Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Annual leave first come first served - NHS

59 replies

MakeMineALarge1 · 22/01/2023 09:39

How can first come first served be fair when the calender is open and you are off for 2 weeks and end up missing out on one of the half terms and had planned to go away

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LakieLady · 22/01/2023 20:01

I'm lucky in that in my team it really doesn't matter how many are off at any time and we all manage our own workloads, so it only needs one of us to be working to deal with any emergencies.

In my previous team, it was very different. The rule was that for periods when lots of people wanted to be off, the people who'd had that same period off the previous year were lowest priority. There was a move to prioritise leave in school holidays for parents of school age children, but that was quickly knocked on the head when 2 colleagues pointed out that would mean that some people would never be able to go on holiday with their partners who worked in education.

First come, first served is brutal, but not unfair.

Els1e · 22/01/2023 19:26

We do first come, first booked with the exception of school holidays. With those, everyone says what they want, then the manager allocates it, taking into consideration who was off last time. Seems to work out ok. A couple of us don’t have school age children so don’t mind working.

Rockingcloggs · 22/01/2023 18:52

Never worked anywhere that doesn't approve/decline holidays on a first come first serve basis.

I remember being ambushed by more than two or three parents every time I had a Christmas or summer holiday booked to get me to change. Erm, no.

Grumpybutfunny · 22/01/2023 18:46

Someone is always going to be upset my annual leave just this time it's you. Longer serving staff also get more days in the NHS than new starters. I know some industries do bidding by seniority and other do a ballot. We open our calendar on NYD so the poor buggers working NYE get first preference for the coming year, but we take Christmas out of it. Parents aren't the only ones that want peak time off for example October and feb are peak Caribbean season

Spidey66 · 22/01/2023 18:41

Tbf in your shoes this would have been one of those rare exceptions to my 'no work emails on holiday' rule and emailed from holiday. If you're on NHSMail you can do it on your phone or tablet. Don't look at your inbox, just send the email and Bob's your aunts live in lover.

jay55 · 22/01/2023 18:34

Someone has to be last.

blubberyboo · 22/01/2023 18:31

And loyalty isn’t the same as having an S in your name

blubberyboo · 22/01/2023 18:30

Princesspollyyy · 22/01/2023 18:20

@blubberyboo

It would never be fair for annual leave to be picked according to length or service or how senior you are.

Everyone is entitled, and these factors don't make anyone more entitled.

That's like saying 'everyone with an S in their name gets to pick first'.

It just doesn't make sense. Whoever put that in place must have worked there a long time because they obviously benefited from it. Thankfully this method doesn't seem popular with many workplaces judging by replies to this thread.

I disagree, there are few perks of jobs anymore least of all working long service.

it very slightly rewards loyalty although in practice the newer members of staff arent usually disadvantaged as several people are allowed off at the same time. It ensures a calm orderly manner of selection. Everyone gets a good range of holidays to choose from and there aren’t any cries of “this isn’t fair because he or she got in first”

I see people at the bottom of the list still getting Christmas / Easter etc and it means everyone is forced to choose their strongest preference the first time round therefore not hogging all the good spots for themselves.

Princesspollyyy · 22/01/2023 18:20

@blubberyboo

It would never be fair for annual leave to be picked according to length or service or how senior you are.

Everyone is entitled, and these factors don't make anyone more entitled.

That's like saying 'everyone with an S in their name gets to pick first'.

It just doesn't make sense. Whoever put that in place must have worked there a long time because they obviously benefited from it. Thankfully this method doesn't seem popular with many workplaces judging by replies to this thread.

fiftiesmum · 22/01/2023 18:11

It doesn't help that in many parts of the NHS there are so few staff that only one person can be on leave at any one time.

MakeMineALarge1 · 22/01/2023 17:22

I am not suggesting I should get first dibs on everything because I have children, I just think first come first served isn't fair on anyone when#
1 - it isn't announced when the calenderer is open
2 - people can't put their requests in because
they are physically away

OP posts:
MakeMineALarge1 · 22/01/2023 17:19

WetBandits · 22/01/2023 13:44

OP, if you knew when the calendar was opening and you weren’t at work, you should have emailed whoever approves your leave requests to book for the year ahead. Should your colleagues all have waited until you returned from your holiday to book their leave?

I was actually away, in a foreign country with dodgy internet.
So no I don't expect the world to revolve around me.

OP posts:
MakeMineALarge1 · 22/01/2023 17:18

EasterIsland · 22/01/2023 14:07

I have got everything else I need apart from October - I can probably take either side but that means taking him out of school.

Why? YABU - no-one needs to go away at half-term. And children should not be taken out of school for holidays.

no one needs to go away at any time, so by that logic no one should get leave at all

OP posts:
SauMore · 22/01/2023 16:14

Zanatdy · 22/01/2023 10:12

Busy periods like school holidays we do requests, rest of year is first come first served. That system doesn’t sound fair at all

We do this too.
And if Christmas requests are oversubscribed then manager will look at who had it last year

blubberyboo · 22/01/2023 16:11

Princesspollyyy · 22/01/2023 10:53

What?!

So the most senior people get first choice, followed by the people who had been there the longest?

Followed by everyone else? So someone who had only been there a few months would have to take what was left?

That's the most unfair way I've ever seen. Thankfully I've never come across this.

My work does this and it’s actually very fair. The first people don’t get to pick all their leave first.. just 2 weeks then it goes round in rotation and then back to to the first person again for their next week and so on. This means everyone knows when it’s their turn and they get 48 hours to think about what they want. It also means if the most senior or longest serving people pick Christmas then you’ll at least have summer or Easter etc

NeedAHoliday2021 · 22/01/2023 14:44

I’m nhs and mine now has to go to the whole team so it takes weeks to sign off. The holiday I wanted is now £1300 more than if I’d booked 3 weeks ago. There must be some kind of approach that is fair and quick. My manager hates making decisions so everything is by committee so no one is upset (but in reality everyone is fed up with a lack of decisiveness).

LlynTegid · 22/01/2023 14:37

Not saying when a calendar/application time will be is unreasonable, whatever system you have. Just lazy management, I doubt in the OPs case a way to favour someone (or not).

As to some of the options, thoughts:

Fair to have a maximum of two weeks in the summer period.
Fair to have only a given number of other 'peak times'.
Reasonable to have a closing date, all requests in when a decision is made.
Those without children may want time off in school holidays to visit or go on holiday with someone with children (as an aunt, or grandparent, for example), or to help an adult child with looking after grandchildren.
Those without school age children may want to go to an event. Edinburgh Fringe is in August, for example (if you can afford to go!).

whataboutsecondbreakfast · 22/01/2023 14:14

Me and the other person both have school children - she has got all of her first choices, I have got everything else I need apart from October - I can probably take either side but that means taking him out of school.

You got everything you wanted apart from one week in October and you're still complaining?

You don't need to be off (or go away) during half-term just because you have a school-aged child. Why can't you use childcare and go away another time?

Washaday · 22/01/2023 14:09

I solved the problem. I resigned and now earn more as an agency nurse meaning I can afford to take all the school holidays off!

EasterIsland · 22/01/2023 14:07

I have got everything else I need apart from October - I can probably take either side but that means taking him out of school.

Why? YABU - no-one needs to go away at half-term. And children should not be taken out of school for holidays.

Ylvamoon · 22/01/2023 13:56

It is what it is. Just try to be quicker next time! I don't think your colleague has had preferential treatment, they just got in there first as they know how the system works. I definitely wouldn't get bitter about it.
If it makes you feel any better, we have had a holiday cap from 3 people off to 2 in a team* 10. 8 of us have school age children.... 3 already have booked and approved leave before the announcement. Now work that one out!

  • due to too many sickness days last year. But that's another issue!
Bellalalala · 22/01/2023 13:56

So apart from one instance you got all the holidays you wanted?

Its entirely normal to not always get the leave you want.

One of you would have got it and one of you wouldn’t have. Sounds like you are saying it would only be fair if you got it and not her.

Quveas · 22/01/2023 13:54

MakeMineALarge1 · 22/01/2023 13:08

Me and the other person both have school children - she has got all of her first choices, I have got everything else I need apart from October - I can probably take either side but that means taking him out of school. So yes I am more than happy to accept missing out on it, it just the principle of first come first served when its not clear when the calender opens from and it isn't formally announced yet someone who has been there longer does know this and gets priority

This isn't logical. You and this other person both got the same dates, except for October. That suggests that at least one other person also wanted October and got it - since its obvious that more than one person can be of at the same time, otherwise your and this other person couldn't have both got all the other school holiday dates. So it's this person's "fault" they got in first, plus whoever else got in first, plus the system isn't fair because you can't have what you want? You do know that you don't own dates just because you have children? In any system you are going to get turned down for something - unless you are suggesting that you want parents to get first dibs on all the dates they want?

The world doesn't revolve around your wants. And you are lucky you got almost all the dates you wanted. In my team, and many others, we have to restrict the numbers allowed leave in school holidays, and so it's my "pick" as the manager to sort out who gets the dates they want "fairly", and most parents only get about half of the school holidays because that's all we can give them. There's a job to do, and it needs doing all year, not just when convenient.

fiftiesmum · 22/01/2023 13:53

Our department can recruit but not retain.

Riverlee · 22/01/2023 13:52

So you got all the holiday you were hoping for, except for one week. Sounds like you haven’t done too badly.

I know you said you were hoping to go away during that week, but you will just have to change your plans.

i don’t see a problem with the holiday booking system being opened on a certain date. However, certain peak times should be managed. Ie. In my department, we rotated in turn who had the Christmas period off.

Swipe left for the next trending thread