Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to decline Exit Interview?

97 replies

chickensinthebed · 22/01/2023 19:09

I am moving onto a new job and have been asked to attend an exit interview. I declined one as I thought 'if you have nothing good to say just keep quiet' but my manager is insisting that I have one saying that it's compulsory that I have one. Really? I thought you could decline one- I didn't know it was compulsory. But anyway, here are the reasons why I declined my exit interview.

  1. I am a starter in my role but a lover of research and have been very contributive to my team. However, some of my comments (in regards to what research says) has not been received well by some of my managers (mainly my line manager) and since then I have been micromanaged.
  1. I applied for a higher position (within my team) did not get it (obviously) but it was my manger who was conducting the interviews and I just knew I was wasting my time . But no worries, I got offered a same higher role, within another company. So that's ok.
  1. Suddenly put on an informal performance management plan over, I believe , silly reasons. I received my new job offer before I know I was in an informal performance plan and my manager was querying with me if she should ask HR to inform the new employees (who I will be starting my new job with) that I am on an informal performance management plan.
  1. Anyway (of course) I passed the informal management plan and my manger told me that when I leave, they had already hired someone to take my place and it wouldn't be too long. Ok- fair enough it's a business and they got to keep meaning but it did feel a bit ouch.
  1. I contribute a lot to my team, way more than on my salary. Even to the point we're my colleagues, who were much more senior to me, were asking me to make a presentation on this topic and that etc. which is fine. I love it. But I don't think I was valued - more so from my line manger. But it is what it is.

Anywhoo... I was informed that I had to have an exit interview- and it could be with a line manager or another team lead. I declined because... well what's the point. I am moving on. They are moving on. I don't see a point in "lying" during an exit interview. I might as well save my face and decline al together.

So firstly, AIBU to decline an exit interview and can your job enforce you to have one.

OP posts:
Aprilx · 23/01/2023 00:08

chickensinthebed · 22/01/2023 19:19

But do you think I should have one? Would this go against me? Make me seem as negative?

Yes you need to go, it is a “reasonable request” of your employer and you are still employed. What they can’t do though is make you speak. So go, and say you have nothing to contribute.

AndMeMyGrooveAndMyFriends · 23/01/2023 00:04

You could offer to put it in writing and send it to a manager/director of your choice?

Tormundsbeard · 22/01/2023 23:53

I have had two exit interviews, one after resignation and one after redundancy. Both were with HR. I found both really satisfying and cathartic. Both companies had policies of exit interviews being held with HR staff who hadn’t been involved with you during your time at the company. I used them as an opportunity to speak frankly about frustrations about various company practices and culture issues. The HR I spoke to each time appeared to appreciate the feedback - not sure whether things changed, but I felt much better having got it all off my chest.

if I were you I’d agree to an exit interview with HR only.

TidyDancer · 22/01/2023 23:53

Can you ask for it to be done on paper instead? You can give very simple answers that way. Where I am at the moment, that's how it's done now and it's up to the departing employer whether your line manager is allowed to see the contents. If you don't agree it stays with HR.

Belladonna208 · 22/01/2023 23:52

Exit interviews are really just so HR can put ticks in boxes to say they've met whatever percentage senior management, execs etc have decreed has to be met. They don't change anything. I'm planning on saying as little as possible when I move on from my current job. At my last one it just got stuck in the line manager's filing cabinet and never even passed on to HR. If you feel you have to do it just say as little as possible. And since you've already got your new job presumably your references were already in. Good luck - hope your new place values you more.

AndMeMyGrooveAndMyFriends · 22/01/2023 23:43

Nobody can force you to speak in an exit interview.

It reminds me of those police interviews on TV where someone who has been arrested just says "no comment" to every question!

DoorstoManual · 22/01/2023 23:41

Be very careful on the way up, you never know who you will meet on the way down.

ButterCrackers · 22/01/2023 23:36

If you have to have this meeting keep it nice. Just keep on saying that you are moving on in your career and that you will keep in contact.

EngTech · 22/01/2023 23:35

Go along, be polite and professional and answer every question with “ No comment”

Ringading123 · 22/01/2023 23:31

It's not compulsory by law and it's not going to affect you any in way by not attending. You already have a new job, it's not something that's mentioned on references and even if it was it could only say exit interview declined and you just say I was on annual leave/ holiday.

My last job they always do exit interviews and I had a whole speech of what I was going to say, with all the reasons I left and how undervalued I was but then I thought you know what it's not worth it, it's just feeding the negativity and I was moving on! I never even got asked in end to have one but If I had I would have just kept it simple and said I wanted to progress and didn't feel I was going to there but had enjoyed my time there and the colleagues I worked with! Never burn bridges as you never know when you will come across people again!

BertaHoon · 22/01/2023 23:29

Aquamarine1029 · 22/01/2023 23:22

The only compulsory things are death and taxes. Tell them to jog on.

Even then I'd argue re taxes.

BertaHoon · 22/01/2023 23:28

Fuck em. It's not an HR thing. Your line manager wants to make themselves look good. No need to whatsoever. Move on, don't look back.

NaatQ968 · 22/01/2023 23:26

Decline decline decline.

What they gonna do? It is 100% not compulsory.

FangsForTheMemory · 22/01/2023 23:24

In all my jobs, exit interviews have been with HR anyway. You could ask for that?

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 22/01/2023 23:24

If you’re in the same industry then just smile, say there’s no point as you’re leaving for the opportunity at x company and no point wasting anyone’s time.

Don’t give any fuel to any fire with your line manager or their friend.

SuperHandss · 22/01/2023 23:23

You’re being a bit dramatic - sorry.

Just do the interview. Why are you leaving? I applied for a similar role here and was declined so looked elsewhere.

It doesn’t have to be an attack, just fair answers & it’s done.

Aquamarine1029 · 22/01/2023 23:22

The only compulsory things are death and taxes. Tell them to jog on.

honestlyno · 22/01/2023 23:19

How unusual to have an exit interview with a line manager. Obviously just a tick box exercise if they are not providing space for you to give completely honest feedback.

ehb102 · 22/01/2023 23:06

This exit interview sounds as legit as your "informal management plan". Decline, smile sweetly and say no thank you.

GoAgainstNicki · 22/01/2023 23:04

Erm no. I’d just tell them that I don’t want to do one. What are they gonna do? Force you to go and answer all of the questions. Just focus on the new job, congratulations btw

BigMandysBookClub · 22/01/2023 22:57

Speak to HR. Then when you've booked one with HR just tell your boss you have already arranged one and you don't see the point in repeating yourself having another one with them.

Womencanlift · 22/01/2023 22:46

The HR one will be meaningless as it will be more focused on gathering statistics around leavers. In any company I have worked in the HR one was just a questionnaire, the interview was with my department

They can be productive. The process in my last job was you had the interview with a manager from one of the other teams in our department. You got sent the questions ahead of time so you had time to consider your answers. You could also submit them in writing ahead of the interview.

I wrote down my comments, had the interview with the other manager but then also went through them with my own manager. Yes the conversation with my manager was slightly uncomfortable as I was VERY honest however they listened and from what I understand from friends still in the team, my comments did lead to my manager make changes for the better

Meant I left on a good note. My type of work is a small world and so best to not shit stir on the way out as you never know who you will bump into in the future

Swimmingpoolsally · 22/01/2023 22:42

It’s incredibly difficult when the employee thinks their performance Is excellent, as you do. And your management feels it’s severely lacking. It’s seldom something that can be reconciled.

personally id go say some nice shit and leave it there. You never know when you might meet your manager again.

WoolyMammoth55 · 22/01/2023 22:38

OP, the honest truth is that in your shoes I'd just do it and lie politely.

Smile and be breezy and say you were actively looking for your next step up the ladder in the industry you love, that you are very excited about the future and grateful for what you've learned in the role.

Don't get into any of the office politics/drama/toxicity.

The world can be smaller than you think and people from this team might end up on future teams you'll be on - keeping your chin up and your dignity intact and smiling politely and saying nothing critical is the easy way forward.

Why give the manager an excuse to tell a single person that you've been difficult about the exit interview? Manager is obviously the problem but if you just smile and kill them with kindness then you give them no satisfaction.

Best of luck in the new job!

Margrethe · 22/01/2023 22:22

laidbacklife · 22/01/2023 20:43

I too have just accepted a new role so listened to this podcast, as where I work exit interviews are the norm. Great podcast! Glad I listened to it :)

So glad it was helpful!

Swipe left for the next trending thread