relationship. Tell him you want him to be happy, but you're concerned about him and the way he is being treated, and the way his partner behaves. That you'll be there for him no matter what he chooses to do, but that he deserves much, much better. I would tread really carefully with the term 'abuse/abusive' (although that's exactly what this is) as he might panic and get defensive. I think it's fair to say that she is extremely controlling and you do not see this as a healthy relationship.

CleopatrasBeautifulNose · 23/01/2023 11:30

These things are usually so slow and insidious you don't know you're in until you're in if that makes sense. 😔
I bet it was incredible and exciting when they got together and all the drama comes from her 'passion for him'... Until one day he wakes up and realises it stopped being fun a long time ago and he's stuck.

Hiimblahblah · 23/01/2023 11:27

CandlelightGlow · 23/01/2023 11:16

Would you say that if the OP's DP's friend was a woman and the person OP is describing was a man? Please check your biases.

OP he is in an abusive relationship and I would ask your DP to speak to him confidentially. I think it's a really really difficult thing to navigate as a third party, because you don't want to invoke backlash from the abusive partner which would be directed at him, but you want to intervene when you know someone close to you is going through this.

My city's local domestic abuse charity has set up an advertising campaign recently where they tell people who suspect domestic abuse to contact them (not just for victims themselves to contact them). Would this be an option? They can give you professional advice on what might be best to do.

Thank you so much for this!

As much as I would love to say it would be an option, I don’t think that he believes that he’s being abused 😞 I can’t explain why tbh, but I just have a feeling if that makes any sense?

OP posts:
LookyEre · 23/01/2023 11:25

Swimmingpoolsally · 23/01/2023 09:11

Fairly sure there is two sides to this …

Would you say this if the abusive partner was a man? If OP said he friend was with a man who did all of this? You'd come on and say 'fairly sure there are two sides to this...'? No I highly doubt it.

OP just keep your distance and if he asks tell him the complete truth. You feel his in a controlling relationship and you're always there for him but you cannot be around his partner.

Hiimblahblah · 23/01/2023 11:24

Calphurnia88 · 23/01/2023 11:06

@EmailMeDontcall the response you're getting is because you've said that your DH's family would say the same about you. OP hasn't just described this woman as controlling and abusive, she's included really specific examples of controlling and abusive behaviour - demanding to see his phone, interrogating him and getting angry about his previous sexual partners, making violent threats towards his sister, ignoring him for days after an argument, making him feel afraid to spend time with friends.

Surely you're not saying that the same could be said of you, and using autism as an excuse?

@Hiimblahblah I disagree with PP who have said to stay out of it. If this were one of my close girlfriends I would have to say something. It's up to your friend what he chooses to do, but sometimes you need a wakeup call (speaking from experience).

Thank you for this ❤️

May I ask how you would recommend I approach it?

OP posts:
Hiimblahblah · 23/01/2023 11:22

theseangeldelights · 23/01/2023 10:52

OP, you know that all the examples you've mentioned could be spun to sound bad when there may be another story? I'm not saying that is the case, just be very careful when making assumptions about other people's relationships!

This is fair, and I totally understand it. I consider myself an open minded person, and I hate to have an opinion on someone before I’ve seen their character with my own eyes.

However, this woman has told me herself that, when she lived with them, she ignored her family for months on end when they had a row. She (seemingly proudly) told me that it got to the point where her sister cried and screamed at her for ignoring her for several months. She’s admitted to doing this same thing (only for a week, rather than months) to her own DP. She also informed me about demanding to know what clothes he wore on nights he slept with previous partners (and then asking him again months later to see if he lied), and admitted to reading his texts (hence her threatening his sister to me).

OP posts:
CandlelightGlow · 23/01/2023 11:18

Why do you think he is with her? Do you think she has redeeming qualities or he is in a domestic abuse situation?

There are some really ignorant responses on this thread. All abusers have "redeeming" qualities it's how the dynamic works. Just because they are capable of being nice sometimes does not in any way negate the abuse.

Hiimblahblah · 23/01/2023 11:16

CleopatrasBeautifulNose · 23/01/2023 10:43

@DanseAvecLesLoups 👏👏
Well done, having difficult conversations takes courage, your friend really needed that. Thank goodness you were by his side and didn't just look the other way.
My close friends brother didn't get that, now he's married and stays because his abusive wife would cut him off from his kids, hang him out to dry and take it out on the children (one with sen) if he left. He's a shell.
The abusive wife has had a successful career, is lauded as a shining example in her field, but in her personal life she's something else, so cold and nasty and has systematically isolated him from any support.

This is absolutely heart breaking 💔

How dare any woman treat their children this way, it fucking sickens me!! Your poor friends brother 😢

OP posts:
CandlelightGlow · 23/01/2023 11:16

Swimmingpoolsally · 23/01/2023 09:11

Fairly sure there is two sides to this …

Would you say that if the OP's DP's friend was a woman and the person OP is describing was a man? Please check your biases.

OP he is in an abusive relationship and I would ask your DP to speak to him confidentially. I think it's a really really difficult thing to navigate as a third party, because you don't want to invoke backlash from the abusive partner which would be directed at him, but you want to intervene when you know someone close to you is going through this.

My city's local domestic abuse charity has set up an advertising campaign recently where they tell people who suspect domestic abuse to contact them (not just for victims themselves to contact them). Would this be an option? They can give you professional advice on what might be best to do.

Hiimblahblah · 23/01/2023 11:14

RudsyFarmer · 23/01/2023 10:39

Why do you think he is with her? Do you think she has redeeming qualities or he is in a domestic abuse situation?

Honestly, I think he does love her, but IMHO she’s not the love of his life.

I genuinely believe he’s in a race to get married and have babies because his friends are doing it and he feels like he’s missing out. He was with his previous DP for almost a decade and it went tits up, and I feel like he might be trying to make up for lost time.

I’ve been wrong before though, so I could very well be wrong now 🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
Hiimblahblah · 23/01/2023 11:08

GrinAndVomit · 23/01/2023 10:20

I had a friend in this situation.
I realised if I said anything, it would mean that her partner had more reason to isolate her from me so I played nice.
I was polite to him. I never slagged him off but never sang his praises. I made a conscious effort to not speak about him at all.
I wanted to make sure she would feel safe coming to me when she was ready to leave. I knew if I said anything negative about him, she’d cut me off like she did other friends and family. I knew if I was too nice about him, she’d feel like I wouldn’t believe her.
A year or so later, she left. We are still friends.
It was a difficult rope to balance on.

You just need to know your friend quite well to be able to predict his reaction. Would a conversation about her mean the end of your friendship or just give him food for thought?

I’m so sorry to hear this. Thank goodness she got away and your friendship is still intact ❤️

My DP has told his friend exactly what he thinks of the situation he’s in, but it hasn’t changed anything. I’ve know his best friend for a very long time, and I would like to sit down and talk to him about his situation. However, I know in my heart I would only be doing it to vent my own frustrations about his relationship, which would be selfish. It would be different if I had something to say that he didn’t already know, but I don’t 😞

OP posts:
Calphurnia88 · 23/01/2023 11:06

@EmailMeDontcall the response you're getting is because you've said that your DH's family would say the same about you. OP hasn't just described this woman as controlling and abusive, she's included really specific examples of controlling and abusive behaviour - demanding to see his phone, interrogating him and getting angry about his previous sexual partners, making violent threats towards his sister, ignoring him for days after an argument, making him feel afraid to spend time with friends.

Surely you're not saying that the same could be said of you, and using autism as an excuse?

@Hiimblahblah I disagree with PP who have said to stay out of it. If this were one of my close girlfriends I would have to say something. It's up to your friend what he chooses to do, but sometimes you need a wakeup call (speaking from experience).

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 23/01/2023 11:02

MN is very interesting.

Talks of an abusive woman, and people say “There’s two sides to every story” “Keep out of it”.

But if this was an OP talking about her female friend and a man who demands to check her phone would be told to call 101 immediately.

ReneBumsWombats · 23/01/2023 10:59

theseangeldelights · 23/01/2023 10:52

OP, you know that all the examples you've mentioned could be spun to sound bad when there may be another story? I'm not saying that is the case, just be very careful when making assumptions about other people's relationships!

Talking about kicking the fuck out of his sister? Checking his phone and trying to catch him out regarding previous relationships?

ShimmeringShirts · 23/01/2023 10:55

@EmailMeDontcall but there are better ways to manage it, therapy works massively. But when the world sees one autistic person acting in a way that is abusive for a NT person it affects their views and opinions of all autistic people. They then go on and carry those opinions throughout their lives and apply them to other people with autism they come across. It does affect everybody, and it is on you to find ways to cope with it in real life. Adults with autism or AuDHD aren’t prone to meltdowns, we find ways to cope. When you’re an adult you have the capacity to recognise and control yourself, that’s not the same for children which is where the meltdowns come from.

theseangeldelights · 23/01/2023 10:52

OP, you know that all the examples you've mentioned could be spun to sound bad when there may be another story? I'm not saying that is the case, just be very careful when making assumptions about other people's relationships!

CleopatrasBeautifulNose · 23/01/2023 10:43

@DanseAvecLesLoups 👏👏
Well done, having difficult conversations takes courage, your friend really needed that. Thank goodness you were by his side and didn't just look the other way.
My close friends brother didn't get that, now he's married and stays because his abusive wife would cut him off from his kids, hang him out to dry and take it out on the children (one with sen) if he left. He's a shell.
The abusive wife has had a successful career, is lauded as a shining example in her field, but in her personal life she's something else, so cold and nasty and has systematically isolated him from any support.

RudsyFarmer · 23/01/2023 10:39

Why do you think he is with her? Do you think she has redeeming qualities or he is in a domestic abuse situation?

Guihgesfy5es · 23/01/2023 10:37

EmailMeDontcall · 23/01/2023 10:34

Thankyou for wording it so kindly, I’ll chat with my husband I do regularly feel guilty and he says he’s fine and understands but I’ll make an effort to check regularly he is feeling ok

Glad it helps. That's the best you can do. Check in with others to see if they are ok too. He might feel bad about saying he is not ok, sometimes people, especially men feel the need to be "strong" and look after those they love. My advice would be to do as you say and then consider asking in another way in a few months to make sure he has more than one chance to open up

I feel this would be a good way to have an open and mutually supportive relationship.

Best of luck

EmailMeDontcall · 23/01/2023 10:36

nc1013 · 23/01/2023 10:34

@EmailMeDontcall ..... I’m not abusive. Your comments are extremely offensive. I’ve explained how I need to call my husband more than the average person would NOT to check up on him but for SUPPORT when needed. You have taken a snapshot of something and jumped to conclusions much like MIL etc do which is very offensive. Each person with ASD is different and one of my coping strategies is to have my husband to talk to whenever I need it. It’s not every 10 mins it might be 2/3 times a day it’s not excessive and I don’t need to be attacked or to feel like I have to justify how I manage my medical condition to a random who has jumped on me in a judgemental manner. How I manage MY autism doesn’t give anyone else a bad name.

I wouldn't deem calling a partner 2/3 times a day to be abusive or controlling in its own right. Obviously your DHs family see more to it than that?

I think when you always hear one side of a conversation and someone is talking about times etc you could easily assume they were in a controlling relationship if you don’t know the background

EmailMeDontcall · 23/01/2023 10:34

Guihgesfy5es · 23/01/2023 10:31

It might be worth talking to your partner about whether he is coping with this.

I had an autistic colleague who was an intern and had several meltdowns. As her manager, I became a trusted person and wanted to help. I think I did and hope what I did make a difference to her long term career. However, the meltdowns and coaching took a toll on myself. She didn't recognise the impact this would have on others. I spoke to her about this and she really thought it was not a problem as "lots of people have mental health issues". I don't think I convinced her that she needed to get help for meltdowns but she did get some help. After the year was done, her flatmate couldn't cope, I found it incredibly difficult and stressful. She had a committed boyfriend and parents who she expected to cope with frequent meltdowns.

Everyone is different and I do not think you will be the same as this person. But perhaps her autism made it hard for her to recognise the emotional toll she placed on others so she could cope with her life. Maybe it's worth checking in whether it is causing others significant trauma to make your life easier

Thankyou for wording it so kindly, I’ll chat with my husband I do regularly feel guilty and he says he’s fine and understands but I’ll make an effort to check regularly he is feeling ok

Swipe left for the next trending thread