Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to make an insurance claim against my sisters in laws?

116 replies

Jellywellyfish · 21/01/2023 22:18

This isn’t directly from me, but writing on their behalf for some honest opinions.

So, some time ago my mum got bitten by a dog which was owned by my sisters in laws. It was a very bad bite, and my mum (in her early 80s) had two big open wounds (15cm wide) and 48 puncture wounds and was taken to hospital by ambulance . The said dog was a rescue pit cross (but sister lives in country where these dogs aren’t banned) and also had a history of being a dangerous dog biting other animals and people. Dog not muzzled when my mum visited the house, and she did not know dog had previously bitten another human. She didn’t believe there was any reason to not trust the dog, but at a family gathering the dog randomly went for her biting her leg.

She was on holiday visiting my sister at the time so it basically ruined her trip and left her traumatised and post holiday she had 8+ visits to docs and hospital for checks, secondary infection, swellings etc and struggled to walk on it for months. Almost a year later it’s healed mostly but left a big dent in her leg and still causes frequent pain due to nerve damage and she can’t sleep very well. Sadly, my mum who always loved dogs is now petrified of big dogs and gets really stressed if dogs are off leads in park etc and will actively avoid parks now.

3/4 months after trip she told my sister she was going to make an insurance claim as she could claim for travel expenses and medical supplies such as bandages etc she’d had to buy over the weeks and months. She was okay with this and sent her details of hospitals she attended etc.

When the claim went through a letter was sent from a solicitor at the travel insurance company to my sisters in laws detailing what the claim was for and to request their insurance details to process a claim if there was one. This is when it hit the fan.

My sister rang my mum screaming at her asking why she got solicitors involved it was supposed to be a straight forward claim but there stuff in the claim about lack of enjoyment and that couldn’t be true as she had a good time. She said my mum had to drop the case immediately and she should have never got a solicitor involved. My mum said she didn’t actively get solicitors involved she’s just doing what insurance company says and confirmed she didn’t write the letter or tell them to put that detail in, but asked why it shouldn’t be included in the claim as it’s true.

This has caused a massive rift as my sister thinks the claim should be dropped- it’s leaving her in a very awkward position with her partner and in laws and the repercussions on her in laws. Her partner now refuses to ever speak to my mum again as they think what she’s doing is totally uncalled for. So this means my mum can never go over to see my sister again as my sisters partner will not allow it. But my sister now also says if my mum proceeds with the case she will never speak to her again.

My mum understands that it puts my sister in an awkward position but doesn’t understand why my sister can’t stay impartial enough to speak to her. My mum feels strongly like she would like to see the claim through as the whole thing genuinely affected her in a physical and mental capacity. But she also desperately wants to keep speaking to her daughter.

So, is my mum being unreasonable for pursuing an insurance claim against my sisters in laws? Or should she drop the claim out of principle because they are my sisters family?

OP posts:
skyeisthelimit · 22/01/2023 14:49

The whole point of insurance is to cover damages and distress. Some people take these things personally when they shouldn't. The Smiths insurance company will pay out, not the Smiths themselves.

Sacmagique75 · 22/01/2023 14:42

Ah see I can see why you’re frustrated by this as clearly you like to buy and eat certain foods, and equally you don’t want to waste stuff that’s given to you. But honestly? I think YABU. I love it when my FIL occasionally gives us a bag of random crap after his weekly trip to Lidl. It shows he’s thinking of us as he’s going around the supermarket - but then I do like to be thrifty and appreciate the few pounds it saves me.

As you have a baby the way, if you will want future help and input from your MIL, I’d gently suggest you suck it up, be grateful, and chuck away anything you don’t have a use for, or maybe be a bit more vocal about things that would be useful - particularly if she gets pleasure from buying you things- oh next time you’re at ASDA could you grab us XYZ? (Or failing all else invite her over for a meal and feed it straight back to her, maybe that’s her primary motivation for doing it?!)

ancientgran · 22/01/2023 14:34

This is why you have insurance, you hand it over to them (both parties) and let them sort it out. It isn't personal and I don't see why anyone should get upset. Tell your sister to let the insurers do their thing.

theGooHasGone · 22/01/2023 14:34

It's also worth noting that if the dog had attacked a random person in the street, they would still have been in for all this and more. The only alternative is for them to basically hand a blank cheque to the person injured in perpetuity. They're being incredibly cheeky by trying to leverage the relationship and guilt to stop the claim being pursued.

theGooHasGone · 22/01/2023 14:28

This got a bit more complicated based on the updates. It's good that the Smiths paid in the first place (and that the dog was destroyed) but as there's nerve damage and ongoing care involved, I still don't think your mum is in the wrong. The whole point of having insurance is to cover unexpected expenses and provide some level of security.

The fact that they were so against her claiming on insurance in the first place is very suspect. I would speculate that the Smiths and their son (and now your sister) know that the dog's insurance won't cover the event because it had a history of attacking a child - they probably didn't tell the insurance company this in the first place, but it's now on record. As such, the insurance won't pay out and they're left liable. They should have liability cover through their home insurance, but it may result in a whacking great increase to their premiums. Still, it's better than bankruptcy.

None of this is your mum's fault though - the Smiths shouldn't have had the dog in the first place, but then as they did, they should have been honest with the insurance company. If they lied and now their cover is void (or they wouldn't have got cover if they'd been honest) that's totally on them. Would they still be so adamant if the dog had injured one of their nephews/nieces?

Unfortunately your mum is going to have to shoulder the pain of losing communication with her daughter, but that's all she should have to lose here. Your sister is caught in a rough position but none of this is your poor mum's fault - it's a lot more than just a ruined holiday.

LIZS · 22/01/2023 14:25

Did they claim for the cruise cancellation separately? Did dsis have insurance cover?

Squamata · 22/01/2023 14:24

So she doesn't have many out of pocket expenses, it's mainly damages for intangible things like emotional distress?

You might not know that other countries approach this stuff in a very different way, we have the tort of negligence but other countries take a less victim friendly approach.

If it's international, are you sure you can get the money if they refuse to pay up? Is the money coming from in laws or insurance?

JudgeRudy · 22/01/2023 14:20

It's a tricky one but it looks as if the relationship is damaged now so nothing to salvage.
Your mum has suffered terribly and she's out of picket too. Who does SIL think insurers get to investigate and process claims, the office junior? It's about someone being held legally responsible.
Do they actually have insurance for the dog? Can you I insure a dog that has a history of biting? Do they still have the dog?
Sounds to me like they don't have insurance, and they are more concerned about their finacial welfare or the dog (if its still around). That's let your MIL know where her welfare comes in the pecking order.
I'd say the relationship is no longer salvageable. Proceed with the claim.

Dahliasrule · 22/01/2023 14:17

I think she should let it go. The dog has been destroyed, the Smiths paid for the majority of the expenses and she is getting counselling on the NHS. It is not worth a rift with her daughter.
She is out of pocket for the cruise and the taxis. It might be worth discussing that.

bluegreygreen · 22/01/2023 14:13

I'm assuming from the Smiths' perspective they have paid the medical expenses (likely thousands of dollars) and extra travel expenses for OP's mother to travel home more comfortably.

They are now potentially going to be hit with more expense (especially if their insurance company decides not to cover the dog, which is possible) at a time when they thought things were sorted.

I do feel sorry for OP's sister (and concerned for her in that relationship) as she is stuck in the middle, but threatening to go no contact with her mother is not helpful.

pelargoniums · 22/01/2023 14:12

MissMaple82 · 22/01/2023 13:57

Yes I think she is being unreasonable. She's in her 80s! She's not got much time left in life amd her relationship with her daughter should come first over some claim that would cause a rift in any relationship

I think the opposite: 80s and not much time left and that time has been made bloody miserable by this dog, and she’d like compensation for the horror. Nothing stopping her daughter siding with her and supporting her in this.

WhatACarrieon · 22/01/2023 14:03

FeinCuroxiVooz · 21/01/2023 23:36

if your sil has insurance then its not going to cost her for the claim to go through, so why should she care?

if sil didn't have insurance then she may have misunderstood the process. your mum will have held travel insurance. making a claim against that insurance doesn't just trigger a payout with no further consequences. that insurance claim triggers for the insurance company to identify the person or persons responsible for the incident and the insurance company launches the legal case to sue them for the full cost of the claim. if the person being sued has insurance against the liability then typically the two insurance companies will have a formula to agree an appropriate way to apportion things so that they can settle and don't actually have to go through the court process, but otherwise the suit will go ahead.

Yes this is what I was thinking:

1- Mum claims travel insurance
2 - Travel insurance pays out £X
3 - Travel insurance claims £X from liable party
4 - If liable party have insurance (pet insurance policy may cover it; might be some other Personal Legal Protection policy) then the two insurance companies either agree together, or liable party settles with Travel Insurance and recharges Own Insurance Cover
5 - If Liable Party have no cover, they pay Travel Insurance settlement out of pocket

6 - the breed is not banned in the country, but is there a rule that such "registered incidents" that lead to civil or criminal action are reported and can cause repercussions for the animal, and they're also concerned about that?

7 - If sister lives abroad with DH and his family network, threats to be cut off in certain ways from home (Mum banned from visiting) but also probably pushed out in the cold there as well aren't going to help her behave rationally

Suggest you get really clear understanding of each issue at hand. YANBU claiming the costs from the insurance, but the fall out needs unravelled, understood and considered before all parties can decide the best way forwards

MissMaple82 · 22/01/2023 13:57

Yes I think she is being unreasonable. She's in her 80s! She's not got much time left in life amd her relationship with her daughter should come first over some claim that would cause a rift in any relationship

Greentree1 · 22/01/2023 13:34

Seems like your mother's old age has been ruined by this dog bite, limited mobility, ongoing nerve damage, continuing hospital visits, she will probably never fully recover at her age. Not to mention the mental and emotional trauma. She should get whatever she can from the insurance she will need it for her future care. Absolutely devastating for her. The sister should be begging for forgiveness not trying to blackmail her mother.

welshpolarbear · 22/01/2023 13:27

Guys read the update from op. The dog was PTS by the authorities.

Celinia · 22/01/2023 13:25

This is grim and I can understand your mum wanting to get some reimbursement for a traumatic holiday. But she’s faced with stark choices: pursuit the claim and risk the relationship with the family; or, drop the claim and try to move on. I don’t know what the owners were thinking allowing an unpredictable large dog to mingle around family members? If your mum decides to drop the claim and visit them again , I hope the in laws keep any new dogs away from the house.

stopbeeping · 22/01/2023 13:15

SisterCassandra · 21/01/2023 23:20

They’re not behaving much like family are they? Do you think perhaps they’re not insured to cause this furore? I totally disagree with people who say an insurance claim is always going to wreck a relationship. My daughter was injured in a property open to the public and owned by friends as a child. As an adult she still has scars. We claimed on insurance on her behalf and are still friends with the owners who totally understood their responsibility. Claiming on insurance shouldn’t be taken personally, it’s not a declaration of war, it’s just what insurance is for, to at least partially recompense for a loss. I feel very sorry for your mother who has suffered damage likely to last her all her life and pressure or not I do not understand how her own daughter can behave like this. Your mother is morally right to pursue this claim. Surely she would be unable to forget her daughters attitude and attempt at blackmail even if she drops it now, the damage to that relationship is already done.

Such a balanced post with good advice and it's so true too

stopbeeping · 22/01/2023 13:11

That dog needs to be pts

I can't believe how grim your sister is being about it all
She is making it into a bigger problem by refusing to comply

Your mum shouldn't have to endure this, sister should have reimbursed her immediately anyway

Go no contact with her

She also sounds like she is in a coercive relationship

Does your sister have kids? I would be totally panicked about them being around the dog

MatildaTheCat · 22/01/2023 13:10

I know you’ve said they have insurance but does it cover a known-to-be dangerous dog with a bite history? I can imagine a lot of insurers would try to avoid paying out on that. A bit like having someone fall through a floor that is well known to be completely rotten in places.

FeedMeTiramisu · 22/01/2023 13:08

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

100% this.

WingingItSince1973 · 22/01/2023 13:04

I can see why your dm would make further claims. The poor lady is now spending her last years in constant pain and in fear. The Smiths should have never allowed that dog in the vicinity of people after it attacked a child and another dog! They put your mum in danger, they are the reason she is now spending time at physio and extra doctors appointments when she's at such an age. Them paying for medical fees and a taxi home seem to be hoping this would pacify her. I'm not saying your mum is out for every penny but obviously the insurance company have raised an issue for compensation which she rightly deserves. It's complicate with your sister in this relationship with her in laws but I would be absolutely moritified it my very elderly mother was attacked in such a way by a dog with a history like this one.

Firstmonthfree · 22/01/2023 12:18

If she thought it was just an insurance claim then I can see why she is annoyed. She probably thought is would be purely financial to settle the medical bills and that would be the end of it.

by getting solicitors involved she’s probably now worried that she will be left with conditions on the dog ownership- it must be muzzled or maybe destroyed. I can see why she is worried. They situation has changed from what she agreed to.

whether you think she should keep the dog or not, the point is that the nature of the claim has changed from what she agreed to.

PuppaDontPreach · 22/01/2023 12:11

I cant ever see a situation where a family member puts an insurance claim and solicitors against another family member, and the relationship carrying on as normal.

So you'd prefer to have insurance that pays out to everyone except your own family members? Mad.

A lot of people on this thread not understanding how third party liability insurance works.

MrsSkylerWhite · 22/01/2023 11:38

Your poor mum. If I were your sister I would have the dog pts.

Could be a kid’s face next time.

XelaM · 22/01/2023 11:35

silverclock222 · 22/01/2023 11:27

Agree, money or daughter.

This.

Swipe left for the next trending thread