Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to make an insurance claim against my sisters in laws?

116 replies

Jellywellyfish · 21/01/2023 22:18

This isn’t directly from me, but writing on their behalf for some honest opinions.

So, some time ago my mum got bitten by a dog which was owned by my sisters in laws. It was a very bad bite, and my mum (in her early 80s) had two big open wounds (15cm wide) and 48 puncture wounds and was taken to hospital by ambulance . The said dog was a rescue pit cross (but sister lives in country where these dogs aren’t banned) and also had a history of being a dangerous dog biting other animals and people. Dog not muzzled when my mum visited the house, and she did not know dog had previously bitten another human. She didn’t believe there was any reason to not trust the dog, but at a family gathering the dog randomly went for her biting her leg.

She was on holiday visiting my sister at the time so it basically ruined her trip and left her traumatised and post holiday she had 8+ visits to docs and hospital for checks, secondary infection, swellings etc and struggled to walk on it for months. Almost a year later it’s healed mostly but left a big dent in her leg and still causes frequent pain due to nerve damage and she can’t sleep very well. Sadly, my mum who always loved dogs is now petrified of big dogs and gets really stressed if dogs are off leads in park etc and will actively avoid parks now.

3/4 months after trip she told my sister she was going to make an insurance claim as she could claim for travel expenses and medical supplies such as bandages etc she’d had to buy over the weeks and months. She was okay with this and sent her details of hospitals she attended etc.

When the claim went through a letter was sent from a solicitor at the travel insurance company to my sisters in laws detailing what the claim was for and to request their insurance details to process a claim if there was one. This is when it hit the fan.

My sister rang my mum screaming at her asking why she got solicitors involved it was supposed to be a straight forward claim but there stuff in the claim about lack of enjoyment and that couldn’t be true as she had a good time. She said my mum had to drop the case immediately and she should have never got a solicitor involved. My mum said she didn’t actively get solicitors involved she’s just doing what insurance company says and confirmed she didn’t write the letter or tell them to put that detail in, but asked why it shouldn’t be included in the claim as it’s true.

This has caused a massive rift as my sister thinks the claim should be dropped- it’s leaving her in a very awkward position with her partner and in laws and the repercussions on her in laws. Her partner now refuses to ever speak to my mum again as they think what she’s doing is totally uncalled for. So this means my mum can never go over to see my sister again as my sisters partner will not allow it. But my sister now also says if my mum proceeds with the case she will never speak to her again.

My mum understands that it puts my sister in an awkward position but doesn’t understand why my sister can’t stay impartial enough to speak to her. My mum feels strongly like she would like to see the claim through as the whole thing genuinely affected her in a physical and mental capacity. But she also desperately wants to keep speaking to her daughter.

So, is my mum being unreasonable for pursuing an insurance claim against my sisters in laws? Or should she drop the claim out of principle because they are my sisters family?

OP posts:
XelaM · 22/01/2023 11:35

ChangedmynameagainforChristmas · 22/01/2023 11:32

I am a dog lover. A lifelong devotee if you like. I have always owned dogs and admired most breeds.
If this were my mum and she had been bitten like this and it were my dog that had inflicted the wounds I would have taken the animal and had it pts myself for the sake of everyone concerned including the dog.

The dog was already taken away and PTS

XelaM · 22/01/2023 11:34

For the sake of a few hundred pounds which as I understand your mum spent on taxis and dressing in the UK, I would not ruin my relationship with my daughter or cause her problems with her in-laws when she's abroad with just her in-laws as family.

The cost of the cruise your mum could have claimed on her travel insurance.

ChangedmynameagainforChristmas · 22/01/2023 11:32

I am a dog lover. A lifelong devotee if you like. I have always owned dogs and admired most breeds.
If this were my mum and she had been bitten like this and it were my dog that had inflicted the wounds I would have taken the animal and had it pts myself for the sake of everyone concerned including the dog.

silverclock222 · 22/01/2023 11:27

Awk · 21/01/2023 22:42

I cant ever see a situation where a family member puts an insurance claim and solicitors against another family member, and the relationship carrying on as normal.

Your Mum just needs to decide which one means the most to her, and pursue whichever one that is (the claim or the relationship).

Agree, money or daughter.

Jellywellyfish · 22/01/2023 11:23

LIZS · 22/01/2023 11:06

She could have claimed on her travel insurance. But she chose not to on their say-so? I don't think she would get flight cost back, it is only to put her in same position and she flew there and back.

No you’re right, although she included the flight in the claim they have said she took the flights so she can’t be reimbursed. The cruise is hopeful.
my mum is 82 and was quite frankly traumatised when this happened (I spoke to her daily after it happened and she was crying and quite inconsolable) and it was all quite a lot for her to deal with and she trusted what she was being told to do. As her family back in the UK we had never experienced anything like this before and trusted my sister would ensure they were doing all they could do make her trip home comfortable.

OP posts:
Blueberrywitch · 22/01/2023 11:10

It sounds like your sister isn’t in a very good position, with a family who own a dog who attacks humans and a partner who will ban her mum from visiting her. Sounds like an awful unsafe situation for her.

LIZS · 22/01/2023 11:06

She could have claimed on her travel insurance. But she chose not to on their say-so? I don't think she would get flight cost back, it is only to put her in same position and she flew there and back.

MeinKraft · 22/01/2023 11:01

The smiths paid for the medical bills etc and I guess they did all that in the hope they wouldn't have the stress of letters from solicitors and insurance companies dropping on their doormat. Yeah your mum might be within her rights to take this action but it's not something I would do against family.

Jellywellyfish · 22/01/2023 10:49

MatildaTheCat · 22/01/2023 09:59

I’m going to make a couple of assumptions.

1.The Smiths live is the USA where legal claims can be astronomical.
2.They are not insured.

The chances are they could be ruined by a legal action. Has your sister discussed any of this with you? I think this is absolutely vital in deciding whether the pursue the case or not. If they are insured then this isn’t in any way personal- a bit like claiming for any accident that takes place on the property of another person. If they are not insured then she really will have to choose.

Not easy. Do you have any idea of the value of the claim? Even if it’s relatively modest the legal fees could be extremely high.

My mum asked if they’re insured before she contacted her insurance. They do have insurance which is why she went ahead with it.

they really don’t know but it could in the thousands. But as the smiths are insured it would only effect their premiums from what I understand, so not bankrupt them. My mum would never pursue if that was the case.

OP posts:
Jellywellyfish · 22/01/2023 10:40

blueluce85 · 22/01/2023 09:55

I voted yanbu until I saw that your mum had been reimbursed. Exactly what is she claiming for through insurance...ongoing medical?

Well it’s a bit of a funny one as when it happened the smiths were adamant they paid the medial costs. While there she wanted to ask her insurance if they could upgrad her seat on the flight to business or first to get more leg room so she didn’t have to sit in coach with a bad leg for a long flight but they were all insistent with her that she not touch travel insurance and that’s why they paid for a taxi the other end. she was just a bit bewildered by it all so went along with it. She is claiming for the cost of the flight for a holiday she didn’t get to enjoy as this happened four days into her 2.5 week trip. She and my sister were also supposed to go on a cruise while she was there which my mum paid for which obviously couldn’t happen either. She basically spent three weeks in an apartment recovering so she was well enough and the wound in a stable enough state to fly home. There were also 5/6 trips to the hospital after coming home, so around £120s worth of taxis and medical supplies for dressing the wound x3 times a day (with dog bites they basically leave the wound open as bacteria can thrive so has to be left to weep and is very messy) and also some private physio as the wait list was astronomical and given her age she didn’t want to wait as she wants to ensure she stays mobile. She is also following up with counselling but that is via nhs as this time. She has said she will reimburse the medical expenses if the claim was successful. Also the claim will sort of future proof her for future problems which may arise from it so she could go private rather than wait for the nhs.

OP posts:
Blort · 22/01/2023 10:09

Its insurance to insurance, no idea why your sister is taking it so personally??

honeylulu · 22/01/2023 10:07

so why is there an insurance claim when everything was reimbursed?

Depends what else the travel insurer covered - further medical treatment/consultations after the initial stages perhaps? Nerve damage would require a lot of follow up.

As a PP has said the onward claim was instigated by the insurers selling to recover their outlay from the third party wrongdoers. This is called subrogated recovery and it's in the insurance policy small print that the policyholder must allow it. The insurer/their solicitor has probably asked the mum if she wants to add any uninsured losses to the claim i.e. Compensation for the actual injury (known as general damages) and she probably said yes as the solicitors were doing the recovery claim anyway. THAT is the only bit that the mum has authority to drop. If she drops the uninsured loss element of the claim the subrogated claim will still continue - it won't all go away. If the Smith dog insurance includes liability cover then the two insurers just deal with each other.

The in laws sound appalling and your sister's husband controlling. Your mum has nothing to feel bad for though it's sad she's effectively been cut off from your sister because of the bloody dog attack! I think all you and she can do is let your sister know you are there for her if she needs you.

cheercaptain · 22/01/2023 10:07

Your mum is not being unreasonable. She is in the right to claim. If she goes ahead or not, the relationship going forward will still suffer. In her shoes, I will drop the claim but I will also not visit your sister again.

MatildaTheCat · 22/01/2023 09:59

I’m going to make a couple of assumptions.

1.The Smiths live is the USA where legal claims can be astronomical.
2.They are not insured.

The chances are they could be ruined by a legal action. Has your sister discussed any of this with you? I think this is absolutely vital in deciding whether the pursue the case or not. If they are insured then this isn’t in any way personal- a bit like claiming for any accident that takes place on the property of another person. If they are not insured then she really will have to choose.

Not easy. Do you have any idea of the value of the claim? Even if it’s relatively modest the legal fees could be extremely high.

Can2022getanyworse · 22/01/2023 09:59

Clymene · 21/01/2023 22:41

The dog should be insured. It's not your mum's problem if it isn't.

The fog should be PTS.

XelaM · 22/01/2023 09:56

They sound like terrible dog-owners BUT I completely understand why they are pissed off with the insurance claim if they had paid your mum's medical bills plus taxi/trainers already. If I were your mum, a relationship with my daughter would be more important to me than a bit of extra money.

blueluce85 · 22/01/2023 09:55

I voted yanbu until I saw that your mum had been reimbursed. Exactly what is she claiming for through insurance...ongoing medical?

StillWantingADog · 22/01/2023 09:52

@LIZS
no wonder the inlaws are miffed if they paid everything in full then have an insurance claim against them for the same costs!!!!

LIZS · 22/01/2023 09:50

StillWantingADog · 22/01/2023 09:44

Op you write
Immediately after it happened my sister’s inlaws paid the medical bills at the hospital so my mum wouldn’t have to be out of pocket for this. They also brought my mum some new trainers as hers filled with blood, and they paid £150 for a taxi from the airport in the UK to her house as my mum was fretting about an 8 hour flight and then a four hour bus journey when she landed in the UK- she was travelling alone

so why is there an insurance claim when everything was reimbursed?

What is she claiming for if she is not out of pocket? They may not have contacted her directly but presumably your sister gave updates on her recovery.

LadyGAgain · 22/01/2023 09:46

I think the fact that the dog wasn't destroyed after it had bitten A CHILD lends itself to their character. Sue the hell out of them. If your sister is unable to understand that it's not personal - it's one insurance company paying another (in this case The Smiths who didn't bother to insure their dangerous dog) then she's really not very bright.

StillWantingADog · 22/01/2023 09:44

Op you write
Immediately after it happened my sister’s inlaws paid the medical bills at the hospital so my mum wouldn’t have to be out of pocket for this. They also brought my mum some new trainers as hers filled with blood, and they paid £150 for a taxi from the airport in the UK to her house as my mum was fretting about an 8 hour flight and then a four hour bus journey when she landed in the UK- she was travelling alone

so why is there an insurance claim when everything was reimbursed?

Awk · 22/01/2023 09:42

Even if your mum dropped the claim the relationship is likely dead and buried anyway, so she should pursue the claim.

DingDongDenny · 22/01/2023 09:37

Firstly, thank goodness the dog was destroyed, but the Smiths really need to take responsibility since it had already bitten a child. The fact they didn't tell your mum, or more sensibly keep the dog away from guests was really negligent

The other thing I've taken from your update is that your sister sounds like she is possibly in an abusive relationship and her DH is controlling her and undermining her relationships. Although your mum is perfectly in her rights to pursue the compensation, if I was her I'd be more worried about your sister and her having somewhere to go if she ever decides to leave

Jellywellyfish · 22/01/2023 08:47

To clear a few things up due to my terrible grammar!

  • dog belonged to my sister’s inlaws (her partner’s parents). For sake of confusion I will call her inlaws ‘The Smiths’
  • The Smiths had owned the dog for approx 8/9 months prior to this but it had already attacked a dog and a child at their home (bit the child’s leg and said child had to be taken to hospital in ambulance also). My mum did not know it had attacked a child prior. The dog was taken away by the fire brigade who attended the scene as they could see on their records the dog had bitten someone before so they removed the dog and it was destroyed.
  • My sister’s relationship with her partner is a bit of an odd one. They have been together for 12 years or so but bizarrely myself or my family do not have any kind of relationship with her partner (just more polite/amicable) - we do feel as though there is manipulation going on as any friends my sister had have gone. She has no one but her partner and their small group of friends. They got married without telling anyone, not even me and I’m very very close to my sister.
  • The dog is insured by The Smiths and although a pit cross the country where they live don’t deem them dangerous breeds although you cannot legally own the breed in the UK.
  • The Smiths have not suggested they will settle out of court but when they realised my mum had raised a claim they offered to buy her a flight to see my sister and asked in return for my mum to drop the claim
  • I am very close to my sister and have been talking to her all the way through. I have tried to help her see things from my mums point of view but there is absolutely no telling her. She’s mortified my mum has done this to her inlaws and I suspect that is because she’s in another country and her partner and her in laws are the only people she has in her life. Read into that what you will. My sister has also said if I agree with my mum then she will stop speaking to me. I have said that her choice to not speak to our mum is hers to take and I will continue to have a relationship with both her and my mum. She is upset that it means she can’t come home anymore and she blames my mum for this because my mum has an opportunity to drop the case but won’t
  • I agree that my mum should have given my sister a heads up about the letter which was going to be sent to her inlaws. They would have still been unhappy but she should have been transparent.
  • Immediately after it happened my sister’s inlaws paid the medical bills at the hospital so my mum wouldn’t have to be out of pocket for this. They also brought my mum some new trainers as hers filled with blood, and they paid £150 for a taxi from the airport in the UK to her house as my mum was fretting about an 8 hour flight and then a four hour bus journey when she landed in the UK- she was travelling alone.
  • Sadly, once my mum had left the county my sister’s partner nor her inlaws failed to make any contact with my mum to see how she was. Not in the days/weeks or months afterwards. I think it may have been a case of out of sight out of mind but my sister has since said they were embarrassed about what had happened which is why they didn’t reach out.
  • I think my mum was a bit naive and didn’t quite realise how complicated this would get and how legal it might become. I think she genuinely felt she deserved some compensation for the taxis she had to pay for to get too and from hospital when she was home as it wasn’t her fault.
OP posts:
2023bebetter · 22/01/2023 07:18

Pathetic response..."she must have had a good time here.

Tell them to grow up it's not personal