Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to feel that teachers shouldn't really be striking?

464 replies

Pinky1011 · 23/01/2023 02:47

They have 3 months PAID holidays only work 9-4pm, no dangerous or really bad working conditions, great job security, good pensions, They had pay rises last year up to 8%!!! I work in the private sector and haven't had a pay rise in almost 6 years! I just feel compared to alot of other professions, teachers have it quite good? I mean their starting salary is the same as a junior doctor. I get it inflation has wrecked everyone, but surely the issue should be getting inflation down? Not just demanding for more money, which by the way only fuels inflation further. AIBU to feel that teachers just don't know how good they have it compared to the rest of us?

OP posts:
foxynoxy · 24/01/2023 07:58

Changechangechanging · 24/01/2023 07:34

then...would you support the actual pay for maths teachers to be 10-15k higher than other subjects? So they could hit 55k without taking on extra responsibility?

In my opinion all that would happen is the cheaper/more popular subjects would rapidly become.shortage subjects because a)we should value a rounded education and b) the workload is high in all subjects so it achieves nothing other than anger and frustration paying some of.us more than others. I say that as a shortage subject teacher.

Personally I think letting state school teachers off a percentage of their loans at 5 and 10 years with total write off at 15. I would totally write off the loan of any teacher staying in a school in a very deprived area for 5 years. I would increase the pay of experienced teachers to stop them seeking better pay outside of.educatikn and to keep them in the classroom rather than have no choice but to climb the career ladder for more.money

And I would.ensure that there is.enougjnfunding in schools for heads not be forced to find any reason to push out more expensive staff.

I can see your point and it may cause ill feeling so would probably be a non starter but some disciplines are basically oversubscribed and not everyone within those disciplines will be able or want to switch to the higher paying shortage disciplines. I can't see them leaving teaching in droves because of it but can understand that the staff room could become tense. Shortage subjects are often those where the skills are also in demand in the private sector though and without at least attempting to address pay I'm not sure how this will be resolved.

The loans are a good point and could incentivise some people to enter teaching.

Agree that headteachers should not be put in the position where pushing out experienced and more expensive staff is to their gain. A teaching post should be fully funded, where an individual sits on the scale shouldn't matter.

Your other point on paying more for experience is a tricky one and exists across all professions. If you are good at your job then you progress to the next rung on the ladder which is often leading/managing and no longer "doing". I've previously worked places where the experienced do-er can end up earning the same or more than the team leader and that causes plenty of other issues with nobody prepared to become the leader/manager and deal with HR related issues.

Changechangechanging · 24/01/2023 07:34

then...would you support the actual pay for maths teachers to be 10-15k higher than other subjects? So they could hit 55k without taking on extra responsibility?

In my opinion all that would happen is the cheaper/more popular subjects would rapidly become.shortage subjects because a)we should value a rounded education and b) the workload is high in all subjects so it achieves nothing other than anger and frustration paying some of.us more than others. I say that as a shortage subject teacher.

Personally I think letting state school teachers off a percentage of their loans at 5 and 10 years with total write off at 15. I would totally write off the loan of any teacher staying in a school in a very deprived area for 5 years. I would increase the pay of experienced teachers to stop them seeking better pay outside of.educatikn and to keep them in the classroom rather than have no choice but to climb the career ladder for more.money

And I would.ensure that there is.enougjnfunding in schools for heads not be forced to find any reason to push out more expensive staff.

NEmama · 24/01/2023 07:24

foxynoxy · 24/01/2023 07:11

I personally would argue that it's not fair to keep equal pay. And before everyone jumps down my throat I'm not trying to turn teachers against each other.

However as stated in my earlier posts shortages are often in certain disciplines and also geographical areas. It is no coincidence that some disciplines do not struggle to recruit staff when teaching is one of the only careers related to their degree that offers a half decent salary.

My experience with shortage subjects is that there is a heavy emphasis on bursaries and golden handshakes but little incentive after that. An overhaul is needed with clearly defined distinct pay scales.

Again not trying to turn teachers against each other. And not arguing for anybody to have their pay reduced. Just new pay scales in harder to attract disciplines.

We need to improve conditions for everyone. It's not only about pay.

Any pay rises have not been funded recently which causes further gaps elsewhere

Quinoawoman · 24/01/2023 07:22

Mexicola · 24/01/2023 06:52

I completely agree in respect of primary school teachers. I have about 6 primary school teacher friends and over the long summer break they go in about 3 times to clean and sort their classroom and set up for the new year. About an hour after school every day to mark etc. (which when you only teach 9-3 gives you a two hour window for a normal day anyway. Not to mention they get a full morning or afternoon away from the classroom included in that to do admin and marking.

it’s the same as usual all the lazy “hard done” ones make the loudest noise about how busy they are all the while, all the efficient work smarter not harder crowd just get on with it.

I’d say it’s decent pay even if you only worked half those holidays. Even if you don’t technically get paid for all the holidays and it’s worked out over 12 months you’re still not hard done by like you all make out!!

I have worked with teachers like this before. Generally they are either not fulfilling their respinsibilities WRT planning and marking, or riding on the coat tails of other team members who ard doing all the planning and organisation for them.

I consider myself to be someone who does a good job and knows how to prioritise - but I was still working from 7.30 to 5.30 on school days, plus about 2 evenings a week until 9pm at home on school-related stuff. That's a lot less than most others do.

Quinoawoman · 24/01/2023 07:12

foxynoxy · 24/01/2023 06:51

Yes, the opportunities to progress to the higher bands are few and far between. However, I would also argue that your husband and best friend's salaries are not typical within their fields too outside of the SE. If you are based in the SE or a major city then I recognise that there can be a pay issue in the same way as other public sector roles (mine included).

There are opportunities outside of teaching and the public sector to earn big money. I too have friends that made arguably better career choices after uni but unfortunately trying to gain parity through significantly increasing the pay in public sector roles is not the answer.

Then you have to expect experienced teachers to leave the profession, leaving shortages for your kids.

You can't have it both ways.

foxynoxy · 24/01/2023 07:11

NEmama · 24/01/2023 07:01

@foxynoxy it'd be lovely as I am a maths teacher but it wouldn't really be fair would it.

Some schools do offer financial incentives to get people into roles that are hard to fill.
Some schools also offer extra TLRs to retain good staff who are hard to replace. It's just not talked about much as it's kept quiet.

Still struggle to attract and retain staff in general. Mfl teachers are shortage too.
Science maths can't even get subject specialist on supply.

I personally would argue that it's not fair to keep equal pay. And before everyone jumps down my throat I'm not trying to turn teachers against each other.

However as stated in my earlier posts shortages are often in certain disciplines and also geographical areas. It is no coincidence that some disciplines do not struggle to recruit staff when teaching is one of the only careers related to their degree that offers a half decent salary.

My experience with shortage subjects is that there is a heavy emphasis on bursaries and golden handshakes but little incentive after that. An overhaul is needed with clearly defined distinct pay scales.

Again not trying to turn teachers against each other. And not arguing for anybody to have their pay reduced. Just new pay scales in harder to attract disciplines.

NEmama · 24/01/2023 07:01

@foxynoxy it'd be lovely as I am a maths teacher but it wouldn't really be fair would it.

Some schools do offer financial incentives to get people into roles that are hard to fill.
Some schools also offer extra TLRs to retain good staff who are hard to replace. It's just not talked about much as it's kept quiet.

Still struggle to attract and retain staff in general. Mfl teachers are shortage too.
Science maths can't even get subject specialist on supply.

foxynoxy · 24/01/2023 06:57

NEmama · 24/01/2023 06:28

Even with a £27000 bursary. It's awful isn't it.
We have 2 maths trainees NE uni.

Serious question then...would you support the actual pay for maths teachers to be 10-15k higher than other subjects? So they could hit 55k without taking on extra responsibility?

Not being goady but it's something that I think needs a rational debate.

Mexicola · 24/01/2023 06:52

I completely agree in respect of primary school teachers. I have about 6 primary school teacher friends and over the long summer break they go in about 3 times to clean and sort their classroom and set up for the new year. About an hour after school every day to mark etc. (which when you only teach 9-3 gives you a two hour window for a normal day anyway. Not to mention they get a full morning or afternoon away from the classroom included in that to do admin and marking.

it’s the same as usual all the lazy “hard done” ones make the loudest noise about how busy they are all the while, all the efficient work smarter not harder crowd just get on with it.

I’d say it’s decent pay even if you only worked half those holidays. Even if you don’t technically get paid for all the holidays and it’s worked out over 12 months you’re still not hard done by like you all make out!!

foxynoxy · 24/01/2023 06:51

Quinoawoman · 24/01/2023 06:22

But that is pretty much the maximum you will ever earn as a teacher. Unless you become a head teacher or deputy, yoi hit UPS 3 and there is nowhere else to go. No further chance of promotion. So the starting salary is good but after that, it kinda goes nowhere.

I have a 1st class degree and chose teaching. My husband has a 2:2 and chose to go into IT. He earns almost 4x my FTE. My best friend from uni went into tax consultancy and earns a 6 figure salary. I feel like I've been mugged off majorly by my own career choices.

Yes, the opportunities to progress to the higher bands are few and far between. However, I would also argue that your husband and best friend's salaries are not typical within their fields too outside of the SE. If you are based in the SE or a major city then I recognise that there can be a pay issue in the same way as other public sector roles (mine included).

There are opportunities outside of teaching and the public sector to earn big money. I too have friends that made arguably better career choices after uni but unfortunately trying to gain parity through significantly increasing the pay in public sector roles is not the answer.

NEmama · 24/01/2023 06:28

Supernova18 · 23/01/2023 09:45

I have a trainee teacher at the moment. His course has 2 trainee teachers in his subject area, 2! there are 25 places..

Even with a £27000 bursary. It's awful isn't it.
We have 2 maths trainees NE uni.

Quinoawoman · 24/01/2023 06:22

foxynoxy · 23/01/2023 19:27

Please don't put words in my mouth. I did not call anybody a "thicko".

I consider a 47k salary (adjusted for unpaid leave) approx 40k with unpaid leave to be a good one. This is achievable for a significant proportion of teachers in locations all across the country.

But that is pretty much the maximum you will ever earn as a teacher. Unless you become a head teacher or deputy, yoi hit UPS 3 and there is nowhere else to go. No further chance of promotion. So the starting salary is good but after that, it kinda goes nowhere.

I have a 1st class degree and chose teaching. My husband has a 2:2 and chose to go into IT. He earns almost 4x my FTE. My best friend from uni went into tax consultancy and earns a 6 figure salary. I feel like I've been mugged off majorly by my own career choices.

echt · 24/01/2023 06:18

MrsHamlet · 23/01/2023 21:09

Working to rule only works if there is a rule though. And if I don't get my books marked in DT, which I won't, I'd sure as hell be disciplined for not doing in the "any other hours".

This.

The directed/non-directed time, and the vagueness of the latter, works to the English government's advantage in terms of a work to rule.

I've only seen WTR work, and yes it did work, was in the last but one pay round in Victoria. The teachers' contract explicitly states 38 hours per week on the premises for 40 weeks. It's gold and you'll never see a UK government agreeing to a contract like this.

It's the weekly total that nails it.

Do teachers work above and beyond that? Yes they do. The point is they can't be made to do it. It obliges management to do some planning of, say, meetings/catch-up/revision sessions and not behave as if they have some Mary Poppins magic bag of teacher time to fund such stuff.

bk1981 · 24/01/2023 06:08

BlueWhippets · 23/01/2023 07:27

@bk1981 Starting salary is about the same as a junior doctor though..

If you teach in Central London it is £1000 less. It is significantly lower if you teach in the rest of the country. As I said, a quick Google before posting would have explained this to you.

NewPapaGuinea · 24/01/2023 05:58

You say you don’t consider it part-time, but continually bang on about pro-rated and adjusted pay. Teachers work full-time through longer working weeks.

Twiglets1 · 24/01/2023 04:15

FamousPrincess · 23/01/2023 20:17

If I had another chance in life, I'd love to be a teacher for the primary kids in London as paid really well, rewarding and loads of hols.

I don’t know…. A friend of mine left her TA role in our school to begin teacher training in a local primary school in quite a deprived area.
She dropped out because she hadn’t anticipated being abused (verbally & physically) by primary school aged children and called a cunt.

Overandunderit · 23/01/2023 23:07

I trained and lasted two years. I loved teaching but hated being a teacher. Regular 50+ hour weeks and the holidays are a fiction other than the 6 week holidays.

Now work in a public sector job loosely related to teaching, make more than I would as a teacher finish at 4.30 and don't take home any work or stress... I still have anxiety dreams about that time.

100% solidarity with teachers for demanding better. These disingenuous posts about "oh I just want to understand what's so bad 13 weeks holiday!" are grim and goady.

HereBeFuckery · 23/01/2023 22:54

@foxynoxy

I didn't 'put words in your mouth'. In fact, I explicitly used the verb 'imply' because I read between the lines of your condescending post saying that teachers get a good pay deal based on their qualifications, which they would not be able to command in other industries. I pointed out that many teachers, myself included, are over qualified and could choose to command higher salaries elsewhere. Would you prefer us to leave teaching and remove children's access to our knowledge and skills?

"What am I conceding? I have never stated it's an easy job nor that they shouldn't be paid more to attract and retain talent."

You have, in fact, said exactly this. You said that teachers get a decent salary given their level of skills, experience and qualifications. The inference to be drawn here is that the salary is adequate for the abilities of the teachers.

Perhaps you don't enjoy others pointing out the inconsistencies in your argument, but as I say to Y7, that seems to be a 'you' problem, not a 'me' problem.

noblegiraffe · 23/01/2023 21:11

I believe Winedup is in Scotland where the contract does specify hours that could potentially be worked to.

England doesn't have a rule to work to, which is why work-to-rule here would be shite. And was shite when we did it in the Gove years. No one noticed.

MrsHamlet · 23/01/2023 21:09

Working to rule only works if there is a rule though. And if I don't get my books marked in DT, which I won't, I'd sure as hell be disciplined for not doing in the "any other hours".

WineDup · 23/01/2023 20:47

echt · 23/01/2023 20:36

Those would be the ones marking and prepping after the 9-4. Would you like them to stop?

I’ve been thinking about this and actually, I think teachers working to rule would be a good idea, to prove what we really do.

arrive at work 8:30am, set up for class, teach til 3. That’s 6.5 hours per day. 32.5 per week.

Im contracted for 35/week, so I do need to do my other 2.5 weekly hours. And I’ve got an hour long meeting once per week after school, so I’ve still got 1.5 hours left. I need to keep some of that, since approx once per month we have parents night for 3hours. Which leaves me 3 hours per month for planning and marking. I could probably run round quickly and mark the jotters while I am teaching, but I’m going to have to cancel my supported study. Oh and there is tracking to do as well? Oh the netball club is on? Sorry, no it isn’t. Oh, and your child will be exclusively working from textbooks, as I don’t have time to plan anything more engaging. And I’ll not be able to photocopy the homework sheets. Or mark the homework once it’s done. Oh, and don’t expect me to upload anything on Google classroom.

foxynoxy · 23/01/2023 20:39

noblegiraffe · 23/01/2023 20:27

As previously mentioned the shortages are typically across certain disciplines. Whenever it is suggested that some disciplines should be better compensated to attract and retain talent there is outrage.

Whenever it’s suggested that teachers are paid more to attract and retain talent, people roll out the ‘cushy’ job argument.

Now you concede that is not enough to attract and retain talent?

What am I conceding? I have never stated it's an easy job nor that they shouldn't be paid more to attract and retain talent.

I would strongly suggest that a blanket pay increase is both unnecessary and counterproductive. My feeling would be that targeted pay increases in certain disciplines and geographical areas would alleviate shortages somewhat. I suspect there would be no political appetite to broach it again, which is terrible news for our children. They deserve better.

echt · 23/01/2023 20:36

Rewis · 23/01/2023 20:20

I do think teachers work hard and it's not always 9-5. But there are also a lot of martyr teachers.

Those would be the ones marking and prepping after the 9-4. Would you like them to stop?

noblegiraffe · 23/01/2023 20:27

As previously mentioned the shortages are typically across certain disciplines. Whenever it is suggested that some disciplines should be better compensated to attract and retain talent there is outrage.

Whenever it’s suggested that teachers are paid more to attract and retain talent, people roll out the ‘cushy’ job argument.

Now you concede that is not enough to attract and retain talent?

FlairBand · 23/01/2023 20:25

Rewis · 23/01/2023 20:20

I do think teachers work hard and it's not always 9-5. But there are also a lot of martyr teachers.

I agree.