Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think formula feeding parents are bent over a barrel?

283 replies

inpixiehollow · 22/01/2023 15:57

Just been discussing this with a friend and interested to know peoples thoughts.
Am I being unreasonable to think that the NHS/govt should manufacture a nutritionally complete formula for babies, sold at cost price to families? Not disputing the importance of real access to proper breastfeeding support but we have to acknowledge that some women cannot/don't want to breastfeed and instead are victim to formula companies turning over huge profits. If people want fancy formulas/special additives then the option should be there but with rising cost of living I don't think its acceptable that something so necessary for many babies is getting to the point of unaffordable.
I am a massive advocate for breastfeeding so please don't take this as an attack or downplaying the massive lack of help for bf in the UK, I just wish both options were made more accessible for whatever feeding choices people make.

OP posts:
Cuppasoupmonster · 22/01/2023 18:11

Twizbe · 22/01/2023 18:10

@TiddleyWink there is an awful lot of work women do that's unpaid which in turn saves the country money. Ubpaid caring, voluntary work, unpaid childcare etc.

Economist (mostly women by the way) have been looking at how to quantify the benefit to economies of women breastfeeding.

And what did they come up with?

Inyournightgarden · 22/01/2023 18:10

For gods sake what about taking responsibility for your own choices in life?

when you have or even plan to have kids you know you may need to buy formula, and you know what it costs.

why do people expect everything handed to them on a plate? Even at cost is taking the mick. Yes it’s crap that things cost money but grow up, it’s part of life.

i swear some of you on here live in fantasy land

Twizbe · 22/01/2023 18:10

@TiddleyWink there is an awful lot of work women do that's unpaid which in turn saves the country money. Ubpaid caring, voluntary work, unpaid childcare etc.

Economist (mostly women by the way) have been looking at how to quantify the benefit to economies of women breastfeeding.

SE1982 · 22/01/2023 18:09

I see your point about the additional cost for those who cannot breastfeed for whatever reason although we all have to pay to feed our children or use any benefits we are entitled to.

That said the Government is not going to fund formula milk mainly because the government currently has a public health initiative which aims to have most babies breastfed to improve overall health and subsequently reduce NHS costs going forward. Funding formula where it is a choice is obviously not in line with this policy so it won’t happen. Years ago you could usually request formula on post-natal wards but now the majority of hospitals will not give mothers formula unless there is some kind of medical reason for it and therefore if you want to formula feed the midwives have to emphasise that you need to bring your own formula at your expense as you will not be provided with any of you can breastfeed. They don’t even fund breastfeeding support adequately and yet pregnant women are constantly being told about the importance of breastfeeding and put under pressure to do it. The policy is based on scientific facts so I think it is right be honest about the importance of it and try to increase breastfeeding rates, however, having had a baby quite recently I think the way that the government now handles both breast and formula feeding needs to be improved I think. I’ve breastfed for some time with a few issues and I received virtually no help from the NHS. If you’re unhappy about the cost or formula (which I don’t totally disagree about by the way) I think a better target would be the formula companies who price it.

AnneLovesGilbert · 22/01/2023 18:09

sendbobs · 22/01/2023 18:05

It’s only ‘free’ if you place zero value on a woman’s labour. Which, sadly, lots of people do.

Spending time with your newborn is not labour it's the absolute bare minimum. Formula feeding mums also sit on the sofa and relax with their babies, so how is it a waste of time?

Agreed. And bf gives a baby much more than just food.

People always spout that as if ff babies make up bottles and feed themselves.

Human infants require a lot of care. Someone’s got to change nappies and provide milk in one form or another. Bf mums spend much less time getting a boob out than washing, sterilising and mixing bottles.

MajorCarolDanvers · 22/01/2023 18:08

@inpixiehollow

Sold at cost price. Not free.

So who do you think is going to pay for the loss of revenue if not the tax payer?

Oigetoffmylawn · 22/01/2023 18:08

It's an unfortunate reality of the cost of living crisis. It impacts EVERYTHING. Including infant nutrition.

StillWeRise · 22/01/2023 18:06

absolutely agree with OP
an analogy would be own brand/basics paracetamol vs branded
companies are still making and selling the basic version, that costs pence, and people are free to buy the overpriced stuff in fancy packs if they choose
the point is, formula companies have a financial incentive to promote formula feeding and undermine breastfeeding, hence their sneaky ads for 'follow-on formula' etc
the amount of money spent promoting and supporting breastfeeding compares shamefully with the amount spent promoting formula/bottles/sterilisers/teats etc etc
of course women should choose what is right for them and their baby but that choice should be free of financial consideration
its very sad but not surprising to hear of women watering down formula and as for buying it on the black market, this is absolutely chilling
what times we live in

sendbobs · 22/01/2023 18:05

It’s only ‘free’ if you place zero value on a woman’s labour. Which, sadly, lots of people do.

Spending time with your newborn is not labour it's the absolute bare minimum. Formula feeding mums also sit on the sofa and relax with their babies, so how is it a waste of time?

Hankunamatata · 22/01/2023 18:04

I'd argue that it's a cost you factor in when planning on having a baby. Same as being able to afford nappies, pram and other baby equipment

FrenchFancie · 22/01/2023 18:04

i produced no milk or colostrum at all with DD - I also did my best to bleed to death shortly after her delivery, and then got pre-éclampsia after delivery (who knew you could do that?!?!?).

with one thing and another I couldn’t BF and had to FF. the expense even ten years ago made my eyes water - not so much in the first few weeks but when we got close to weaning and she was drinks lots 🤦‍♀️ so expensive!!

im another one who had a horrendous experience with a busy body in cafe Nero - I was about six weeks post parfum and had struggled out to the cafe with DD, ordered a coffee and cake and warmed up a bottle for DD - this absolute cow bag of a woman came over and told me I didn’t deserve DD if I was just going to feed her poison…

i was teetering on the edge of horrific PND at that time and I genuinely believe that comment tipped me over the edge. It took me nearly a year to recover and DD is an only child because I was so worried about returning to that dark place if I got PND again. I had suicide plans and I even tried to give DD up as I didn’t think I was fit to be her mother.

i think we need more support for mothers generally and in particular an honest conversation about feeding, and that BF doesn’t work for everyone and that that’s ok.

IDontCareMatthew · 22/01/2023 18:03

MajorCarolDanvers · 22/01/2023 17:44

It is not the job of the tax payer to pay for baby food.

I agree....the entitlement on this thread!

Beseen22 · 22/01/2023 18:03

Cuppasoupmonster · 22/01/2023 16:57

What does that ‘support’ look like though? Should a theatre nurse walk out halfway through an operation because her baby needs to be fed? Should a teacher leave their class of kids? Should a woman working in a nursery plonk herself down, breastfeed and leave her charges to run riot without her? How do you make it work? I’m genuinely interested.

When I started my first newly qualified nurse post I was an exclusiviely expressing mum to a 12 w old. DH was made redundant at a fairly inconvenient time. I pumped pre work, then at lunchtime break for 30 mins then as soon as I got home from my shift. I wasn't a maternity returner but I believe I would have been entitled to an extra pump break if I was or if it had been risk assessed properly. The hardest parts were walking to work with my pump 40 min walk uphill and trying to switch from nights to days and work out when to pump. I kept it going til he was 1 and then stopped for the covid vaccine (recommended not to breastfeed at the time, but was ready to stop by then!).

No I don't think the NHS should manufacture formula. The NHS doesn't manufacture things, there are generic medications manufactured by pharmaceutical companies like TEVA once the original patent of a branded drug expires. There are generic forms of baby milk (Aldi) however it is a less popular choice than the known brands that our own mums probably used and trusted (Cow and Gate).
I'm in Scotland and unfortunately we didn't qualify for anything as we had literally sold our flat a month before my DH lost his job so it was either lose all of our deposit or make it work with me pumping and working until we could. If we had qualified there is a fairly decent contribution. Baby box with pretty much all needs for 1st year, £642 payment before baby born, £18 every 4 weeks when pregnant, then £36 every 4 weeks until baby is 1. It's now a prepaid card so allows the parent to have the choice of what milk they want to use rather than you are low income so need NHS milk.

Also I gave birth abroad and had an IBCLC in hospital, visited me about 8 times over the 2 days and my youngest just would not latch. I've bf successfully before so knew what to do and had ample support but it wasn't an option for us. I don't feel any regret over the situation at all, we gave it a good go.

MotherOfHouseplants · 22/01/2023 18:03

inpixiehollow · 22/01/2023 17:26

This is an interesting point but most of these formula companies are absolute giants like Nestle/Danone etc so I actually don't have much sympathy for them losing money though the implications for their employees would definitely be something to consider theoretically.

We are talking about companies who literally invented a brand new, totally unnecessary product (in the form of follow-on milk) in order to have something that they can legally advertise and establish their brand. If they can no longer manufacture first milk they will find other ways. They will sponsor ‘breastfeeding consultants’ to go in maternity wards and baby groups in pseudo scrubs covered in their logo, just like the Bounty ladies.

TiddleyWink · 22/01/2023 18:03

roarfeckingroarr · 22/01/2023 16:01

It's not the government's job to do this.

We should have much better support for breastfeeding. It's free and it's the best option for your baby's health.

It’s only ‘free’ if you place zero value on a woman’s labour. Which, sadly, lots of people do.

Views on breastfeeding and formula feeding in this country are so messed up, it’s just used as yet another tool to bully and control women. Often by other women which is the most messed up part of all ☹️

CalpolDependant · 22/01/2023 18:03

I had to FF my (now 7mo) daughter because of a crash C that went horribly wrong. I was in labour for over 100 hours and then in theatre for over 5. She almost died and then I almost died when my placenta ruptured.

I didn’t get to hold my daughter for 6 hours. Missed her birth. Missed the golden hour. Missed that initial skin to skin. Didn’t even get to go to the shitty postnatal ward with all the other mums.

My colostrum came in on day 5 and my milk proper on around day 9. Meanwhile I formula fed, and eventually I pumped and combi fed. It wasn’t a choice, it was horrific. I felt like a total failure. But I’ve never been too angry at the price of formula. Gotta feed my kid.

inpixiehollow · 22/01/2023 18:02

MajorCarolDanvers · 22/01/2023 17:44

It is not the job of the tax payer to pay for baby food.

Sold at cost price. Not free.

OP posts:
CecilyP · 22/01/2023 18:00

TeaAndStrumpets · 22/01/2023 17:24

In the war National Dried Milk was introduced to enable mothers to go back to work. In the 1950s and 60s it was available at baby clinics ( I assume cheap or free) I remember going with my mum to get the tins. We also got cod liver oil and very concentrated orange juice.

I looked up National Dried Milk. Apparently it was discontinued in the 70s because people preferred other types of formula. I wonder if it was reintroduced now would it be popular?

You’re right National Dried was introduced in 1940. Its production was put out to tender by the government. It couldn’t be reintroduced in the same form because it wasn’t modified like modern formulas. However a similar scheme could be introduced, though I can’t see a political will to to so. Governments prefer to give vouchers to low income families. It also reduced in popularity as mothers increasingly preferred to use branded products believing them to be superior.

Twizbe · 22/01/2023 17:58

@inpixiehollow I've just finished it. I knew some of it but not the full detail of what went on.

Ive also just qualified as a breastfeeding peer supporter and know how little support there is for women who WANT to breastfeed. There's so many myths and misinformation out there, all aimed at undermining confidence and making women feel that they've done something wrong.

inpixiehollow · 22/01/2023 17:57

User98866 · 22/01/2023 17:48

Feeding babies should be taken out of the hands of large corporations. They can’t be trusted. They are disgusting, immoral and haven’t cleaned up their act since the 80s at all. Takes a bit of interest in the subject and digging but people would be shocked at what’s goes on. I would love to see a very cheap or free National formula milk. Even with the healthy start vouchers families have been struggling with the cost of formula for years (there was a government report on it not that long ago linked below). I dread to even think of what’s going on now. Watering down milk and staring cows milk and solids super early I would imagine.
www.infantfeedingappg.uk/wp-content/uploads/2018/11/APPGIFI-Inquiry-Report-cost-of-infant-formula.pdf

I absolutely agree with you. I have sadly read articles and reports from parents who have watered down formula milk to make a tin last longer :( i feel buying food is easier (shop at cheaper shops, food banks, community pantries to budget for very inexpensive meals where you can) but with formula people can't make it home, have limited choices and I know my local food bank doesn't accept donations of baby milk

OP posts:
Twizbe · 22/01/2023 17:56

@BadNomad I'm a mother of a CMPA child.

Did you know that the formula companies are spending a lot of money to convince parents that their babies have CMPA? A tin of specialist formula cost £35! That's a nice bit of profit if they can get the NHS to buy more. I'm thankful I had a great dietician who supported me continuing to breastfeed alongside the special formula. Other parents aren't so lucky. I've met many woman who've been told they cannot breastfeed a CMPA - not true.

The thickened formula is just marketing there's no real scientific evidence it helps, hence why not all formula is as thick.

Soya formula shouldn't be given to newborns without proper medical advice. We're mammals and need to feed our babies with animal milk.

Anything that is proven to be of benefit to babies is required by law to be in a first infant milk. Anything else they add is just for marketing.

inpixiehollow · 22/01/2023 17:53

Twizbe · 22/01/2023 17:36

Yes!

Have a read of a book called why the politics of breastfeeding matter. It's a real eye opener into the down right horrific practices of infant milk manufacturers.

A plain tin, cost priced, complete formula should be available.

That combined with proper support for mothers to breastfeed.

I also read this book, the details are a little foggy as admittedly it was a while ago but it was very interesting and glad you understood exactly what I'm asking for!

OP posts:
User98866 · 22/01/2023 17:53

Also next big scandal will be allergy milks. NHS prescriptions went up by something like 600% in a few years. They release these into the market often with absolutely no clinical data to back up claims. Formula companies have been the main driver in ‘education’ on CMPA. See this great deep dive by Dr Helen Crawley who is such a champion for good infant feeding practices. If you have half hour to spare.

Mamoun · 22/01/2023 17:50

Breastfed and agree 100%.
Also breastfeeding isn't free: breastpads, nipple cream, feeding yourself extra, potential pump and other material.

whataboutsecondbreakfast · 22/01/2023 17:48

Formula is therefore an additional expense that these women have due to a medical condition/disability.

I don't see it as an additional expense. I see it as something every family should expect to budget for - the same way they budget for nappies, childcare or clothes.

If you can (and want to) breastfeed instead then great, you save some money. In the same way people save money by getting hand me downs, or having childcare provided by family, or having children who are lucky enough to toilet train at two instead of six etc.

Feeding your child is something that should be budgeted for from birth.