Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I can't afford a car then?

266 replies

Rakatakatar · 22/01/2023 11:29

I'm self employed, started my own business domestic cleaning 4 months ago. Has been doing really well, just gone up to 3 days a week.

My car is on its last legs, it has MOT due in March but it isn't worth saving as it's a 2006 model with a heap of problems.

I assumed I'd be able to get finance of some form but nope. Nowhere will accept me, being self employed without 6 months proof of earnings is working against me, plus I have bad credit from years ago.

This morning I decided to suck it up and ask my parents for a loan. They said no 🥴

Anyone been in a similar position? What did you do?
I'm worried that if I can't get a car sorted I won't be able to work and then I'll really be screwed.

OP posts:
OhMyGodnessyMe · 22/01/2023 13:41

@Thatboymum I think it's far better to save and buy rather than use credit. You paid £4 K in interest on a loan for £10K.
That's terrible, frankly.
You'd have been better off buying a banger for £1K and saving towards a better car.

I've never, ever had a loan for a car. I saved (even as a student at uni) and bought a banger, saved and upgraded, and have kept on like that for decades.

lapasion · 22/01/2023 13:40

Namechangethisonetime · 22/01/2023 12:33

You buy a cheap second hand car. Plenty about.

There’s actually a huge shortage of second hand cars in the UK at the moment.

Iizzyb · 22/01/2023 13:39

OP just on the UC issue, if you run your business as a limited Co and have separate business account and pay yourself from the business presumably you can keep the extra £ above your "wages" in the business and it wouldn't then affect your UC claim as it wouldn't be "your" money & then the business could contribute to the cost of the car. If you put your car through the business there can be tax advantages too. Whether these will be relevant on 3 days a week, I'm honestly not sure but definitely worth having a look.

If you have a local business adviser somewhere it might be worth asking about this. There are some additional requirements if you have a ltd co - you have to report to companies house every year but it's very minimal when you're a small business & you can buy an "off the shelf company for next to nothing. You & DH can be directors & secretary.

Might be worth looking into? X

OhMyGodnessyMe · 22/01/2023 13:38

DH is currently learning to drive, he is almost at test level. He has better credit than me and has been accepted by a car lender. He can take out the car in his name right? And I can drive it as well as him?

I can't get my head around this. Or rather why you can't see it as an option.
By 'TAKE OUT THE CAR ' surely you mean buy it on credit?

If he can get finance to buy a car, and you are a married couple, why doesn't he just buy the car you need for your new job?

The insurance co don't care who bought the car, just who is driving it.

He can be the registered keeper and you can be the driver.

You need to check the insurance for you alone and him as a named learner driver.

How old are you both? You sound quite young.

Thatboymum · 22/01/2023 13:37

Op try a company called first response finance, they specialise in finance for those who can’t get it easily tho the apr is obviously high, I used them 4 years ago whilst recovering from a poor credit score they gave me a focus st worth 10k and the repayment loan was £16k which wasn’t great but it was affordable for me as a newly self employed beautician I got it and the repayments over 4 years massively helped my credit score climb also wheee I can now thankfully get good finance deals

BIWI · 22/01/2023 13:32

Why not investigate joining a car club?

Itloggedmeoutagain · 22/01/2023 13:29

Rakatakatar · 22/01/2023 11:51

Possible solution. Not sure if anyone here can advise.

DH is currently learning to drive, he is almost at test level. He has better credit than me and has been accepted by a car lender. He can take out the car in his name right? And I can drive it as well as him?

You need to make sure that you are insured on it for business use. Given that he's not passed yet I would assume you'd need to be the main driver. In my area there's quite a wait for tests.
How much would the repayments be? If you lost a couple of clients would you be able to make the repayment?

OhMyGodnessyMe · 22/01/2023 13:24

If you were my DD I'd loan you the money but draw up an agreement whereby you paid it back, properly each month by DD, but without interest.

I did this with my DD who was able to part finance a newer car, but I put £4K towards it and she repaid at £400 a month.

Could your parents do this?

Itloggedmeoutagain · 22/01/2023 13:24

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 22/01/2023 11:59

Yes but they did fix it enough to pass MOT so they can do that again!
Tell them to do that.
Do not buy another car yet. Try and squeeze as many months out of this car as you can.

Last yr the car I had failed first time but this year it passed first time. So you just don't know what will happen. Just tell them you NEED the car to pass

It's not something they make up!

User963 · 22/01/2023 13:22

Not sure how far away
your clients are but
what about a cargo bike or bike plus trailer?

OhMyGodnessyMe · 22/01/2023 13:21

Your only options are to get a cheaper car with a year's MOT- you should be able to get one for £500. Or, depending on where your clients are, cycle, walk or use public transport.

Can't you get clients who live within walking distance?

You'd have to insist they had the cleaning apparatus etc you need.

I had a cleaner years ago who arrived on her bike.

Teateaandmoretea · 22/01/2023 13:21

So DH buys the car in his name then. If he has only just passed his test it will actually look dodgier to an insurance company having you as the main driver and him as the legal keeper, however. As he would be more expensive to insure probably.

Although yes don’t put yourself as the main driver on a car that a kid is driving round miles away, but as a married couple I doubt it matters. I have to think twice which of our cars I’m the main driver on tbh. I drive both, DH drives both. No idea who uses one more than the other and when DH claimed on the one I was the main driver on they didn’t question it.

Throwaway0912 · 22/01/2023 13:19

BrunchAndYoga · 22/01/2023 13:17

If it is your only resort I would try first response finance. You can get the finance pre approved before you go to the dealers so that you know how much you have to spend and they are very good to deal with and take into account individual situations if you explain to them over the phone. They are high interest but if you need a car it’s better than not having one.

Would second this. But only if you have three months of bank statements that show a consistent income coming in, you can include benefits too. If your bank statements show sporadic or no income, or loads of late paid direct debits, you'll find it really difficult to get approved.

BrunchAndYoga · 22/01/2023 13:17

If it is your only resort I would try first response finance. You can get the finance pre approved before you go to the dealers so that you know how much you have to spend and they are very good to deal with and take into account individual situations if you explain to them over the phone. They are high interest but if you need a car it’s better than not having one.

Throwaway0912 · 22/01/2023 13:17

Coming from a finance background here, specifically in sub prime.

There are lenders out there who will lend (at a cost!) To close to anyone. The exorbitant APRs are indicative of the high risk the company is taking on someone who's proven they've been unable to sustain payments to anything.

However, my main concern is your comment about £400 leaving you with close to nothing. Second hand cars are at an all time high after the pandemic. A 3k runaround in 2020 is now 5k, and 5k at a subprime rate will set you back around 200pcm for 4 years. You'll need to maintain that well for 4 years to have a chance of making it to the end of the term, and have you got the funds to do that? It doesn't sound it. You could end up trashing your credit further if you fall into difficulty.

Income - are you declaring anything on your bank statements? Sub prime companies especially can't just take your word for it and need to evidence income via bank statements, 3 months is enough for most though. So if you've said you earn 2k per month and they see nothing going into the bank, it'll be a decline.

If your bad credit truly is years ago, and you're genuinely banking all of your income, I'm really surprised no finance lenders will touch you.

Cocobutt · 22/01/2023 13:16

I didn’t realise you had a DH.
Can he not lend you any money or take out a small loan?

Could you not pick up some evening work to save some money for a better car?

I’d do everything you can to get a cheap run around for a couple of months and then buy a better one from the extra money you get from the evening work.

FatAgainItsLettuceTime · 22/01/2023 13:12

If you started the business 4 months ago, have 2 months till you need a new car and will need 6 months proof of earnings then surely you'll meet that requirement by end of March?

Luredbyapomegranate · 22/01/2023 13:11

Rakatakatar · 22/01/2023 11:51

Possible solution. Not sure if anyone here can advise.

DH is currently learning to drive, he is almost at test level. He has better credit than me and has been accepted by a car lender. He can take out the car in his name right? And I can drive it as well as him?

Yes - this will work fine.

You just need to put both of you on the insurance.

WonderingWanda · 22/01/2023 13:10

If you really can't sort the car then you might have to limit your cleaning to local /reachable by public transport destinations and be the sort of cleaner who uses the clients hoover and cleaning products. This is what my cleaner used to do. Is that an option for the meantime or do you also need the car to get to your childcare?

Nottelling15 · 22/01/2023 13:10

Save as much as you can between now and the MOT
Put the car in for a test and see what it fails on
If it fails on lots then scrap cars still have a high value ATM then once you sell it for spares or repairs and take what you have saved you'll be able to find a cheap run about that will see you through a year or so
You don't need a brand new or nearly new car and there are plenty of second hand cars for sale
Car prices go up and down and personally I wouldn't have a brand new car on finance
Can your partner not do any of the repairs on your car?

StrawberryMuffins · 22/01/2023 13:09

"Do I save all my money for a cheap car or do I save all my money for an auto electrician?"

If this is the actual question, then I think repairing your car is likely to be the cheapest way to get you back on the road. Start by getting another opinion or two from another garage. But IMO buying an old, cheap second hand car is a big throw of the dice and it is wise to expect it needs some money spent on it. People sell their car when they do for a reason - even if it's got a new MOT, they'll be thinking it probably won't get through the next one. Could be something big and expensive that's about to go.

If you had the cash to deal with it that would be fine, but in your situation I would be inclined to spend more than your car is worth to keep it going.

If your hard limit is £400 then I think it's probably an impossible problem. Even a service will be £200+ these days. But hopefully if DH can afford driving lessons and a car loan you have a bit more wiggle room.

Shinyandnew1 · 22/01/2023 13:08

How far away are the places you clean? Could you get a bike or moped?

If your DH has better credit, could he get a credit card and you buy an older car with that? If money is tight, getting a newer car in finance may not be a great idea

FamousPrincess · 22/01/2023 13:08

Motnight · 22/01/2023 13:03

Have to say that I agree with this. And it was cheeky asking your parents for money when your husband is able to finance you.

Thanks.
As a parent, we have given hundreds of thousands to our children. We did this as they had their own home and all have BTL's and on their own two feet. We even gave one of our kids 5k when at a young age he bought a lovely, nearly new big 7 seat SUV and he said he did it so we could go out in one car. Had he bought the car on hp, he would not have got a penny.
People need to learn to stand on their own two feet if they are able bodied and not beg parents for money,

pattihews · 22/01/2023 13:07

You're an adult, you have to do that part yourself, OP.

I know you won't believe it, but I'm trying to find a way out for you that won't end up in disaster when you take out a three-year-loan to buy another secondhand car that packs up on you in 2 years' time. Or when you scrimp on insurance and then get faced with a litigious client who expects you to pay for the whole kitchen floor to be retiled when you drop a cast iron pan and break a couple of tiles. (This is a real-life example) Being self-employed is fraught with risks.

The way out is to find a job. People I know in your position have done things like evening work in supermarkets and bars or worked at the weekend when their partner is at home to cover childcare.

Flowersonthewall123 · 22/01/2023 13:07

Can you ask your parents to sort the finance side and you pay them each month?

Swipe left for the next trending thread