Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to feel that teachers shouldn't really be striking?

464 replies

Pinky1011 · 23/01/2023 02:47

They have 3 months PAID holidays only work 9-4pm, no dangerous or really bad working conditions, great job security, good pensions, They had pay rises last year up to 8%!!! I work in the private sector and haven't had a pay rise in almost 6 years! I just feel compared to alot of other professions, teachers have it quite good? I mean their starting salary is the same as a junior doctor. I get it inflation has wrecked everyone, but surely the issue should be getting inflation down? Not just demanding for more money, which by the way only fuels inflation further. AIBU to feel that teachers just don't know how good they have it compared to the rest of us?

OP posts:
echt · 23/01/2023 04:31

I really don’t think people appreciate the value of these pensions and how lucky they are to have them, which is why I think they should be brought into the debate.

They are not part of what teachers are striking about, that's why, though I can see why it would be a handy distraction for you.

NocturnalClocks · 23/01/2023 04:30

I've reposted your comments about it. I'm asking whether you have any studies that back up those ideas about the causality of inflation? Because even Friedman didn't buy your take on it (the one the UK Government is currently trying to sell).

garlictwist · 23/01/2023 04:30

I think being a teacher is hard work. I wouldn't want to do it. But I do think it's fairly well paid compared to other sectors.

FlairBand · 23/01/2023 04:29

NocturnalClocks · 23/01/2023 04:09

At the moment, govt pays about 24% salary into a teachers pension each year and teacher pays around 7-10% depending on their pay scale.

That's not entirely true. The teachers' pension scheme is unfunded. No amount is being paid into a pension scheme for them, nothing. All they have effectively is a promise from the Government that they'll be paid something, which we all know isn't worth the paper it's written on because it can and will be changed and downgraded again.

The contribution rates are correct.

You are correct that it’s an unfunded scheme but to imply that the value of 24% annually into a DB pension could be eroded over time to anything comparable to 3% into a DC pot is grossly misleading. I know there have been changes but I really don’t think that in any world it could be argued that they weren’t rational, mostly because the reason that changes We’re introduced we’re to counter the problem of people were living longer… and therefore costing more than was provided for in the scheme.

I really don’t think people appreciate the value of these pensions and how lucky they are to have them, which is why I think they should be brought into the debate.

NocturnalClocks · 23/01/2023 04:28

I said pay rises don't solve the inflation issue and there is a POSSIBLITY that it could exasperate it

itsgettingweird · 23/01/2023 04:27

When you actually find out about teachers pay you'd realise you have literally NO idea. And I'm not a teacher.

Fact 1 - they don't get paid holiday for 3 months. They get a salary that reflects their working year.

Fact 2 - they don't work 9-4. They teach 8.30/9 - 3/3.30 and then do all their planning, assessment and writing reports, making resources and referrals to outside agencies.

Fact 3 - they had a small pay rise this year after a pay freeze. That pay rise is coming out of already existing school budgets. It's coming from money allocated to educate our children which is already low. In fact - after years of claiming to raise finding they've finally admitted they've referenced the funding to 2010 levels. So that's 12 years of cutting funding to raise it to a time where inflation is 15% above that and then they expect the teachers to have a pay rise from that money.

Teachers are only allowed to strike for pay. So they have to strike saying what they can.

What they are striking for is our children's education and future. For our children - the future of this country to be provided for educationally.

And the fact they are paid the same as a junior doctor shows how badly underfunded our NHS is too - not that teachers are wrong!

NocturnalClocks · 23/01/2023 04:27

I didn't say inflation was CAUSED by higher salaries, only that it doesn't solve the problem and can actually make inflation worse

NocturnalClocks · 23/01/2023 04:26

Not just demanding for more money, which by the way only fuels inflation further

echt · 23/01/2023 04:26

Pinky1011 · 23/01/2023 04:22

@echt I mean strike for the issues that the extra funding is needed for,
Don't strike for more money, because I'm sorry but teaching is not low a paid profession.

Teachers. Can't. Strike. About. Funding. It. Would. Be. Illegal.

That includes issues attached to funding.

Pinky1011 · 23/01/2023 04:25

@NocturnalClocks you keep misquoting me, I never once said inflation is caused or is driven by salary increases?

OP posts:
NocturnalClocks · 23/01/2023 04:24

Ah, I see some have already confirmed before I'd finished writing my post that I was correct, they cannot strike about lack of school funding.

So there we are.

We all know they all want that as well as their pay restored to 2010 levels ideally. Wouldn't it be lovely if we could all go back to that time, before the country was decimated by idiots.

Pinky1011 · 23/01/2023 04:22

@echt I mean strike for the issues that the extra funding is needed for,
Don't strike for more money, because I'm sorry but teaching is not low a paid profession.

OP posts:
NocturnalClocks · 23/01/2023 04:21

But that's my point, there is no evidence that salary rises drive inflation. It's a fallacy. The causality has always worked the other way around in every study on this that I've seem. Do you have any evidence that salary rises would further increase inflation or exacerbate it? I'd be genuinely interested if you do.

And yes, more funding for schools is needed. As I said I don't work in that sector so I know little about it but I believe there are limited grounds upon which their unions can ballot for a strike so I'm not sure they can legally strike over lack of school funding specifically? Perhaps one of the members of a teachers' union can confirm and enlighten us. But it's fairly apparent that their strike is not just about their pay, the same as with the striking NHS staff.

echt · 23/01/2023 04:20

Interesting you say that teachers are only legally allowed to strike about pay, I didn’t know that and wonder if that’s why the real conversation about conditions is being drowned out by people who compete over how many hours overtime they have to work (teachers and non teachers)

Teachers don't work overtime. You get paid for overtime.

FlairBand · 23/01/2023 04:19

blackbird77 · 23/01/2023 04:08

That argument would only hold for recruitment of new people though. It wouldn’t explain the retention crisis. Retention is even more of a problem than recruitment. Why are 1/3 of teachers leaving the profession for alternative jobs after only a few years of teaching? Clearly something is amiss if so many people want out. They are actually doing the job and experiencing the day to day realities of it.

The holidays, pension and pay is clearly not a worthwhile trade off for the working hours, working conditions, stress, disrespect, behavioural and pastoral issues or so many teachers wouldn’t be leaving the profession. Either the latter has to get better or the former has to increase to offset the emotional cost of putting up with the latter. Since teachers are only legally allowed to strike about pay, this will most likely be the reason.

Yes it’s mostly true for hiring new teachers yes (and not helped by people who say “well if you think teaching is so easy why don’t you try it….!”), but it also creates a culture of negativity and dissatisfaction which can influence working environments and ultimately decisions.

I know I’ve mentioned pensions a few times but I honestly think that they should be part of the solution.

There is no job anywhere where you can have both the benefits of a private sector salary and a public sector pension. And by the way, private sector salaries have also taken a huge real terms hit, they’re really not that great. If the public sector wants parity with private sector then we need to look at pensions as part of the solution. If they want pensions to stay the same then there needs to be an acceptance that pay is not entirely comparable. If conditions are the problem then we need to say so.

Interesting you say that teachers are only legally allowed to strike about pay, I didn’t know that and wonder if that’s why the real conversation about conditions is being drowned out by people who compete over how many hours overtime they have to work (teachers and non teachers).

echt · 23/01/2023 04:18

More funding is needed YES, teachers should be striking for that

Teachers. Can't. Strike. About. Funding. It. Would. Be. Illegal.

What don't you get about that?

Pinky1011 · 23/01/2023 04:15

Um I did not say teachers should not have pay rises because it will make inflation worse??? I said pay rises don't solve the inflation issue and there is a POSSIBLITY that it could exasperate it (if goods just go up in line with everyone getting more money, this is a possibility I didn't say it was the cause or it will definitely happen) and I said pay rises don't solve the working conditions issues. They solve none of the issues that are actually causing teachers to go on strike. More funding is needed YES, teachers should be striking for that. But not for more money in their pockets imo. Which like I said doesn't solve any of the issues I stated and is more like sticking a plaster on a broken bone.

OP posts:
talkingmorenonsense · 23/01/2023 04:14

My brother qualified as an English teacher and was very keen to teach. Within a year he talked of leaving due to the long hours, poor working conditions, the school was often freezing and the building was crumbling, abuse from kids and their parents and having to teach a syllabus he found completely useless. In one week he had his classroom trashed twice, a child hit him and he received several abusive emails from a parent. He left at the end of that term.

Education is so important for our kids and for our country. Teachers should be supported and very well paid.

echt · 23/01/2023 04:12
NocturnalClocks · 23/01/2023 04:11

Same for NHS staff, fire service staff etc. There is no money to pay it, so none of them will be paid what they are expecting to be paid, unfortunately.

FineMom · 23/01/2023 04:09

Another one here backing the teachers.
OP, inflation is not being caused by the pay rises - it’s being caused by price increases caused by for example privatised energy companies profiteering in a way that they are simply not allowed to do in France. I suggest you get better informed and if you are dissatisfied with your pay, then get unionised 👍. Keeping teachers’ (or nurses’ or train drivers’ or postal workers’) pay down won’t help you it will just mean we all have poorer services and a low wage, high prices economy.

NocturnalClocks · 23/01/2023 04:09

At the moment, govt pays about 24% salary into a teachers pension each year and teacher pays around 7-10% depending on their pay scale.

That's not entirely true. The teachers' pension scheme is unfunded. No amount is being paid into a pension scheme for them, nothing. All they have effectively is a promise from the Government that they'll be paid something, which we all know isn't worth the paper it's written on because it can and will be changed and downgraded again.

blackbird77 · 23/01/2023 04:08

FlairBand · 23/01/2023 03:45

I do think there’s also a connection between teachers / teaching unions criticising their pay and conditions, and low employment and retention rate.

Even if I were looking to change careers I would be put off from teaching by all the headlines and complaints, when actually more than zero schools function well and have great, positive staff, strong leadership and good morale, beating in mind nowhere is perfect.

I’m not blaming teachers for lack of teachers and I know I will get flamed for saying it, but you’re hardly going to attract hoards of new people to a sector in which people are constantly telling how terrible their life is are you?

(Especially when no one ever talks about the good bits)

That argument would only hold for recruitment of new people though. It wouldn’t explain the retention crisis. Retention is even more of a problem than recruitment. Why are 1/3 of teachers leaving the profession for alternative jobs after only a few years of teaching? Clearly something is amiss if so many people want out. They are actually doing the job and experiencing the day to day realities of it.

The holidays, pension and pay is clearly not a worthwhile trade off for the working hours, working conditions, stress, disrespect, behavioural and pastoral issues or so many teachers wouldn’t be leaving the profession. Either the latter has to get better or the former has to increase to offset the emotional cost of putting up with the latter. Since teachers are only legally allowed to strike about pay, this will most likely be the reason.

NocturnalClocks · 23/01/2023 04:06

Pinky1011 · 23/01/2023 03:55

@NocturnalClocks pay rises does not address any of the issues as to why the teachers are striking. And if they are granted pay rises and inflation isn't put under control then the issue isn't solved. This is my point. Inflation needs to be solved, you can't solve inflation by just throwing more money onto the problem.

You're conflating issues now. Your OP said teachers shouldn't have payrises because that would increase inflation (and I pointed out there's no evidence for that) and because you haven't had one (suggest you focus on that and change jobs).

Your last post then changes the focus and says effectively that schools should be improved. I agree. For that to happen they need far more funding. Have you written to your MP about that?

FlairBand · 23/01/2023 04:03

Here is a genuine question.

Would teachers (and other public sector workers) accept a change to their pensions in return for higher pay or better conditions?

The govt is absolutely hamstrung by the cost of public sector pensions, the likes of which have now completely disappeared in the private sector where the typical worker gets just 3% employer pension contributions into a DC scheme, as opposed to the lifelong inflating income that teachers for example will get. Private sector workers btw had virtually no recourse when DB pensions were taken away, their salaries didn’t rise proportionately and most did not have access to a union to help them understand the changes let alone do anything about them.

At the moment, govt pays about 24% salary into a teachers pension each year and teacher pays around 7-10% depending on their pay scale.

Historically, public sector pay has always been a bit below private because the pensions were so generous (and they’re still generous even though they have changed a bit). But it strikes me as though this is being taken for granted and people want greater parity with the private sector.

I can see how there is an argument for teachers to have more pay up front and lower employee contributions, even though in the long term the current system is far more valuable. However, reforming pensions is a way to add greater flexibility around pay that would ultimately lower the total cost of employment to the govt … meaning that costs could be redirected to improving conditions whilst also increasing salaries.

Pensions are the single most overlooked benefit and barrier in all these debates and I’m interested to know what people think about including them in a solution (particularly if people want greater parity with private sector).

Swipe left for the next trending thread