Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to feel that teachers shouldn't really be striking?

464 replies

Pinky1011 · 23/01/2023 02:47

They have 3 months PAID holidays only work 9-4pm, no dangerous or really bad working conditions, great job security, good pensions, They had pay rises last year up to 8%!!! I work in the private sector and haven't had a pay rise in almost 6 years! I just feel compared to alot of other professions, teachers have it quite good? I mean their starting salary is the same as a junior doctor. I get it inflation has wrecked everyone, but surely the issue should be getting inflation down? Not just demanding for more money, which by the way only fuels inflation further. AIBU to feel that teachers just don't know how good they have it compared to the rest of us?

OP posts:
NocturnalClocks · 24/01/2023 18:21

But, in the spirit of MN, I would ask why those highly qualified accountants and lawyers don't transfer to the private sector?<ducks for cover>

And based on data I've been looking at about retention of public sector staff in those kind of roles, that's exactly what's happening. Contributing the the even poorer service in the public sector no doubt, as they lose very skilled employees.

Piggywaspushed · 24/01/2023 18:20

So, what should teachers view as their 'counterparts' then? Unlike law there isn't a private/public equivalence.

NocturnalClocks · 24/01/2023 18:19

Piggywaspushed · 24/01/2023 18:04

Are technical skills more important than other skills? Not even sure what that means. Are you implying teachers aren't skilled, or that their skills are somehow of lesser worth?

Would fully support any public sector employee who strikes. Pretty sure some lawyers already have.

But, in the spirit of MN, I would ask why those highly qualified accountants and lawyers don't transfer to the private sector?<ducks for cover>

Errrr... no? I've been arguing teachers and all public sector workers should get a payrise matched to their counterparts in the private sector with similar skills, to rebalance their pay to the market rate for their job/ qualifications. I don't understand your comment.

DdraigGoch · 24/01/2023 18:08

I just read the title and correctly guessed how this thread would go.

Piggywaspushed · 24/01/2023 18:04

Are technical skills more important than other skills? Not even sure what that means. Are you implying teachers aren't skilled, or that their skills are somehow of lesser worth?

Would fully support any public sector employee who strikes. Pretty sure some lawyers already have.

But, in the spirit of MN, I would ask why those highly qualified accountants and lawyers don't transfer to the private sector?<ducks for cover>

NocturnalClocks · 24/01/2023 18:02

Those people often aren't valued as much as teachers because the public don't understand what they do, and they aren't so visible. But public services will soon be in a much greater mess across the board unless they also get a payrise to match their private sector counterparts as they will leave and service delivery can't function without them.

NocturnalClocks · 24/01/2023 18:00

That's not true of lots of lawyers. You are presuming we all work in the private sector whereas thousands of us are public sector and earn less than teachers without the benefit of the holidays.

Oh yes @Willyoujustbequiet absolutely, lawyers or accountants in the public sector are currently much more hard done by than teachers! Jobs which require more technical skills and more study and qualifications than teachers, and in public sector roles attract fewer benefits and longer hours than teachers and have also been hammered by the effective paycuts. And I hear have mostly been offered even lower payrises: as low as 1%!

Willyoujustbequiet · 24/01/2023 17:46

TheKeatingFive · 24/01/2023 16:17

No I don't agree that those in professions on similar salaries do shorter hours. Many who don't carve out really successful careers in law or accounting earn similar amounts and work very long hours

But they wont stay on those salaries. Those on 30k in law or finance will be putting in those hours in an expectation of moving up to better remunerated posts in the near future. It would not be normal in other careers to work 60 hours weeks for 20 years on 30/40k.

Obviously those who are at the top and join Magic Circle/ Big 4 firms/ become partners/ consultants earn more but then so do those who become headteachers of academy chains I guess?

A partner in a magic circle law firm will earn many, many multiples of a head teachers salary though.

The expectation of progression and future pay is different. In law/finance you put in these hours on lower salaries for a while, to get to much higher salaries.

The expectation seems to be that teachers do it as standard for years, without the prospect of big financial reward.

That's not true of lots of lawyers. You are presuming we all work in the private sector whereas thousands of us are public sector and earn less than teachers without the benefit of the holidays.

Technonan · 24/01/2023 17:40

The holidays aren't paid. I wish people would understand that. The pay is calculated with standard annual leave. The rest of the break is unpaid. Teachers get paid every month, but that is becasue the pay is broken down to go into monthly payments but once again TEACHERS ARE ONLY PAID FOR THE SAME HOLIDAYS THE REST OF US GET.

I don't teach any more. I loved it. but it was very high pressure, and it's one of those jobs that never ends - there's always work to take home for evenings and weekends. It's very fulfilling, but it's hard work. I wouldn't do it now.

noblegiraffe · 24/01/2023 16:59

Lots of data entry in teaching.

NocturnalClocks · 24/01/2023 16:51

noblegiraffe · 24/01/2023 16:46

Admin staff who cost far less though could be doing that data entry, not teachers!

Guess whether we can afford admin staff. Teachers, on the other hand, can simply add it to their to-do list.

Oh absolutely, I am sure that's why it's happening. But what a ridiculous false economy, to waste teachers' time on data entry. 🙄😡

noblegiraffe · 24/01/2023 16:46

Admin staff who cost far less though could be doing that data entry, not teachers!

Guess whether we can afford admin staff. Teachers, on the other hand, can simply add it to their to-do list.

NocturnalClocks · 24/01/2023 16:46

noblegiraffe · 24/01/2023 16:34

The problem with reducing workload is

  1. I don't think other countries are so comprehensively propping up failing social services, SEN services and mental health services

  2. Extra workload isn't necessarily pointless. Like in my dept after mocks we type in the score for every single assessment question for every single pupil into a spreadsheet. This then generates a list of strengths and weaknesses for each kid that can be given to them, forestalling any parental enquiries as to 'what do they need to work on?'. In Y11 that data goes into an app that generates tailored revision questions for each student.
    So it's a time-consuming admin task, but if we stopped doing it, we'd lose something.
    It's the same as where the expectation is to run revision classes for Y11. Once the expectation is there, removing it leads to the worry that the kids are missing out.

Admin staff who cost far less though could be doing that data entry, not teachers! If budgets are pushed then that is bonkers, wasting teachers' time on such mindless tasks that anybody could do.

NocturnalClocks · 24/01/2023 16:39

TheKeatingFive · 24/01/2023 16:17

No I don't agree that those in professions on similar salaries do shorter hours. Many who don't carve out really successful careers in law or accounting earn similar amounts and work very long hours

But they wont stay on those salaries. Those on 30k in law or finance will be putting in those hours in an expectation of moving up to better remunerated posts in the near future. It would not be normal in other careers to work 60 hours weeks for 20 years on 30/40k.

Obviously those who are at the top and join Magic Circle/ Big 4 firms/ become partners/ consultants earn more but then so do those who become headteachers of academy chains I guess?

A partner in a magic circle law firm will earn many, many multiples of a head teachers salary though.

The expectation of progression and future pay is different. In law/finance you put in these hours on lower salaries for a while, to get to much higher salaries.

The expectation seems to be that teachers do it as standard for years, without the prospect of big financial reward.

In law or finance people on the pathways to very high salaries are often working 80-100 hours weeks for less than teachers earn (at first). Then it increases. This is why I distinguished between those on that pathway with Magic Circle/ Big 4 etc and the rest. And compared that kind of career path to perhaps what a headteacher of a large academy chain might achieve in terms of salary, in later career.

Many of those working in small firms or not as successful will have lower hours comparable to a standard teacher: 50-60 hour weeks maybe. But with fewer weeks off, and similar kinds of pay trajectories to teachers.

So in general teachers were not really hard done by, in terms of professions. Also the level of study and qualification required to become a lawyer or accountant is higher. But as a broad comparison, it makes rough sense. However, in recent years as I said the refusal of the Government to uprate their pay appropriately to match the private sector has made the comparison no longer hold. As has the erosion of working conditions resulting from schools not being properly funded. So on that basis I understand their anger and think all public sector workers should be given a sensible payrise and education should also be one of the Government's top funding priorities now, after so much neglect. Our state education is beyond a joke now, internationally. It's embarrassing and doesn't bode well for the future of our country. And teachers are rightly furious about this. As we all should be.

noblegiraffe · 24/01/2023 16:34

The problem with reducing workload is

  1. I don't think other countries are so comprehensively propping up failing social services, SEN services and mental health services

  2. Extra workload isn't necessarily pointless. Like in my dept after mocks we type in the score for every single assessment question for every single pupil into a spreadsheet. This then generates a list of strengths and weaknesses for each kid that can be given to them, forestalling any parental enquiries as to 'what do they need to work on?'. In Y11 that data goes into an app that generates tailored revision questions for each student.
    So it's a time-consuming admin task, but if we stopped doing it, we'd lose something.
    It's the same as where the expectation is to run revision classes for Y11. Once the expectation is there, removing it leads to the worry that the kids are missing out.

PurplePinecone · 24/01/2023 16:25

Op, there is such as shortage of teachers. Please sign up and become one.

You have made it sound a walk in the park...why are you not already teaching?

TheKeatingFive · 24/01/2023 16:17

No I don't agree that those in professions on similar salaries do shorter hours. Many who don't carve out really successful careers in law or accounting earn similar amounts and work very long hours

But they wont stay on those salaries. Those on 30k in law or finance will be putting in those hours in an expectation of moving up to better remunerated posts in the near future. It would not be normal in other careers to work 60 hours weeks for 20 years on 30/40k.

Obviously those who are at the top and join Magic Circle/ Big 4 firms/ become partners/ consultants earn more but then so do those who become headteachers of academy chains I guess?

A partner in a magic circle law firm will earn many, many multiples of a head teachers salary though.

The expectation of progression and future pay is different. In law/finance you put in these hours on lower salaries for a while, to get to much higher salaries.

The expectation seems to be that teachers do it as standard for years, without the prospect of big financial reward.

NocturnalClocks · 24/01/2023 16:09

TheKeatingFive · 24/01/2023 15:59

whereas private sector workers have much smaller pensions but funded and more protected

This isn't true at all. Private sector pensions can be devastated by stock market crashes or funds failing. They're much less protected as things stand.

However, more broadly I think hours worked above and beyond by teachers are far in advance of what's generally expected from those on similar salaries. So either that needs to be addressed or the pay needs to increase in line with the reality. So I guess we are in fundamental agreement on that point.

Oh of course DC schemes have more financial risk attached, because they are actual invested money! But that's financial risk, rather than risk of non-payment, risk that for say a 30 year old teacher, with a scheme which on the surface looks great but is tied to state pension age... it's fairly obvious that when these liabilities become unpayable Governments can raise state pension age to 75 or even 80 and ta-da! Most of the liability goes away.

No I don't agree that those in professions on similar salaries do shorter hours. Many who don't carve out really successful careers in law or accounting earn similar amounts and work very long hours. Same with many staff in medicine. Obviously those who are at the top and join Magic Circle/ Big 4 firms/ become partners/ consultants earn more but then so do those who become headteachers of academy chains I guess? But in many of the professions you get a salary to get the job done, and for the last 15 years people work extremely long hours for increasingly poor salaries, when you factor in inflation.

However, the recent assault on public sector salaries particularly in this last year or two - to hold them down in the face of record inflation - sticks out particularly to someone on the outside who looks at data (I'm an economist). It's not sustainable. You can only really tell professionals to do high-stress roles with long hours for a fixed salary if that salary at least keeps pace with others with similar skills.

ConsuelaHammock · 24/01/2023 16:02

What do you do op?
How many hours do you work?
What’s your salary?
What’s your educational background?
How many weeks paid holidays do you get a year ?

TheKeatingFive · 24/01/2023 15:59

whereas private sector workers have much smaller pensions but funded and more protected

This isn't true at all. Private sector pensions can be devastated by stock market crashes or funds failing. They're much less protected as things stand.

However, more broadly I think hours worked above and beyond by teachers are far in advance of what's generally expected from those on similar salaries. So either that needs to be addressed or the pay needs to increase in line with the reality. So I guess we are in fundamental agreement on that point.

ConsuelaHammock · 24/01/2023 15:54

Teachers get just over 5 weeks paid holiday a year. Same as most jobs I imagine. The hours they work is none of your concern.

NocturnalClocks · 24/01/2023 15:52

TheKeatingFive · 24/01/2023 15:43

That's why these exercises work by benchmarking pay/ payrises against private sector equivalent roles: people with similar qualifcations, experience and seniority. If their private sector counterparts have received rises then of course public sector workers with the same skills should get equivalent rises, otherwise the best ones will leave

But it's never as simple as comparing salary. Pension, job security, conditions, etc.

I 100% agree that there is a huge problem with teacher retention. However it seems like it's less to do with the package at first glance, and more to do with the fact that the hours being put in are not in line with what's stated or perceived to be the case.

Well, that's true of almost every professional job re. hours and level of work/ stress. Teachers are nowhere near unique in that. Their pay - like all public sector workers - needs restoring to an appropriate level comparable to private sector counterparts with similar skills.

The pensions are irrelevant really as no proper comparison can be made: public sectors have very generous but unfunded promises that won't be kept whereas private sector workers have much smaller pensions but funded and more protected - unless the Government tries to steal chunks of them again through changes to rules as they have done previously. But that would be shooting themselves in the foot because then people will stop saving for pensions and the state will have to fund even more in the end.

Teachers' main issue seems to be their working conditions and schools being underfunded so that they can't do their jobs properly no matter how hard they try. Like I said I'm not one, but this is my impression. But they're not allowed to strike about that, so this strike seems to be a proxy strike to try to wake people up to the fact that Government need to fund education properly. Then their jobs would better, and children would be supported properly, and productivity in the economy might have a hoe of recovering one day in the future.

TheKeatingFive · 24/01/2023 15:47

Again: I am not a teacher, nor do I have a public sector pension, nor am I a member of a union. I'm not talking about me!!

Okay then, 'they' are

NocturnalClocks · 24/01/2023 15:46

TheKeatingFive · 24/01/2023 15:45

Doubt anybody will fall for that again

Well there you go then. You're prior warned, unionised and up for the fight. That's a lot more than most.

Again: I am not a teacher, nor do I have a public sector pension, nor am I a member of a union. I'm not talking about me!!

NocturnalClocks · 24/01/2023 15:45

E.g. most in if these unfunded schemes eligibility date is tied to state pension age. Government will likely keep raising that until most people can't collect their public sector pensions until soon before they die, drastically reducing the liability.

Change the infation measure it's tied to again.

Change the years ratio again to reduce accrual rates.

And many more. There are many, many ways to gradually bring the "liability" down by adjusting conditions it in favour of the Government and to the detriment of those expecting to receive these non-existent pension funds. And they will do this? Because they have no choice, because there is no money.