Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell DH his mother has cancer?

109 replies

Richvanilla · 22/01/2023 15:23

Name changed for this.

Backstory is that my husband works away for 4 months at a time and is currently halfway through his current trip (i.e. has another 8 weeks to go).

MIL called me yesterday to tell me she has been diagnosed with breast cancer but it has been caught very early and all being well she will have surgery to remove it and that will be it over.

She has asked me not to tell DH (her son) as it is hard enough for him working away for such long periods without adding in the stress of this too.

I don't know how I feel about keeping this "secret" from him but also, it's not my secret to tell. I feel like I can't win either way. If I tell him then MIL will be annoyed and if I don't then DH will be annoyed that I didn't tell him (at least I think he would be... Or maybe he would agree I was right not to tell him as she asked me not too).

Everyone else knows, his brothers, his cousins etc so he will be the only one who hasn't been told.

I have no idea what to do... Any advice gratefully received!

OP posts:
Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 22/01/2023 16:38

I think it was wrong of her to put you in this position, but maybe she needed to share the information with you so she could talk about it. A cancer diagnosis of any kind is scary, so I kind of understand where she is coming from. I don’t want to be unkind but I also think she’s over simplifying. Cancer is not straightforward and hopefully all will be well and go to plan, but there are no guarantees and while I really don’t think it’s your responsibility to tell your DH if she’s asked you not to, I would have a chat with her and explain that she’s put you in a very difficult and uncomfortable position. Tell her you can’t win no matter what you do and that given the seriousness of a diagnosis like this you really don’t think you can keep it from DH. Give her the opportunity to either agree to tell him herself a soon as she can or tell her you will, whether she agrees or not. Just out of interest - did she tell you first and then ask you not to say anything, or did she ask you to agree to keep quiet before telling you ? Either way is not on, but blurting it out and then asking you not to say anything is really unfair as she didn’t give you a chance to say you don’t want to know if you have to keep it a secret from DH.

OhMyGodnessyMe · 22/01/2023 16:36

If she didn't want him to know it seems daft to have told Op!

MIL may have had to account for being out of action and in hospital for surgery.

I think if this had been more serious and terminal, with a very poor prognosis, his mother should have told him, but as it's relatively minor and likely to be a day in hospital for a lumpectomy, there is no point worryinghim IF THAT IS HER WISH.

This reminds me of families who argue over their loved ones funerals. The person who died expresses 'unpopular' wishes for their funeral and some family member isn't happy and wants to do it all 'their way'.

FarFromObvious · 22/01/2023 16:35

You need to respect the wishes of the person with cancer. Whether you like it or not. Anything else is disrespectful.

I am surprised that so many people’s relationships would not survive a secret like this being kept. Breaking someone’s confidentiality without an urgent need to do so, is just awful.

RenoNovice2023 · 22/01/2023 16:34

It’s not about OP. Her MIL has asked her not to tell her son for very obvious reasons. Respect that otherwise if things get worse she will never tell you again. Or anything else for that matter. He’ll know in 8 weeks when he is home. Stop thinking the worst and be positive. It can be sorted just like the op says. Just think it’s not bad as being told you are terminally Ill with weeks left to live. I know you might be shocked but extended family support will help you all. Just don’t worry someone who can’t help, can’t get home, and will fret unnecessarily about a mum who will probably be over the worst inn8 weeks time.

diddl · 22/01/2023 16:32

Is it likely that anyone else will tell him?

If she didn't want him to know it seems daft to have told Op!

Surely MIL could have told them both in 8wks time!

OhMyGodnessyMe · 22/01/2023 16:31

KangarooKenny · 22/01/2023 16:25

I’d say he has a right to know, everyone else already knows.

But it's not about what you think is right is it?

It's not your body. It's nothing to do with 'rights'.

It's what his mum wants.

And if he 's not on the phone or in touch with his siblings, he won't know anyway.

His mum is coming at this from a sense of care.

My own mum has sometimes not told me about her illnesses until after the event , for the same reason- to spare me worry when being long-distance and unable to do anything about it.

People make decisions and choices that may seem perverse but as she is dealing with cancer, the very least is for her DIL to do as she asks.

neighboursmustliveon · 22/01/2023 16:29

We occasionally have this from fil about fil health and not telling sil who lives about 2 hours away. We usually listen to her, but have on occasion ignored her when we feel sil should know the current status.

In this case I would listen to your mil and wait to see how how news progresses over the coming weeks.

OhMyGodnessyMe · 22/01/2023 16:27

PayPennies · 22/01/2023 15:42

I would feel patronised, betrayed, infantilised and deceived by my spouse and fuck would I ever forgive that.

How ridiculous.

Its HIS mother's wishes.

It's not the OP who is deceiving him.

She has been asked to keep a secret so it won't affect his focus on his work away.

OhMyGodnessyMe · 22/01/2023 16:26

Pretty straightforward .

She has asked you to keep it confidential, so that's what you do.

Your own feelings are not the point here.

Other comments imploring you to tell him are really unfair.

If she'd told you and wanted him to know, fair enough.

But that's not what she wants.

Her wishes at this dreadful time for her trump yours.

KangarooKenny · 22/01/2023 16:25

I’d say he has a right to know, everyone else already knows.

NumberTheory · 22/01/2023 16:23

RenoNovice2023 · 22/01/2023 16:09

Completely agree with this too. This is why I never tell anyone anything as people can’t keep anything to themselves when asked. Your OH can’t do anything whilst away. He can be told when the time is right, especially as it can be dealt with before he gets home. There are many people you can speak to about your worries and concerns. Just don’t place them on someone who can’t help and will worry unnecessarily. If you do this you will be in a much better place to help and support them afterwards.

OP’s primary concern may not be (I would argue should not be) supporting MiL. Her primary concern is her relationship with her DH. And for many couples openness is a big part of creating and maintaining a strong relationship, especially when there is distance involved.

The issue for OP isn’t in needing someone to talk to about what MiL has told her. It’s her making sure her DH feels he can always rely on her.

category12 · 22/01/2023 16:23

I'd respect her wishes.

If he's military, maybe it's worth getting advice from them about how best to manage news of this sort? They'd be the experts.

But overall I'd go with her preference.

Lenald · 22/01/2023 16:21

RenoNovice2023 · 22/01/2023 16:19

Really? I suspect anyone not telling a partner/husband had a very long thought process about this and the fact it is curable would make an easy decision for someone working away. It’s not about you. It’s about the person diagnosed who will be told you don’t know. Be grateful it’s not terminal and you didn’t know until afterwards.

A DH is not a child needing to be protected.

I stand by opinion whole heartedly - keeping this from me is not something I would thank anyone for. I would be getting a divorce, or it would least have a serious detrimental affect on our marriage/relationship.

GolfEchoRomeoTangoIndia · 22/01/2023 16:21

Give her a few more days to get her head round the situation herself, then ring her to ask how she's doing and also ask her permission to tell DH.

Explain to her that he's said he would like to be told bad news in other circumstances and that he's a sensible adult who will understand that this is bad but not disastrous news, that he'd like to be able to chat to his mum and offer moral support and he'd probably be upset to have it kept from him.

RenoNovice2023 · 22/01/2023 16:19

Lenald · 22/01/2023 16:12

I would end things with my husband if he kept the fact my Mother had cancer from me.

Not telling him is an insane suggestion imo.

I would have a chat to MIL and say I’m so sorry, but I can’t keep this from him and I would like to give you the opportunity to tell him first but if you don’t I will have to.

Really? I suspect anyone not telling a partner/husband had a very long thought process about this and the fact it is curable would make an easy decision for someone working away. It’s not about you. It’s about the person diagnosed who will be told you don’t know. Be grateful it’s not terminal and you didn’t know until afterwards.

ManchesterGirl2 · 22/01/2023 16:17

RenoNovice2023 · 22/01/2023 16:09

Completely agree with this too. This is why I never tell anyone anything as people can’t keep anything to themselves when asked. Your OH can’t do anything whilst away. He can be told when the time is right, especially as it can be dealt with before he gets home. There are many people you can speak to about your worries and concerns. Just don’t place them on someone who can’t help and will worry unnecessarily. If you do this you will be in a much better place to help and support them afterwards.

He can't do much to help when he's back either! It's not like he's a surgeon!

Surely, apart from going with them to appointments, and potentially some care tasks if needed, most of what you do for someone with early stage cancer is emotional support. Which can be done through phone calls. And probably he would want to be given the chance to do.

NumberTheory · 22/01/2023 16:17

Hbh17 · 22/01/2023 16:04

Goodness, I'm shocked that people think a woman can't make choices about her own medical information! Moral of the story for me is never to tell anyone if I have a similar diagnosis, then there's no danger of it being passed on without my permission.

Very true - if you want something to be a secret, don’t tell anyone. Once you tell, it’s not just your secret.

Sometimes it’s not a big deal for the person you tell. They won’t have feelings of obligation around the information and other people. So they’ll be happy to follow your wishes because they support you and it’s no cost to them. But in the OP’s situation it clearly is a big deal and it puts her in a really awkward position and jeopardizes her relationship with her husband. It’s not right to expect her to simply follow your wishes when there may be a cost to her.

CohenTree · 22/01/2023 16:16

Do not tell him. He can't do any thing, either about the cancer or in practical terms (hospital visits etc). She doesn't sound in imminent danger of death so all it would do is worry him unnecessarily.

MiddleParking · 22/01/2023 16:15

I assume him coming home is really special to you if he goes away for four months at a time. Is it not going to spoil your next reunion a bit when he has to learn his mum has cancer and you’ve got to either lie to him about having known or tell him you knew all along?

MrsTerryPratchett · 22/01/2023 16:13

Hbh17 · 22/01/2023 16:04

Goodness, I'm shocked that people think a woman can't make choices about her own medical information! Moral of the story for me is never to tell anyone if I have a similar diagnosis, then there's no danger of it being passed on without my permission.

Of course she can. What she can't do is tell everyone and then make decisions about other people's marriages. I won't keep secrets from DH and I would be really annoyed if he knew something about my parents and didn't tell me.

NoSquirrels · 22/01/2023 16:13

There are many people you can speak to about your worries and concerns. Just don’t place them on someone who can’t help and will worry unnecessarily.

OP hasn’t said she’s worried at all, and actually there’s no indication her DH would ‘worry unnecessarily’ and he’s in the same position of helpfulness/helplessness whether he’s away or at home. About the only difference is he can’t give his mum a hug.

I’m sure his mum thinks she’s being sensitive to him, but actually it’s the opposite (unless he’s prone to overreacting).

Lenald · 22/01/2023 16:12

I would end things with my husband if he kept the fact my Mother had cancer from me.

Not telling him is an insane suggestion imo.

I would have a chat to MIL and say I’m so sorry, but I can’t keep this from him and I would like to give you the opportunity to tell him first but if you don’t I will have to.

EpicChaos · 22/01/2023 16:12

Don't tell him, what do you think he can do about it where he currently is? Nothing, is the answer, not a damned thing, except worry himself half to death over it, which will affect his mental health and his work and for what? Something he is powerless to change.
As you said, it's not your secret to tell, prognosis sounds very good, so just leave as is for now.
I hope all goes well for your MIL, it sounds like she has a good, positive mental attitude, which is the best thing to have in that position.

RenoNovice2023 · 22/01/2023 16:09

Hbh17 · 22/01/2023 16:04

Goodness, I'm shocked that people think a woman can't make choices about her own medical information! Moral of the story for me is never to tell anyone if I have a similar diagnosis, then there's no danger of it being passed on without my permission.

Completely agree with this too. This is why I never tell anyone anything as people can’t keep anything to themselves when asked. Your OH can’t do anything whilst away. He can be told when the time is right, especially as it can be dealt with before he gets home. There are many people you can speak to about your worries and concerns. Just don’t place them on someone who can’t help and will worry unnecessarily. If you do this you will be in a much better place to help and support them afterwards.

mathanxiety · 22/01/2023 16:09

I'd tell him, and tell him his mother asked you not to.

I'd tell her what you had done.

It's likely she's chosen this tiny little element of control over the situation because she's shocked and upset over her diagnosis, and I would doubt it's 'very early stage and only needs an operation'.