Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that allowances should be made for mental health conditions and neurodiversity in the workplace?

128 replies

FromTheSoul · 21/01/2023 08:26

I have complex mental health problems and am ND. These things are known about at my place of work but I don't think allowances or considerations are made in the same way they would for a physical illness perhaps. Even though many mental health conditions can also present physically.

I feel like when you say to someone that you suffer with anxiety, SOME people will not take it seriously or will be dismissive. At my workplace I've told a couple of trusted people how bad my mental health can be. For example, recently it's been very bad. I've lost weight, had to increase my meds, seen a private psychiatrist. I have a mix of health anxiety, ocd, ptsd, pnd and a history of panic attacks. As well as that I'm neurodiverse. These things have been clinically assessed which my medical notes will show. So it's not just anxiety at a lower level, mine can be severe.

Up until the last couple of years, post having my children, I've masked these problems at work but it's become harder to do that. I feel that I can do my job, I want to do my job but every so often, I might need allowances to be made. But does this mean I have to let everyone know? I don't really feel comfortable with that. As it is, I have about 5 people at work that know. I also don't want management thinking I'm not up to doing my job because I can do it.

I don't want to say what the type of workplace this is as it could be outing. But the pressure is on in the type of work.

But I just wonder if mental health and ND was better known about (still!... in 2023) and considered in the workplace generally, then things would be different.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
EasterIsland · 22/01/2023 13:09

And legally, the adjustments aren't there to take workload off people, but to adjust arrangements for work, so that they can do their jobs. THe point is "reasonable."

This principle makes sense, and it's why the experience of @jessieminto is so shocking : it's unfair and also shooting the management/business in the foot. Accommodations would have enabled her workplace to keep her productive - they've lost someone who sounds like a very productive employee.

The problem we hit with a colleague with a mental illness (as opposed to a physical disability) was the denial (even when they were sectioned), the covering up, the refusal to engage, and the lack of acknowledgement tht others were having to take up the work they dropped.

BirdyWoof · 22/01/2023 12:17

Ameanstreakamilewide · 22/01/2023 09:03

There's a woman i work with, who has been on sick leave for about 3 months, or thereabouts.

She's now come back to work, but is constantly asking for more time off and asking to leave early.
I heard one of her close colleagues on the phone to his manager complaining about her unreliability, because they can't trust her to actually complete a task.
So someone else has to routinely also her job as well as their own.
It also begs the question of what she is actually doing at work.

It's an untenable situation, really, and something's gotta give. Especially because of the bad feeling it's stirred up. People get resentful.

This is really common these days and I think a lot of people are just losing their patience with it now, to be honest. I certainly am.

I have empathy because I’ve been there and I know how debilitating MH issues can be, but

It isn’t anyone else’s responsibility to pick up my slack.

It has to be something that works for everyone involved. As an example- say I don’t like doing presentations because of my anxiety, someone else will have to do more because of that. However, I need to have a strength where I can take the workload off that person in the other regard (ie I’m good at doing research). I can’t just offload work onto others and do the bare minimum while being paid the same wage. That isn’t fair.

Ultimately people need to come in with reasonable expectations of what adaptions need made to support them in work, but they still need to do the job. They need to put in place measures outside of work that continue to support them on their journey so they do get better. And, if things are still too difficult, then they need to look for work that is better suited.

There are an increasing number of individuals who want adjustments made, to barely do their job, get paid the full amount and be able to use their diagnosis as a get out of jail card for every single thing they either

  • don’t want to do
  • don't like doing
  • haven’t done
  • have no intention of doing

I think ultimately that is why people aren’t interested in hearing about other people’s health problems to be honest. It’s not for a lack of empathy, but simply that whenever people mention that they’re struggling with x or y, it’s always with an underlying explanation of why they haven’t done their job properly, or trying to guilt trip others into offering to do work for them.

This is exactly why I think people should keep their health concerns to themselves in work and only mention it to their line manager, HR and OH. Talk to those about it who need to know, agree adjustments and then get on with your job. All your colleagues don’t need an excuse to why you aren’t going to meet your deadlines every week.

PermanentTemporary · 22/01/2023 10:30

@Ameanstreakamilewide not ok id agree. Quite clearly she's not ready to be back at work. But also an employer has a right to say that sick leave has to end at some point.

Twillow · 22/01/2023 10:21

Generally I've found that they are. But YABU to expect that allowances should be made without sharing it with management, just as with a physical condition.

Puffin87 · 22/01/2023 10:19

Ameanstreakamilewide · 22/01/2023 09:03

There's a woman i work with, who has been on sick leave for about 3 months, or thereabouts.

She's now come back to work, but is constantly asking for more time off and asking to leave early.
I heard one of her close colleagues on the phone to his manager complaining about her unreliability, because they can't trust her to actually complete a task.
So someone else has to routinely also her job as well as their own.
It also begs the question of what she is actually doing at work.

It's an untenable situation, really, and something's gotta give. Especially because of the bad feeling it's stirred up. People get resentful.

This is one of the main reasons I don't disclose having a serious disability. I don't want to be lumped in with people like this.

TheOrigRights · 22/01/2023 09:08

I wonder if OP will be back let us know we have helped with her situation.

Ameanstreakamilewide · 22/01/2023 09:03

There's a woman i work with, who has been on sick leave for about 3 months, or thereabouts.

She's now come back to work, but is constantly asking for more time off and asking to leave early.
I heard one of her close colleagues on the phone to his manager complaining about her unreliability, because they can't trust her to actually complete a task.
So someone else has to routinely also her job as well as their own.
It also begs the question of what she is actually doing at work.

It's an untenable situation, really, and something's gotta give. Especially because of the bad feeling it's stirred up. People get resentful.

Ameanstreakamilewide · 22/01/2023 08:54

In the situation with the student teachers, I wouldn't have the nerve to come right out with it and say i only wanted to work x amount of lessons and I didn't want to plan the lessons myself.

How do they say it with a straight face?!

It's incredibly entitled and the (so-called) adult equivalent of getting their mum to write a note to excuse them from PE.

EasterIsland · 21/01/2023 22:56

StClare101 · 21/01/2023 22:10

I’ve also been in this position. I was the manager. It impacted me greatly and of course the rest of my team.

Commiserations, @StClare101 - I left that particular work place. I think it’s really tough on managers who often have NO resources for this sort of thing.

And sometimes, a mental illness is trickier and more difficult to manage than a physical illness, because there’s a whole denial thing going on.

Dishwashersaurous · 21/01/2023 22:34

They are and they should be.

However, there needs to be a proper occupational health assessment and what adjustments are appropriate and necessary.

What reasonable adjustments have you requested?

EasterIsland · 21/01/2023 22:34

GCAcademic · 21/01/2023 11:10

I think this is a massive issue. I work somewhere where accommodations are made very liberally for people with mental health issues and all too often these accommodations come at the expense of other people’s mental health and / or workload.

I hear you!

Some workplaces are over reliant on those of us with robust mental and physical health - or maybe we’re just good copers!

Cuppasoupmonster · 21/01/2023 22:14

How can you expect people to make allowances and be more understanding if you don’t feel ‘comfortable’ telling them? Confused people aren’t mind readers. Bit baffled by your whole post tbh

StClare101 · 21/01/2023 22:10

EasterIsland · 21/01/2023 21:34

The crux of this is “reasonable” adjustments. And tne problem is that sometimes there are very widely different ideas about what is reasonable.

I used to work with someone with a chronic and serious mental illness and it could be very difficult at times because they would not engage with Occupational Health. They thought they could do the job, but would inevitability have a relapse and just drop everything. We used to have to pick up the work (not the kind of work place where you could leave stuff not done). We were all under pressure and distressed by the situation at times - seeing a colleague have a psychotic episode in a meeting but them completely denying that there was anything wrong - it’s not a sustainable situation.

I know that trying to manage this colleague drove my then boss into ill-health themselves. The problem was intransigent - this colleague was not capable of holding down the job full-time but proved very evasive in engaging with support. It became a disciplinary matter unfortunately. It was awful all round.

I’ve also been in this position. I was the manager. It impacted me greatly and of course the rest of my team.

BornBlonde · 21/01/2023 22:03

jessieminto · 21/01/2023 11:14

As an experienced manager with a physical disability I need to point out there is a lot of factually correct information on this thread about what should happen and what rights you have.

In practice, the world is very different. It's not that simple and you will not get the adjustments you need or are entitled to. You will get fired or managed out instead. They will call it redundancy. You need to be in a union at all times.

Every adjustment has to be negotiated, no matter how reasonable. And every adjustment 'costs' you something, you need to be more flexible about something else in return or demonstrate you are worth the extra effort somehow. That's the reality of working with a disability, seen or not.

As a wheelchair user, I have been denied an accessible desk. I've been refused a shift pattern that would enable me to take medication at the specified times. I've been refused a shift pattern that enables me to finish on time every day, rather than unknown unplanned for extra hours of up to 90mins after a 9hr day. I've been refused access to the company car park as it's reserved for directors only, even though I have a blue badge and a wheelchair and there is no other places to consistently park. I've been refused a desk fan, not allowed to bring in my own or have one provided, even though my medication is heat sensitive and could cause an overdose if I get too hot. I've been refused meetings in ground floor rooms when there is no lift in the building and I'm in a fucking wheelchair. I asked for a pot plant to be moved, as it was blocking the wheelchair access in to the building, I was getting a face full of fern every day. Denied. The list goes on.

Yes it's all wrong. No. I never went to tribunal. Every time I complained I lost my job. The largest payout I got was around 15 months salary, the smallest was just 3 months. But I was still out of work because I tried to assert my rights. And my CV is a shit show.

My advice to anyone who needs reasonable adjustments is to start being incredibly reasonable yourself first. Negotiate and make your request a win/win for the business. Be really clear about what you need, why, and how the business will benefit from doing this. It shouldn't have to be this way but the laws are not enforced and there is no one to protect you.

@jessieminto what you describe is dreadful. So sorry to read your experiences

My2pence2day · 21/01/2023 22:02

Puffin87 · 21/01/2023 21:15

Although I wouldn't say menial, just something suited to the way that person's disability manifests.

As in if you get anxious speaking on the phone, don't go for a call centre job.

Yes this is better, menial is probably the wrong word. I just meant "low stress"

EasterIsland · 21/01/2023 21:34

The crux of this is “reasonable” adjustments. And tne problem is that sometimes there are very widely different ideas about what is reasonable.

I used to work with someone with a chronic and serious mental illness and it could be very difficult at times because they would not engage with Occupational Health. They thought they could do the job, but would inevitability have a relapse and just drop everything. We used to have to pick up the work (not the kind of work place where you could leave stuff not done). We were all under pressure and distressed by the situation at times - seeing a colleague have a psychotic episode in a meeting but them completely denying that there was anything wrong - it’s not a sustainable situation.

I know that trying to manage this colleague drove my then boss into ill-health themselves. The problem was intransigent - this colleague was not capable of holding down the job full-time but proved very evasive in engaging with support. It became a disciplinary matter unfortunately. It was awful all round.

XenoBitch · 21/01/2023 21:16

Sometimes, no allowances can be made. In my last job, nothing could be done, and I had to soldier on like everyone else.

Puffin87 · 21/01/2023 21:15

Puffin87 · 21/01/2023 21:13

I agree with this. Some people with disabilities will thrive in a stressful job. Others won't.

Although I wouldn't say menial, just something suited to the way that person's disability manifests.

As in if you get anxious speaking on the phone, don't go for a call centre job.

Puffin87 · 21/01/2023 21:13

My2pence2day · 21/01/2023 19:15

If you can't handle a stressful job, then don't have a stressful job. Do something more menial. That's what happens with people I know in RL.
Some of the examples here sound like people basically want to be spoon-fed and hand-held, which ultimately means someone else will have to pick up the slack

I agree with this. Some people with disabilities will thrive in a stressful job. Others won't.

IDontCareMatthew · 21/01/2023 19:38

My2pence2day · 21/01/2023 19:15

If you can't handle a stressful job, then don't have a stressful job. Do something more menial. That's what happens with people I know in RL.
Some of the examples here sound like people basically want to be spoon-fed and hand-held, which ultimately means someone else will have to pick up the slack

That's what the world is becoming it seems!

No resilience at all.

Busybutbored · 21/01/2023 19:30

Caterguin · 21/01/2023 18:56

Similar with trainee teachers. They only want to teach one or two lessons occasionally and don't want constructive criticism of their lessons. If they get honest feedback, they don't feel supported. They often don't want to plan their own lessons. This has been a pattern over a few years now. And we have a few mentors, so it's not like it's one arsey mentor.

Obviously the sink or swim approach to pgces probably wasn't brilliant, but fuck me, if you survived that and your probationary year, nothing was ever as bad again.

I possibly am a little unsympathetic. But kids whose teachers have long periods of absence have a shit deal.

I don't understand this at all, why pick these jobs. It sounds more that they want part time jobs for full time pay? Or someone to do the 'hard bits', or the idea of the job but not the actual job.
What happens in these situations, do they eventually leave? Sounds very difficult having people like this in your 'team'.

Scooopsahoy · 21/01/2023 19:25

If you can't handle a stressful job, then don't have a stressful job. Do something more menial. That's what happens with people I know in RL.

I think a part of the problem is that ‘progressing’ at work is presented as the norm and as something we should all aspire to. When actually for a lot of people’s mental health, and general quality of life, sticking with a lower-paid lower-stress job would be best.

But we’re all fed this line that once you’re good at a job the next obvious step is to try and get a promotion to the next level, rather than carry on at your current level. And yes I know it’s bound up with issues of pay and income, but we as a society need to stop idolising progressing at work, and stop to think about the links with stress this causes.

MissMarplesbag · 21/01/2023 19:23

www.ambitiousaboutautism.org.uk/what-we-do/employment

Ambitious about Autism has lots of resources for neurodiverse people in education and employment.

JudgeRudy · 21/01/2023 19:21

Fleabigg · 21/01/2023 09:54

Mental health conditions can be classed as disabilities and allowances can and are made in many settings. It’s also true though that there can be some jobs that, with all the allowances in the world, still aren’t suitable for a particular individual.

I agree. It's one thing asking for reasonable adjustments (unsure what OP is expecting herer) but sometimes the adjustments or 'leeway' people want isn't reasonable and the jobs not for them. Hopefully this isn't the case here and OP will be able to discuss with OH/HR/managent what would help her manage her condition so she can fulfil the role

My2pence2day · 21/01/2023 19:15

If you can't handle a stressful job, then don't have a stressful job. Do something more menial. That's what happens with people I know in RL.
Some of the examples here sound like people basically want to be spoon-fed and hand-held, which ultimately means someone else will have to pick up the slack

Swipe left for the next trending thread