Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think formula feeding parents are bent over a barrel?

283 replies

inpixiehollow · 22/01/2023 15:57

Just been discussing this with a friend and interested to know peoples thoughts.
Am I being unreasonable to think that the NHS/govt should manufacture a nutritionally complete formula for babies, sold at cost price to families? Not disputing the importance of real access to proper breastfeeding support but we have to acknowledge that some women cannot/don't want to breastfeed and instead are victim to formula companies turning over huge profits. If people want fancy formulas/special additives then the option should be there but with rising cost of living I don't think its acceptable that something so necessary for many babies is getting to the point of unaffordable.
I am a massive advocate for breastfeeding so please don't take this as an attack or downplaying the massive lack of help for bf in the UK, I just wish both options were made more accessible for whatever feeding choices people make.

OP posts:
BungleandGeorge · 22/01/2023 17:22

But there’s loads of things in life that are essential but no free and that someone makes a profit on. Practically everything tbh!
breastfeeding is most definitely not free- mum needs to eat an enormous amount of additional calories plus breast pads, bras, bf tops, pumps etc etc. all that is sold at a profit too. That’s just life. Basic formula isn’t that expensive and is available free to low income parents

picnicshnicnic · 22/01/2023 17:21

I breastfeed, but yes, I see where you are coming from.

Not free, because nothing is ever free, it would be at the taxpayers expense. But yes, at cost, because formula is terribly expensive and there are large profit margins.

ThanksItHasPockets · 22/01/2023 17:20

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 22/01/2023 17:17

Not the point, I know, but I recently noticed a massive price difference between C&G and Aptamil, and wondered why anyone would be buying the latter.

Because the higher price is a deliberate choice to position Aptamil as a premium brand. Many parents are willing to pay that premium in the belief that it is a superior product. It isn’t, but branding has a very very powerful influence on consumer behaviour.

inpixiehollow · 22/01/2023 17:19

Scienceadvisory · 22/01/2023 17:14

Perhaps bother to read the comment before you comment yourself. She clearly states they are not not-for-profit I.e. they make a profit.

fair enough I mis-read it. However then that point is completely irrelevant to my post? I stated the NHS should manufacture a formula to sell at cost price, not already existing formula companies who can carry on selling their product for whatever price they like.

OP posts:
Floralnomad · 22/01/2023 17:18

I think it’s perfectly ok as is . I couldn’t breastfeed for medical reasons and chose a very expensive formula option by buying SMA ready made , we did occasionally use powder and make it ourselves . The emphasis if there is any spare money should be on promoting and assisting people to breast feed not making it cheaper to formula feed .

Scoobyblue · 22/01/2023 17:17

It is the parent's responsibility to feed their child not the government's. Child benefit and healthy start vouchers are available to help those in lower incomes.

DangerNoodles · 22/01/2023 17:17

Formula companies spend a vast amount on advertising, because formula advertising has been proven reduce breastfeeding rates and more money for them. To help improve breastfeeding rates the government banned the advertising of infant formula. To get around the ban formula companies invented 'follow on' milk for babies age 6 months plus which they can advertise.

There should be an outright ban on formula advertising, no exceptions. Then formula wouldn't have to be so expensive and less women would have thier breastfeeding journeys sabotaged by big business. I don't agree with subsidising formula other than specialist persciption formulas. People on certain benefits already recieve vouchers for formula, there has to be a line between state help and people who can taking responsibility for themselves. Obviously accidents happen but if you can't afford 10 or 20 a week on baby you shouldn't be planning a pregnancy.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 22/01/2023 17:17

Not the point, I know, but I recently noticed a massive price difference between C&G and Aptamil, and wondered why anyone would be buying the latter.

BooCrew · 22/01/2023 17:16

Hallyup14 · 22/01/2023 16:52

You have a child. You need to feed that child. You buy food from the supermarket for that child, just as you do for your other children and yourselves. None of that food is sold at cost price, it's all for profit.

I don't see the issue. You have a free option but choose not to use it (far, far too many women claim they 'can't' breastfeed for whatever reason, it's simply not true. If they don't want to, that's up to them, but mothers in countries without readily available access to formula and clean water manage to feed their babies successfully because they have no other choice).

Cool, so you don't believe any women who say they couldn't breastfeed? Lovely to know. I suspected as much from a lot of women.

Just so you know, I wouldn't have chosen for my son to lose so much weight he was hospitalised and tube fed for three days, while trying and failing to express milk for him. I fully intended to breastfeed but it didn't work. He was happy and healthy again after being given formula, and is now a very bright four year old.

Cuppasoupmonster · 22/01/2023 17:16

Suprima · 22/01/2023 17:14

complete anecdata, but:

in my baby group of women, all babies are formula fed because of fear of saggy breasts, boyfriends not liking it and babies ‘sleeping better’

they buy it off the local thieves every now and again to make it cheaper when it’s available- but it’s bought as usual within the shop because it’s better than the alternative

breastfeeding support in our area is terrible.

there is still a lot of cultural unfucking to do around breastfeeding. It’s not just a case of cost.

Which group is this? NCT?

SouthLondonMum22 · 22/01/2023 17:16

Dogdogwoofwoof · 22/01/2023 17:07

I breastfed my children as it was the free option. However if I had the option of free formula I'm certain I wouldn't of breastfed.

Fair enough.

MrsAvocet · 22/01/2023 17:15

inpixiehollow · 22/01/2023 16:31

Just to reiterate I did state sold at cost price, not supplied for free (unless of course families are using vouchers they are entitled to). Lets not beat around the bush, the Govt takes some of the big formula company's money in taxes so it absolutely benefits them to keep people buying formula and turning over a company's profits.

There's your answer.
Providing formula at cost would not be a no cost option to the government - there would be effects on the economy.
It might be a good idea, but then't wouldn't it also be a good idea to provide apples at cost from government orchards and low cost potatoes and carrots from government run farms? It's been done of course...just under different political ideologies that didn't end up being very popular!
We live in a country where wealthy people get wealthier from the sale of water for heaven's sake. If we don't even have nationalisation of most public services, why on earth would a right wing government have any interest in a publicly owned baby formula company? Breast feeding promotion is a complete red herring - it's all about money.

whataboutsecondbreakfast · 22/01/2023 17:15

inpixiehollow · 22/01/2023 17:09

Formula companies make huge profits! Please look this up before you come to come to comment if genuinely believe they are 'not for profit' organisations.

You need to re-read what @Businessflake said.

She said they're not not-for-profit organisations.

Scienceadvisory · 22/01/2023 17:14

inpixiehollow · 22/01/2023 17:09

Formula companies make huge profits! Please look this up before you come to come to comment if genuinely believe they are 'not for profit' organisations.

Perhaps bother to read the comment before you comment yourself. She clearly states they are not not-for-profit I.e. they make a profit.

Suprima · 22/01/2023 17:14

BadNomad · 22/01/2023 17:06

A lot of people only breastfeed because it is free. If formula was free then a lot more would definitely take that option and share the job of feeding with their partners.

complete anecdata, but:

in my baby group of women, all babies are formula fed because of fear of saggy breasts, boyfriends not liking it and babies ‘sleeping better’

they buy it off the local thieves every now and again to make it cheaper when it’s available- but it’s bought as usual within the shop because it’s better than the alternative

breastfeeding support in our area is terrible.

there is still a lot of cultural unfucking to do around breastfeeding. It’s not just a case of cost.

AnuSTart · 22/01/2023 17:13

Dogdogwoofwoof · 22/01/2023 16:58

I genuinely think that if formula was sold at cost or given away "free" or on prescription for all who want it, it would mean that breastfeeding rates would be even lower than they already are!

Exactly this.
It's shortsighted.
Long term it's in the economy's interest to have the highest levels of breastfeeding possible. It's political correctness and short sighted #kindness to say it has no effect on the long term health of infants to feed them on cow's milk.

Lenald · 22/01/2023 17:13

roarfeckingroarr · 22/01/2023 16:01

It's not the government's job to do this.

We should have much better support for breastfeeding. It's free and it's the best option for your baby's health.

It wasn’t the best option for my babies health.

That’s a sweeping statement.

MotherOfHouseplants · 22/01/2023 17:13

A polite reminder that breastfeeding is only free if you place no value on the mother’s time (and I breastfed two children into toddlerhood).

Snaketime · 22/01/2023 17:12

I haven't RTFT but as someone who tried desperately to breastfeed my DD but couldn't (which caused me to feel like a failure and to have bad PND, to the point I wanted to kill myself) those first couple of comments are horrific. Some women CAN'T breastfeed no matter how hard they try and no matter how much help they have.
I couldn't breastfeed my DS either as he was allergic to my milk.

I agree OP, there should be a balance of both more help/education about breastfeeding and a cheaper formula option, the price is ridiculous. I work in a shop and the amount of times mothers have come in to buy formula and have literally scrapped money together to buy it and sometimes are even short and have to put it back.

WillTimeCome · 22/01/2023 17:12

I don't undertstand what's hard to get about what the OP is saying. It would be good if there was an option - not free, but also not for profit, whereby FF was cheaper than some of the excessive prices that are being charged right now. No frills, basic packagaing. Easy concept to grasp.

Not a bad idea OP.

Cuppasoupmonster · 22/01/2023 17:11

*lead. Not less.

OddsocksinmyDocs · 22/01/2023 17:11

Personally, I think the best way forward would be to remove the 'breast is best' mantra that is spewed out. Scientifically, breast is best but feeding your child formula is hardly the death sentence some people make it out to be...

Cuppasoupmonster · 22/01/2023 17:11

MakingMarlsAndOtherThings · 22/01/2023 17:05

“Personally, No - I wouldn’t want the NHS in its current state or this shitshow of a government manufacturing anything I give to my baby.”

This.

You make a good point.

It turns out a lot of donated breast milk given to prem babies contained less recently 😬

Greyhave · 22/01/2023 17:09

Not really no. When you decide to have a baby, feeding the baby along with all of its other needs becomes your financial responsibility.

Formula isn’t all the same. I tried a couple of different ones for my babies before finding the right one and I was happy to pay more for that, offsetting it against the money saved buying supermarket own brand nappies.

We also need to get over this weird attitude towards breast is best where formula companies aren’t even allowed to advertise first milk.

The only difference I can see between my kids and those who were breastfed exclusively is that they slept better as babies, gained weight more easily and were able to be looked after and fed by other family members from time to time.

Fortunately they aren’t obese with a load of health conditions and attachment issues like some midwives might have led me to believe. 😂

inpixiehollow · 22/01/2023 17:09

Businessflake · 22/01/2023 17:06

What a ridiculous suggestion. Maybe don’t have babies if you can’t afford to feed them? If someone can’t afford formula for a baby how on earth will they afford to feed a growing toddler?

Formula manufacturers are not not-for-profit organisations.

Formula companies make huge profits! Please look this up before you come to come to comment if genuinely believe they are 'not for profit' organisations.

OP posts: