Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dh threw milk at me

141 replies

Namechangingoverspilledmilk · 21/01/2023 21:39

Name change because this is embarrassing and scary.
My DH and I had a disagreement over who was sleeping on sofa bed- it should be my turn tonight but he wanted to stay up late and game. I said I would go upstairs but also wanted to keep my expected day of Sunday for the nice bed. We no longer share a bed atm because We both snore horribly and I am a terrible light sleeper. Throw a 1yo into mix who sometimes likes to wake in night or early hours and it works best for everyone to do what we need to get a good night's sleep. Anyway when I said well I guess but I want to keep Sunday night too as it isn't me who wants to stay up late and change the pattern of who is going where he got really cross. He was on his way up to feed the baby and our disagreement carried from living room into kitchen. He was pouring milk into the bottle and I broke off what I was saying to point out he had poured too much as we are trying to wean baby off of this night bottle by reducing milk amount slowly. He then really angrily tipped it down sink instead of back into milk carton which I thought was wasteful- we aren't exactly flush with cash atm. He then had tipped too much out so he stomped back to fridge got milk out, slopped more into bottle spilling everywhere. The disagreement was still continuing and I said I thought he was being unreasonable. He then sloshed milk out of the plastic carton towards me- it splashed all over the floor, nearly caught the washing I have hanging up drying and went a bit on my work laptop case. He also made a horrible comment about my mental health- saying it was already shit, in response to me reminding him why we weren't just sharing a bed because of snoring and my MH goes down pan quickly on little sleep.
I was so gobsmacked by what he'd done. I said nothing. He got the mop straight out and started clearing it up and said nothing to me. He went to feed baby and I just went to bedroom whilst he did that. I'm really upset- by the mental health comment but also by the milk throwing. It was meant for me. It was a total moment of loss of control of his anger. This is first time he's done something this intimidating but isn't first time he's just lost his temper in an argument- usually it's verbally and he has previously told me to fuck off and called me a bitch. Those incidents have probably happened 4 or 5 times- a few times in front of our eldest. We've been married nearly 6 years and together for 9 for context.
I'm lying here feeling sick. I don't know if I'm overreacting but I know that what just happened isn't right and that serious domestic violence doesn't always start with significant incidents initially it can start with small things like this. I now can't stop thinking about that and my anxiety is sky high worried he might still be angry and come in the room and strangle me or something and then what will happen to my kids. This is absolutely not rational but anxiety isn't and I'm trying to talk myself down. Aibu to be so upset by this incident?

OP posts:
Namechangingoverspilledmilk · 22/01/2023 09:00

@FarFromObvious I think I did put in my OP that the incident had triggered my anxiety hugely and I knew that fear wasn't rational but it still was very much a persistent anxious thought I had after the event.

OP posts:
Namechangingoverspilledmilk · 22/01/2023 08:57

Yes cows milk as baby just turned 1. So we get one of those big 6 pint ones of whole milk to last the week .

Snoring isn't the only issue- I am a very light sleeper and once woken struggle to get back to sleep if someone else is in bed with me. I've always been this way. I spent most of my early 20s when I had partners self medicating with alcohol to try and get a good night sleep whilst bed sharing. Or night nurse or drowsy anti histamine. I made the decision I couldn't do that forever and with kids good quality sleep is very precious and this is the only way I get it. I know other couples who also choose to sleep apart in order to get good sleep. Before second baby came along we had a spare double bed and didn't need to use sofa bed.

OP posts:
FarFromObvious · 22/01/2023 08:56

If him throwing milk at you had you genuinely fearing for your life, then you have huge problems in your marriage. You need to talk calmly today or end things.

If my husband threw some milk at me during a tired irritable argument, it would feel highly unpleasant and out of character. I would definitely be bringing it up later and saying how it made me feel. But I would not ever think that the next step would be strangulation.

Cheeseandlobster · 22/01/2023 08:51

category12 · 22/01/2023 00:21

I think it's fair not to want to swap nights in the bed. It's not an like for like swap. Saturday night when you're home on Sunday is not the equal to Sunday night when you have to go into work in the morning.

If she says no to the swap, he would probably feel like she's stopping him from having his leisure activity on the only night he can really stay up, assuming work on Monday morning.

But if it's more important to her to have the Sunday night in bed, she loses out from the swap. He gets both the leisure time and the restful Sunday night. She gets the night that's less useful to her and the less restful night on the Sunday.

So yeah, he shouldn't ask for the swap.

If he scared you, OP, don't be convinced to dismiss it by the reactions here - we weren't there. Listen to your gut about where your relationship is.

This is exactly what I was trying to say last night but in a less eloquent way. At last someone with sense

qpmz · 22/01/2023 08:48

tara66 · 22/01/2023 08:28

What sort of milk is baby getting -you say it was pour back into carton - so sounds like cow's milk - not baby milk?

Formula in a carton. We still use that for our 2 year old!

RedHelenB · 22/01/2023 08:48

pelargoniums · 22/01/2023 02:10

Ah, so if the wife is a nag it’s OK to throw milk at her – got it! This place sometimes. FFS.

No ones saying its right, just that it's understandable . And yes, being a nagging, controlling wife/husband is also abuse.

Wookiebowl · 22/01/2023 08:45

georgarina · 22/01/2023 08:37

No it's not ok to throw milk at someone.
I remember a different thread months ago where OP had got angry and threw some water at her husband and people were frothing at the mouth, calling her an abuser and saying he should have called the police.
I hope you're ok OP. It reminds me of the nasty things my stepfather used to do, which did escalate into serious violence.

Meanwhile zero milk actually landed on OP, which is would have done if he had wanted to throw milk at her. Not saying what he did was acceptable, but there's quite a stark difference really.

qpmz · 22/01/2023 08:45

Young, healthy people shouldn't have chronic snoring issues!That needs sorting out a priority so you can share the bed. Sleeping separately isn't good for a loving relationship in my view.

There's nothing wrong with baby drinking lots of milk before bed. It can help them sleep through.

His swearing t you is totally out of order.

Maybe you both need a mental health boost, it's not unreasonable to suggest that.

RedHelenB · 22/01/2023 08:45

LoisLane66 · 22/01/2023 01:15

Giving cold milk straight out of the fridge to a baby/1 year old child...?
That's a bit weird..isn't it?

No. Mine had milk from the fridge at that age .

rainbowunicorn · 22/01/2023 08:39

LoisLane66 · 22/01/2023 01:15

Giving cold milk straight out of the fridge to a baby/1 year old child...?
That's a bit weird..isn't it?

Not in the slightest.

RosettaTheGardenFairy · 22/01/2023 08:39

Frazzled25 · 21/01/2023 22:07

In the depths of sleep deprivation with small children I cannot promise you that I wouldn’t have thrown milk at my husband had he followed me around niggling about everything I was doing.

I agree with this.

It takes a lot of will power for me to walk away from an argument, if my DH followed me or tried to keep the argument going in anyway then on his head be it! Luckily my DH knows how hard I work at my deep breathing etc to be able to walk away and would never dream of coming after me.

Leave your husband alone when he shows the strength to walk away and stop micro-nagging him.

georgarina · 22/01/2023 08:37

No it's not ok to throw milk at someone.
I remember a different thread months ago where OP had got angry and threw some water at her husband and people were frothing at the mouth, calling her an abuser and saying he should have called the police.
I hope you're ok OP. It reminds me of the nasty things my stepfather used to do, which did escalate into serious violence.

tara66 · 22/01/2023 08:28

What sort of milk is baby getting -you say it was pour back into carton - so sounds like cow's milk - not baby milk?

RedHelenB · 22/01/2023 08:26

Frenchfancy · 21/01/2023 21:49

In the nicest possible way - you need to get a grip. He was preparing your babies bottle. You are both tired. Find a way to get back to an equilibrium.

This. Sounds a stressful situation you're living in.

Wookiebowl · 22/01/2023 08:23

I would have been annoyed if DH had done what you had tbh, but by the sound of it the way he speaks to you is unacceptable. The sleeping arrangement evidently isn't working and it sounds like you're both tired and have a lack of respect for eachother. You need to communicate

Mylaferret · 22/01/2023 08:18

You didn't do anything wrong. You're entitled to remind him about how much milk to give the baby.

He's emotionally abusing you and there's never any excuse for swearing and calling you names at all let alone in front of your child.

Babycakes6 · 22/01/2023 08:13

Desertbarncat · 21/01/2023 23:04

Emotional and verbal abuse are abuse. Absolutely. And can very often escalate into physical abuse. He cannot control his temper, even in front of your kids, and you were intimidated by his physical actions enough to worry about your safety while sleeping. That is not unreasonable.

Totally agree with this! It’s scary that he can’t control himself and also worrying what he could do next time.

GreetingsToTheNewBrunette · 22/01/2023 08:12

Cheeseandlobster · 21/01/2023 23:07

Because having a good night's sleep on Sunday probably means she will be fresh for work on Monday. Why should she sacrifice that because her dh wants to swap to game? Fuck me. This site boggles my brain sometimes

Because he asked? She could have just said no sorry I’d rather stick to the arrangements we have rather than try and take the piss and get the bed for 3 nights in a row (which it would be if they take turns).

Im sure you’d have quite a different response if it was the other way round.

donttellmehesalive · 22/01/2023 07:59

"But HOW is she being selfish about the bed? Based on their agreement she would have the bed Sunday night, which presumably would enable her to get a good night’s sleep and feel mentally strong for the week ahead. Her DH wanted to switch tonight — not so he could work, not so he could get more sleep, not for his mental health, but so he could play video games."

Because op was tired and wanted to go to sleep at 9:30. I don't think it's surprising that her dp didn't want to go up to bed at 9:30 on a Saturday night, whether he's merely playing video games or doing something you'd consider more cerebral. Surely it makes sense in that situation for op to just go up to bed rather than sitting waiting for him to go to bed so that she could get on the sofa bed?

Either way, thanks for the update op. Hope you can discuss it more calmly this morning and decide on a course of action. Maybe you'd be better separating, so you can both have a proper bed every night, and spare yourselves the petty squabbles?

donttellmehesalive · 22/01/2023 07:54

"I think telling her to fuck off and calling her a bitch is abusive. Doing it in front of their child is appalling.

Posters are focusing on the OP's behaviour as though it excuses DH's abuse. I thought we had moved past that? Some behaviours just aren't ok and nothing the other person has done makes it not-abuse."

I've read lots of posts on here where women have snapped after being pushed and pushed, as their DP calmly watches them snap and calls it abuse. Responses have generally always said that it is possible for the person doing the pushing to be the abuser, or certainly equally at fault. Obviously, we don't know if that's the case for op. When I made my point, I felt I'd need to know the context of him telling her to fuck off before automatically calling it abusive.

Namechangingoverspilledmilk · 22/01/2023 07:14

And re cold milk- i agree, I thought v weird. But during heatwave we started giving baby bottles straight from fridge. When autumn came and weather got cooler we offered warm one again and she wouldn't drink it. Tried room temp-ish but again wasn't interested. Some babies genuinely do seem to prefer their milk ice cold.

OP posts:
Namechangingoverspilledmilk · 22/01/2023 07:02

Thanks for the wide variety of opinions. Head is feeling clearer after a sleep.
Just to clarify a few points:

  1. I didn't intentionally follow him into kitchen. He left living room already in a huff. I sat in there for a bit pondering who was being unreasonable. Then I assumed he was upstairs by that point as no sound in kitchen. So I went into kitchen to fill my water bottle. Actually he had gone to loo and came back into kitchen as same time as I was filling bottle.
  2. I didn't make any comment about the spilling of milk at any point. My only comment was - and I tried to make it non antagonistic: don't forget baby only has xyx oz now. I can see how when someone was in a bad mood that would be annoying no matter how it was delivered.
  3. the throwing of milk- and it was throwing- occurred whilst he walked the few paces from kitchen sink to fridge. He had been screwing the lid onto milk carton then unscrewed it, stopped as he passed me and jerked the now open carton towards me causing lots of milk to spill all over floor. Similar to when people on crap reality TV progs swill their drink at someone.
OP posts:
Howtoberight · 22/01/2023 04:43

BurtonsRevenge · 22/01/2023 03:17

You know

There's no point crying over spilt milk.

💥

BurtonsRevenge · 22/01/2023 03:17

You know

There's no point crying over spilt milk.

T1Dmama · 22/01/2023 03:14

Lots going on here…
He’s already angry because you’re insisting on the bed being yours 2 nights in a row (rightly or wrongly is irrelevant) then you criticise his efforts to make up a bottle for the baby….. then in anger he tips too much away which you probably moaned about, then spilt milk which you probably tutted or made comments about…. You wound him up and he threw a bit of milk in your direction and you’re now going from that to ‘he’s going to strangle you’ ….. all of this is one thing…. BUT if your husband is THAT angry, why the heck would you still allow him to feed the baby?? I’d have calmly said (at the start of his mood and before the milk incident) you carry on gaming and I’ll get this one… fed the baby and headed to bed…. It sounds a bit like you clashed over the sleeping agreements and instead of just going to bed you followed him to the kitchen and nagged about milk…. I always think of someone is going to hover over someone while they do something then you might as well do it yourself…. Rather than stand and ‘supervise and criticise’.

Id actually be more worried about the verbal abuse in front of the kids, and the comment about your mental health! If he isn’t apologetic in the morning about being so personal and hurtful I’d probably tell him he owes you one for that comment alone