Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend husband and sexual assault

34 replies

user1471553275 · 21/01/2023 17:07

My friend told me almost 18 months ago that her husband had been charged with sexual assault crimes against two young women. The assaults occured some time ago and at the time were underage. For context he was well into adulthood so not an 18 year old (not that it would make it ok either). I've always felt that he did it if the police and courts we're pursuing it. She claimed it was just "two girls" say so. I get that she is his wife and it's a no win situation. She needs to support him as what if he was innocent but it's always made me feel like she's being taken for a fool. I think he's quite controlling and he belittles her.

At various points she's advised that just a few days prior to a court appearance he's only just found out about it. Again I feel he has lied to her. Surely you'd get more than 2-3 days notice if you needed to be on court? He's been convicted but plead guilty. She's still defending him and dismissing the women who were his victims. She indicated he confessed/plead guilty on the advice of his solicitor and due to significant circumstantial evidence. He's yet to be sentenced. From what I understand he won't go to prison.

I feel awful. I want to support my friend but I feel deeply uncomfortable that she is dismissing what happened to these women/teenagers. I feel angry that she's being so blind. Do innocent people plead guilty just to save people from a trial (as she claims). I don't think so. I think he didn't want her to hear what he did. At no point has he disclosed to her what he'd discussed with his solicitor etc. I get she's devastated but how can she believe that these "girls" as she refers to them have just made something up. They had nothing to gain.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Auntyacid · 23/01/2023 08:30

I’ve been in a similar situation although the assault was not as severe by the sound of it. I can’t say too much more as it’s very outing but she’s never seen the light and still believes him to be the victim. He got away with it and from where I’m looking at things doesn’t appeared to have changed his ways.

OhhhhhhhhBiscuits · 22/01/2023 09:47

I would walk away and tell her exactly why. Those poor kids will be ostracised at school if she stands by this sex offender. I would never blame kids for the sins of the father, but would never ever let my children round their house or want them at a party etc...... just incase they came into contact with this bastard. If she doesn't cut him off she could well find herself very lonely which is sad but also of her own making.

Naunet · 22/01/2023 09:38

I don’t think I could be friends with a woman who defended a man who attacked 2 children, but then I was abused as a child myself so that’s for the sake of my own mental health.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 21/01/2023 19:48

I had a friend who worked with sex offenders and have done some research in the subject - even when they are caught and when they can tell you rape is wrong and admit what they did, they will claim that they are not guilty and really genuinely seem to believe this. I am guessing that your friend is around some pretty believable sounding stuff. And to be honest, if a family member is accused of something and denies it, isnt our first instinct to believe them? Especially if our whole life would be destroyed if we had to disbelieve them? I am not condoning her dismissal of the women, or excusing him - just trying to understand why she is so much in denial. I would set a limit though - like I couldnt be around her while she was with him, that you care about her and will be there for her in the future if that changes. But that you think she is making a bad decision.

Tiredmamma8 · 21/01/2023 19:32

Sounds like your friendship is over and you already know that, if you’re asking on a chat group. It’s hard to decide that you don’t want to be friends with someone anymore. Especially if you’re close enough for them to tell you their husband is a convicted paedophile and that they believe his story.

I’m not sure I would even explain to her, it doesn’t sound like she would listen anyway. I would just not be available and if I saw her just say I’m late for an appointment.

ShakespearesBlister · 21/01/2023 19:01

It does sound like she's in denial. Her dismissal of what the girls went through will be driven by what he has told her (or withheld from her). She will believe he was set up because it's what he told her and she wants to believe he couldn't be capable of doing it because if she does accept it's true then she will have to accept her whole life with him was a huge lie. She's not ready for that yet. Don't be surprised if other things come to light as well. I think you need to decide how this sits with you. I'd be distancing myself and I say this through experience. I once knew a man who suddenly got taken to court accused is sexually assaulting 2 young girls. Of course they were lying and both set him up because he refused to give them money etc. I then did my own research and found out he was jailed previously for sexually assaulting a young girl. He went back to prison obviously. Most people distanced themselves but some remained in denial even then. Denial is a powerful thing and even when everyone else sees it clear as day people like your friend still won't accept it. You may find she will start to realise the details don't add up and start asking questions herself eventually but all the time he is filling her head with his version it is unlikely she will question the details.

flagpole · 21/01/2023 19:00

Please don't discount that she is in an abusive relationship that she feels she cannot get out of. I was in a similar situation with a man i was absolutely terrified of and had no option but to outwardly support him. It was a survival mechanism and actually probably the hardest thing to get over afterwards because i felt so much shame over it

Jafffffacakes · 21/01/2023 18:56

I have a friend who was in a similar situation. He lied and lied to her and he didn’t do it, then it was an admin error and then it wasn’t his fault etc etc. she believed everything he said right up until the day when he admitted it all - but again on,y because he had to fora more lenient result. She was devastated as she had believed him. She’s still with him and it’s all been swept under the carpet.

there is nothing you can say or do I’m afraid.

user1471553275 · 21/01/2023 18:54

I really appreciate the replies. My husband is like "what if she sees this". I love her and want to support her but I can't support her on this. I get it's denial but to me it's a horrific crime. It's not something menial. I think I'm best to keep my distance. I've only ever asked her once if she thought he did it and she was adamant he wouldn't so no point in pushing it. I get her world would come crumbling down. My husband is much more sympathetic of what an awful position she's in. I said though would he be comfortable if we had a daughter that she went to their house or got a lift with him. He was clear, no he wouldn't.

Social services do have to be notified and I think the school. I feel bad for the kids too incase it gets out.

I fortunately have never been assaulted and just can't get my head around it. I appreciate the measured responses that what I'm feeling is normal. I'll keep my distance and if she presses I'll be honest. I feel wholly uncomfortable about it and her support for him. If she ever sees this (I don't think she's on Mumsnet) and realises it's me I'll have to be upfront. His sentencing isn't for a while. Honestly....I wish he was going to prison. For the women and perhaps as her chance for escape and to start over.

OP posts:
LemonSqueezy0 · 21/01/2023 18:45

I've seen numerous women stand by men in these situations, and they do want to maintain their lifestyle and life plan regardless. They attend court with them, hear all the details and still stand by them. In and of itself it's not actually an unusual situation. But I couldn't be friends with someone who could bury their head in the sand that much. I would never trust them or their judgement again.

Id make it clear she would have my support if she ever left him, but until then the friendship would be on the back burner.

Greenshake · 21/01/2023 18:44

Passportpondery · 21/01/2023 18:16

If he goes on the sex offenders register surely their children can no longer live with him?

Not necessarily, there are several things that would factor in this decision.

NoDairyNoProblem · 21/01/2023 18:40

I could never be in his company again or hear what a great misunderstood guy he was so unfortunately the friendship would go if my friend stuck her head in the sand.

Sex offenders register isn’t something done on a whim. He pleaded guilty to seek leniency.

soundsystem · 21/01/2023 18:31

So... he sexually assaulted a girl under 16, a child? Surely social services will want to see that she's keeping her children safe? How old are they? Girls/boys? Even if he's not a risk to them directly surely they'll be ostracised - no-one would let their teenage daughter found a friends house when the dads on the sec offenders register?!

Bowsersfightnight · 21/01/2023 18:28

I would also be thinking about the women who have been assaulted. Seeing their abuser supporting by a loving wife standing by his side must be really tough for them.

Yesthatismychildsigh · 21/01/2023 18:26

Bad friend or not, I couldn’t support her. And I’d have to tell her why.

Bowsersfightnight · 21/01/2023 18:25

I would personally really really struggle to stay friends with her OP. No she didn’t do it and yes it’s a very very difficult situation, she’s clearly in deep denial however I could not be friends with someone who dismissed these women who were children when assaulted.

Maybe I’m being overly sensitive due to my own traumas but I couldn’t look past it personally. If she accepts it and stops supporting him I would support her as best I could but not if she remained standing by him.

MilkshakesBringAllTheCoosToTheYard · 21/01/2023 18:25

dapsnotplimsolls · 21/01/2023 18:19

I assume she's blaming them to avoid blaming him? If he probably won't go to prison then she obviously wants to stay with him and has to find a way to justify this to herself - he's the 'innocent injured party', they're the 'evil liars'.

That's such a good way of putting it. Believing them means ripping her life apart and she's not ready to do that. Maybe she never will. But the only way to go on as she is, is to disbelieve, disbelieve, disbelieve and blame, blame, blame.

Of course, every beat of our society supports that so it's easy enough to do.

My friends are my ride or die; I'll always support them but I don't know if I could by extension support him by going along with this fiction. You could say 'I don't believe him, I believe the women, that means we can't talk about certain things if we're to continue being friends' but if you do that I'm certain she'll cut you out because she needs everyone around her to maintain the fiction that her husband is blameless.

It's fucking shit being a woman sometimes.

dapsnotplimsolls · 21/01/2023 18:19

I assume she's blaming them to avoid blaming him? If he probably won't go to prison then she obviously wants to stay with him and has to find a way to justify this to herself - he's the 'innocent injured party', they're the 'evil liars'.

Passportpondery · 21/01/2023 18:16

If he goes on the sex offenders register surely their children can no longer live with him?

user1471553275 · 21/01/2023 18:14

I believe the two women did know one another but I still don't believe her logic that they've conspired together. It's historical and no gain as he's not famous. I don't think anyone would just seek to destroy someone's life. He did it. And I wish she saw it.

OP posts:
user1471553275 · 21/01/2023 18:11

Thank you all. I feel so conflicted. She's my friend but I cannot believe she's being so blind. She has been since this all started and I get you have to believe your partner until proven otherwise but I feel that is now the case. I believe he may get a lighter sentence re not prison as a result of the plea. I don't think it's a kindness at all.

She was at the conviction and no details as he plead guilty. I only know what she's told me and I have seen some paperwork showing sexual assault (no details of what that entailed but to me it doesn't matter) and the same but on someone under 16. She told me what he told her it was and I've never believed it would get to court if only that. A handful of other people know and we are all of the view that she's being naive to the extreme.

She is absolutely burying her head in the sand and I thought she'd open her eyes once the case was sorted one way or the other. If he was innocent then fair enough.

I don't believe she's lying. I think she has told me everything she knows and I don't think he's been remotely honest with her.

He has got to go on the register and they do have children. I get people do bad things and it's not the fault of family. It's her dismissal of the women that I'm struggling with. They were victims and it's wrong. I'm shocked she's making out like he's been stitched up. My heart is breaking for her as my friend but also I can't get my head round how she can defend it all.

OP posts:
IcakethereforeIam · 21/01/2023 18:11

I wonder if there a 'stages' type thing that women go through in these situations, like the stages of grief. If he's not been sentenced, could she go to that, doesn't the judge sum up the case prior to sentencing? I'd be tempted to encourage her to go. She might see his victims and recognise who she's been blindly defaming and lashing out at.

He's not changed he was an abusive man then and it sounds like he's still abusive with the belittling and controlling behaviour. I hope she gets away from him.

CountrysideHideaway · 21/01/2023 18:10

I’d have to share my feelings and thoughts with her as I’d be very concerned for her. If she was going to stand by him, I’d probably distance myself a bit as I couldn’t sit and listen to her deny it all. She’s another of his victims though so I’d let her know if she decides to leave, I’d support her in any way she needs.

BunchHarman · 21/01/2023 18:00

I’d tell her that innocent people do not plead guilty. If she continues with her ludicrous and offensive victim blaming, I’d end the friendship.

determinedtomakethiswork · 21/01/2023 17:58

Did those young women even know each other?

Swipe left for the next trending thread