Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I’ve got no chance against the other side’s Solicitor have I?

111 replies

Watchingthetiderollaway · 22/01/2023 09:37

Sorry not an AIBU, but wanted to post here for hopefully extra responses.

I appealed against a child maintenance decision and a Tribunal hearing has been arranged for just over 3 weeks time. I only found out last week that my ex has got himself a Solicitor, and now I feel defeated already as she’s clearly going to know every legal loophole there is in order to help him win the case.
I can’t afford legal representation and I’m feeling so pissed off that my ex can make out he’s broke to the cms but then be able to afford a Solicitor.

The only way I found out he has a Solicitor is because she contacted me asking me to send her all paperwork that I’m hoping to rely on in the hearing. Has anyone else been in a similar position?

OP posts:
Saladd0dger · 23/01/2023 10:59

I went to tribunal last year. Over video call due to covid. The judge will go through and read everything before you start. My ex and I both received packs containing all evidence from each side with each page numbered. Do you have that? He should be providing it to his solicitor himself

Shitfather · 23/01/2023 10:55

Kennykenkencat · 23/01/2023 10:44

I helped my disabled, unable to work friend with her divorce and an exh who despite her name being jointly on everything apart from his cash only business and him paying off their mortgage. He was going to be the one owning the family home as he has paid for it.
He too was declaring earnings well below his expenses

I learned so much about divorce law. Friend kept the marital home and an amount of money which in total equalled 60% of the marital pot

I would try to get the court date adjourned Even if you can’t I would start reading now about what the law states around whatever he is trying to claim.
Even take a day or 2 off work so you can spend the day preparing.

Read up on court cases with similar claims

I would ask for company accounts (you can get online previous years accounts through HMRC website and him to provide a year/6 months if his personal bank statements and list of expenses and evidence of how they are being paid. If he is claiming that he has only a small income then he needs to show it and how he is spending his money,

If his family are “loaning” him money i.e the amounts are transferred to his account with the word Loan in the reference or are they just transferring him money where there is no expectation of repayments

Remember op the law is there to read. The only difference between you and the solicitor is they know every aspect of particular laws off the top of their head
You have to find them, read them and understand the different interpretations and make a note of them for reference

My friend ended up fighting SS to keep her children and by the time it got to family court she knew more about the laws involving SS than any SW or their solicitor.

Dont be afraid, Read carefully what your ex is asking. And read the laws and cases surrounding that type of claim. Including the claims that failed and why

You can do it.

@Kennykenkencat there is some great advice here. Can HMRC really provide accounts for a company?? I may need to go to tribunal for similar reasons. I can see ex’s very healthy accounts on Company House.

Slowingdownagain · 23/01/2023 10:46

The court has to make allowances for you as a litigant in person, including explaining your rights to you.

However, I wonder if you could afford some legal advice on this - maybe not for the hearing, but at least some advice on your case so you can feel better prepared?

Kennykenkencat · 23/01/2023 10:44

I helped my disabled, unable to work friend with her divorce and an exh who despite her name being jointly on everything apart from his cash only business and him paying off their mortgage. He was going to be the one owning the family home as he has paid for it.
He too was declaring earnings well below his expenses

I learned so much about divorce law. Friend kept the marital home and an amount of money which in total equalled 60% of the marital pot

I would try to get the court date adjourned Even if you can’t I would start reading now about what the law states around whatever he is trying to claim.
Even take a day or 2 off work so you can spend the day preparing.

Read up on court cases with similar claims

I would ask for company accounts (you can get online previous years accounts through HMRC website and him to provide a year/6 months if his personal bank statements and list of expenses and evidence of how they are being paid. If he is claiming that he has only a small income then he needs to show it and how he is spending his money,

If his family are “loaning” him money i.e the amounts are transferred to his account with the word Loan in the reference or are they just transferring him money where there is no expectation of repayments

Remember op the law is there to read. The only difference between you and the solicitor is they know every aspect of particular laws off the top of their head
You have to find them, read them and understand the different interpretations and make a note of them for reference

My friend ended up fighting SS to keep her children and by the time it got to family court she knew more about the laws involving SS than any SW or their solicitor.

Dont be afraid, Read carefully what your ex is asking. And read the laws and cases surrounding that type of claim. Including the claims that failed and why

You can do it.

shiningstar2 · 23/01/2023 10:25

I would ask his solicitor to send to you any evidence they intend to rely on. I certainly wouldn't be sending a new y evidence I have to them without their own evidence. Also if you have to send your evidence ahead to the tribunal be will his solicitor be able to have sight of this. If they can request your evidence from the tribunal ahead of the case make sure you request theirs. I have no idea though if they could get sight of your evidence this way 🤔

Gilles27 · 23/01/2023 10:19

I represented myself during a court battle with my ex over custody of the children. Each time we went to court I wrote a letter to the judge explaining my side of the story and pointing out the flaws in her side of the argument. I got to court an hour before the hearing and asked an usher to give my letter to the judge. When we went into the court the judge knew all the facts and could ask me questions directly. As she had representation she couldn't speak in the court, only her solicitor could. Her solicitor didn't know as much about our children and what my ex had done as I did so I had an advantage. Her solicitor complained each time about being 'ambushed' by me, but I just acted dumb and said I thought the judge needed to know, so that's who I'd written to.

The outcome was good for me and the children. I probably saved myself thousands in legal fees and had a better result.

Send nothing to the other side. Represent yourself. If you have a solicitor it must be very frustrating to have to spectate while strangers decide what is best for your family.

GreetingsToTheNewBrunette · 23/01/2023 09:59

@Watchingthetiderollaway theres a person on tiktok called the legal queen she does lives most evenings where she answers family law questions! Might be worth having a look and asking any questions you might have to her as she’s qualified and has her own law firm. Good luck!

ZenNudist · 23/01/2023 09:53

He should be supplying his tax returns for the years prior to your split. I'd expect these to show low salary but dividend payments.

Look at his parents company accounts on companies House. If they are making decent revenue and profit.

Check what company directors earn in your area. You can argue that if his family are not for some reason paying him right now he has earning capacity to support his children but instead is supporting his family. That will pay off for him in the future if he should inherit.

Ask for a history of dividend payments from before you split. He should be paid a consistent amount but if its dropped then it will be telling.

The pension point is s good call but don't put it past his family to skip this too. They can always top up later.

If divided goes down, everyone else stays the same and profit goes up then you have a pattern that shows he is doing down his income to stiff his own dc.

Losingmymind85 · 23/01/2023 09:52

OP you've had some excellent advice on here already.

  1. the case is with the tribunal. All papers should from both sides should be with them in advance (usually 14 days) before the hearing. Late evidence will be accepted in advance of hearing but only if it gives both sides chance to review. I've been in hearings where solicitors provide evidence 5 minutes before and Judges either recess to allow panel to review or adjourn. Either way, it is not looked upon favourably.
  2. send her nothing. It's under the jurisdiction of the tribunal now. If your ex's solicitors want paperwork, she can go through the tribunal. You should not be contacted-it's massively inappropriate. You're not her employee ffs.
  3. Solicitors do not get an easy ride in tribunals. Panels will often ask questions over them that you know they'd never (or at least phrase differently) ask an unrepresented appellant.
  4. tribunals are designed so that you don't need representation. I didnt do CSA ones but in the ones i did do, it usually goes: opening by panel, explanation of current position, complainant position, questions to conplainant, Respondent position, questions to Respondent. Closing submissions by both. Someone with specific knowledge of these types of tribunals may be able to advise on specifics, but I'd say it's good to have a bullet pointed list of your key points, alongside the references to corresponding evidence. Remember it's judged on evidence and balance of probability. You don't need to prove everything,it just needs to be proven that it's more likely than not. Best of luck.
Mmmmdanone · 23/01/2023 09:44

Surely all the evidence you have sent to the tribunal/cms is already in the appeal papers. You shouldn't have to send anything directly to his solicitor. If you take anything to the tribunal it will be copied to all parties to look at. If it's too much for them to consider on they day they will likely adjourn so best to send in to the tribunal now.

TinyArsePhone · 23/01/2023 09:20

I took my child's school to a disability discrimination tribunal a couple of years ago, and I self represented.

The school had a solicitor probably paid for with the funding they weren't spending on my child and he was absolutely fucking useless. He made a legal error that nearly lost them the case a week before the hearing, and then he just didn't know the details or the law when it actually came to the hearing itself. It was actually unbelievable how bad he was.

The chair and the panel were extremely fair and made sure everything ran properly, so don't worry too much. It feels like you're at a disadvantage but actually, you know the case inside out and the solicitor knows the bare minimum!

Thesenderofthiscard · 23/01/2023 09:12

'Good point, he’ll probably lie and say his family paid for him though.'

That could be the truth.

Family courts aren't usually overly impressed by one side coming in with big guns blazing, it, unequal sides makes it more complicated. So it certainly won't be a case of them being impressed by some lawyer, or letting him off on loop-holes.
They'll be thinking about what's fair, and what's best for the kids

Bestcatmum · 23/01/2023 09:09

You'll be fine, I won a case against a barrister my ex hired to try and intimidate me.
Just have your facts there, your financial records and what you want.
The judge will be sympthetic towards you for not having a solicitor.
A solicitor does not have the ability to sway a judge, they assess the case on facts.
Your exH is a shit by the way.

AngelinaFibres · 23/01/2023 09:03

WigglyGlowWorm · 22/01/2023 11:45

Oh and, what a saddo, arguing about maintenance. These ‘men’ forget that they’re arguing over the provision for the children that they claim to love. When the child reaches adulthood, will they even want a relationship with someone who thought so little of them?

This. Remind yourself of this every single day. My exhusband left 26 years ago. The children were 3 and 2. He argued over every penny . He was 32 and had got himself a 17 year old girlfriend. It was more important to impress her/ buy her stuff than it was to pay what he was supposed to to our children.I went back to work to support us. It was the hardest time of my life but my children are now adults and we are very close. They no longer bother with their father. His second wife is currently divorcing him and the teenage child from that relationship is also NC with him. Be strong, be unemotional ( that's the hardest bit) take a friend if you can and do your homework. Your children will see, and they will remember, the stress caused to their mother by their father.

NanaWelshcake · 23/01/2023 08:47

2bazookas · 22/01/2023 12:26

if I don’t send anything at all, could the solicitor argue that my evidence can’t be used because she hasn’t got copies of it I wonder?

The solicitor represents EX; she is never going to suggest anything to a court that disadvantages him. She WILL point out to the court, anything she can use that disadvantages you or puts you in a poor light.

You're the one contesting a child maintenance decision. Failure to provide paperwork could look as if you're withholding information that would undermine your claim.

Then she can provide it to the tribunal.

MrsPinkCock · 23/01/2023 08:40

I agree with @tirednewmumm

There are so many inaccuracies in this thread 🤦‍♀️

Disclosure obligations apply to both parties when court ordered - and this includes documents that adversely/negatively affect your own clients case. You/he still have/has to disclose them. If there is anything you think should have been disclosed then write to the solicitor and ask for it. (You aren’t entitled to a copy of their retainer as that’s privileged)

Judges will take extra time to explain the law and proceedings to unrepresented parties and the SRA requires solicitors to behave well towards unrepresented parties by not being oppressive or heavy handed, by explaining the basic legal position and by recommending that they seek legal advice if they are unsure.

You’re also required to cooperate which in practice means copying your disclosure to the solicitor representing your ex. Frankly hearings run far more efficiently when both parties work together and actively cooperate. If they’re going to be sent the documents anyway, why not just copy them in? I presume that this is written into whichever civil procedure rules governs the tribunal anyway (it’s certainly in the employment tribunal rules which is my area of law) and in the nicest way, being deliberately obstructive isn’t going to help you and may actually get the judges back up!

Patineur · 23/01/2023 08:21

tirednewmumm · 23/01/2023 08:00

This is truly terrible advice (solicitor here)

The court will look at that as you being shady and unreasonable. It's totally normal to share your evidence with the other side in advance (in virtually every adversarial legal setting). The day in court/tribunal goes a lot more productively if everyone knows what they're actually arguing about!

She will be fair and as some have said the courts/tribunal service tend to be a bit more lenient on those representing themselves. That's in terms of procedure and paperwork. You still have to behave like a grown up and be honest etc.

It likely will be better than negotiating with him directly as she's a professional but yes she will know the law well and is obliged to do the best for her client. That being said she won't be willing to break the law/rules for him so in theory it should be a fair settlement

This. The tribunal will be totally unimpressed with attempts to spring surprises or keep any of your evidence away from the solicitor.

Ginandthings · 23/01/2023 08:20

If he’s a director have you checked companies house, accounts have to be filed annually showing turnover, dividends paid etc. also any shares held in the company are listed - it may be that he is hoping to show a low salary as is being paid in dividends so it’s worth a look as you just need the company name.

Patineur · 23/01/2023 08:20

Watchingthetiderollaway · 22/01/2023 14:16

Oh Uncooperative is an understatement!
Re his bank statements, the court haven’t asked him to provide them so he may argue that he doesn’t have to.

Check out whether there's a process whereby you can make applications to the court and, if so, how it works. If so, make an application for an order for him to provide copies of all relevant bank and Building Society statements and any other documents you think he has been withholding.

tirednewmumm · 23/01/2023 08:00

365names · 22/01/2023 09:42

And don’t send her anything

This is truly terrible advice (solicitor here)

The court will look at that as you being shady and unreasonable. It's totally normal to share your evidence with the other side in advance (in virtually every adversarial legal setting). The day in court/tribunal goes a lot more productively if everyone knows what they're actually arguing about!

She will be fair and as some have said the courts/tribunal service tend to be a bit more lenient on those representing themselves. That's in terms of procedure and paperwork. You still have to behave like a grown up and be honest etc.

It likely will be better than negotiating with him directly as she's a professional but yes she will know the law well and is obliged to do the best for her client. That being said she won't be willing to break the law/rules for him so in theory it should be a fair settlement

GoldilockMom · 23/01/2023 07:52

Firstly have you looked at legal aid? Im sure you can claim this for child support.

Friends just been through this and the first hearing is a fact finding hearing where solitons are asked to provide anything that has been missed before the actual court date.

You need to provide a list of your incoming and outgoings - plus list the extras - shoes clothes clubs etc

It should be based on your children - I believe there is a list document somewhere to complete.

WhyCantPeopleBeNice · 23/01/2023 07:51

When my ex business partner left his wife he downplayed what he had by reducing his usual salary and dividends and instead took money as a director's loan.
Be sure to ask for directors loan accounts as well as benefits in kind.

Is his business the sort where cash payments are made? This is the other 'loophole' and if it's a family business they won't want any potential cash earnings/tax fraud being associated

Additionally does anyone else in the family do a similar level job? Does he have a sibling who is also a director so you can compare salaries and benefits if he tries claiming wages have dropped due to covid?

Oh and pension account, be sure to check what he's squirreling away in a pension account tax free instead of contributing towards his children as well as company contributions

Watchingthetiderollaway · 23/01/2023 07:47

Just setting off to work now and will be back on here later today.

OP posts:
Watchingthetiderollaway · 23/01/2023 07:46

Shitfather · 23/01/2023 07:35

As long as you know the ins and outs of your case, you will be fine! You’ll have to be your best advocate. Make sure to ask the judge that your ex provided full disclosure of his dividends and business accounts.

Check online for the court’s email address. under the heading, put in caps !!URGENT LITIGANT IN PERSON HEARING CASE NUMBER XXXX!!”

Your other option is to go in person and speak to a clerk. In your position, I’d be asking for the hearing to be adjourned as you are at significant disadvantage by not having sufficient notice to prepare as a litigant in person.

Also, as you are a LIP, other side’s solicitor needs to provide you with the case bundle.

Thanks for your post too, very helpful advice!

OP posts:
Watchingthetiderollaway · 23/01/2023 07:46

Badsox · 23/01/2023 07:11

You need to ask to see the family business accounts for every year since and three years before your marriage breakdown. You need to know how much IS in his directors loan account. He is no doubt drawing the minimum wage and keeping his money in the business to avoid paying. You will need proof that in married life his drawings were significantly more than now. Good luck!

Oh as he is a Director, I agree that he can probably hide his money in the business,

OP posts: