Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think formula feeding parents are bent over a barrel?

283 replies

inpixiehollow · 22/01/2023 15:57

Just been discussing this with a friend and interested to know peoples thoughts.
Am I being unreasonable to think that the NHS/govt should manufacture a nutritionally complete formula for babies, sold at cost price to families? Not disputing the importance of real access to proper breastfeeding support but we have to acknowledge that some women cannot/don't want to breastfeed and instead are victim to formula companies turning over huge profits. If people want fancy formulas/special additives then the option should be there but with rising cost of living I don't think its acceptable that something so necessary for many babies is getting to the point of unaffordable.
I am a massive advocate for breastfeeding so please don't take this as an attack or downplaying the massive lack of help for bf in the UK, I just wish both options were made more accessible for whatever feeding choices people make.

OP posts:
Twizbe · 22/01/2023 18:43

@Cuppasoupmonster I went to check the source.

This was a study by 2 Australian economists. They estimated the value of breastfeeding as an estimate of a nation's capital assets.

They calculated that the capitalised value of breastfeeding was around A$37 billion. That's comparable with the value of a huge telecoms company. It exceeded the value of livestock and plantation forests.

If women were supported to practice optimal breastfeeding then the value would be A$100 billion.

Sadly governments in general don't value women's time.

SleepingStandingUp · 22/01/2023 18:43

roarfeckingroarr · 22/01/2023 16:01

It's not the government's job to do this.

We should have much better support for breastfeeding. It's free and it's the best option for your baby's health.

And yet @roarfeckingroarr with all the support you get with twins (loads, pre covid!) Inc a midwife physically manhandling my breasts) my milk just didn't come in so I had to buy formula. I don't think hospital would have been happy me saying oh its fine, I'm sure they can go a few days without food until my milk comes in!! In the end I managed to express and feed them for a few weeks then dried up. With DS and emergency c sec at 35 weeks I had similar issues but didn't need to actually feed him for weeks as he was ill so had time to work on in in hospital and build up

Scottishskifun · 22/01/2023 18:42

I get what your trying to say OP and the sad state of affairs isbaby banks do exist for the bare essentiado.there are alot of schemes to help lower income families with the cost child benefit, healthy start grants and charities.

I bf both of mine the first was a struggle as tongue tie, neonatal stay etc but I did get much more feeding support because of these factors.
For me it's saved a lot of money and a £15 hakaa is all I have used with the second one. I generally find bf support groups very helpful and someone is always willing to lend a pump etc outif needed

Starlightstarbright1 · 22/01/2023 18:39

I do wonder if the people replying supporting the idea are still in the baby stage.

I have a teen Ds to feed. I would love to buy him a tub of formula for the week. He is in a medium men's clothes i would love to buy baby clothes and a size 9 mens trainers.

I really don't get this idea babies should be free.

MadameDe · 22/01/2023 18:36

There are so many issues at the moment I think subsidised formula will be the last thing on the government's mind. If the baby / mother has real issues it is possible for it to be prescribed (in cases where baby isn't gaining weight). Otherwise, I do think buy it or breast feed.

mumasore · 22/01/2023 18:36

@Twizbe and this is part of the problem!

Information on how to breastfeed can be found on Google...

Point is new mums are scared and vulnerable and need support for things like this

Poppingmad123 · 22/01/2023 18:34

I wish there was better support, education & promotion of breast milk & feeding so more people choose/try to bf & its a normalised thing. I understand not everyone can produce breast milk, no matter how hard they try but everyone should be taught about it before baby is born & be supported properly after the baby is born, ideally in hospital for a few days & be on the nhs. It only needs to be done for the first baby too. If a mother is able to do it with that help for the first born, she’s likely to continue for the next baby & so on. Having a baby should be nurtured & time allowed for that bonding & families should also be taught to be supportive of bf, sadly so many aren’t! So if bf became the norm, ff companies wouldn’t be profiting so much, demand would decline & prices would drop.

Testina · 22/01/2023 18:31

MotherOfHouseplants · 22/01/2023 18:20

Own brand is cheaper. Aldi first milk is £8.59 for 900g.

Yes, like I said - I didn’t even have to look for the cheapest! And yet the first one I found was easily covered by Child Benefit.
So the government is already paying to feed all babies where income is <£50K or even almost £100K for some couples.

As a tax payer: no, I don’t want to buy your formula (or your breast pads: this isn’t about feeding choices) because (a) you should pay it yourself and (b) your CB is covering it anyway 🤷🏻‍♀️

Whatwhatwhatnow · 22/01/2023 18:29

inpixiehollow · 22/01/2023 16:04

yeah we should have much better support but as a country we're pretty poor at it and I know it won't be improving in my local area at least due to budget cuts. This also doesn't take into account that some women cannot or do not want to bf, why should they be penalised?

If someone doesn't want to do it, then it's their choice. There are plenty of things I'd like to choose not to do but financially I have to. I don't see why the government should support them.

I have a lot more sympathy for people who cannot breastfeed but at the end of the day we all have to buy food that is sold for profit.

Namechangeforthis6 · 22/01/2023 18:28

UWhatNow · 22/01/2023 16:10

I’m just wondering where it ends though? We’ve already got schools feeding children free in the early years, free breakfast and holiday lunch clubs. Does the British taxpayer really have to take over feeding children from birth? Where is the parental responsibility in this?

I'd rather feed babies with my tax money than subsidise mp's luxury food expenses

BubziOwl · 22/01/2023 18:28

GodspeedJune · 22/01/2023 16:32

No I don’t think it needs to be provided at cost, unless the breastfeeding associated costs are going to be subsidised also?

Decent breast pads are £6-7 a box. Then there’s nursing bras, nursing clothes etc. I enjoy breastfeeding but it isn’t free. There are societal benefits on a population level in reduced illness in children with breastfeeding too.

I don't think it's totally comparable... I never once owned a nursing bra or specific nursing clothes, and I have whacking great big boobs. Well-chosen normal clothes and bras worked just fine.

They're nice to have maybe, but they're not essential, whereas if you're formula feeding then formula is obviously pretty essential.

Anyway, to the poster upthread who said maybe we should have profit-free food too... it's an un-ironic yes from me Grin

mummyh2016 · 22/01/2023 18:26

Honestly? It will cost you more than £12 a week or however much a tub of formula is costing to feed your baby once they're weaned. And I say this as someone who has just done 12 months of formula feeding. Those on low incomes/claim certain benefits get milk vouchers anyway.

Emmamoo89 · 22/01/2023 18:21

BIahBIahBIah · 22/01/2023 16:08

I'd like free nursing bras and nursing pillows and nursing tops, etc. Thanks.

And breast pads and shit tonne of food

whataboutsecondbreakfast · 22/01/2023 18:21

YippieKayakOtherBuckets · 22/01/2023 18:16

It’s clear that very few people on this thread have much experience working with families on very low incomes.

Absolutely anything which is visibly ‘NHS’ or distinctively aimed at very poor people very quickly develops a stigma. It’s part of the reason why National Milk was discontinued in the 70s. I work in schools and we have terrible trouble getting eligible parents to register for free school meals. The major benefit of universal FSM in infants, and of cashless catering systems in secondary schools, is that they remove any visible sign that a child receives FSM and uptake rises accordingly.

Thinking off the top of my head of half a dozen families that I work with, all would be very very reluctant to buy a generic ‘government’ milk. I am pretty sure that all of them would prefer the current system of Healthy Start vouchers to buy commercially available milk with a bit of dignity.

I think this is really valid.

There's similar stigma in America around food stamps. People don't want to buy the government subsidised versions of anything.

MissWings · 22/01/2023 18:21

I see what you are saying. Aldi does a reasonable formula though in terms of price.

I could have been given all of the education and support in the world regarding breastfeeding (and I am not a stupid person) but I still would have chosen formula over breast every single time, and I did for all three. I’m just grateful I had the choice.

MotherOfHouseplants · 22/01/2023 18:20

Testina · 22/01/2023 18:18

I’ve not even looked for the cheapest option. And I’m pretty sure that Cow & Gate from Boots isn’t it!
So the largest feeding amount there is 5 feeds of 7 scoops at 4.5kg each - so 158g a week. That 800g carton for £10 will last 5 days.

So: the government already pays enough Child Benefit to feed a baby.

Own brand is cheaper. Aldi first milk is £8.59 for 900g.

Hevasparkle · 22/01/2023 18:20

Yes formula costs too much and I do feel something ought to be done to subsidise it.
with my first I spent £1000s trying to BF, private lactation consultants, private tongue tie division then many double electric pumps in an attempt to exclusively express.
about 4 months in I gave up as I was miserable and constantly attached to the pump. I was horrified at the cost of formula , especially the ready made stuff which sometimes there was no choice but use if we were out and about.

was so relieved when my second latched at birth (luckily still had my pump for when needed, but wasn’t “free” either)

Testina · 22/01/2023 18:19

Forgot the photo!

To think formula feeding parents are bent over a barrel?
Twizbe · 22/01/2023 18:18

mumasore · 22/01/2023 18:15

Yes and I'd really like to see help from midwives from birth about making up bottles and storing bottles and sterilising etc.
we were sent home as young first time parents with just a warning from our midwife of make sure you do the formula properly or it could kill him!

Even a quick option session would be great same as loads of sessions in antenatal on breastfeeding

All the information about making up feeds is on the tin.

Testina · 22/01/2023 18:18

I’ve not even looked for the cheapest option. And I’m pretty sure that Cow & Gate from Boots isn’t it!
So the largest feeding amount there is 5 feeds of 7 scoops at 4.5kg each - so 158g a week. That 800g carton for £10 will last 5 days.

So: the government already pays enough Child Benefit to feed a baby.

YippieKayakOtherBuckets · 22/01/2023 18:16

It’s clear that very few people on this thread have much experience working with families on very low incomes.

Absolutely anything which is visibly ‘NHS’ or distinctively aimed at very poor people very quickly develops a stigma. It’s part of the reason why National Milk was discontinued in the 70s. I work in schools and we have terrible trouble getting eligible parents to register for free school meals. The major benefit of universal FSM in infants, and of cashless catering systems in secondary schools, is that they remove any visible sign that a child receives FSM and uptake rises accordingly.

Thinking off the top of my head of half a dozen families that I work with, all would be very very reluctant to buy a generic ‘government’ milk. I am pretty sure that all of them would prefer the current system of Healthy Start vouchers to buy commercially available milk with a bit of dignity.

mumasore · 22/01/2023 18:15

Yes and I'd really like to see help from midwives from birth about making up bottles and storing bottles and sterilising etc.
we were sent home as young first time parents with just a warning from our midwife of make sure you do the formula properly or it could kill him!

Even a quick option session would be great same as loads of sessions in antenatal on breastfeeding

Twizbe · 22/01/2023 18:13

@Cuppasoupmonster I'd need to go and check the figure but I think it was something like A$100 million.

There's a few because it is country dependant.

mistermagpie · 22/01/2023 18:13

"It’s only ‘free’ if you place zero value on a woman’s labour. Which, sadly, lots of people do.

Views on breastfeeding and formula feeding in this country are so messed up, it’s just used as yet another tool to bully and control women. Often by other women which is the most messed up part of all ☹️"

Couldn't agree more with this. I formula fed three babies (won't bore anyone with the story, but couldn't with the first, didn't want to with the second and managed about 6 weeks with the third but breastfeeding is just not for me) and I'm not really sure what the answer is. Yes, formula is expensive but formula feeding is, in many many ways, easier than breastfeeding. People like to say that breastfeeding is so straightforward but for lots of people it isn't, and the 'doing' of it is all on one person. Everyone says 'oh just make a nest on the sofa and watch a box set' for the cluster feeding nightmare days - but people with multiple kids or other responsibilities can't do that. Breastfeeding is hard logistically, mentally and physically for lots of women.

So I don't think it's as easy as saying 'formula feeding is expensive and breastfeeding is free' because it's not a straight choice between the two anyway.

I do think formula is 'too' expensive though, and there simply aren't enough budget options like there are with, say, nappies and clothes and other baby stuff. And even if there was 'Tesco value' baby milk - nobody is going to want to buy that or be seen buying it are they?

MrsMiddleMother · 22/01/2023 18:12

I understand where you're coming from op but I disagree. Child benefit and healthy start vouchers and in place to ensure poor parents can feed their babies, most women can choose to breastfeed or FF but with formula comes the cosy. It doesn't really matter if companies profit or not, people need to be able to feed their child and if they can't do that they rt shouldn't be having children. Circumstances change of course, which is why the above is in place.

I breastfed for only 8 weeks before stopping due to postnatal depression and switched to Formula. Whilst pregnant I found lots of great information and tips about breastfeeding because I looked for it, which is what all parents to be should do, noone should do it for them. I struggled around the 4 week mark and contacted my health visitor, again which every mother should if they need support.
I think that parents need to hold more responsibility.

Swipe left for the next trending thread