Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to feel that teachers shouldn't really be striking?

464 replies

Pinky1011 · 23/01/2023 02:47

They have 3 months PAID holidays only work 9-4pm, no dangerous or really bad working conditions, great job security, good pensions, They had pay rises last year up to 8%!!! I work in the private sector and haven't had a pay rise in almost 6 years! I just feel compared to alot of other professions, teachers have it quite good? I mean their starting salary is the same as a junior doctor. I get it inflation has wrecked everyone, but surely the issue should be getting inflation down? Not just demanding for more money, which by the way only fuels inflation further. AIBU to feel that teachers just don't know how good they have it compared to the rest of us?

OP posts:
noblegiraffe · 24/01/2023 23:12

Winedup please don’t give Clav any personal details, she has a very nasty habit of using them against people.

Clavinova · 24/01/2023 23:09

WineDup
NMW have been offered a 9.68% pay rise
But we haven’t - we have been offered 5%

If you worked full time, your salary would rise from £42,336 per annum to £44,453 per annum - (you are at the top of the pay scale - is that correct?)

My employers pension contribution is irrelevant; I’m speaking about the money I have in my account on payday, since to be honest I might not make retirement, and my future pension isn’t going to put food on the table come week 3 of the month

In that case - can you opt out of the pension scheme and reduce your pension contributions by half in an alternative scheme?

Who said anything about ditching my partner or his salary? Not sure why you’d assume that I’d need to be a single parent to get universal credit?

How much is your household income?

WineDup · 24/01/2023 22:56

MistressIggi · 24/01/2023 22:42

9%??? Teachers in Scotland are striking tomorrow and I doubt very much we'd be losing another day's pay if there was a 9% offer on the table. I can't even imagine how much glue that poster is on!

The media reported it as a 27% pay rise, because they looked at the original probationers salary (£28k) to the new band 1 salary. Discounting the incremental rise that comes from moving from a probationer to a full qualified teacher. Ridiculous.

WineDup · 24/01/2023 22:52

Clavinova · 24/01/2023 22:14

WineDup
I am paid £17 per hour for my time. NMW will be £10.42 per hour come April. My pay slip claims my hourly rate is £25 though. My salary is £25k. If I worked the same hours at NMW, my salary would be £16,255

NMW is currently £9.50 per hour - you can't uplift one side of the comparison without uplifting the other. The Scottish Government have already offered an uplift of 6.85% for the lowest paid teachers - 5% for most.

on NMW I’d take home £1200, which includes the sliding scale pension payment I’d make if this NMW job was part of the same scheme

As a teacher in Scotland your employer pays 23% of your pensionable income towards your pension;

teachinscotland.scot/news/teachers-pensions/

I also lost out on 5 years earning while I trained to be a teacher

Clearly you are going to be far better off over your working life on an FTE of £40,000 plus - compared to someone on NMW; better choice of where to live (mortgage/rent), better pension, access to credit (for cars, home improvements etc.) ...

Oh, and, on NMW I’d be entitled to £90/week towards childcare costs, and right now I get £0
So actually, I’d be better off on NMW

Is your doppelganger a single parent? But you are not. I don't see how you will be better off financially ditching your partner and his salary.

Annoyingly, I had already typed a reply and it deleted.

Okay we will put it this way then. NMW have been offered a 9.68% pay rise, which has been approved. If teachers were offered 9.68%, they would accept. But we haven’t - we have been offered 5%. So yes, you can compare the two; because those are the figures that have been approved.

My employers pension contribution is irrelevant; I’m speaking about the money I have in my account on payday, since to be honest I might not make retirement, and my future pension isn’t going to put food on the table come week 3 of the month. We aren’t quite there, yet, but we have already had to cancel our TV package, we have to be mindful of energy use, our savings are gone, and we are having to cut back on everything. We have basically no disposable income.

We live in a two bed ex council, we have one car (not a new one) and we have only been abroad once since 2013.

Who said anything about ditching my partner or his salary? Not sure why you’d assume that I’d need to be a single parent to get universal credit?

whatkatydid2013 · 24/01/2023 22:46

MurrayTheDemonicTalkingSkull · 24/01/2023 22:28

Just wanted to pop onto the thread and clarify that this is bullshit. Teachers in Scotland have been offered 5% and then, when that was rejected, a rehashed offer that gave the majority of staff… 5%. Yes, the newly qualified were offered 6.85%, but not sure why it should be the case that someone who is experienced, working the same job, gets proportionally less of a pay award.

And this is the pay offer for 2022/23 that we’re talking about here. Nearly a year overdue, as it has been almost every year of the 12 I’ve been a teacher.

Plus private sector pay offers all differ anyway. I got 10% in 2021 and 6 last year. I’ve averaged around 6% a year over the 20 years I’ve worked in finance. Based on those I know in professional jobs in the private sector that’s pretty modest but it’s better than much of the public sector

MistressIggi · 24/01/2023 22:42

9%??? Teachers in Scotland are striking tomorrow and I doubt very much we'd be losing another day's pay if there was a 9% offer on the table. I can't even imagine how much glue that poster is on!

MurrayTheDemonicTalkingSkull · 24/01/2023 22:28

BeethovenNinth · 23/01/2023 06:08

ps I agree with the posts about the admin and crap curriculum. But what has that got to do with pay? They have been offered 9 percent in Scotland but want 10.

like the OP in the private sector this is laughable. I had two per cent this year and work long hours

Just wanted to pop onto the thread and clarify that this is bullshit. Teachers in Scotland have been offered 5% and then, when that was rejected, a rehashed offer that gave the majority of staff… 5%. Yes, the newly qualified were offered 6.85%, but not sure why it should be the case that someone who is experienced, working the same job, gets proportionally less of a pay award.

And this is the pay offer for 2022/23 that we’re talking about here. Nearly a year overdue, as it has been almost every year of the 12 I’ve been a teacher.

Abraxan · 24/01/2023 22:26

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

cardibach · 24/01/2023 22:15

@FamousPrincess you wrote All in all, these days teachers all get around 16 weeks of lave inc BH's, teacher days and their extra health and welling being time off
It’s nonsense.
Most BHs fall in holiday time, and in any case don’t affect the number of days worked. That’s 195 (it was 194 for the jubilee and probably will be for the coronation).

Teacher days? I assume you mean INSET. These are working days for teachers, only the pupils are off (and again, they don’t affect the 195 teaching days. When they were created they came off the holidays - for no extra pay).
Extra health and well-being time off? I have no idea what you are talking about with this one. Nope. Can’t even begin to address such nonsense.

Clavinova · 24/01/2023 22:14

WineDup
I am paid £17 per hour for my time. NMW will be £10.42 per hour come April. My pay slip claims my hourly rate is £25 though. My salary is £25k. If I worked the same hours at NMW, my salary would be £16,255

NMW is currently £9.50 per hour - you can't uplift one side of the comparison without uplifting the other. The Scottish Government have already offered an uplift of 6.85% for the lowest paid teachers - 5% for most.

on NMW I’d take home £1200, which includes the sliding scale pension payment I’d make if this NMW job was part of the same scheme

As a teacher in Scotland your employer pays 23% of your pensionable income towards your pension;

teachinscotland.scot/news/teachers-pensions/

I also lost out on 5 years earning while I trained to be a teacher

Clearly you are going to be far better off over your working life on an FTE of £40,000 plus - compared to someone on NMW; better choice of where to live (mortgage/rent), better pension, access to credit (for cars, home improvements etc.) ...

Oh, and, on NMW I’d be entitled to £90/week towards childcare costs, and right now I get £0
So actually, I’d be better off on NMW

Is your doppelganger a single parent? But you are not. I don't see how you will be better off financially ditching your partner and his salary.

NocturnalClocks · 24/01/2023 22:09

This is neither facts nor economics, it’s total ignorance of how pensions actually work.

If you say so. Given I've audited them, been a trustee for one, am qualified in this area and am an economist by profession and spend time looking at the national data on projections and liabilities, I will politely disagree with you.

FlairBand · 24/01/2023 21:58

NocturnalClocks · 24/01/2023 15:21

How would you quote the pension contributions?

Saying they’re fake is just stupid. They’re a cost associated with employment that will yield a very generous pension at retirement. The argument that they’re unfunded is spurious, they’re not going to disappear overnight.

They are fake because no actual money is being paid anywhere, at all, for those schemes. It's just an IOU, which will be changed, as it already has been.

I think TPS pays around average salary years service / 80… so average salary of £38k over 25 years would be around £11,800 a year, of which 3/4 or c. 9k is from employer contributions… which is roughly the same as I’ve allowed for.

It says it will currently, yes. Will it, though? No. Because there is no money to pay for it.

Pensions are part of your pay.

I am not a teacher or part of any public sector pension scheme, so no. I'm simply explaining the facts and economics of it.

This is neither facts nor economics, it’s total ignorance of how pensions actually work.

titbumwillypoo · 24/01/2023 21:50

"I would direct funding towards private tutor sessions for disadvantaged DC and those who are still struggling after lockdown."

So tutor sessions that a TA can qualify for in 45 minutes that cost upwards of £150 a day to Hays Education who then pay the TA £50?

Or do you mean catch up sessions currently run by TA's on £12,000 a year if a school is lucky enough to still be able to afford them?
I plan and run reading, handwriting, toe by toe, SALT, six bricks, precision and RWI. I have 12 hours a week of interventions that I squeeze into 8 hours because the rest of the time i'm supporting in class. I monitor all the data and keep the class teacher up to date on progress. I have 14 children out of a class of 26 who have School Support Plans and only one of them has an ECHP (funding 16 hours).
I love my job as a TA but wouldn't be able to afford it if my wife didn't earn what she did.
The teachers i work with bust their asses everyday to give children the best start in life and overall just want education to be funded properly.

noblegiraffe · 24/01/2023 21:48

The lockdown stuff is just obvious goady shit.

Shinyandnew1 · 24/01/2023 21:46

I would offer 7.5% to NHS staff on the basis that they worked through the pandemic

I know a number of speech therapists who WFH from the first week of lockdown and stayed there for months, yet were still prioritised for a vaccine. The majority of teachers I know were in school, mixing with large numbers without PPE or a vaccine. It’s not quite as simple as NHS= all front line, hard working and risking their lives during covid so are deserving of bigger pay rises and teachers= didn’t work at all because schools were closed to some pupils, so should be happy with smaller unfunded pay rises.

BakedBear · 24/01/2023 21:44

Stackss · 24/01/2023 20:51

Personally I am in favour of increasing education budget. However, I’m not convinced that inflation-busting pay rises for teachers is the best use of funds.

I think a 5% pay offer for teachers is fair, and I would offer 7.5% to NHS staff on the basis that they worked through the pandemic while schools were closed for many months.

The priority for me would be supporting DC to catch up from the lost learning during lockdown rather than fuelling inflation further with bumper payouts to teachers.

Schools. were. not. closed.

GreetingsToTheNewBrunette · 24/01/2023 21:37

@Stackss and what pay rise would you give to civil servants

WineDup · 24/01/2023 21:26

Stackss · 24/01/2023 21:01

@noblegiraffe

The reality is that no one getting inflation busting pay rises in any sector. We are now seeing inflation on a downward trend so the last thing we want to do is send it spiralling again with bumper pay awards.

5% is fair and reasonable in my view. My preference would be to give higher rises to the lower paid teachers, with a pay freeze for the likes of headteachers.

This shows a fundamental lack of understanding of teachers pay structures. The vast majority of teachers are at the top of the scale, and there is really no way for promotion for the majority of teachers, because they are removing all the promoted posts (eg no longer having subject leads, moving to faculty head models) - middle management equates to about £200 per month extra.

WineDup · 24/01/2023 21:22

Stackss · 24/01/2023 20:51

Personally I am in favour of increasing education budget. However, I’m not convinced that inflation-busting pay rises for teachers is the best use of funds.

I think a 5% pay offer for teachers is fair, and I would offer 7.5% to NHS staff on the basis that they worked through the pandemic while schools were closed for many months.

The priority for me would be supporting DC to catch up from the lost learning during lockdown rather than fuelling inflation further with bumper payouts to teachers.

… I worked right through the pandemic. In the classroom. With no PPE. With no social distancing.

My partner works for the council and for a £500 bonus, plus a 5% pay rise in 2021, backdated. And he got two extra days annual leave for working through the pandemic.

They worked in an office, with the option to work from home, he was only in contact with his direct team (5) and they were able to maintain distance at all times.

Not everyone in the NHS worked as normal. I broke my ankle in Jan 2020 and my physio was one 10 minute phone call, to use a personal example.

I support the NHS and local authority pay rises.

noblegiraffe · 24/01/2023 21:22

I would direct funding towards private tutor sessions for disadvantaged DC and those who are still struggling after lockdown.

Oh, you know that there is already funding for that? It's shit though, schools can't get tutors to do it. Guess why?

Stackss · 24/01/2023 21:20

@noblegiraffe

I would direct funding towards private tutor sessions for disadvantaged DC and those who are still struggling after lockdown.

FrippEnos · 24/01/2023 21:19

Swissmountains · 24/01/2023 20:07

I will never tire of reminding you of your cosy job, with your half a year holidays, your 5-9% pay rise and your gold plated pension.

Join the real world just for six months, and then come back and tell me it is all buttercups and butterflies. In the real world you really wouldn't survive a snowflake mentality.

CBA with most of the BS that you have posted but UPS pay rise is under 3%.

But you do you.

noblegiraffe · 24/01/2023 21:17

How about any pay rise? You know, one that isn't a pay cut?

How do you propose to improve education without teachers?

Stackss · 24/01/2023 21:17

@noblegiraffe

I would increase the education budget but bumper pay rises for teachers wouldn't be my priority use of that funding.

noblegiraffe · 24/01/2023 21:16

As for the starting salary being excellent, even the Tories recognised it wasn't excellent and made a manifesto promise to bump it up significantly (not yet met).