Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dh threw milk at me

141 replies

Namechangingoverspilledmilk · 21/01/2023 21:39

Name change because this is embarrassing and scary.
My DH and I had a disagreement over who was sleeping on sofa bed- it should be my turn tonight but he wanted to stay up late and game. I said I would go upstairs but also wanted to keep my expected day of Sunday for the nice bed. We no longer share a bed atm because We both snore horribly and I am a terrible light sleeper. Throw a 1yo into mix who sometimes likes to wake in night or early hours and it works best for everyone to do what we need to get a good night's sleep. Anyway when I said well I guess but I want to keep Sunday night too as it isn't me who wants to stay up late and change the pattern of who is going where he got really cross. He was on his way up to feed the baby and our disagreement carried from living room into kitchen. He was pouring milk into the bottle and I broke off what I was saying to point out he had poured too much as we are trying to wean baby off of this night bottle by reducing milk amount slowly. He then really angrily tipped it down sink instead of back into milk carton which I thought was wasteful- we aren't exactly flush with cash atm. He then had tipped too much out so he stomped back to fridge got milk out, slopped more into bottle spilling everywhere. The disagreement was still continuing and I said I thought he was being unreasonable. He then sloshed milk out of the plastic carton towards me- it splashed all over the floor, nearly caught the washing I have hanging up drying and went a bit on my work laptop case. He also made a horrible comment about my mental health- saying it was already shit, in response to me reminding him why we weren't just sharing a bed because of snoring and my MH goes down pan quickly on little sleep.
I was so gobsmacked by what he'd done. I said nothing. He got the mop straight out and started clearing it up and said nothing to me. He went to feed baby and I just went to bedroom whilst he did that. I'm really upset- by the mental health comment but also by the milk throwing. It was meant for me. It was a total moment of loss of control of his anger. This is first time he's done something this intimidating but isn't first time he's just lost his temper in an argument- usually it's verbally and he has previously told me to fuck off and called me a bitch. Those incidents have probably happened 4 or 5 times- a few times in front of our eldest. We've been married nearly 6 years and together for 9 for context.
I'm lying here feeling sick. I don't know if I'm overreacting but I know that what just happened isn't right and that serious domestic violence doesn't always start with significant incidents initially it can start with small things like this. I now can't stop thinking about that and my anxiety is sky high worried he might still be angry and come in the room and strangle me or something and then what will happen to my kids. This is absolutely not rational but anxiety isn't and I'm trying to talk myself down. Aibu to be so upset by this incident?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MinBins · 22/01/2023 23:02

There have been lots of feedback here on what happened, who is at fault etc. So won't go into that.

One thing I caught in your message is that he's sworn at you and has been derogative in front of your eldest. That's not okay.

Hope you manage to sort it out and get some rest, sleep deprivation brings out all the crankiness in us.

LottoLaura · 22/01/2023 22:15

OldFan · 22/01/2023 22:12

Sloshing milk towards someone isn’t the same as throwing anything.

It is throwing something towards someone.

It’s really not

by definition it’s not. Nothing was propelled. Milk was sloshed.

MademoiselleTrunchbull · 22/01/2023 22:14

I agree that it sounds like an argument. I'd probs have erred on the side of him being the most unreasonable, but I've witnessed years of my mum following my dad around the house berating him until he finally snapped - at which point she'd be playing the victim.

OldFan · 22/01/2023 22:12

Sloshing milk towards someone isn’t the same as throwing anything.

It is throwing something towards someone.

OldFan · 22/01/2023 22:12

It sounds like overall he's pretty accommodating of your needs

Not really. He sounds like a stroppy a-hole.

LottoLaura · 22/01/2023 22:11

OldFan · 22/01/2023 22:08

OP’s partner did not throw milk at her.

@MrsSkylerWhite He deliberately and pointedly threw milk towards her.

Throwing anything is a really bad sign.

Sloshing milk towards someone isn’t the same as throwing anything.

The OP is seriously in the wrong on just about every level here

OldFan · 22/01/2023 22:08

OP’s partner did not throw milk at her.

@MrsSkylerWhite He deliberately and pointedly threw milk towards her.

Throwing anything is a really bad sign.

SnarkyBag · 22/01/2023 21:45

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 22/01/2023 20:16

Er...I am as much a gamer as my husband (and children) are. We are saddos that have a gaming room. I don't place a moral judgement on leisure activities.

It doesn't matter the activity, if someone wants to stay up in the room someone needs to sleep in, they either swap beds for that night only or they wait until it is their night to use the room. If it doesn't matter to the other party to swap the nights then fine, but it does bother OP.

But she doesn’t need to sleep in there. There is a perfectly useable bed elsewhere. The only reason he has to have this sleeping arrangement at all is to accommodate the OP’s poor sleep and mental health. I think some flexibility is reasonable. Does he just have to suck up only using the room for gaming on certain nights indefinitely? Sorry but that’s nonsense.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 22/01/2023 20:16

SnarkyBag · 21/01/2023 23:20

I think posters like you are getting your knickers in a twist because it’s gaming. Which ordinarily I would agree many gamer DH’s on here seem to be tossers. But taking it at face value it just sounds like the they have less than ideal sleeping arrangements with apparently no flexibility to stay up late and game on a Saturday night.

if the OP posted to say her DH wouldn’t swap beds so she could stay up to watch a film everyone would be calling him a prick.

Er...I am as much a gamer as my husband (and children) are. We are saddos that have a gaming room. I don't place a moral judgement on leisure activities.

It doesn't matter the activity, if someone wants to stay up in the room someone needs to sleep in, they either swap beds for that night only or they wait until it is their night to use the room. If it doesn't matter to the other party to swap the nights then fine, but it does bother OP.

LottoLaura · 22/01/2023 17:11

I’d have done a lot more than sloshed some milk in your direction.

You were being so unreasonable, how on earth can you not see that?

theGooHasGone · 22/01/2023 17:07

Given that your sleep issues are as bad as they are (and you say you've always been like this) you really do need to figure out a way for both of you to sleep in a proper bed every night and stop the situation where one of you can't use the living room. It doesn't have to be together if that's a problem (although that's still ultimately likely to cause issues in the longer term) but consistency of environment is important for sleep hygiene. In addition, your husband probably feels like there's a total lack of intimacy and any time for each other. A lack of good communication has negative consequences really quickly and resentment builds. It sounds like overall he's pretty accommodating of your needs but this doesn't happen in a vacuum.

Maybe consider getting a proper single bed which will fit elsewhere? Treating the sofa bed as a temporary solution doesn't seem to really be working well for either of you and the situation is going to keep going downhill until it's addressed.

pocketvenuss · 22/01/2023 15:48

For the love of god now any display of frustration and or anger is abuse? Get a grip. You sound like you are both tired and stressed. You are reacting by being nagging and micro managing him. He is reacting by flaking about splashing milk everywhere.

monsteramunch · 22/01/2023 15:31

He sounds like a lazy, selfish manchild in your last post OP.

Can you bear the thought of spending the rest of your life having to either beg another adult to behave like an adult or doing all of the adulting yourself?

You could be happy without him, but I don't see how you can ever be happy with him.

Namechangingoverspilledmilk · 22/01/2023 15:25

He doesn't game excessively- just at weekend, he's too busy during week to game.
I am back at work now in what many would consider a pretty demanding job and so I need my sleep to be decent quality. I would be happy to sleep on sofa bed all the time if I had to as that's how important decent sleep is for me to function well at home and in workplace. And I have said this before and offered it and he hasn't wanted to do it like that which is kind.
A big issue is he never wants to discuss things like this afterwards. He just wants to pretend it hasn't happened- maybe will do silent treatment for a few hours or something then just continues as though everything is normal. I try to communicate with him about things which I feel need to be addressed things like share of domestic load and chores especially since I've gone back to work and he just gets snappy, short tempered and so I give up really. He doesn't listen to me when I talk- if I ask him a question from another room because I'm sorting eldest out, he would hear and not respond eg 'Have we got bread in?' Or 'is heating on/off?' so question I need to have answer to and he just won't answer. So I'll ask again thinking he hasn't heard me and then he'll get cross and answer as though I've been really out of order and annoying for keeping on asking. I've explained multiple times until he answers I don't know if he's heard me. Our communication as a couple is shit. Anything hard or uncomfortable he doesn't want to discuss.
I feel as though my communication skills are strong and this is one of my strengths at work but also in personal relationships with good friends. I've tried different tacts to bring stuff that I know will make him cross up eg the fact he keeps leaving bathroom in a state after shaving his beard. And it always ends the same- him getting pissed off and making out that I'm v unreasonable.to bring it up and am just a nag.
But I don't see why I should just accept having a 3rd child to clean up after? I've got 2. That's enough. And why should my life be made harder by his laziness when it comes to tidiness etc.?

OP posts:
GreetingsToTheNewBrunette · 22/01/2023 12:55

Have either of you been to a sleep clinic? I wouldn’t want to not sleep with my partner and be shoved onto a sofa bed so I think it’s a bit compromise on his behalf in that respect too, so trying to get 3 days in the actual bed does seem a little cheeky.

I hope you’re feeling better now OP. Anxiety is horrible.

donttellmehesalive · 22/01/2023 12:32

queenMab99 · 22/01/2023 11:16

I think he should cut down on the gaming, it makes him short tempered, unreasonable, and affects sleep patterns, I have noticed this with teenagers.

OP hasn't said how long he games for.

Or that it affects his sleep patterns beyond not wanting to go to bed at 9:30 so op could sleep on the sofa.

This is two sleep-deprived people who no longer share a bed. She is frightened of him now, since he sloshed milk in her direction. It sounds as if he doesn't currently like her very much. I think they both need to talk about it today before it spirals into increasing contempt and separation.

PipinwasAuntieMabelsdog · 22/01/2023 12:31

Hi @Namechangingoverspilledmilk

Breaking down the last bit of your OP:

I don't know if I'm overreacting but I know that what just happened isn't right and that serious domestic violence doesn't always start with significant incidents initially it can start with small things like this. I now can't stop thinking about that and my anxiety is sky high worried he might still be angry and come in the room and strangle me or something and then what will happen to my kids. This is absolutely not rational but anxiety isn't and I'm trying to talk myself down. Aibu to be so upset by this incident?

  1. You are overeacting to think that this incident will lead to you being killed by your partner, your anxiety has kicked in (an if it were to escalate in the future would likely protect you actually, because your flight response is easily triggered. For many living at risk of DV this does not kick in, often due to previous relationships modelling a 'it could be worse' so they stay .
  2. YANBU to be upset, but you need to see it in context, both of you are knackered and you really should have just let him get on with feeding the DC, a little extra milk one night, would not wreck weaning.
  3. Are you still on ML? I am, and if DS is having a bad night, DH goes into the spare room to sleep, because he needs to be on top form for work. (We both work in HE and lecturing when you are knackered is impossible. He is also sciences so needs to be vigilant in labs for safety) If you are on Mat leave YABU to expect 3 nights of unbroken sleep including Sunday, if DH is working next day.
Ggggggoooo · 22/01/2023 12:29

This kind of thing reminds me of when my partner and I used to argue a lot. I would overreact and worry about abuse, he felt unheard and would shout more to counter me shutting down. Not ok imo but neither was my behaviour a lot of the time yet I acted like the ultimate victim.

We don’t argue like that anymore. Literally what fixed it was more communication, walking away from arguments until we calmed down, not holding a grudge and understanding that he had feelings too. I had an abusive background so I worried endlessly about abuse but that lack of trust actually made our relationship worse. I’m glad ultimately I didn’t listen to the people who only took my side and told me he was abusive when my behaviour was also not ok.

Our relationship is good now and I’m glad we stuck it out. Communication, love and trust is so key.

MrsSkylerWhite · 22/01/2023 11:36

Desertbarncat · Yesterday 23:04
Emotional and verbal abuse are abuse. Absolutely. And can very often escalate into physical abuse. He cannot control his temper, even in front of your kids, and you were intimidated by his physical actions enough to worry about your safety while sleeping. That is not unreasonable“

I grew up in an
abusive situation where my mother and I were under constant threat of extreme violence.

Both parties are accountable in this situation. OP’s partner did not throw milk at her.

They are both over tired and angry and need to work together to sort themselves out.

RNLD1981 · 22/01/2023 11:28

queenMab99 · 22/01/2023 11:16

I think he should cut down on the gaming, it makes him short tempered, unreasonable, and affects sleep patterns, I have noticed this with teenagers.

Out of interest queenMab99, how much time is OPs DH gaming for?

queenMab99 · 22/01/2023 11:16

I think he should cut down on the gaming, it makes him short tempered, unreasonable, and affects sleep patterns, I have noticed this with teenagers.

PrincessConstance · 22/01/2023 11:08

Oh my, what a tantrum. However, why are you micromanaging the milk?

Wookiebowl · 22/01/2023 11:05

Namechangingoverspilledmilk · 22/01/2023 08:57

Yes cows milk as baby just turned 1. So we get one of those big 6 pint ones of whole milk to last the week .

Snoring isn't the only issue- I am a very light sleeper and once woken struggle to get back to sleep if someone else is in bed with me. I've always been this way. I spent most of my early 20s when I had partners self medicating with alcohol to try and get a good night sleep whilst bed sharing. Or night nurse or drowsy anti histamine. I made the decision I couldn't do that forever and with kids good quality sleep is very precious and this is the only way I get it. I know other couples who also choose to sleep apart in order to get good sleep. Before second baby came along we had a spare double bed and didn't need to use sofa bed.

I mean he's sleeping alone and every other night on an uncomfortable bed so you can get a good night's sleep- that must be quite hard tbh. Not saying he shouldn't do it, but that's a pretty big compromise.

Setupaccountforthis · 22/01/2023 10:21

I think this is a rather important issue for you to take advice of people on a forum. You don't know the demographics of people commenting here and you might be highly influenced and impacted mentally.

Anxiety is a very difficult thing to manage. It changes your whole perspective on things and doesn't let you think clearly. Please seek professional help - there are even free or low-cost services. And don't believe everything you see on the internet. There's a lot of misleading or inaccurate content around mental health, especially on social media. That's not education. Don't let it influence you.

Always remember that your feelings are valid. Don't let anyone disregard them and make you feel like you're 'crazy, overreacting' etc. But work through your feelings instead.

Orangepolentacake · 22/01/2023 10:04

tara66 · 22/01/2023 08:28

What sort of milk is baby getting -you say it was pour back into carton - so sounds like cow's milk - not baby milk?

Not the point but you can get formula in 1 litre cartons. Wouldn’t advise pouring back once it’s been poured into another container tho (maybe for toddlers isn’t a problem)

Swipe left for the next trending thread