Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I’ve got no chance against the other side’s Solicitor have I?

111 replies

Watchingthetiderollaway · 22/01/2023 09:37

Sorry not an AIBU, but wanted to post here for hopefully extra responses.

I appealed against a child maintenance decision and a Tribunal hearing has been arranged for just over 3 weeks time. I only found out last week that my ex has got himself a Solicitor, and now I feel defeated already as she’s clearly going to know every legal loophole there is in order to help him win the case.
I can’t afford legal representation and I’m feeling so pissed off that my ex can make out he’s broke to the cms but then be able to afford a Solicitor.

The only way I found out he has a Solicitor is because she contacted me asking me to send her all paperwork that I’m hoping to rely on in the hearing. Has anyone else been in a similar position?

OP posts:
Watchingthetiderollaway · 23/01/2023 07:44

Neededanewuserhandle · 23/01/2023 07:23

I represented myself at Family Court - mine was over access not finances, but ex's lawyer was hopeless and it definitely didn't give an advantage. The court gave me everything I asked for (although what I was asking wasn't unreasonable).

You're going to need to have some evidence for your allegation though.

I’m glad you were able to get what you asked for, I bet your ex was NOT happy spending out on a lawyer and it proved a waste of his time and money!

OP posts:
Watchingthetiderollaway · 23/01/2023 07:42

Menopausecankissmyass · 23/01/2023 07:00

@Watchingthetiderollaway a Judge will always ensure that a non-represented person gets fair treatment at the court and will make sure you are aware of what is happening at all times, if anything it can often work in your favour to a certain degree as you will be given more leeway.

It is part of the process to exchange documents before a hearing, solicitor has asked you for you yours, and you can ask for whatever documents your ex is relying on. This will give you chance to go over what road he is going down and think of what you want to say in court about that.

You are allowed to have someone with you, so please do look into it if you feel it would help.

Be strong, you can do this x

My sister is going to go with me for moral support, which has made me feel less anxious!

OP posts:
Watchingthetiderollaway · 23/01/2023 07:36

All of your posts are very helpful, and even though I’m still apprehensive, I’m feeling a bit more confident now thanks to the advice from everyone.

OP posts:
Shitfather · 23/01/2023 07:35

As long as you know the ins and outs of your case, you will be fine! You’ll have to be your best advocate. Make sure to ask the judge that your ex provided full disclosure of his dividends and business accounts.

Check online for the court’s email address. under the heading, put in caps !!URGENT LITIGANT IN PERSON HEARING CASE NUMBER XXXX!!”

Your other option is to go in person and speak to a clerk. In your position, I’d be asking for the hearing to be adjourned as you are at significant disadvantage by not having sufficient notice to prepare as a litigant in person.

Also, as you are a LIP, other side’s solicitor needs to provide you with the case bundle.

Neededanewuserhandle · 23/01/2023 07:23

I represented myself at Family Court - mine was over access not finances, but ex's lawyer was hopeless and it definitely didn't give an advantage. The court gave me everything I asked for (although what I was asking wasn't unreasonable).

You're going to need to have some evidence for your allegation though.

Badsox · 23/01/2023 07:11

You need to ask to see the family business accounts for every year since and three years before your marriage breakdown. You need to know how much IS in his directors loan account. He is no doubt drawing the minimum wage and keeping his money in the business to avoid paying. You will need proof that in married life his drawings were significantly more than now. Good luck!

Menopausecankissmyass · 23/01/2023 07:00

@Watchingthetiderollaway a Judge will always ensure that a non-represented person gets fair treatment at the court and will make sure you are aware of what is happening at all times, if anything it can often work in your favour to a certain degree as you will be given more leeway.

It is part of the process to exchange documents before a hearing, solicitor has asked you for you yours, and you can ask for whatever documents your ex is relying on. This will give you chance to go over what road he is going down and think of what you want to say in court about that.

You are allowed to have someone with you, so please do look into it if you feel it would help.

Be strong, you can do this x

FeinCuroxiVooz · 23/01/2023 06:55

I know you are already planning to ask for the other side's evidence but it would be good to find a way to see their evidence before you give them anything. someone has to go first and they are the experienced professionals so I think you can politely say "you first" and can then check over what they send before responding, which may be to your advantage. this is an advantage they very much want to keep for themselves obviously but there's no legitimate reason they should have it. presumably if he is hiding his wealth then some of what he submits will be fabricated, and you may be able to prove this. if you are very lucky you may have documentary evidence that shows up a lie, but you won't know what that would be until you see what the lies are.

theworkwasthething · 23/01/2023 06:36

There's a very helpful Facebook group that might be worth joining- CMS advice. They are understandably careful about who they let in, but it's worth a try?

Notsandwiches · 23/01/2023 06:31

I'd be asking for a copy of their letter of retainer as part of disclosure although be prepared he may argue someone else is paying the bill.

Do yourself a favour and write down all the points you want to make.

The Judge will make reasonable accommodations for you.

junebirthdaygirl · 23/01/2023 05:59

One thing to remember is that the solicitor may be representing the woman in the following case in the court that day before the same judge. They are walking a tightrope because whatever they bring forward in your case may work against them with their next client so that may keep them on a leash. Also the judge will be well aware of men trying to dodge their responsibility to their dc as they will have come across it many times before. They are no fools. Keep everything factual and as far as possible refrain from getting emotional or personal. Make everything about your children and no one can deny that that is fair.

One of my family members represented themselves in court and got on far better than at an earlier hearing where they used a solicitor as they felt their voice was heard.

You will be OK.

Watchingthetiderollaway · 23/01/2023 05:44

Oysterbabe · 22/01/2023 13:13

A cards on the table approach is best. The judge doesn't let people produce evidence like rabbits from a hat, it's only right that everyone sees everything that's available. His solicitor will advise him on the likely outcome based on the evidence. If you have some that helps, it's worth disclosing it so that his solicitor can advise him to reach agreement.

This is what I thought, that maybe the tribunal wouldn’t accept last minute documentation on the day, but I just don’t know. I’m new to all this and so I’ve got no clue as to what a tribunal is like.

OP posts:
Watchingthetiderollaway · 22/01/2023 14:16

LexMitior · 22/01/2023 13:40

The key thing is it's pretty likely your ex has been uncooperative so you don't have evidence or disclosure from him to make your case.

That needs pointing out. When you write to a lawyer don't think of them. Think what you need what you need and what a judge needs to make a good decision for you.

You can make it very very clear he has been unreasonable for a long time. You can point to this in court, and make that clear.

Judges do not like anyone who could settle but choose to not engage and go to court instead. This is why a lot of men lose at court btw because they hang out too long, or think the court is there to ratify their personal views. That is not what it is for.

Oh Uncooperative is an understatement!
Re his bank statements, the court haven’t asked him to provide them so he may argue that he doesn’t have to.

OP posts:
Watchingthetiderollaway · 22/01/2023 14:13

Ginjanotaninja · 22/01/2023 13:11

I know it seems like David vs Goliath, but you need to turn up and know whats going on. These websites provide clear and simple advice and info on family court issues. The first one centres and Bath and Bristol but the info is televant to any court.
www.familycourtinfo.org.uk/
www.advicenow.org.uk/family-court

There are also some good videos on you tube. Here is the link to the first in a series of 3. m.youtube.com/watch?v=cgAVMahol7Y&list=PL-A3hOBxg24hYiFRM8QqzmNV2K948DrOH&index=3

I hope that helps you. Good luck

Thank you for the info!

OP posts:
Watchingthetiderollaway · 22/01/2023 14:12

LexMitior · 22/01/2023 13:10

You are a litigant in person. Technically this solicitor cannot play the kind of games that she would with another lawyer.

My advice to you is to serve it right back to her. I am a solicitor and she will be hoping that she can scare or put you off.

Don't be scared. You write back and demand evidence of your ex's income, the bank statements, or whatever evidence you need now.

She is just a bit of window dressing for your ex. Get tough and make it clear that, if he were reasonable, provided this information and reached agreement, there would be no tribunal at all. You have no desire to waste the tribunals time but he does.

He's a time waster. You use her and go right back to frame him as such. It's his intransigence that means you are going at all.

Lawyers are ten a penny. Good ones will seek a deal in these circumstances. A greedy one will rinse your ex and he loses anyway.

Best of luck.

Thanks, that’s helpful!
I did wonder about his bank statements, but not sure if he has to provide them to the court?

OP posts:
Watchingthetiderollaway · 22/01/2023 14:09

Bollindger · 22/01/2023 13:04

You should have his bank statements.
Go through them and see what he is spending on.
Was the car the one you had together.
Mortgage payments or rent, are payments shown?
Does he have a pension.
His phone who pays for it.
All these can show he benefits from the buisness.

I don’t have any up to date bank statements unfortunately

OP posts:
LexMitior · 22/01/2023 13:44

In discounting - yes the aim is to cut down your claim.

There are two ways to do this, either pad the claim but putting all you need and more. This is a respectable way to negotiate and expected. Don't fall for the greedy woman line. These are your children. Inflation is at 10 percent.

Then calculate a settlement amount but keep that to yourself. Also any settlement needs inflation linking so it keeps maintaining value. A judge will ensure this but you need to keep an eye on it too.

LexMitior · 22/01/2023 13:40

The key thing is it's pretty likely your ex has been uncooperative so you don't have evidence or disclosure from him to make your case.

That needs pointing out. When you write to a lawyer don't think of them. Think what you need what you need and what a judge needs to make a good decision for you.

You can make it very very clear he has been unreasonable for a long time. You can point to this in court, and make that clear.

Judges do not like anyone who could settle but choose to not engage and go to court instead. This is why a lot of men lose at court btw because they hang out too long, or think the court is there to ratify their personal views. That is not what it is for.

gravyriceandchips · 22/01/2023 13:22

Dont sent his solicitor anything.

Let her and him gather their own evidence.

Of you send her what you have she will look at ways to discount it as that's what he will be paying her for.

Oysterbabe · 22/01/2023 13:13

A cards on the table approach is best. The judge doesn't let people produce evidence like rabbits from a hat, it's only right that everyone sees everything that's available. His solicitor will advise him on the likely outcome based on the evidence. If you have some that helps, it's worth disclosing it so that his solicitor can advise him to reach agreement.

Ginjanotaninja · 22/01/2023 13:11

I know it seems like David vs Goliath, but you need to turn up and know whats going on. These websites provide clear and simple advice and info on family court issues. The first one centres and Bath and Bristol but the info is televant to any court.
www.familycourtinfo.org.uk/
www.advicenow.org.uk/family-court

There are also some good videos on you tube. Here is the link to the first in a series of 3. m.youtube.com/watch?v=cgAVMahol7Y&list=PL-A3hOBxg24hYiFRM8QqzmNV2K948DrOH&index=3

I hope that helps you. Good luck

LexMitior · 22/01/2023 13:10

You are a litigant in person. Technically this solicitor cannot play the kind of games that she would with another lawyer.

My advice to you is to serve it right back to her. I am a solicitor and she will be hoping that she can scare or put you off.

Don't be scared. You write back and demand evidence of your ex's income, the bank statements, or whatever evidence you need now.

She is just a bit of window dressing for your ex. Get tough and make it clear that, if he were reasonable, provided this information and reached agreement, there would be no tribunal at all. You have no desire to waste the tribunals time but he does.

He's a time waster. You use her and go right back to frame him as such. It's his intransigence that means you are going at all.

Lawyers are ten a penny. Good ones will seek a deal in these circumstances. A greedy one will rinse your ex and he loses anyway.

Best of luck.

Bollindger · 22/01/2023 13:04

You should have his bank statements.
Go through them and see what he is spending on.
Was the car the one you had together.
Mortgage payments or rent, are payments shown?
Does he have a pension.
His phone who pays for it.
All these can show he benefits from the buisness.

2bazookas · 22/01/2023 12:26

if I don’t send anything at all, could the solicitor argue that my evidence can’t be used because she hasn’t got copies of it I wonder?

The solicitor represents EX; she is never going to suggest anything to a court that disadvantages him. She WILL point out to the court, anything she can use that disadvantages you or puts you in a poor light.

You're the one contesting a child maintenance decision. Failure to provide paperwork could look as if you're withholding information that would undermine your claim.

itsgettingweird · 22/01/2023 12:22

You see, I thought about this but I’m thinking that if I don’t send anything at all, could the solicitor argue that my evidence can’t be used because she hasn’t got copies of it I wonder?

You're evidence must be sent to the court. It's their responsibility to send out the tribunal bundles.

If the court has accepted your evidence then that's what matters.

I provided a last minute document at ehcp tribunal which arrived the evening before. I email court straight away and all parties involved (as per the directions from tribunal). They tried to have it dismissed but the judge asked why and gave a 20 minute recess for them to read it and pointed out they'd already seen it.

I think they are quite wise to parties wanting evidence barred because it doesn't help their case and helps the other side asking for the tribunal!

Swipe left for the next trending thread