Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that people should be able to cook?

159 replies

bobbytorq · 21/01/2023 10:57

I've been lsitening to radio 2 this morning and Joanna Scanlan is on ans she said she made a roux for the first time recently and found it hard work. I make a roux often and it's really easy and my kids have been making them since they were 10/11 too. It made me think that there musrt be loads of people who just don't have the cooking basics.

OP posts:
renonovice · 21/01/2023 12:02

I'm a 2nd gen immigrant who grew up with home cooking from scratch. I hate cooking, it's boring. I do love baking though.

wakeysleepy · 21/01/2023 11:58

It all depends on upbringing I think and personal interests. I'm a bloody good cook but because I love it.

My mum made literally everything from scratch, so I did the same. It was only when I was at uni that I realised it's ok to use jars for cooking, but I only ever do if I'm feeling really lazy.

I'm Indian so I can bang out a curry and some chapatis with my eyes closed. For lots of other people, it's hard work.

For me, baking is hard work. The most I can do is a standard cake. Making puff pastry or bread from scratch is a no no.

ReneBumsWombats · 21/01/2023 11:56

You enjoy your killer roux skills, she can enjoy her acting success and stream of awards and nominations.

AdoraBell · 21/01/2023 11:53

Everyone should be able to cook something, doesn’t have to be roux. My DDs started joining in cooking or preparing things when they were quite young, one wanted to chop the raw chicken I was preparing when they were 3. She did the lettuce instead. Then I let her to chop the chicken when it was cooked, that didn’t need the sharp knife.

My late mother didn’t teach us to cook, just excepted us to be able to cook once we turned 16.

I don’t judge people who can’t cook or a not comfortable cooking.

Casilero · 21/01/2023 11:48

I can make a roux now without thinking but I messed up quite a few times when I first started cooking. Either too thin, too lumpy, burned it.

I don't think cooking is something that comes naturally for a lot of people. I still mess things up and I've been cooking for almost 40 years. I find I'm easily distracted and will forget a key ingredient, or overcook the meat as forgot to note what time I put it on. Can't use a meat thermometer as I've lost all 3 of them.

x2boys · 21/01/2023 11:44

It depends what you mean by cooking ,do I make everything from scratch no,,i.use packets and jars as itjustst makes life a bit simpler
but i.don't just bung a frozen meal i in the oven r either
We get by I make chillies,curry,s as ,roast dinners ,shepherd's pie, etc,etcI'm not an amazing cook but I can cook.

ouch321 · 21/01/2023 11:43

Roux is just melting butter in a pan then stirring in flour, giving it a whisk and then adding milk and then optional extras like cheese no?

PAFMO · 21/01/2023 11:40

I'm ancient and have O'level domestic science. So, yeah, I can make a roux. I can also make puff pastry from scratch. Go me.

I'd consider a more relevant life skill being able to put healthy food on the table for my children tbf.

Making a roux is a basic skill if you intend sauce making to be a big part of feeding yourself.

I doubt it is for most people.

Joanna Scanlon sounds like she's one of those "oh me, can't do anything basic" people. And the OP sounds the opposite.

ShirleyPhallus · 21/01/2023 11:34

Applesandcarrots · 21/01/2023 11:20

Roux can also be brown used in other sauces. It's a thickener used quite widely

I know how to make it but only do so for white sauce to go in lasagne

i think there is also a generational divide here, stuff in white sauce, gravy, cheese sauce etc is very much stuff that my parents and grandparents eat. I rarely eat that kind of food.

Quinoawoman · 21/01/2023 11:34

There are lots of reasons why people might not be able to cook, but I think a lot of it comes down to how you were brought up, your preferred diet (which is linked to upbringing) and your finances.

Imagine you were not brought up in a home where cooking was the norm and you lived on frozen food. You have very little budget yourself to spend on food and have followed the same pattern as your parents. You are aware that your diet is not the healthiest and that cooking from scratch would probably be better, but you fear that your kids won't like what you cook and that it will end up in the bin, wasting precious resources you can't spare. You also worry that you will mess it up, so it will taste awful and again it will end up in the bin. You google a recipe and find that the recipe calls for lots of ingredients you don't have, like herbs or spices. The cost per portion might be low because you only use a tiny amount but can you afford the initial outlay for all the ingredients, knowing that if everyone hates it or it goes wrong, you won't make it again?

Lots of people are also refusing things like potatoes from the food bank as they can't afford to cook them. Just saying.

sweeneytoddsrazor · 21/01/2023 11:33

I consider myself a good cook, I can cook meals from scratch, make my own pastry, sauces , bread, and so on but I cannot make a decent custard or decent poached egg.

ODFOx · 21/01/2023 11:31

You can't pick out one skill and use that as a benchmark.
Eldest DD barely uses the 'old fashioned/classic' cooking techniques that I taught her but cooks light, vegetable and meat low carb meals mostly.
When my parents got married (in the 60s) she was from a rural farming family: lots of eggs and seasonal veg , pies and cobblers and meat left in the aga all day cooked to within an inch of its life. My father on the other hand was living with friends in the city and they ate steak and chops with boiled potatoes and grilled tomatoes.
So he taught her to make a rare steak, she taught him to scramble eggs and make pastry. If you have never needed to make a roux, why would you learn?

BogRollBOGOF · 21/01/2023 11:31

A roux would not be my measure of basic cooking. I'd say it's more intermediate as it's often combined with other cooking stages and can curdle easily, so requires monitoring and technique.

A tomato based sauce to make something like bolognese is simpler and a more basic skill. That's more transferable to make things like simple curries.

The majority of people should have the competency to cook a range of healthy meals covering the key food groups (time is another issue) but some people with conditions that affect executive function or co-ordination may struggle.

WandaWonder · 21/01/2023 11:29

If I was forced too I could if I absolutely had too, I am forever grateful my husband does 99% of it while I happily do other things

Baldieheid · 21/01/2023 11:28

Not everyone enjoys cooking. I do, and I was lucky enough to have a Mum who was a trained cook, so I enjoy the entire process, from planning, shopping, cooking and, of course, eating.
I'd like to think if anyone I know wants to learn but isn't confident, they'd ask me and I could pass my skills on, but I don't blame them if they're not interested or don't have time. We're fortunate that there are healthy, easy alternatives these days.

MintJulia · 21/01/2023 11:27

I did three years of home economics at school, years 7-9. We learnt the basics of nutrition, cooking and sewing.

On the basis of an hour a week for those three years, I cook from scratch every day, make all my own curtains and soft furnishings and know how to keep ds healthy. I can repair our clothes, making them last much longer. I can make clothes if necessary.

Those lessons have saved me thousands over the years. The difference between just one set of decent ready made curtains and making them myself is probably £500. I've never been overweight or wasted money on "slimming" foods. I can avoid some price rises by knowing what to substitute.

Those skills are essential for anyone without a helpful mum.

Ilovelurchers · 21/01/2023 11:27

Making a roux is not the only measure of ability to cook. I don't think my husband can make one (I mean, he obviously could - he could look it up on the internet and then do it) and he isn't massively in to cooking but he can cook a number of things from scratch.

I do loads of cooking with my 10 year old daughter, but that is only because she really enjoys it. I wouldn't insist if she wasn't in to it. I left home without being able to cook anything at all, and consider myself a fairly decent home cook now.

It's not rocket science. Very easy to teach yourself anything about cooking you want to know, as long as you have access to the internet. Much harder for those who don't,of course.

Also agree there is a financial element to cooking from scratch. Tho each individual meal might turn out cheaper, you have to be able to make the initial investment in the different types of pans, different seasonings you might need to make stuff taste nice, etc etc..

Fairislefandango · 21/01/2023 11:22

Well ideally yes, people should be able to cook, but there are all sorts of reasons why it's not that surprising that many people can't. There's really no need to be smug or judgmental about it.

Fwiw I don't really think teaching it more in schools would help that much. People either learn to cook at home when they're growing up, or choose to learn later as adults. Or they don’t, because it's not a priority for them.

I did home economics at school and my mum was a pretty good cook. Neither of those things actually taught me to cook though - I taught myself as an adult because I like good food and so I had the motivation.

People who claim they just can't learn to cook or follow a recipe are talking bollocks though (barring disabilities etc). Anyone can cook if they want to learn.

Mamaneedsadrink · 21/01/2023 11:21

Absolutely! My mum is an amazing cook, and her mum even better. Unfortunately mum decided that my education was more important and didn't teach me, so now I have no idea how to cook traditional meals for my gradmothers native country. Ironically my mum being progressive has not done me any favours. My cousins are all the same!

Applesandcarrots · 21/01/2023 11:20

PeekAtYou · 21/01/2023 11:18

Not being able to make a roux is hardly s measure of whether or not you can cook. Lots of people may not even eat food in a white sauce.

Roux can also be brown used in other sauces. It's a thickener used quite widely

PeekAtYou · 21/01/2023 11:18

Not being able to make a roux is hardly s measure of whether or not you can cook. Lots of people may not even eat food in a white sauce.

Applesandcarrots · 21/01/2023 11:16

Yanbu but you will get proper "but" Olympics here.
Most of my immigrant friends and I still can't get our heads over the fact that unlike in many other countries (maaany) including our native ones, only "well off" people here can apparently cook and afford to cook. It's the other way around nearly everywhere. No way could my family afford ready meals and takeaways!

Not learning when someone was a child is also not a stopper. I mean we would never know most things then, wouldn't we.

PuttingDownRoots · 21/01/2023 11:13

Roux is just the flour, butter and milk base for things like cheese sauce.

Thesearmsofmine · 21/01/2023 11:13

A roux is a white sauce. I make it all the time as a base for meals. Loads of people can’t cook for a whole host of reasons, I won’t judge them for it.

Gymtok · 21/01/2023 11:11

I've never even heard of a roux.