Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think formula feeding parents are bent over a barrel?

283 replies

inpixiehollow · 22/01/2023 15:57

Just been discussing this with a friend and interested to know peoples thoughts.
Am I being unreasonable to think that the NHS/govt should manufacture a nutritionally complete formula for babies, sold at cost price to families? Not disputing the importance of real access to proper breastfeeding support but we have to acknowledge that some women cannot/don't want to breastfeed and instead are victim to formula companies turning over huge profits. If people want fancy formulas/special additives then the option should be there but with rising cost of living I don't think its acceptable that something so necessary for many babies is getting to the point of unaffordable.
I am a massive advocate for breastfeeding so please don't take this as an attack or downplaying the massive lack of help for bf in the UK, I just wish both options were made more accessible for whatever feeding choices people make.

OP posts:
inpixiehollow · 22/01/2023 16:35

GodspeedJune · 22/01/2023 16:32

No I don’t think it needs to be provided at cost, unless the breastfeeding associated costs are going to be subsidised also?

Decent breast pads are £6-7 a box. Then there’s nursing bras, nursing clothes etc. I enjoy breastfeeding but it isn’t free. There are societal benefits on a population level in reduced illness in children with breastfeeding too.

The govt could save a hell of a lot of money on NHS services by investing in proper bf support, reducing occurrence of illness in mothers & children. Sadly though they choose not to invest and we have one of the poorest bf rates in the world. They do get a nice big chunk of those formula company's money though by taxing them so they of course will favour that option.

OP posts:
Cuppasoupmonster · 22/01/2023 16:34

mumoffourminimes · 22/01/2023 16:18

It's a good idea, making formula more accessible for those that need/want it but also removing the incentives for big companies (making huge profits) to advertise formula and push formula/undermine breastfeeding. The public health impact could be huge and positive.

Disclaimer before the rant, I breastfed for 8 months with the odd bottle of formula and then FF from 8-12 months. So, anyone who think I have a weird projection going on because I don’t agree with them can stop right there Smile

I don’t think formula ‘undermines breastfeeding’, it has saved many many many more lives than it has damaged. It is already illegal to advertise formula for use before the age of 1. How can you ‘undermine breastfeeding’ anyway? It doesn’t have feelings, it isn’t a person Confused

The fact is breastfeeding, while it has a small benefit which means it’s the NHS encouraged method, simply doesn’t have the incredible properties that mean it is worth spending £££ promoting it. There is zero noticeable difference between a breastfed child and non-breastfed child, you can only see the effect if you look at hundreds of thousands of children. And even then it doesn’t protect completely against any
one thing.

I think mumsnet has a strange cognitive dissonance in which it believe in freedom of feeding choice on paper but in reality wants formula to be a dirty word, hidden from view in case it ‘undermines breastfeeding’. If you trust women to make the right decision for them, then they should have the information on both methods (with stats, not just talk of ‘amazing health benefits’ which turn out to be a slightly lesser chance of an ear infection).

I also once saw a poster on here who genuinely believed her child didn’t need the MMR as she was breastfeeding and ‘I had measles therefore
my child will be immune through my milk’. When another poster pointed out the measles antibodies have no effect after the first 2-3 months of feeding the poster never came back to the thread 😬

IDontCareMatthew · 22/01/2023 16:33

rainyskylight · 22/01/2023 16:18

And cot manufacturers should sell cots at cost. And nappies should be sold at cost. Etc etc.

Having a child costs money.

Yes so think it through first!

user432900976 · 22/01/2023 16:33

No. Breastfeeding is already damaged by politics. There are certain rules regarding the sale of formula to overcome this.

GodspeedJune · 22/01/2023 16:32

No I don’t think it needs to be provided at cost, unless the breastfeeding associated costs are going to be subsidised also?

Decent breast pads are £6-7 a box. Then there’s nursing bras, nursing clothes etc. I enjoy breastfeeding but it isn’t free. There are societal benefits on a population level in reduced illness in children with breastfeeding too.

MrsRinaDecker · 22/01/2023 16:32

I think maybe just tighter rules on how much companies can charge for it or restrictions on price increases? So only in line with the consumer price index or some such? Otherwise, I think it’s something parents need to factor in when planning a family. Plus as others have said, there are already healthy start vouchers for those on low incomes.

IDontCareMatthew · 22/01/2023 16:32

Survey99 · 22/01/2023 16:07

The government already supports low income parents, why is infant formula, which is much much cheaper than feeding a growing teen, any different?

Got to agree!

If you are falling at the first hurdle in your kids life I kind of wonder how anyone could think they could afford one in the first place

inpixiehollow · 22/01/2023 16:31

Just to reiterate I did state sold at cost price, not supplied for free (unless of course families are using vouchers they are entitled to). Lets not beat around the bush, the Govt takes some of the big formula company's money in taxes so it absolutely benefits them to keep people buying formula and turning over a company's profits.

OP posts:
Overthebow · 22/01/2023 16:30

mumoffourminimes · 22/01/2023 16:20

Centrally manufacturing and selling at cost price I mean. Making it free (paid for by taxes) I think is a non starter in the current climate.

And of course BF is in no way free and it (in most family circumstances) involves the mother losing ability to earn an income.

How does bf make the mother lose the ability to earn an income in most cases? Absolutely no one I know who breastfed lost an income because of bf. They’re all still employed and earning money. No difference my ff friends. I guess if you make it an issue maybe…

mumoffourminimes · 22/01/2023 16:28

@inpixiehollow and the same for all NHS drugs

SouthLondonMum22 · 22/01/2023 16:28

It could definitely be a way for formula companies to not profit so much and/or claim that their formula is best because of x, y & z.

I wouldn't want it on prescription though, even if it would be free for the year. It sounds difficult enough for those with babies who have allergies, I don't trust that it would work with all families who use formula.

sanityisamyth · 22/01/2023 16:28

roarfeckingroarr · 22/01/2023 16:01

It's not the government's job to do this.

We should have much better support for breastfeeding. It's free and it's the best option for your baby's health.

This.

Survey99 · 22/01/2023 16:27

inpixiehollow · 22/01/2023 16:14

Please understand my post.. I didn't say free formula provided by the government. I said formula manufactured by and then sold to parents for a cost price, removing massive profits most companies get to make on something essential for some families.

Why not extend to the government manufacturing and providing profit free food to all children under 18? 🤔

Having children is a choice and when you make that choice you are responsibile for them and the associated costs.

Cuppasoupmonster · 22/01/2023 16:25

roarfeckingroarr · 22/01/2023 16:01

It's not the government's job to do this.

We should have much better support for breastfeeding. It's free and it's the best option for your baby's health.

Why? As OP said some women don’t want to. Do you also think it isn’t the government’s job to provide free school meals, or healthy start vouchers etc?

LottoLaura · 22/01/2023 16:25

mumoffourminimes · 22/01/2023 16:20

Centrally manufacturing and selling at cost price I mean. Making it free (paid for by taxes) I think is a non starter in the current climate.

And of course BF is in no way free and it (in most family circumstances) involves the mother losing ability to earn an income.

How does BF mean a mother loses the ability to earn an income?

Ive seen some tosh on her before but this is something else!

VioletaDelValle · 22/01/2023 16:25

People choose to have children knowing that they have a responsibility to feed them and that’s pretty much the most basic responsibility a parent can have

FF is still feeding your child 🙄

UWhatNow · 22/01/2023 16:23

rainyskylight · 22/01/2023 16:18

And cot manufacturers should sell cots at cost. And nappies should be sold at cost. Etc etc.

Having a child costs money.

Exactly! And that’s the cheap end of parenting… wait until all their friends start wearing £300 North Face puffa jackets and £100 Airforce trainers…

inpixiehollow · 22/01/2023 16:22

rainyskylight · 22/01/2023 16:18

And cot manufacturers should sell cots at cost. And nappies should be sold at cost. Etc etc.

Having a child costs money.

If you can't afford a cot you can buy one secondhand, get one from friends/family. Buy one on credit and repay etc etc. Its not an ongoing, absolutely necessary cost like formula is for some families.

OP posts:
JustWantedACat · 22/01/2023 16:22

JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 22/01/2023 16:16

Sometimes it isn't a choice though... my milk never came in so I had no milk. If I didn't use formula my baby would have starved.

Not being able to breast feed my baby was horrendous. I was devastated. And then the absolute kick in the teeth was the extortionate cost of the baby milk formula.

And as for the awful woman on the till in Sainsbury's who delighted in telling me that I'd got X amount of nectar points for my food, but obviously none for the formula as I should be breastfeeding... she's very lucky to be still breathing.

Wow she really said that! In my case my reply would be "well you can't breastfeed if you have no fffing breasts from cancer!"

FuckoffeeBeforeCoffee · 22/01/2023 16:22

JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 22/01/2023 16:16

Sometimes it isn't a choice though... my milk never came in so I had no milk. If I didn't use formula my baby would have starved.

Not being able to breast feed my baby was horrendous. I was devastated. And then the absolute kick in the teeth was the extortionate cost of the baby milk formula.

And as for the awful woman on the till in Sainsbury's who delighted in telling me that I'd got X amount of nectar points for my food, but obviously none for the formula as I should be breastfeeding... she's very lucky to be still breathing.

That's shocking. I think I'd have lost it.

mumoffourminimes · 22/01/2023 16:20

Centrally manufacturing and selling at cost price I mean. Making it free (paid for by taxes) I think is a non starter in the current climate.

And of course BF is in no way free and it (in most family circumstances) involves the mother losing ability to earn an income.

Maray1967 · 22/01/2023 16:20

roarfeckingroarr · 22/01/2023 16:01

It's not the government's job to do this.

We should have much better support for breastfeeding. It's free and it's the best option for your baby's health.

Tell that to my son - who not one single midwife in Liverpool Womens could get to properly breastfeed.
Thank God I had a sensible community midwife who told me he was doing what her second child had done (she bf her first and third) and to bottle feed him.
Option 1 - accept that bf will be extremely difficult, express what you can but generally get on with ff as well as you can. Outcome - happy baby and mum, and very healthy 23 year old in the future.
Option 2 - as some folks I know went for: determination to bf if it almost kills you, stressed out mum and baby- and guess what - no discernible health advantages, so it would appear, judging by how often their kids are ill.

Yes, OP - there should be support for formula feeding. It should not be refused out of some weird view that to do so gives people an easy way out of bf. I fully intended to bf - had no bottles etc in the house. My son had other ideas - and any ‘support’ I was likely to have received could have made him quite ill. mw made it clear that if I battled on trying to bf with him screaming and pulling away and refusing to even attempt to latch (he never rooted) he would lose weight and become ill.
No bloody way was I doing that.
My two are walking adverts for Cow & Gate - hardly ever ill. Do I regret not battling on? Not at all.
Eat healthily in pregnancy and wean healthily. The months in between? Either way is fine.

LottoLaura · 22/01/2023 16:20

It would be better for it to be available on prescription for those who can’t BF.

As it’s free for the first year post birth.

rainyskylight · 22/01/2023 16:18

And cot manufacturers should sell cots at cost. And nappies should be sold at cost. Etc etc.

Having a child costs money.

loveisanopensore · 22/01/2023 16:18

I think it should be sold at cost. The majority of the cost is going into marketing and advertising.

www.who.int/news/item/28-04-2022-who-reveals-shocking-extent-of-exploitative-formula-milk-marketing