Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I’ve got no chance against the other side’s Solicitor have I?

111 replies

Watchingthetiderollaway · 22/01/2023 09:37

Sorry not an AIBU, but wanted to post here for hopefully extra responses.

I appealed against a child maintenance decision and a Tribunal hearing has been arranged for just over 3 weeks time. I only found out last week that my ex has got himself a Solicitor, and now I feel defeated already as she’s clearly going to know every legal loophole there is in order to help him win the case.
I can’t afford legal representation and I’m feeling so pissed off that my ex can make out he’s broke to the cms but then be able to afford a Solicitor.

The only way I found out he has a Solicitor is because she contacted me asking me to send her all paperwork that I’m hoping to rely on in the hearing. Has anyone else been in a similar position?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
strugglingmmum · 10/03/2023 19:02

Hi
Best of luck and sorry to jump on your post.
My ex has also said he’s taking the CMS decision to tribunal but this is following a financial investigation and rejection to mandatory reconsideration.
Surely the financial investigation provides all evidence? Or would I need to? I thought this was between him and CMS- I didn’t realise I would have to go too!
Thank you

AtomicRitual · 24/01/2023 17:40

A director's loan is where a director of a company withdraws money from the company, but without it being recorded as a salary or dividend payment. i.e. the company "loans" him the money.

It is officially illegal, though does happen, and HMRC tax the company on it if it is not repaid within 9 months of the year end.

HMRC brought in the tax charge because too many people were "borrowing" money from their companies but never declaring it as income or paying tax on it.

If it's a family business he'd definitely have to have all his family behind him for them to agree to pay a tax on his behalf that is otherwise unnecessary. The company would get the tax back as and when the loan is either repaid (by either him literally repaying the loan, or by him taking a salary or dividend to cover it), but in the meantime it's a cashflow disadvantage to the company.

Watchingthetiderollaway · 24/01/2023 05:16

Menopausecankissmyass · 23/01/2023 21:04

@Watchingthetiderollaway if your ex goes to court represented, the solicitor will speak on his behalf.

With regards to financial, documents, both parties have to supply everything they are relying. As a general rule, you will file yours at court/tribunal and serve a copy on the other side (your ex's solicitor). Inform the tribunal when filing docs that a copy has been served on the o/s also. Please do not take the advice on not sending anything - all this will do, if you decide to produce anything on the day, is cause the hearing to be delayed whilst the other party considers them, or even adjourned for another date.

If you feel that you have not been provided with everything, write to the solicitor asking for the documents and send a copy of that correspondence to the court. This means that all parties are up to date and aware of what you are doing.

With regards to company accounts/directors, go on to Companies House Beta. You will see an option to search for a company, click on that and type in company name. Once you see your ex's company click on the name and it will bring up all the details with various headings. Click on "People" and it will show everyone who is a director or company secretary. Under this heading you can see who the beneficial owner is i.e the person basically on the top of the food chain so to speak. If you then go into the Filings tab you will see who owns what with regards to shares and all company accounts that have been filed to date.

Hope this helps x

Good advice too, thank you

OP posts:
Menopausecankissmyass · 23/01/2023 21:04

@Watchingthetiderollaway if your ex goes to court represented, the solicitor will speak on his behalf.

With regards to financial, documents, both parties have to supply everything they are relying. As a general rule, you will file yours at court/tribunal and serve a copy on the other side (your ex's solicitor). Inform the tribunal when filing docs that a copy has been served on the o/s also. Please do not take the advice on not sending anything - all this will do, if you decide to produce anything on the day, is cause the hearing to be delayed whilst the other party considers them, or even adjourned for another date.

If you feel that you have not been provided with everything, write to the solicitor asking for the documents and send a copy of that correspondence to the court. This means that all parties are up to date and aware of what you are doing.

With regards to company accounts/directors, go on to Companies House Beta. You will see an option to search for a company, click on that and type in company name. Once you see your ex's company click on the name and it will bring up all the details with various headings. Click on "People" and it will show everyone who is a director or company secretary. Under this heading you can see who the beneficial owner is i.e the person basically on the top of the food chain so to speak. If you then go into the Filings tab you will see who owns what with regards to shares and all company accounts that have been filed to date.

Hope this helps x

Ursula82 · 23/01/2023 20:52

Good grief!!

Shitfather · 23/01/2023 20:43

Ursula82 · 23/01/2023 19:37

Do come back to update as to what happens and educate people though!

ODFOD. You’ve added diddly squat that is useful to this thread. Nobody questioned the legality of the structure of his business, but it does appear you missed the point of why she is going to court - to challenge CM. There are very clear guidelines and processes in place by the CMS about what issues can be taken to tribunal. Diversion of income via excessive dividends is one. Excessive pension is another. Or how about changing the shareholding of a company to avoid paying CM. Employing a family member - yep that can be looked at also. These are all perfectly legal structures. WE ALL KNOW THAT. Perhaps you could educate yourself further, but these are some of the challenges that are allowed. Rights of the Child is a good website for you to look at. HTH.

Ursula82 · 23/01/2023 19:37

Shitfather · 23/01/2023 18:01

Didn’t think so.

Do come back to update as to what happens and educate people though!

EvelynBeatrice · 23/01/2023 18:47

I haven't had time to read the full thread but if the company in question is a limited company you can access the latest accounts free online. Google companies house beta service and just put in the company name. You'll be able to see accounts, names of directors etc. If it's a 'small company ' ( there's a legal definition) then less info will be available, but it's worth a look

Shitfather · 23/01/2023 18:01

Ursula82 · 23/01/2023 17:54

🤷‍♀️

good luck

Didn’t think so.

Ursula82 · 23/01/2023 17:54

🤷‍♀️

good luck

Shitfather · 23/01/2023 17:47

Ursula82 · 23/01/2023 16:07

why? Because no matter what the dividends statement showed, as long as legal… there wouldn’t be any ramifications whatsoever on your ex. So the information is irrelevant to the judge I am afraid

Do you have experience of child maintenance tribunals? Has every judge in the land refused variations based on income diversion? I haven’t questioned its legitimacy.

Watchingthetiderollaway · 23/01/2023 17:37

I’ve just got back and read all of your posts thoroughly, I can’t reply to everyone as I’ll be busy doing my DC’s dinner soon, and then taking the dog out. What I want to say is thank you very much all of you for the advice, I feel more confident now that even if the Solicitor wipes the floor with me, I’m not going to go down without a fight so to speak.
I do have a couple of queries if anyone could help. Do you know if ex will be able to talk too, or would it just be the Solicitor who normally does?
As it’s a family run business, I want the judge to assume that ex’s family could be the ones who are receiving the dividends officially, and then passing them on to ex, but I can’t see a way to convince the judge that this is likely what is happening as I can’t really prove this.

Re a directors loan, I’m also a bit confused as to how this works?
thanks once again

OP posts:
Ursula82 · 23/01/2023 16:07

Shitfather · 23/01/2023 12:33

Hmmm good point re confidentiality. I requested cunty ex provide his daily contracting rate and he cited commercial sensitivity. However, I can’t see why a judge cannot order full disclosure of dividends are being used to divert income. This is the whole point of applying for a variation and going to tribunal.

why? Because no matter what the dividends statement showed, as long as legal… there wouldn’t be any ramifications whatsoever on your ex. So the information is irrelevant to the judge I am afraid

Ursula82 · 23/01/2023 16:05

Ursula82 · 23/01/2023 11:00

In a court, in front of lawyers… a judge said to your ex “I’ll sign whatever you put in front of me”?

This was for @ForfuckssakeEXHstopbeingatwat

Shitfather · 23/01/2023 12:33

ThisModernLove · 23/01/2023 12:01

Ex works for the family business as a Director, without going into detail, I believe he’s hiding his money in the business, aided by his family, and not declaring the correct earnings

op - I’m in the same situation. Can I ask how you intend to prove this? Feel free to pm me if you don’t want to post it. It’s been 2 years and I’m no further forward. Apparently he earns an utter pittance and can’t support himself... director of multi million pound family business.

Was ordered to disclose by court and has refused citing his employment contract requiring confidentiality! I’m so at the end of my rope and just want him to play fair for my kids.

Hmmm good point re confidentiality. I requested cunty ex provide his daily contracting rate and he cited commercial sensitivity. However, I can’t see why a judge cannot order full disclosure of dividends are being used to divert income. This is the whole point of applying for a variation and going to tribunal.

Ursula82 · 23/01/2023 12:26

The issue is @Thesenderofthiscard he’s not actually doing anything illegal. And although you know his intentions are malicious, if he’s not actually breaching any law - then he’s not actually hiding anything.
He has structured his business in such a way that unfortunately leaves you short, but from a legal standpoint - as long as the structure is legal, very very little can be done

ThisModernLove · 23/01/2023 12:01

Ex works for the family business as a Director, without going into detail, I believe he’s hiding his money in the business, aided by his family, and not declaring the correct earnings

op - I’m in the same situation. Can I ask how you intend to prove this? Feel free to pm me if you don’t want to post it. It’s been 2 years and I’m no further forward. Apparently he earns an utter pittance and can’t support himself... director of multi million pound family business.

Was ordered to disclose by court and has refused citing his employment contract requiring confidentiality! I’m so at the end of my rope and just want him to play fair for my kids.

AtomicRitual · 23/01/2023 11:53

Shitfather · 23/01/2023 10:55

@Kennykenkencat there is some great advice here. Can HMRC really provide accounts for a company?? I may need to go to tribunal for similar reasons. I can see ex’s very healthy accounts on Company House.

I think Kenny is confusing HMRC with Companies House. HMRC wouldn't get involved I don't think.

Companies House has the record of companies' accounts, but the information shown may be minimal if it is a "small" company. Small companies can have up to £10m turnover (among other thresholds), so it could actually be a very profitable, sizable business, but not have to disclose turnover or profits on public record.

What should be disclosed, however, is if there is a Director's loan outstanding at the end of a reporting period. I say should in italics, as unfortunately, there are many accountants who overlook this, or the company has prepared their own accounts without the knowledge that this is disclosable.

PP's comments of suggesting reviewing a number of years' tax returns prior to the breakup are very useful to show evidence of deliberately withholding information, though again I'm not sure how far the court can go. Accounts are my area of expertise, rather than family law, unfortunately!

HelpASisterOut999 · 23/01/2023 11:32

I was represented at Family Court and my rep ensured he dealt with my ex as well as me, I think the onus is on any solicitor/barrister etc to ensure the best outcome for the children, so although they are obviously hired by one party it isn't as straightforward as one vs the other.
Good luck, I hope you get on OK.

AtomicRitual · 23/01/2023 11:21

As a director of a family business, especially if the family are on his side, he may very well be able to hide his earnings unfortunately.

I am an accountant and many of our clients are similar companies and, for tax purposes, they earn a small salary and the remainder of their earnings as dividends. Both of these are used to determine maintenance payments, but if he were to transfer his shares to another family member who then just "lends" him money, it would, as far as his reported earnings are concerned, show that he didn't earn much.

To do that though, the other family member(s) lending him the money would have a much bigger tax bill themselves, so they would really, really have to want to screw you over to go along with it.

Legally speaking though, I have no idea what a court could do in this instance.

I wish you luck OP. Shame he doesn't put as much effort in to his own children as he does in to screwing you over.

Slowingdownagain · 23/01/2023 11:20

Shitfather · 23/01/2023 11:04

my understanding is that his solicitor needs to provide this to OP also as she is a LIP. I’ll find the link from the Court website - there are some rules surrounding this.

Yes, this is true too. The Ex's solicitor has special obligations in respect of sharing evidence with OP as a litigant in person.

Shitfather · 23/01/2023 11:04

Saladd0dger · 23/01/2023 10:59

I went to tribunal last year. Over video call due to covid. The judge will go through and read everything before you start. My ex and I both received packs containing all evidence from each side with each page numbered. Do you have that? He should be providing it to his solicitor himself

my understanding is that his solicitor needs to provide this to OP also as she is a LIP. I’ll find the link from the Court website - there are some rules surrounding this.

Shitfather · 23/01/2023 11:03

Patineur · 23/01/2023 08:20

Check out whether there's a process whereby you can make applications to the court and, if so, how it works. If so, make an application for an order for him to provide copies of all relevant bank and Building Society statements and any other documents you think he has been withholding.

Agree. This is excellent advice. It is very important to highlight to the judge you are at significant disadvantage by not having transparency. Either make an application or ask the judge to order him to do so.

Have you been on Companies House to get his accounts? Is he a contractor of some sort? If so, also request info on his daily rate. Email solicitor and request this info.

Ursula82 · 23/01/2023 11:00

ForfuckssakeEXHstopbeingatwat · 22/01/2023 10:39

Please don't bottle out. I did, in similar circumstances and the judge just allowed my school x to have exactly what he wanted..he literally said "I'll sign whatever you put in front of me" . In hindsight, I should have gone, representated myself as I knew the ins and outs much better than a solicitor or barrister who'd had the file 5 minutes. They are used to self reps and won't bury you in legal jargon.

In a court, in front of lawyers… a judge said to your ex “I’ll sign whatever you put in front of me”?