Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to feel that teachers shouldn't really be striking?

464 replies

Pinky1011 · 23/01/2023 02:47

They have 3 months PAID holidays only work 9-4pm, no dangerous or really bad working conditions, great job security, good pensions, They had pay rises last year up to 8%!!! I work in the private sector and haven't had a pay rise in almost 6 years! I just feel compared to alot of other professions, teachers have it quite good? I mean their starting salary is the same as a junior doctor. I get it inflation has wrecked everyone, but surely the issue should be getting inflation down? Not just demanding for more money, which by the way only fuels inflation further. AIBU to feel that teachers just don't know how good they have it compared to the rest of us?

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 24/01/2023 15:45

Doubt anybody will fall for that again

Well there you go then. You're prior warned, unionised and up for the fight. That's a lot more than most.

TheKeatingFive · 24/01/2023 15:43

That's why these exercises work by benchmarking pay/ payrises against private sector equivalent roles: people with similar qualifcations, experience and seniority. If their private sector counterparts have received rises then of course public sector workers with the same skills should get equivalent rises, otherwise the best ones will leave

But it's never as simple as comparing salary. Pension, job security, conditions, etc.

I 100% agree that there is a huge problem with teacher retention. However it seems like it's less to do with the package at first glance, and more to do with the fact that the hours being put in are not in line with what's stated or perceived to be the case.

NocturnalClocks · 24/01/2023 15:42

TheKeatingFive · 24/01/2023 15:37

How do you think private sector DB schemes were removed?

These were legal, contractual obligations as well

In what sense were they 'removed' though? They were phased out for new joiners or exchanged, in agreement, for other benefits. They weren't unilaterally 'removed' with no consultation or legal agreement.

"exchanged, with agreement"

🤣 Doubt anybody will fall for that again.

Schemes in the public sector themselves bave been changed even for those already in the schemes. Terms and conditions will be changed again. No doubt there'll be many more strikes as it happens but it'll happen anyway. The projections on costs in 20/30 year show that the promises made cannot be paid, so they won't be. They'll be gradually eroded.

Same as with state pensions etc.

Anybody who believes any promise from Government is worth the paper it's written on is in a very precarious position.

NocturnalClocks · 24/01/2023 15:38

TheKeatingFive · 24/01/2023 15:33

So no, public sector workers are not unreasonable to expect their salaries to rise at at least the level that private sector counterparts in comparable roles do.

But private sector workers are not uniformly getting inflation level pay rises, far from it. It's also much easier to cut pay and cut jobs in the private sector, so it's continually self correcting.

The argument around struggling to recruit and retain teachers is the strongest one I feel. That's the thing to focus on in making the case.

That's why these exercises work by benchmarking pay/ payrises against private sector equivalent roles: people with similar qualifcations, experience and seniority. If their private sector counterparts have received rises then of course public sector workers with the same skills should get equivalent rises, otherwise the best ones will leave...

TheKeatingFive · 24/01/2023 15:37

How do you think private sector DB schemes were removed?

These were legal, contractual obligations as well

In what sense were they 'removed' though? They were phased out for new joiners or exchanged, in agreement, for other benefits. They weren't unilaterally 'removed' with no consultation or legal agreement.

TheKeatingFive · 24/01/2023 15:33

So no, public sector workers are not unreasonable to expect their salaries to rise at at least the level that private sector counterparts in comparable roles do.

But private sector workers are not uniformly getting inflation level pay rises, far from it. It's also much easier to cut pay and cut jobs in the private sector, so it's continually self correcting.

The argument around struggling to recruit and retain teachers is the strongest one I feel. That's the thing to focus on in making the case.

KTheGrey · 24/01/2023 15:32

Yeah, my dad was a Uni lecturer and he did very little work for a decent amount of money and a good pension. But I don't think that he is representative.

The pressure on teachers charged with teaching teenagers necessary skills is grim, and the senior management fail to manage behaviour of both parents and students in many schools, exacerbating the pressure.

No amount of money - or unpaid leave, which is what those "holidays" are - compensates for 5.30am starts and never ending assessment, imo. I worked over 60 hours a week to deliver a reasonable level if teaching in a department with a shockingly underdeveloped curriculum and I am not planning on going back any time soon.

NocturnalClocks · 24/01/2023 15:31

TheKeatingFive · 24/01/2023 15:29

It says it will currently, yes. Will it, though? No. Because there is no money to pay for it.

It's a legal obligation. They're not 'fake' or 'opt outable'.

Oh dear me, how naive.

How do you think pension schemes were downgraded previously then, from final salary to average salary for example?

How do you think private sector DB schemes were removed?

These were legal, contractual obligations as well.

TheKeatingFive · 24/01/2023 15:29

It says it will currently, yes. Will it, though? No. Because there is no money to pay for it.

It's a legal obligation. They're not 'fake' or 'opt outable'.

NocturnalClocks · 24/01/2023 15:29

snowlolo · 23/01/2023 06:50

I get it inflation has wrecked everyone, but surely the issue should be getting inflation down? Not just demanding for more money, which by the way only fuels inflation further.

So should teachers ask the government politely to please work on reducing inflation? Do you think they'll listen? Don't be ridiculous.

There is still an issue that ALL public sector workers have had a huge salary reduction. The govt need to address it.

Indeed.

There's also no evidence that oay rises drive inflation. The causality works the other way around. Even Friedman accepted this!!

So no, public sector workers are not unreasonable to expect their salaries to rise at at least the level that private sector counterparts in comparable roles do.

And if the Government cared about inflation, prosperity or living standards - imstead of hammering public sector workers with paycuts - it would have done something about productivity over the last 13 years, would rejoin the single market immediately, would have had an energy and food security strategy, and would... drumroll!... be investing hugely in education.

NocturnalClocks · 24/01/2023 15:21

How would you quote the pension contributions?

Saying they’re fake is just stupid. They’re a cost associated with employment that will yield a very generous pension at retirement. The argument that they’re unfunded is spurious, they’re not going to disappear overnight.

They are fake because no actual money is being paid anywhere, at all, for those schemes. It's just an IOU, which will be changed, as it already has been.

I think TPS pays around average salary years service / 80… so average salary of £38k over 25 years would be around £11,800 a year, of which 3/4 or c. 9k is from employer contributions… which is roughly the same as I’ve allowed for.

It says it will currently, yes. Will it, though? No. Because there is no money to pay for it.

Pensions are part of your pay.

I am not a teacher or part of any public sector pension scheme, so no. I'm simply explaining the facts and economics of it.

Witchcraftandhokum · 24/01/2023 15:18

OP at best you're just poorly informed and can't be arsed to do any research, at worst you're as thick as pig shit.

FamousPrincess · 24/01/2023 15:00

Twiglets1 · 24/01/2023 04:15

I don’t know…. A friend of mine left her TA role in our school to begin teacher training in a local primary school in quite a deprived area.
She dropped out because she hadn’t anticipated being abused (verbally & physically) by primary school aged children and called a cunt.

Thanks. Yes, you get that and more often in the run down areas from what I have heard, Often its the parent/s that are worse that bullies. Hoever, on the whole in a nice area, it is a nice job and a daughter of ours was a manager in a nursery, close to promary age, kids were good as gold - it was the parents and other staff that were the proble

All in all, these days teachers all get around 16 weeks of lave inc BH's, teacher days and their extra health and welling being time off,

Parrotsandpussies · 24/01/2023 14:34

I have been teaching almost 40 years. I love my job. But I don't love the fact that in my small one-form entry primary school, 3 staff have been off with work-related stress in the last year. I don't love the fact that I rarely get more than 5 hours sleep, work whenever school is open over the holidays and yet still I'm asked for more. I don't love that we continued working face-to-face with the children throughout most of the pandemic and yet still the vast majority of the public thinks we were sitting back doing internet shopping and learning a hobby. I don't love the fact that during on-line learning I rarely worked a less than 12 hour day and yet still people think we should not strike because we have it so easy.
We are striking for a funded pay rise because the last one had to come from the school budget. Yeah, the same budget that the fuel bills have to be paid from. Go figure. And then go and volunteer in a school. Shadow a teacher. Then report back.

TheKeatingFive · 24/01/2023 12:55

Unfortunately, it is and I don’t know how it can be undone. Is there an Ofsted type inspectorate in RoI? Their ‘wants’ are to blame for a number of very poor admin-heavy workloads-curricular Deep Dives for primary schools for one.

No there isn't. I mean there probably is something, but it doesn't loom anywhere near as large as Ofsted.

I appreciate this is a huge thing to fix, but it's just such a shame that unnecessary burdens are being placed on teachers time.

Shinyandnew1 · 24/01/2023 12:21

TheKeatingFive · 24/01/2023 09:32

The question I have is does the admin/planning burden need to be so great?

I'm in ROI and while teachers work hard, they don't seem to do the crazy hours that U.K. teachers do. Yet the outcomes for students don't appear to be affected by this.

I get this is top down policy, but what's the rationale for so much time being spent on this and how could it be challenged?

I agree with you. As one who has been teaching for 25+ years, I know that it didn’t used to be this way and doesn’t need to be.

Unfortunately, it is and I don’t know how it can be undone. Is there an Ofsted type inspectorate in RoI? Their ‘wants’ are to blame for a number of very poor admin-heavy workloads-curricular Deep Dives for primary schools for one.

Piggywaspushed · 24/01/2023 12:12

TheKeatingFive · 24/01/2023 09:32

The question I have is does the admin/planning burden need to be so great?

I'm in ROI and while teachers work hard, they don't seem to do the crazy hours that U.K. teachers do. Yet the outcomes for students don't appear to be affected by this.

I get this is top down policy, but what's the rationale for so much time being spent on this and how could it be challenged?

This comes up a lot on MN . It would require huge structural changes but also, tbh, a change in the mindset of teaching leaders in England (and I presume Wales and Scotland - no idea about NI) and of teachers themselves. It's not a quick fix but I agree that other countries get things more right - in terms of meetings, admin, CPD , and pupil contact time (which is far lower in nearly every other OECD country).

For example, emails keep flying around our department asking colleagues to give up frees to house students catching up on assessments. I actually can't imagine that being gainsayed in a lot of other countries. Fixing culture is hard and one reason why work to rule fails.

by the way, in case tis hasn't been said , the DfE is on strike on the very day they are telling schools what to do in a strike.

CynthiaRothrock · 24/01/2023 10:58

Sorry but you are wrong. I'm not a teacher bit jave worked in several schools. Most staff are in from. 7.30/8am and alot (90%) are here until 6pm. I have seen staff assaulted and hospitalised. I have seen over the year their admin loads increase 10fold. I see 6 classes share 1 TA between them. I see them Burnt out before the xmas break started. I see. More and more children with medical needs and SEN than ever before.
Teachers dont always have same holiday as their children so they still have childcare issues. Most teachers and school staff never see their childrens sports days or nativity because they can't book time off. Oh and yes they get paid every month, however the salarie is split over the year so no they dont get more paid holiday than anyone else!
Unless you have worked in a school dont judge.

whatkatydid2013 · 24/01/2023 10:03

While I agree teachers don’t have a terrible salary for the start of their career there are significant limits to getting anything above the top of the upper pay range.

When my brother started work as a teacher in 2007 his starting salary of 19.5k was a decent chunk above most of our graduate new hires on 17k. However after 16 years our new hires who stay are typically going to be earning around £50k with a minority getting to 6 figures. His cohort are typically going to earn somewhere around £40k with it being very unusual to be above around £60k at the top of the lead practitioner scale.

Brother is a graduate so in a subject where they have limited staff and is a genuinely engaging teacher who helps his students achieve better results at A level than are expected based on their performance up to GCSE. He’s now a head of department and he’s said he has no real interest in being a head teacher so he’s just never really going to progress. If pay doesn’t rise in line with inflation or close to inflation he’ll just earn less in real terms and, unlike most professions, he doesn’t have the option to go to a different employer to do same type of role with more money. The whole system seems structured so that the best, most motivated staff will often become the ones most likely to leave the profession. That seems foolish as surely those are the people we want educating our kids.

luckylavender · 24/01/2023 09:38

Pinky1011 · 23/01/2023 02:47

They have 3 months PAID holidays only work 9-4pm, no dangerous or really bad working conditions, great job security, good pensions, They had pay rises last year up to 8%!!! I work in the private sector and haven't had a pay rise in almost 6 years! I just feel compared to alot of other professions, teachers have it quite good? I mean their starting salary is the same as a junior doctor. I get it inflation has wrecked everyone, but surely the issue should be getting inflation down? Not just demanding for more money, which by the way only fuels inflation further. AIBU to feel that teachers just don't know how good they have it compared to the rest of us?

Posts like this make me want to weep and I'm not even a teacher.

TheKeatingFive · 24/01/2023 09:32

The question I have is does the admin/planning burden need to be so great?

I'm in ROI and while teachers work hard, they don't seem to do the crazy hours that U.K. teachers do. Yet the outcomes for students don't appear to be affected by this.

I get this is top down policy, but what's the rationale for so much time being spent on this and how could it be challenged?

DrManhattan · 24/01/2023 08:58

You are being unreasonable.

100% support for the strikers

Twiglets1 · 24/01/2023 08:54

Dervel · 24/01/2023 08:15

I have a few friends in teaching. One of them was explaining they pay rises they all got came out of the current school budget, so way less money for other needed things.

I am sadly of the view that striking will unlikely help, but if a union wants to crack on with it so be it. I’m also a parent with a child being flagged for additional needs, and his school has been fierce in advocating him getting extra support. They have been amazing the head and the senior leadership team especially.

I’m of the view decent teachers are real heroes who go above and beyond way more than what they are paid to do. As such it’s not hard for me to want to support them!

One of the main things that NEU teachers are striving over is to get the pay rise from central government not expect schools to fund it from their existing budgets.
If your child has additional needs this issue could affect them more than most as schools may cut costs by cutting the number of TAs they employ. So I’m pleased you are supporting the strike, it is in your own best interests to do so.

Dervel · 24/01/2023 08:15

I have a few friends in teaching. One of them was explaining they pay rises they all got came out of the current school budget, so way less money for other needed things.

I am sadly of the view that striking will unlikely help, but if a union wants to crack on with it so be it. I’m also a parent with a child being flagged for additional needs, and his school has been fierce in advocating him getting extra support. They have been amazing the head and the senior leadership team especially.

I’m of the view decent teachers are real heroes who go above and beyond way more than what they are paid to do. As such it’s not hard for me to want to support them!

Spendonsend · 24/01/2023 08:07

The fringe pay isnt enough to keep people in the fringe either. We have so many great staff who move to a cheaper housing area.

Swipe left for the next trending thread