Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I need to work in a different school - ethnicity and culture related

131 replies

Melte · 21/01/2023 22:48

I've taught in my current school for six years, and the demographics have changed a little, but not significantly from what I've always known.

I've always been in the minority to around 85% (2016) - around 95% (today) of pupils of a different ethnicity and religion, despite the school not being of any religious denomination.

In the last 12 months or so, I haven't had any chance of successfully managing the behaviour of the older boys. They will listen to and show respect to male teachers of of their own culture, male teachers of my culture, female teachers of their own culture and then women like me, in that order.

I'm repeatedly called derogatory names, when I'm not routinely being referred to as 'man', tutted at, laughed at, talked over and ignored. They'll bang on my classroom window or throw the door open when passing. They deliberately interrupt or misinterpret things I say, feigning sincerity. They make veiled suggestive comments. They get too close, take items aggressively, imply they will touch me, and on occasion outright threaten criminal behaviour.

I've tried and persisted with every behaviour for learning strategy I know and made sure my lessons are the best they can be, but I can't get through to them. I feel unsafe and unable to do my job for the others in this one class.

I spoke to a father on the phone this week who initially didn't believe his son would be disrespectful, before admitting that he does behave this way towards his mother, and I've watched one since September in a restorative meeting with his Head of Year try to assault his mother in anger.

I feel guilty for thinking in these terms, but I can't change the culture and attitude myself. I'm conflicted, as this only seems to be an issue with a year group who reinforce each others' behaviour and are ones whose behaviour was poor when they were younger, and this is their first full year back in school since lockdown.

AIBU to think I need to work in a school where I look like the pupils?

OP posts:
ThrallsWife · 22/01/2023 10:20

bagelbagelbagel · 22/01/2023 10:03

I agree, but you have to also hold in your mind that they are children and their brains aren't fully developed. I had a (white female) student that used to shout 'Shit teacher!' at me, for a whole term. I had to breathe and remember that she was 15, from a chaotic background and her brain was a mess of hormones and trauma.

She got the best of me every lesson despite the abuse. By the end of the year she was saying 'Hi Miss!' when she came into class.

Yes, those examples exist, but that's not what the OP is talking about. She is talking about an inherent culture across a whole group of students, not just individuals.

And even in my school with highly misogynist and openly racist students there were a small handful who were the sweetest, politest young men you could imagine.

It was, however, the bigger picture with so many students for whom I was trash by the simple fact of being white, non-Muslim, with child and unmarried as a woman that stuck and was more than just a few isolated individuals. It was an inherent culture.

That doesn't just happen with Muslims, by the way. I spent some time in Japan, where a very similar hierarchy applied and where, as an unmarried, young woman, I had far less say than my male, older or married counterparts.

PedantScorner · 22/01/2023 10:17

NeverDropYourMooncup · 21/01/2023 23:21

You're seriously posting that you want to work in a school that has more white children because you can't teach Muslim boys?

Not RTFT but the OP doesn't mention muslim boys. I live in a multicultural area and misogyny doesn't appear to be confined to race, religion, sex or skin colour.
It is usually excused by 'It's their culture'.

bagelbagelbagel · 22/01/2023 10:03

ThrallsWife · 22/01/2023 09:57

You are the problem. You're sensitised to the differences. If anything you should change jobs because you are probably teaching in a bias way that you're not cognisant of.

When kids are literally saying to your face "I don't have to listen to you because you're a woman" or "Unmarried women are (insert native word for worthless bitch here)" or "You're not [my religion] so I don't have to listen to you", which have all happened to me, and I am considered a very strong teacher, that bias is definitely not coming from the teacher, but the children who have grown up with that attitude in mind.

I agree, but you have to also hold in your mind that they are children and their brains aren't fully developed. I had a (white female) student that used to shout 'Shit teacher!' at me, for a whole term. I had to breathe and remember that she was 15, from a chaotic background and her brain was a mess of hormones and trauma.

She got the best of me every lesson despite the abuse. By the end of the year she was saying 'Hi Miss!' when she came into class.

ThrallsWife · 22/01/2023 09:57

You are the problem. You're sensitised to the differences. If anything you should change jobs because you are probably teaching in a bias way that you're not cognisant of.

When kids are literally saying to your face "I don't have to listen to you because you're a woman" or "Unmarried women are (insert native word for worthless bitch here)" or "You're not [my religion] so I don't have to listen to you", which have all happened to me, and I am considered a very strong teacher, that bias is definitely not coming from the teacher, but the children who have grown up with that attitude in mind.

BabyOnBoard90 · 22/01/2023 09:52

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

bagelbagelbagel · 22/01/2023 09:49

I worked in a school like this (East London) and my experience was very different to yours, possibly because the headteacher was a woman, and SLT mixed.

There were three non-Muslim teachers in our dept, I was one of them, and it never felt alienating. We went out for coffee and cake, meals out, shisha. We laughed a LOT, all felt safe taking the piss out of each other too.

Very occasionally I would encounter an older boy who would try to undermine me, but I was able to put him in his place pretty quickly, reminding him that I was there to do a job and that job was to help him, so he would be very silly to put himself in a position to deny himself that help.

I always found Year 9 girls infinitely more terrifying than Year 11 boys!

HappyFannyPetrow · 22/01/2023 09:45

Disagree that it’s not cultural - it clearly is. We are all very much aware there are parts of the world where women are treated as second class citizens and the cycle is perpetuated by children being raised thinking that it’s normal. It’s the school’s responsibility to put in place measures to remedy this very early on, encouraging mutual respect and tolerance from the day the kids enter reception.

If the SLT don’t take your concerns seriously I’d walk, and tell them exactly why.

Untitledsquatboulder · 22/01/2023 09:37

OP have you posted about this before? I can remember 3 threads since September from a female teacher struggling to teach Muslim boys. If it is you, why keep posting but not finding a new job?

ScrollingLeaves · 22/01/2023 09:35

It sounds as though the school has a dreadful discipline policy. There are some London schools with excellent discipline with this cultural group I think.

Beware that a school with a different demographic could also be like this - you see them written about on Mumsnet. So check out any school you move to very thoroughly.

Lilgamesh2 · 22/01/2023 09:33

@PeachDelany Right. But she clearly says that the children have a hierarchy that determines how they choose to respect teachers - and that hierarchy is based around sex and race (or religion).

Explaining it all away by "teacher weakness" is a bit harsh.

The children are at fault here, and any adult that ignores their attitudes (eg other male teachers who could help address it, plus their parents and communities if they encourage it). I don't think we should blame the individual female teacher for being weak as she is facing such an uphill battle to change this, it's basically impossible.

TempsPerdu · 22/01/2023 09:29

People will slate you, but this is a thing. I worked in a school where there were examples of what you say and some parents absolutely looked down on women like me

It absolutely is a thing, and I’ve experienced it myself as a teacher at primary level - boys openly telling me that they won’t take instruction from ‘women like you’, and little support from male dominated SLT. It was incredibly challenging with a class of 10 year olds, let alone at secondary level, so you have my sympathy OP.

A no nonsense, take no prisoners approach helps as a temporary measure but ultimately (barring a huge shake up of SLT) I suspect that you may well need to find a different setting. I did, and my own well-being was a hundred times better for it.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 22/01/2023 09:28

Sometimeswinning · 21/01/2023 23:33

No she wants to teach children who respect others. That's OK. Not sure where you work. I doubt it's a school 🤣

You'd be wrong, then.

Could the OP put on her application for a new school that she is interested in the role because she's looking for more white faces or ask at interview 'how many Muslim boys do you have here and can I not have to teach them?'?

Or does that make it a little clearer?

PeachDelany · 22/01/2023 09:22

Lilgamesh2 · 22/01/2023 09:14

Being white and female isn't a weakness.

It's about respect

Quinoawoman · 22/01/2023 09:17

2023bebetter · 22/01/2023 08:36

Strange how because male SLT are treated with respect others are ignored

I think this is the crux of the matter.

I don't necessarily think it's the cultural differences that are the problem here - more likely to be how the school is being run. As the SLT are all men, they are not being mistreated and are therefore blind to the issues and are doing nothing to tackle the misogyny that is present in the school. They could and should be doing a lot more to support their staff.

I think you do need to move school, but don't be afraid to apply to jobs where there is a high % of pupils from non white backgrounds. Just do your research and talk to female staff members, go on a tour and see how female staff members are treated etc.

Lilgamesh2 · 22/01/2023 09:14

PeachDelany · 22/01/2023 09:09

Children have an antenna for any sign of weakness. I'll never forget being in a class that was close to a riot because the teacher couldn't command the respect of the boys. She ran out in tears and brought the (male)(authoritarian) head in and there was instant silence and obedience.

Being white and female isn't a weakness.

PeachDelany · 22/01/2023 09:09

Children have an antenna for any sign of weakness. I'll never forget being in a class that was close to a riot because the teacher couldn't command the respect of the boys. She ran out in tears and brought the (male)(authoritarian) head in and there was instant silence and obedience.

Lilgamesh2 · 22/01/2023 09:07

This is depressing. Can't believe we have let our country get into this state.

Anyway I agree with others - you can't change it, as from the sounds of it there are too many boys with those attitudes in your school. If you would be happier at a different school then go for it.

turquoisegem · 22/01/2023 09:02

Racism was part of a culture until it was forced out of people and made socially unacceptable.
Now misogyny is part of a culture and needs to be forced out using the same tactics.
Until there's a serious consequence to it people won't have to change their behaviour.

PupInAPram · 22/01/2023 09:01

@turquoisegem SLT = Senior Leadership Team.

ThrallsWife · 22/01/2023 08:57

OP I worked in a school like this. As an unmarried white woman with a child I was lower than scum to some of these kids and they made no effort hiding the fact. I had threats on my life and that of my (at that point) toddler child, had sexual comments made numerous times, sneering and leering were commonplace and I recognise the hierarchy you spoke of in exactly that order.

I stuck around for a few years and it did improve, as it always does when you have known Y11 students from when they were teensy in Y7, but some of the ingrained attitudes will never change and please don't kid yourself that as an individual you cannot change that. A strict no-nonsense attitude and generally not taking any shit helps, as does a record book, where you can then quote the exact things said to you back to the parents on the phone that day. Most are embarrassed on their children's behalf, if only because teachers are meant to be respected in their culture.

What's interesting is that, now I work in a mixed sex and mixed ethnicities school, the girls from that culture especially seem to respect me more for standing my ground.

RedHelenB · 22/01/2023 08:56

Melte · 21/01/2023 23:06

I completely accept it's circumstances and culture, not inherently their skin colour, but I fear that they don't see it that way, and think I'm beneath them partly because of mine.

Why would you even think of threatening to tell someone at their place of worship about their behaviour? Seems odd to me.
I'd just stick to whatever behaviour codes you have in the school. Rise above it, if they see they're getting to you then they'll carry on with
that behaviour.

Greenfairydust · 22/01/2023 08:53

Leave.

Because I assume the school management know full well this is happening and are not willing to challenge it.

Quite a few really naive comments about how this has nothing to do with culture and religion.

Of course it does.

Some religions/cultures still see women as inferior beings that should always obey men. So of course that is going to lead to issues as it normalises misogyny.

I would also consider reporting what is happening in the school to Ofsted if this is something that female staff are regularly subjected to.

monkeysmum21 · 22/01/2023 08:51

Think about your own mental health and find a better job.

Unfortunately, prejudges hardly ever comes one by one: misogynist, racism, accentism, etc tend to come all in one pack. The sad thing is the grass is not necessary greener on the other side of the fence. I’ve work in very selective private school and you see the same although it is expressed in a subtle way.
Good luck

turquoisegem · 22/01/2023 08:48

What's SLT an abbreviation for please?

2023bebetter · 22/01/2023 08:36

Strange how because male SLT are treated with respect others are ignored

Swipe left for the next trending thread