Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think formula feeding parents are bent over a barrel?

283 replies

inpixiehollow · 22/01/2023 15:57

Just been discussing this with a friend and interested to know peoples thoughts.
Am I being unreasonable to think that the NHS/govt should manufacture a nutritionally complete formula for babies, sold at cost price to families? Not disputing the importance of real access to proper breastfeeding support but we have to acknowledge that some women cannot/don't want to breastfeed and instead are victim to formula companies turning over huge profits. If people want fancy formulas/special additives then the option should be there but with rising cost of living I don't think its acceptable that something so necessary for many babies is getting to the point of unaffordable.
I am a massive advocate for breastfeeding so please don't take this as an attack or downplaying the massive lack of help for bf in the UK, I just wish both options were made more accessible for whatever feeding choices people make.

OP posts:
User98866 · 22/01/2023 17:48

Feeding babies should be taken out of the hands of large corporations. They can’t be trusted. They are disgusting, immoral and haven’t cleaned up their act since the 80s at all. Takes a bit of interest in the subject and digging but people would be shocked at what’s goes on. I would love to see a very cheap or free National formula milk. Even with the healthy start vouchers families have been struggling with the cost of formula for years (there was a government report on it not that long ago linked below). I dread to even think of what’s going on now. Watering down milk and staring cows milk and solids super early I would imagine.
www.infantfeedingappg.uk/wp-content/uploads/2018/11/APPGIFI-Inquiry-Report-cost-of-infant-formula.pdf

sjxoxo · 22/01/2023 17:46

MelchiorsMistress · 22/01/2023 16:06

But like you say, it’s a feeding choice. It’s a choice that’s valid but it’s still a choice.

When parents don’t have a choice because their babies need specialist formula on prescription, then of course it should be free. But otherwise, no. People choose to have children knowing that they have a responsibility to feed them and that’s pretty much the most basic responsibility a parent can have so I don’t think there’s any need to provide it for free.

If the NHS is going to start paying for people’s food then I’d rather see people that don’t have a choice about eating expensive foods get help, like those that have to be gluten/dairy free for the sake of their health.

This is the worst post on this thread 😑

BadNomad · 22/01/2023 17:45

Twizbe · 22/01/2023 17:38

No it doesn't. They add ingredients with no real test to see if it actually helps babies or not.

What is needed by a baby is the standard to which all formula must adhere. Anything else is just marketing.

There are many options. Thicker formula to help with reflux. Goat's milk or soya for those who can't tolerate cows milk. Halal. Formula to help with colic. Constipation. Hypoallergenic.

One basic NHS formula will not meet all needs. If all those other companies go out of business, then all those other formula options will no longer be available and babies will suffer.

MajorCarolDanvers · 22/01/2023 17:44

It is not the job of the tax payer to pay for baby food.

Lifeisapeach · 22/01/2023 17:43

Companies exist to make profits ! That’s a fact of life. Without those profits they wouldn’t exist! It’s just the way our capitalist world exists. Without the profits they won’t have investors. Without investors they won’t have the funds for factories staff and research. Selling at cost is never an option. Someone would need to foot the bill. And our gov already give a tonne of hand outs .

TeaAndStrumpets · 22/01/2023 17:41

Georgyporky · 22/01/2023 17:32

There used to be a product called (I think) National Dried Milk.
It came in large tins, was cheap, & was sold at mother & baby clinics.

Anyone else remember this?

Yes I still remember the orange juice concentrate too. Mum had to put it on a high shelf to stop us helping ourselves!

Viviennemary · 22/01/2023 17:41

I disagree totally. What next government start manufacturing nappies. New borns need them too. Ridiculous!

Thriwit · 22/01/2023 17:41

Do people genuinely believe that every mother can breastfeed if they just try hard enough, and do it better?
There are genuinely women who cannot breastfeed for a variety of medical reasons. I’ve seen estimates from 3%-10%. At approx 620,000 live births in U.K. every year, that’s 18,600-62,000 women that this affects.
Formula is therefore an additional expense that these women have due to a medical condition/disability.
I don’t think it’s unreasonable to give some help with the cost of this - not necessarily free, but some help.
Healthy Start vouchers are a start, but your family income really has to be very low to qualify. Maybe extending these to women who can’t breastfeed for medical reasons would at least be a start.

Spanielsarepainless · 22/01/2023 17:40

My sister was fed National Dried Milk. I used to go with my mother and her to the clinic every week or month to collect it. Sister would be weighed in a basket thing.

Twizbe · 22/01/2023 17:38

BadNomad · 22/01/2023 17:31

The competition between the companies forces them to make better and better formula. If you take away that competition, quality will drop to a bare basics level. If you're happy with a bare basics level, you can buy that cheap already.

No it doesn't. They add ingredients with no real test to see if it actually helps babies or not.

What is needed by a baby is the standard to which all formula must adhere. Anything else is just marketing.

Twizbe · 22/01/2023 17:36

Yes!

Have a read of a book called why the politics of breastfeeding matter. It's a real eye opener into the down right horrific practices of infant milk manufacturers.

A plain tin, cost priced, complete formula should be available.

That combined with proper support for mothers to breastfeed.

pollykitty · 22/01/2023 17:34

I breastfed for 4 years and completely agree. A friend who had a baby around the same time as me and bottle fed from the beginning told me all about the lack of support she had from midwives and nurses and all the lectures she received. She had problems know how much to give her baby. I couldn’t care less how babies are fed as long as they are fed. If someone had told me I’d BF for so long when pregnant I would have laughed, but I liked it more than I thought. I got a lot of judgement too which was unexpected.

MonkeyMindAllOverAround · 22/01/2023 17:34

EezyOozy · 22/01/2023 16:04

@roarfeckingroarr that not what I said. Nobody mentioned making it more difficult. But a resistance to making it easier.

I totally disagree. Most people want to breastfeed, many can’t no matter how hard they try.

We should make good breastfeeding advice more widely available not reducing the one of formula. It is incredible that you cannot even discuss different formulas with a paediatrician when you cannot breastfeed, because they are forbidden to advise on formulas’ differences in order to protect breastfeeding!

Georgyporky · 22/01/2023 17:34

Cross-posted.

Georgyporky · 22/01/2023 17:32

There used to be a product called (I think) National Dried Milk.
It came in large tins, was cheap, & was sold at mother & baby clinics.

Anyone else remember this?

BadNomad · 22/01/2023 17:31

The competition between the companies forces them to make better and better formula. If you take away that competition, quality will drop to a bare basics level. If you're happy with a bare basics level, you can buy that cheap already.

whataboutsecondbreakfast · 22/01/2023 17:29

inpixiehollow · 22/01/2023 17:26

This is an interesting point but most of these formula companies are absolute giants like Nestle/Danone etc so I actually don't have much sympathy for them losing money though the implications for their employees would definitely be something to consider theoretically.

The government isn't going to start taking over formula making when it's not going to make them any money.

Who's going to fund all this? Build the factories and set up the infrastructure needed to make all this formula, and how will it be distributed without costing a fortune and therefore not really saving parents anything significant in the long-run anyway.

TeaAndStrumpets · 22/01/2023 17:27

TeaAndStrumpets · 22/01/2023 17:24

In the war National Dried Milk was introduced to enable mothers to go back to work. In the 1950s and 60s it was available at baby clinics ( I assume cheap or free) I remember going with my mum to get the tins. We also got cod liver oil and very concentrated orange juice.

I looked up National Dried Milk. Apparently it was discontinued in the 70s because people preferred other types of formula. I wonder if it was reintroduced now would it be popular?

Here it is

To think formula feeding parents are bent over a barrel?
inpixiehollow · 22/01/2023 17:26

whataboutsecondbreakfast · 22/01/2023 17:23

But if the NHS starts offering cost-price formula to everyone, the formula companies are going to struggle and potentially even close if they're no longer making money.

They're businesses with thousands of employees who rely on them to pay their bills - the decision to make cost-price formula on the NHS isn't a decision that exists in a vacuum - it could have a negative impact on thousands of families.

Parents should be factoring the price of formula into their budgets, the same way they budget for childcare or nappies or uniform.

This is an interesting point but most of these formula companies are absolute giants like Nestle/Danone etc so I actually don't have much sympathy for them losing money though the implications for their employees would definitely be something to consider theoretically.

OP posts:
Suprima · 22/01/2023 17:25

Cuppasoupmonster · 22/01/2023 17:16

Which group is this? NCT?

A small church hall type thing. I have only heard their reasons for their feeding choice because it’s been used as a reason to make a comment towards me.

“Oh I would have done that but I already got stretchmarks so didn’t want to ruin my boobs”
“what does your bf think? Kev says my boobs are his!!!”
“up late last night? You should swap because lil bubba sleeps 11-8”

i think it’s only on MN that breastfeeding is the default and FF is some awful end to someone’s breastfeeding journey.

in some communities BF is absolutely unthought of, seen as dirty, perverse and body-ruining. And it’s completely a feeding choice made with the information they have- not a last resort.

TeaAndStrumpets · 22/01/2023 17:24

In the war National Dried Milk was introduced to enable mothers to go back to work. In the 1950s and 60s it was available at baby clinics ( I assume cheap or free) I remember going with my mum to get the tins. We also got cod liver oil and very concentrated orange juice.

I looked up National Dried Milk. Apparently it was discontinued in the 70s because people preferred other types of formula. I wonder if it was reintroduced now would it be popular?

Scienceadvisory · 22/01/2023 17:23

This plan of the govt selling it at cost would never work. The govt do not own the manufacturing infrastructure to make formula and they don't have the supply chains set up either - this would all require a lot of money to set up from scratch. This would add to the cost of the formula so it's not going to be the cheap option some posters seem to think.

Then there's the fact is very difficult to set a cost price unless you can guarantee a certain number of sales. E.g. if it costs £50m to set all this up and then they can only sell a thousand units then the cost was really 50k each. You would be forcing a massive cost onto taxpayers.

Really we already do this anyway through healthy start vouchers and child benefit. How much more help do parents need in order to do the basics such as feed their kids? And if you can't afford formula then you are going to struggle to afford food when you've got a toddler. Perhaps people need to consider whether they should become parents if they can't afford the basics like formula.

Leah5678 · 22/01/2023 17:23

Healthy start vouchers already exist for poor parents. Why would a company bother producing something if they weren't making a profit? Do you want all food to be sold at production cost as well seeing as everyone needs food not just babies

whataboutsecondbreakfast · 22/01/2023 17:23

inpixiehollow · 22/01/2023 17:19

fair enough I mis-read it. However then that point is completely irrelevant to my post? I stated the NHS should manufacture a formula to sell at cost price, not already existing formula companies who can carry on selling their product for whatever price they like.

But if the NHS starts offering cost-price formula to everyone, the formula companies are going to struggle and potentially even close if they're no longer making money.

They're businesses with thousands of employees who rely on them to pay their bills - the decision to make cost-price formula on the NHS isn't a decision that exists in a vacuum - it could have a negative impact on thousands of families.

Parents should be factoring the price of formula into their budgets, the same way they budget for childcare or nappies or uniform.

inpixiehollow · 22/01/2023 17:22

Scoobyblue · 22/01/2023 17:17

It is the parent's responsibility to feed their child not the government's. Child benefit and healthy start vouchers are available to help those in lower incomes.

But the government wouldn't be paying to feed anyone's child, just providing a cheaper option for parents to purchase. If you disagree thats fair enough but nowhere did I state there should be free formula for anyone other than allergy babies etc. If families could use their vouchers to buy the cheaper formula then it would still remain 'free' to those families who qualify.

OP posts: