Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My Husband and kids forgot my Birthday

359 replies

NowYouTellMe · 21/01/2023 16:33

Feeling disappointed that my Husband and teenage to adult kids forgot my Birthday.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Hillarious · 30/01/2023 14:54

When you're an adult, you do have a certain responsibility to muster the troops to celebrate your birthday, especially if they have a track record for forgetting and this then is an issue for you - whether it's to suggest a meal out, meal in, or ask who's making the birthday cake.

matesalka · 30/01/2023 13:55

Shoogly · 21/01/2023 18:04

Happy belated birthday! You and your husband both need to raise your games. You should exchange gifts, they don't have to cost lots, but it's important to feel appreciated and recognised. Your kids need to know that they need to value the people around them who love them. You remind your kids for your DH and vice versa. Remind your husband about your birthday and go out for lunch or something. Sorry but you sound partly responsible for this, you've accepted it too readily.

Absolutely. Mine is in March and around January we start discussing what we are doing for my birthday and in February I send my husband and 2 adult children my birthday list! Tickets to the theatre, or a book or perfume I would like etc.

Stewball01 · 26/01/2023 06:34

My ex and my DC have the date of my birthday indelibly printed on their brains. No such thing as forgetting. I get phone calls and tuneless singing. And they're adults. My DS will be 52 on Saturday and DD 50 in October. I'd be very upset if they forgot.
You should start dropping hints 2 weeks before.

venus7 · 23/01/2023 19:59

SpacePotato · 21/01/2023 17:36

Hate threads like this, they don't forget at all, especially the DH's or DP's.
Something that's on the same day every fucking year.

They know, they just can't be arsed.
It's an inconvenience.
So used to the woman arranging everything except wiping their arses.

Because you didn't kick off last year they know there is zero consequence to their inaction so they haven't bothered this year either.

Happy Birthday OP 🍷🎂

Sadly, I think it's this....no consequence=same behaviour.

ToWhitToWhoo · 23/01/2023 17:14

dogdaydown · 21/01/2023 19:39

@whataboutsecondbreakfast just one day and he can't manage a card......

Such fucking low standards

What do you really think he's like the other 364 days a year? Caring and sharing or a self centred fecker but he doesn't have affairs or abuse her, so that's just fine?

Honestly, you need to gain more self respect, a man that can't set a reminder on his phone (or is that his wife's job?) is totally pathetic.

But you do you!

Obviously I don't know the OP's dh; and, since birthday acknowledgements are important to her, and he's forgotten twice, I suspect that he is thoughtless.

But it is not 'setting a low bar' to place a much higher value on how one's partner or family member treats one every day than on one special day. In fact, it's often a higher expectation to want people to treat one well every day, than to pull out all the stops on a 'special day'. It's not just the minimum requirement of 'not having affairs or being abusive'. It's about respecting me every day; communicating with me every day; accepting my own capacities and incapacities and strengths and weaknesses and wishes and phobias as genuine, and not dismissing them because it's inconvenient for them or because they're in a bad mood. It's actually asking a lot more of them than a birthday acknowledgement.

ToWhitToWhoo · 23/01/2023 16:55

luckylavender · 22/01/2023 10:41

@LuckySantangelo35 - and I genuinely don't understand why you can't see that everyone is different. Some people hate birthdays, others hate Christmas. Many more cringe at the thought of 'being made a fuss of'. It's very personal. And your 'being made a fuss of' and mine will be very very different.

Ditto. I hate birthdays; cringe at the thought of people making a fuss of me in connection with my new age; and wish those close to me to show appreciation and consideration toward me every day, not on one 'special day'.

We are all different, as you say, and it's inconsiderate not to respect one's family members' preferences - whether by ignoring the birthday of someone like the OP who wishes for it to be acknowledged; or by inflicting birthday acknowledgements on someone like me (no doubt in the minority) who wishes for it to be ignored.

BabyDriversMummy · 23/01/2023 13:52

I read the initial headline and expected “Husband forgot to remind our small children that it was my Birthday”.

At 14/15 I would ask my Dad for money so I could go and buy Mum’s card and gift from him.

Selfish {{bleeps}}. Forget their Birthdays.

LifesTooShortForYourNonsense · 23/01/2023 11:16

YABU. It’s not some kind of test of how much people like you, that they remember a certain date- just remind people it’s your birthday!

YOUR birthday. I have seen so many of these threads - I’m not that excited about other people’s birthdays, just like other people’s holiday pictures.

I was talking to my daughter about my birthday this morning and what we wanted to do, why would you not have a conversation about it before it comes up? 🤷‍♀️

Daffodil63 · 23/01/2023 10:06

Belated birthday wishes. 💐Whilst we probably don’t need anything and our family can’t think of anything it’s the thought that counts. He/you could organise a surprise day out for each other with thought but little expense along the lines of a cycle ride, a picnic, walk, then local concert in park, pub lunch etc all local and not much cost but a whole day planned out rather than a gift. My adult children don’t forget but that maybe because one is DD? Either way it’s not acceptable.

Patineur · 23/01/2023 08:44

Pootle40 · 22/01/2023 19:50

Why should she have to - how ridiculous

She shouldn't have to. But she has a family that doesn't remember. That may be just because they're forgetful and/or inconsiderate, it may be because she treats birthdays in such a low key way, but that's the fact. It doesn't hurt to mention that, say, you're going to have a lazy day because it's your birthday or whatever.

Tygger · 23/01/2023 08:32

Happy birthday 🎂 I'm quite happy to have my birthday forgotten, but I would never forget my partners, children or parents birthdays,even the the in laws.😉

ipullmyhairout · 23/01/2023 08:29

nobird · 23/01/2023 07:31

Really weird that so many think OP is at fault here and not the inconsiderate family. She should not have to do any form of hint-dropping, discussing or reminding about her birthday. She’s said they don’t go big on celebrations and gifts but having her birthday acknowledged (phone call, popping in to see her etc) would at least remind OP she is thought about and valued. And she should not have to plant seeds in people’s heads for that. The people who are meant to love her the most in this world should not be forgetting about her birthday. It’s inexcusable.

OP, I’m glad you told them that their behaviour and lack of forethought upset you. I hope they treat you better in future.

Agree with this

whataboutsecondbreakfast · 23/01/2023 07:46

nobird · 23/01/2023 07:34

And all these people saying they suggest to their partners and families that they go for a meal or do something to celebrate - not everyone lives their lives like you. You are not the default.

It is not martyrdom for a person to just expect those that purport to love them to just remember the bloody date they were born and acknowledge it, without requiring weeks of chat about it and organising an event.

Of course we're not the default.

But we're also not the ones coming on here upset because nobody has acknowledged our birthdays 🤷🏻‍♀️

AmIThatMam · 23/01/2023 07:45

If you are not that bothered about presents, I would say next year the day before. Hey it’s my birthday tomorrow, why don’t we get a takeaway? That’s not setting them up to fail, as they don’t need to plan or do anything.
happy birthday 🥳

vinoinveritas · 23/01/2023 07:37

Sorry to hear this op. If it’s any consolation, you are not alone. My husband normally remembers - but barely. Has done a rush down the garage the night before (or that morning) for sh*te flowers a couple of times. Never any real thought or anything special. Early on in in our marriage he made me cry in the restaurant on my birthday (for taking too long to get ready!) He just ranted on about it all through the meal and ruined it so much it put me off going out to dinner ever again on my birthday! Now I always try and arrange something with a friend to do on my birthday or I visit my parents that day so I know I won’t feel too upset and it’s a ‘back up’. Maybe try that next year

nobird · 23/01/2023 07:34

And all these people saying they suggest to their partners and families that they go for a meal or do something to celebrate - not everyone lives their lives like you. You are not the default.

It is not martyrdom for a person to just expect those that purport to love them to just remember the bloody date they were born and acknowledge it, without requiring weeks of chat about it and organising an event.

nobird · 23/01/2023 07:31

Really weird that so many think OP is at fault here and not the inconsiderate family. She should not have to do any form of hint-dropping, discussing or reminding about her birthday. She’s said they don’t go big on celebrations and gifts but having her birthday acknowledged (phone call, popping in to see her etc) would at least remind OP she is thought about and valued. And she should not have to plant seeds in people’s heads for that. The people who are meant to love her the most in this world should not be forgetting about her birthday. It’s inexcusable.

OP, I’m glad you told them that their behaviour and lack of forethought upset you. I hope they treat you better in future.

BMrs · 23/01/2023 06:18

I remember watching some sitcom where a birthday was forgotten and I always thought, why didn't anyone mention it in the run up to the birthday.

I can't imagine not saying, 'shall we go for a meal for my birthday next week' or 'have you planned anything for my birthday'. Did you purposely not mention anything to test if they would forget?

Darlingx · 23/01/2023 06:03

Your birthday hug 🤗xx I know exactly how u felt . Your birth date is significant to the family . That family unit wouldn’t be here if it wasn’t for you. You literally carried them into this world .As others have said they need to pause from being wrapped up in themselves and give you the heartfelt hug because they are so lucky to have you in their lives and your not to be taken for granted anymore. I would be completely unsubtle about this requirement and make it very visible

Darlingx · 23/01/2023 05:46

My partner never remembers the date of my Birthday or his mothers . We have been together a decade and still he can’t remember the date he knows the month now at least but never the date. So this year I played down his birthday but my family stepped in and made up the fan fare I don’t understand why adult males have this brain freeze on acknowleding birthdays but I also stopped reminding and buying a card for his mothers . He did go and buy her a card but no parcel was sent I usually buy her things and sent them but why ? This admin befalls the woman so I have gradually stopped its because I just realised I have a million invisible admin tasks that clutter up my brain and slow me down he had outsourced it all to me as tradition allows like I am supposed to be his PA but where was mine ?

T1Dmama · 23/01/2023 02:34

It’s devastating OP…
my (now ex) husband NEVER remembered my birthday…. Not once we had a child anyway!!… I have literally always had to say ‘do you need to go in the card factory ?!? And he’d say ‘why is it your birthday coming up?!…. I’d then have to say it’s my birthday/Mother’s Day etc and get him to take our daughter in to choose cards… as she got older she’d get up and be all upset because he hadn’t got her anything to give me on my birthday/Mother’s Day etc and he’d be at work so she couldn’t even dash out with him to get something last minute… I told her it was ok as she was the best gift, but she was so upset and said I should have something…. As years passed she would ask him to take her to get something and he’d venture to Tesco!….
I didn’t really mind not getting anything but it’s the complete lack of effort …. Like he didn’t care!!! One year we were walking through a village and my daughter said sadly ‘I haven’t got you anything for your birthday tomorrow and I keep asking daddy but he just keeps saying next week etc…. Even my first Mother’s Day when my daughter was about 4 months old he never thought to buy me a gift!! And my first Mother’s Day was a HUGE thing for me as I’d been trying to conceive for 11 years and had done 4 failed IVF rounds…..
I will add I always made sure he had a card and a little something from our daughter to open his birthday/Father’s Day etc… I also bought and sent all the cards to his family every year…. And actually despite being broken up I still sent cards to everyone as think it’s the right thing to do after a 20 year relationship…. I also still sent presents to the paternal grandparents from my daughter and even something to him! I’m not sure if I’m a mug or just the better person!!! They thanked my daughter but didn’t acknowledge me (even though the gifts were blatantly obviously done by and paid for by me..
I do struggle with how thoughtless people can be!! It’s costa nothing these days to send a text or Facebook message to someone… and pretty much all phone contracts are unlimited calls these days…
sometimes I wish I could be a person who says ‘right he never bothered so I won’t bother’… but when the day is approaching I just can’t do it .. can’t be that petty!

Kellymm88 · 22/01/2023 22:54

Don’t be upset. It doesn’t mean they don’t care, or love you, it’s just been missed. Which I don’t agree with at all, but don’t rad too much into it. I get that it hurts none the less.
being honest, I’m not totally sure how to rectify it; but don’t take it to heart

Icanflyhigh · 22/01/2023 22:43

NowYouTellMe · 21/01/2023 17:14

I don’t expect them to make it up to me, it wasn’t malicious, just overlooked. I don’t seem to matter anymore

I'm sorry this is so sad. I'd be devastated if my DH and kids forgot mine x

Mossley · 22/01/2023 22:18

I'd cook them a 'non-existent' dinner, present them with empty bowls at the dinner table, utter the words 'F* you' and glide immediately out of the house to treat yourself to dinner with friends, but maybe I'm just a grouch.

Pootle40 · 22/01/2023 21:54

Magicpaintbrush · 22/01/2023 20:07

If you love and care about someone who is of great significance in your life then you remember their birthday, you are responsible for not fucking it up and thoughtlessly forgetting - more so if it's somebody as important as your wife or mother. Maybe you forget if it's Kevin from work's birthday, but forgetting your own wife's is absolutely shitty. And NO she shouldn't be the one to have to remind them, ffs, and those suggesting it's petty or whatever of her not to remind them, wtaf. No. That's just making excuses for the shitness and thoughtlessness of her family. All they had to do was write it on the calendar, acknowledge it, it's not difficult. I'm with you OP, you are not wrong to expect your own family to care. And there are some people being absolute nobheads to you on this thread. I think some posters on MN literally trawl this site looking for people to stick the boot into.

100% this.

Swipe left for the next trending thread