Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Comparing heights of children

170 replies

Led92 · 22/01/2023 17:54

I have a mum friend who often mentions her kids’ heights when they happen to be taller than mine at the time. Like oh is James taller than Ben now? Oh yes look he is. And with our girls as well. I don’t get it. My DD is taller than hers now I think and suddenly it’s not mentioned.

She herself is quite tall but within normal range.
My sister is 5ft10 and often mentions her height. I’m not that much smaller than her.

aibu it really doesn’t matter if kids are taller or shorter unless you think there’s an actual medical problem?!!! Not sure why she keeps mentioning it.

OP posts:
Chasedbythechaser · 23/01/2023 22:49

KimberleyClark · 23/01/2023 21:16

Is it because many women won’t date short men and they don’t want their sons to be men that women won’t date?

It probably is down to this - basic survival of the species.

Tall men are deemed more attractive than short men. All the stories and films are about 'tall' men but as a previous poster pointed out, the tall men have to be well built and not thin/skinny.

It is probably the opposite with women where shorter women are deemed more attractive using words like 'petite' to describe them (obviously I'm not talking about 6ft catwalk models).

My kids are deemed to be on the short side genetically as I am myself. I can't say its ever bothered me at all, other than having to pay 15quid to get every pair of trousers and jeans taken up. I have found myself commenting on tall some kids in my kid's class are as I suppose it is socially acceptable/complimentary whereas it isn't really acceptable to comment on a child being short (other than a petite little girl who it seems to be ok to refer to as dainty/petite/doll like etc).

SkankingWombat · 23/01/2023 22:47

Cuppasoupmonster · 23/01/2023 16:56

How interesting! So obese children are less likely to be tall adults even at the same height as a healthier peer? If that makes sense?

That isn't quite right: it was saying that they won't grow as quickly as their peers as teens. Having done most of their growing towards their final height already, it is common for their shorter friends to catch them up very suddenly once puberty starts whilst the previously 'very tall' DC barely grows. But yes, there is the added complication that, for some, the added early weight will cause an earlier puberty that in turn prevents them achieving the last bit of growth that would have happened in their mid/late teens.

SkankingWombat · 23/01/2023 22:32

tiggergoesbounce · 23/01/2023 20:20

So @SkankingWombat, what was their advice to all of us who are clearly not giving our children the correct lifestyle, environment, or diet???

What a load of Tosh. In general, your child will be the height your child will be 6 say generally, so avoiding malnutrition, etc)

Crikey, you're a bit defensive!
The programme wasn't about advice, it was a science-y 'isn't this fascinating' sorta thing. Whether we like it or not, our lifestyles during childhood affect our final height and whether we reach our maximum potential. Mostly there isn't a lot we can do to change this. We are generally stuck with the quality of air we have where we live, DCs will be fussy eaters and there's little we can do to change that no matter how many vegetables we serve up etc etc.
I have no skin (or judgement!) in this game - my DCs are average height for their ages!

LuciferRising · 23/01/2023 22:14

People are dim about height. Maybe they see it as an achievement because it's the only thing they have to fall back on.

Bagsundermyeyestoday · 23/01/2023 22:09

Led92 · 23/01/2023 21:45

people are welcome to have their own observations or opinions about their own DC’s heights but it’s a bit rude to compare really anything against another child. They’re all great (ish) in their own way with their own things.
Her child basically only says ‘mum’ whereas my child is constantly talking. I don’t say ‘my child has way better language skills than yours’ ?! I might say here he goes again he doesn’t ruddy shut up!

I do think it’s a bit primal as malnutrition does cause growth issues (aren’t North Koreans shorter than South Koreans?!) but I think she’s a bit of a frenemy in that she can be a bit contrary/odd with me on a few things so will probably back off a bit.
I was grateful our older children are in different classes because she can be a bit ‘competitive’.

Totally agree. Mine is so much more ahead then all his peers in everything (height is average), and I would never go on about it or compare (if anything they will mention something, but I'll just nod). Secretly I'm thrilled of course but I'd never vocalise it.

Ricco12 · 23/01/2023 22:06

I would think it's because tall men are deemed more attractive and statistically tall women are more successful

So I guess it pays to be tall.

So this is sparking the competitive mum inside her Confused

EmmaDilemma5 · 23/01/2023 22:04

ethelredonagoodday · 23/01/2023 21:58

My kids are pretty tall for their ages. My DM says things like, ooh DD doesn't want to get much taller, she doesn't want to be too tall?!? Confused not sure quite what I'm expected to do if DD does indeed get 'too tall' whatever that means... 🙄😵‍💫

Haha "I've told her to stop growing mum, she never listens"!

Your mum needs to be showing your daughter that she's incredible just the way she is. Not filling her head with all of that social stereotype bullshit.

RaspberryJamTart · 23/01/2023 22:03

@ethelredonagoodday if you don't know what too tall looks like and their height is not something you worry about, you probably won't end up with kids that are too tall.

EmmaDilemma5 · 23/01/2023 22:02

I've never had anyone mention children's heights (except where a child a few years younger is taller).

But I find mums (and probably dads) are like this and their chat often deteriorates with the more children they have! I know mine definitely has!

I hate comparing children with anything though. Mobility development, language, academic ability. I just find it incredibly boring if there's no real issue.

Next time I'd probably reply with "oh yes. You're taller than me though so your children will probably end up taller than mine. I guess that's genes for you. Anyway, have you seen xxxxxx"

ethelredonagoodday · 23/01/2023 21:58

My kids are pretty tall for their ages. My DM says things like, ooh DD doesn't want to get much taller, she doesn't want to be too tall?!? Confused not sure quite what I'm expected to do if DD does indeed get 'too tall' whatever that means... 🙄😵‍💫

Fizbosshoes · 23/01/2023 21:55

I'm 4ft 10. Virtually every freakin one of my DC friends once they were around 8 or 10 had to really proudly tell me they were taller than me. (My own DC were 13 when they reached my height)

I know, I know, they're only kids but after about the 20th one I wanted to say " I'm short, not unobservant!!!"
And It's not through effort or achievement that anyone got to the height they did. I'm not short because I didn't try hard enough!😂

Led92 · 23/01/2023 21:45

people are welcome to have their own observations or opinions about their own DC’s heights but it’s a bit rude to compare really anything against another child. They’re all great (ish) in their own way with their own things.
Her child basically only says ‘mum’ whereas my child is constantly talking. I don’t say ‘my child has way better language skills than yours’ ?! I might say here he goes again he doesn’t ruddy shut up!

I do think it’s a bit primal as malnutrition does cause growth issues (aren’t North Koreans shorter than South Koreans?!) but I think she’s a bit of a frenemy in that she can be a bit contrary/odd with me on a few things so will probably back off a bit.
I was grateful our older children are in different classes because she can be a bit ‘competitive’.

OP posts:
Songbird54321 · 23/01/2023 21:39

My DD is the youngest in her class, she is also the smallest. Most of her classmates are a good head taller than her. She was 5lbs born and has always been a little dot. People do like to point it out to us though, more so because I am 5'8 so think they expect her to be bigger.
It used to bother me when she was a baby but it goes over my head now

Whatifthegrassisblue · 23/01/2023 21:28

KimberleyClark · 23/01/2023 21:16

Is it because many women won’t date short men and they don’t want their sons to be men that women won’t date?

Maybe? Although if you're good looking, even just charming it's not a problem, I know plenty of short men with very attractive women. One of my good friends is proper short, he must be about 5'2"? He's always had attractive girlfriends and now has a stunning wife

JustDanceAddict · 23/01/2023 21:23

My late teen DS is very tall (6ft4) and people always comment on his height, plus they often think he’s much older & dd is younger, much to DS’s disgust.,

StillMedusa · 23/01/2023 21:21

Other end of the scale here... my adorable toddler DGS is on the first -3rd centile (if we are generous) babies a year younger are his height. And he has a big head of curly hair and is basically a hobbit. Both parents are short so we aren't expecting him to be a 6 footer unless there is a miracle throw back gene!

Odd because I'm a lot taller than my DD, and my son in law's Dad is a 6 footer.

At the moment he looks super cute, as people think he's younger than he is and are amazed at his skills as he scrambles up at soft play etc. But he's going to be 'the short one' at school and I hate to think that other kids and especially other parents will judge :(

KimberleyClark · 23/01/2023 21:16

Is it because many women won’t date short men and they don’t want their sons to be men that women won’t date?

Newlifestartingatlast · 23/01/2023 21:13

Cuddlybug · 23/01/2023 17:46

It's as if tall people actually walk through life believing they're tall because they made better choices and that their DC are taller because they're better parents.

But as @SkankingWombat’s post has shown, this can be true

Bollocks…when they were dependant I walked through life thinking

  1. how the fuck am I going to pay for another pair of shoes in gigantic sizes that have to be imported form American cos shitting school won’t let him wear shoes I can buy in uk to fit
  2. he will get a bad back if he continues to sit like that - shit he can’t even get his legs under the table now
  3. why does his shirt or t shirt keep showing bare belly ven though it’s supposed to be long length - hairy belly in young men is not nice
  4. when will he frigging stop growing

at no time did I consider it was something I’d done. The tall genes in our family come from my mum . It 5 foot 6 I’m actually the runt . Nowt to do with me- just family genes going back to whoever and whenever.

as for my son - no he does think he’s better. He has self esteem issues as he always stood out and was different . He hunches over even as an adult to try to fit in. He dreads buying clothes or shoes which makes how he feels physically even worse. And even shitty clothes cost him way more than standard clothes. Down to socks and underpants. Even larger men’s socks don’t fit him. He has to go to specialist shops.

and he is often fed up with living in a world that is uncomfortable as everything is too small and he can’t fit - whether plane seats, standard tables, door frames, chairs that mean he is hunched over with hips permanently below his knees, or just mirrors windows etc.

stop with the fake and ignorant assumptions and generalisations. Most very tall people I know, and I know plenty even in my own family including my own deceased mother, don’t like it

ilovebagpuss · 23/01/2023 21:12

Both DH and I are taller side 5'9 and 6ft respectively but our eldest DD is 5ft at 16 and her 13 year old sister has already overtaken her. She does get a bit sad sometimes that she isn't taller and I have no idea genetics wise who she takes after she is so dainty and I am a right chunky, big footed person.
I do get a bit hacked off at any "ooh has she stopped growing now then" type comments.
She's perfect as she is but I think it's hard for them if they don't fit either average. My DN is very tall and lovely but she feels self concious.

Cuppasoupmonster · 23/01/2023 21:07

You’re not small @ExasperatedbyJanuary youre completely average! Same size as my sis.

ExasperatedbyJanuary · 23/01/2023 21:05

I really don’t get it. I would hate to be tall! I think it’s because I was one of those early growers at school - reached my adult height by 13, got boobs early, just felt big and lumpy (wasn’t overweight as such, but definitely solid and not at all petite). Now am a slim 5 foot 4 and like being smallish. I guess, ultimately, we never get over our childhood hang-ups, and mine was being big! Now I am happy to be small. I have two daughters and I don’t think they’re going to be tall - none of us are bothered!

But one of my friends goes on about how her 6 year old is nearly as big as my 9 year old quite often. It does bug me a bit - it’s like - what are you trying to prove?! Congratulations- your kid’s a giant!

WineDup · 23/01/2023 21:04

smidge80 · 22/01/2023 20:52

I don't get why parents have to point out the blindingly obvious. We all know how tall our children are!

From experience, it can be really hard when your child is very much on the small side and all their friends tower above them when they say 'gosh look at the difference between them it's like little and large' or 'isn't she so small' and 'she must be the smallest in the class'
They have no idea what worries and tests are going on in the background. The same can be said for the very tall children. People can be so ignorant.

Yep, I’ve got one on the 2nd centile and one on the 91st centile. My 11m old is up to my 7yo’s ribs 😂

Cuppasoupmonster · 23/01/2023 21:00

I agree with PP I’m from a tall family and its not all it’s cracked up to be.

The women don’t like their big hands/feet and ‘swimmer’s shoulders’ (luckily I dodged these somehow). A lot of them have back problems and find it hard to buy nicely fitting clothes.

Very tall men are rarely proportionate in terms of weight and are too thin giving them that prey mantis look.

Newlifestartingatlast · 23/01/2023 20:58

familyissues12345 · 23/01/2023 16:48

Some people are just like it. A friend of mine has a thing about height, but is also a pretty poor judge of how tall people are - recently said her youngest is now 6ft (haven't seen for a while, and is 13 so could be growing like a weed!) but I saw him and he's no taller than me (5ft 7). She's quite petite though so think anyone taller is a giant!

I’m tall - but surrounded by tall family. I constantly misjudge peoples heights too. I think people are shorter than they are- particularly men
so not specific to a certain height I think- just comparing to the people you see the most.

BusySittingDown · 23/01/2023 20:57

I don't mention it all the time but I find it baffling and a bit amazing that my DD1 is 5'10. But mostly because I'm just over 5'2 and I'm just like "how the fuck...?"

DD2 is short and lovely. Although she's only 11 so may grow a fair bit yet, I stopped growing at about 12.

Swipe left for the next trending thread