Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to make an insurance claim against my sisters in laws?

116 replies

Jellywellyfish · 21/01/2023 22:18

This isn’t directly from me, but writing on their behalf for some honest opinions.

So, some time ago my mum got bitten by a dog which was owned by my sisters in laws. It was a very bad bite, and my mum (in her early 80s) had two big open wounds (15cm wide) and 48 puncture wounds and was taken to hospital by ambulance . The said dog was a rescue pit cross (but sister lives in country where these dogs aren’t banned) and also had a history of being a dangerous dog biting other animals and people. Dog not muzzled when my mum visited the house, and she did not know dog had previously bitten another human. She didn’t believe there was any reason to not trust the dog, but at a family gathering the dog randomly went for her biting her leg.

She was on holiday visiting my sister at the time so it basically ruined her trip and left her traumatised and post holiday she had 8+ visits to docs and hospital for checks, secondary infection, swellings etc and struggled to walk on it for months. Almost a year later it’s healed mostly but left a big dent in her leg and still causes frequent pain due to nerve damage and she can’t sleep very well. Sadly, my mum who always loved dogs is now petrified of big dogs and gets really stressed if dogs are off leads in park etc and will actively avoid parks now.

3/4 months after trip she told my sister she was going to make an insurance claim as she could claim for travel expenses and medical supplies such as bandages etc she’d had to buy over the weeks and months. She was okay with this and sent her details of hospitals she attended etc.

When the claim went through a letter was sent from a solicitor at the travel insurance company to my sisters in laws detailing what the claim was for and to request their insurance details to process a claim if there was one. This is when it hit the fan.

My sister rang my mum screaming at her asking why she got solicitors involved it was supposed to be a straight forward claim but there stuff in the claim about lack of enjoyment and that couldn’t be true as she had a good time. She said my mum had to drop the case immediately and she should have never got a solicitor involved. My mum said she didn’t actively get solicitors involved she’s just doing what insurance company says and confirmed she didn’t write the letter or tell them to put that detail in, but asked why it shouldn’t be included in the claim as it’s true.

This has caused a massive rift as my sister thinks the claim should be dropped- it’s leaving her in a very awkward position with her partner and in laws and the repercussions on her in laws. Her partner now refuses to ever speak to my mum again as they think what she’s doing is totally uncalled for. So this means my mum can never go over to see my sister again as my sisters partner will not allow it. But my sister now also says if my mum proceeds with the case she will never speak to her again.

My mum understands that it puts my sister in an awkward position but doesn’t understand why my sister can’t stay impartial enough to speak to her. My mum feels strongly like she would like to see the claim through as the whole thing genuinely affected her in a physical and mental capacity. But she also desperately wants to keep speaking to her daughter.

So, is my mum being unreasonable for pursuing an insurance claim against my sisters in laws? Or should she drop the claim out of principle because they are my sisters family?

OP posts:
PuppaDontPreach · 22/01/2023 05:33

Your poor mum. Of course she’s not being unreasonable.

Your sister is being appalling. The dog should have been PTS. Your sister should try to get her head around the basics of how an insurance claim works in this situation and why it requires solicitors to be involved. Her family member just needs to pass everything on to their insurance company. .

BumpySkull · 22/01/2023 04:57

Your DM is not being unreasonable at all. Everyone saying that you can’t make a claim against a relative and expect it to be the same - that’s because, if you’ve reached the point of having to claim because they’re such self-centred bastards that they expect you to suffer for their incredible stupidity and nastiness, the relationship is already dead and buried. It doesn’t mean that if you drop the claim then they’ll stop being genuinely and truly disgraceful people. The relationship between DM and the in-laws is dead either way and it was dead from the second that they allowed DM to be mauled and didn’t even think she deserved them to pay for a damn bandage!

Your sister is either a nasty arsehole too or she’s being manipulated and controlled. No genuinely decent person thinks that anyone should be mauled by a dog and that they just carry on as if nothing happened. She could have been killed. Are you able to speak to your sister without her husband there or nearby or overhearing and ask her what her genuine opinion is here? Your sister is choosing to protect her in-laws who are entirely in the wrong over your mother who is entirely in the right - that’s either because she’s a horrible person or because she’s not allowed her own opinion.

I hope to hell that the dog was destroyed and that your sister hasn’t got children anywhere near these dangerous people.

theGooHasGone · 22/01/2023 04:32

It sounds like maybe the mum didn't fully appreciate what was going to happen when she submitted the insurance claim, but it's a moot point because if the sister's in-laws had done the right thing and paid her costs in the first place (with pressure applied from the sister and her husband) then this would never have been an issue. Yes, this could technically be classed as an "accident", but it's a breed of dog which is known to be dangerous and the owners are legally liable.

As others have said the dog owners should be absolutely mortified. If I were them I'd be rushing to settle out of court before this gets out of hand.

Aprilx · 22/01/2023 04:17

I also cannot make head nor tail of who is involved in this, sister, sister in law, multiple sister in laws, but I think it is besides the point.

It sounds like a truly horrendous incident and I think your mother deserves to be compensated. But at the same time, I don’t think anyone can sue a family member (which is effectively what she is doing) and expect relations to be the same afterwards. She does rightly or wrongly need to make that choice.

Truthfully, I would choose my daughter over bandages and travel costs. And I don’t in any way mean to minimise what she has been through, but will a bit of money really help. I would be more interested in ensuring that the animal is destroyed to be honest.

Summerfun54321 · 22/01/2023 04:14

If I was the mum in this scenario, I wouldn't be talking to the daughter anyway after she allowed her dog to do this. That dog needs to be destroyed.

Mumtobabyhavoc · 22/01/2023 03:32

Your elderly mother deserves to be fully compensated for any and all damages.
That dog needs to be destroyed.
Family should be mortified at what occured.

theGooHasGone · 22/01/2023 03:31

Did the in-laws even offer to pay the medical bills and deal with the aftermath at the time? It's obviously awkward when a family member gets injured by a pet, but even the hardest-hearted dog owner would have to admit that if your dog bites someone unprompted, you are responsible for it.

If they didn't give a shit at the time, they certainly will now...

Killingmytime · 22/01/2023 03:13

No your mom should not drop the claim. Nerve damage is a bitch ( from personal experience!)
i love animals, I believe a lot of the time it’s the owner/experience the animal’s had.
this poor dog has been through a lot, however it’s not your mom’s fault.
this IS a dangerous dog, ( this dog).
i hope there are no kids in the house.
i think your sister is being manipulated into getting your mom to drop it.
she shouldn’t though.

Fraaahnces · 22/01/2023 03:04

Sister can get fucked. Who cares about her relationship with her in-laws atm? They brought a vicious dog into her home that attacked her elderly mum. Why hasn’t she lost her rag?

pelargoniums · 22/01/2023 03:04

Your mum should keep pursuing the claim. She’s not causing the rift; the mad dog owners are.

Glorianna · 22/01/2023 02:18

It’s the sister’s husband’s family’s dog.

OP, your sister and her husband have well and truly shown their true colours.

Please support your mum in making the claim.

It’s very telling that neither your sister’s husband or his family have offered your mum any recompense, they just want her to drop the claim and lose money. What utter bastards to upset a woman in her 80s, especially as their dog attacked your mum.

Womencanlift · 22/01/2023 00:32

Like other pp’s it’s a bit hard to follow who is involved and who owns the dog but regardless your mum is not being unreasonable in the slightest

The dog should be destroyed, the owners should face consequences for allowing their dog to injure another and your sister should realise that her mum is so much more important than a dog and should be doing everything she can to make your mum comfortable after being injured like that at her age

Smineusername · 21/01/2023 23:58

It's her sister's in laws

StillWantingADog · 21/01/2023 23:50

I really can’t understand if the claim is against your
sister
sister in law
sisters in law
sister’s inlaws?

2023WeAllNeedToTalk · 21/01/2023 23:44

It sounds a difficult situation.
would the in-laws settle out of court? Are they willing to compensate your mum? And would your mum accept that? If they could come to a settlement away from the courts it would probably be better for family relations.
However, the upset it must be causing your mum that the in-laws are being prioritised over her health and well-being must be awful.
They should be angry that the dog attacked your mum rather than mentally attacking her by cutting her off if she seeks justice. The dog really should be put down too as it could attack even worse in the future.

HollaHolla · 21/01/2023 23:37

I don’t think your mum is being unreasonable ; but finding it a bit hard to follow, as can’t work out if it’s your sister, sister in law (singular), or sisters in law (plural). Just that, if it’s her daughter, then it might be easier to resolve, than if it’s her son/daughter’s partner (which might need more intervention.)

FeinCuroxiVooz · 21/01/2023 23:36

if your sil has insurance then its not going to cost her for the claim to go through, so why should she care?

if sil didn't have insurance then she may have misunderstood the process. your mum will have held travel insurance. making a claim against that insurance doesn't just trigger a payout with no further consequences. that insurance claim triggers for the insurance company to identify the person or persons responsible for the incident and the insurance company launches the legal case to sue them for the full cost of the claim. if the person being sued has insurance against the liability then typically the two insurance companies will have a formula to agree an appropriate way to apportion things so that they can settle and don't actually have to go through the court process, but otherwise the suit will go ahead.

Whoknowswhatanymore · 21/01/2023 23:32

Bookkeys · 21/01/2023 23:01

Depends if your mum wants a rift between herself and her daughter for what is effectively the last year's of her life, is it worth it?

I do hope the dog was dealt with so it can't harm anymore people or animals

This ^^

Mabelface · 21/01/2023 23:27

The travel insurance company will state in their terms and conditions that they have the right to approach the third party in order to recover their costs. It's called subrogation.

SisterCassandra · 21/01/2023 23:20

They’re not behaving much like family are they? Do you think perhaps they’re not insured to cause this furore? I totally disagree with people who say an insurance claim is always going to wreck a relationship. My daughter was injured in a property open to the public and owned by friends as a child. As an adult she still has scars. We claimed on insurance on her behalf and are still friends with the owners who totally understood their responsibility. Claiming on insurance shouldn’t be taken personally, it’s not a declaration of war, it’s just what insurance is for, to at least partially recompense for a loss. I feel very sorry for your mother who has suffered damage likely to last her all her life and pressure or not I do not understand how her own daughter can behave like this. Your mother is morally right to pursue this claim. Surely she would be unable to forget her daughters attitude and attempt at blackmail even if she drops it now, the damage to that relationship is already done.

DaveyJonesLocker · 21/01/2023 23:18

God that sounds like a horrific attack. I hope the dog was pts? I'd be more concerned about reporting the dangerous dog than claiming on insurance.

Is it a claim on her own insurance or is the money coming from SIL. Its a really difficult situation but if my mum was attacked by someone's dog she would be the last person I'd be mad at.

FlamingoCroquet · 21/01/2023 23:08

After the attack did your sister and her husband do everything possible to look after your mother, pay for her medical expenses, try to make up for this horrible ordeal? If not, they should be ashamed of themselves and be willing to compensate her.

Tilllly · 21/01/2023 23:08

Does your sister have children? Anywhere near this dog?

Your poor mum. She shld carry on and your sister shld save her fury for the in-laws with a savage animal

Chickychoccyegg · 21/01/2023 23:08

As I understand it this is your sisters sil's dog? Why on earth is your sister preferring to protect her sil rather than her own dm? Her dh also sounds awful, is she in an abusive relationship?
Your dm should continue with her claim, it sounds an awful attack , from a very dangerous dog

Guavafish1 · 21/01/2023 23:07

Also some insurances don't cover certain dogs.

Swipe left for the next trending thread