Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WWYD - Found deceased mum's letters to my dad

109 replies

ThePastKnocks · 20/01/2023 21:12

My parents split when I was a child, my dad was pretty flakey then one year he just didn't turn up for me anymore. He's been like it on and off during my life. I've got to the point that we chat and I enjoy him visiting/meeting up as a family a few times a year but I tend to keep my expectations very low due to my childhood. He seems to be trying his best though and was supportive through the bereavement.

I'd just been looking for a document and found 5 files. The first one is red unlike the others so I took a quick peek thinking I'll have to sort through them later. From a quick glance, it's letters to my dad and then potentially some responses and maybe court stuff.

Should I read the file(s) - I don't know how many are about this.

AIBU - No
YANBU - Yes

OP posts:
MrsJackGrealish · 20/01/2023 22:42

When cleaning out my grandparents house, we found some letters between my Nan and another man, heavily implying that there was an affair going on.

My mum had no idea.

Mydogatemypurse · 20/01/2023 22:28

I read some documents when clearing up after my mum died. Found out my dad had been married b4 my mum. I had no one to ask about it, i dont know if they had any children. Dad was older than Mum.
He was a shit dad when he was with us, and we barely saw him after divorce, so it's entirely believable that he could have had kids he ignored or not.

You can open a can of worms i fear.

junglistmassive · 20/01/2023 22:26

I think she would probably like you to know as an adult what she went through and the lengths she went to try to facilitate a relationship with him. I suspect that's mostly what's in there.

You know he wasn't a good dad and you realise that he's changed somewhat from those days, although maybe not completely. I don't think you'll be shocked.

BatshitBanshee · 20/01/2023 22:26

ThePastKnocks · 20/01/2023 22:14

Sorry, see my update @Thighdentitycrisis . It's about the divorce, navigating co-parenting (or not) and me. Nothing to do with their romantic relationship.

She was sending typed letters and keeping a copy of what she sent, perhaps for court?

It was a bit of a drip feed, I'm a bit frazzled and this has surprised me. It has come at a time when I thought I'd packed away my 'childhood dad' and any associated trauma but I've been reading a parenting book which suggested reflection on your own childhood and how it impacts us as parents. Now to find this, it could open up old feelings but it could help too.

DH has suggested reading them with a therapist but I'm wondering if I really need to know any more. Reflecting upon them both, they were toxic in their own ways.

Well then risk vs. reward OP. I'm very careful about what and how I dredge up things from childhood, depending on the day it could be fine or could be very triggering and send me into a spiral. I will say that through therapy, I've learned to revisit certain situations and parent myself - it's been very beneficial.

Maybe skim read first and if it starts to hurt then stop. Are you in a place with your dad now where you could say hey what was this about or why did this happen? Weigh up what you would gain by reading and what you would lose.

Also there's nothing stopping you from putting them in a box and maybe revisiting later. You don't need to do anything this minute.

TakeABite · 20/01/2023 22:22

As a teenager I found a letter my DF had written to DM, they were divorcing.

I wish I hadn’t read it.

Fink · 20/01/2023 22:17

I would scan through them all (or ask a friend to, if it brought up too many difficult memories) to make sure there was nothing except personal correspondance - no legal documents etc. I certainly wouldn't be disposing of them until I knew that for sure: even if the first few were personal, some people don't file very consistently and there may be more significant documents in there too.

If they turned out all to be personal letters, then I think it would depend on whether you think your dad would want them or not. If he would, then you could offer them the next time you meet, and if he says he's not interested then dispose of them or keep them as you wish. If he definitely wouldn't want them or your relationship isn't such that you could ask him, then don't offer.

ThePastKnocks · 20/01/2023 22:14

Sorry, see my update @Thighdentitycrisis . It's about the divorce, navigating co-parenting (or not) and me. Nothing to do with their romantic relationship.

She was sending typed letters and keeping a copy of what she sent, perhaps for court?

It was a bit of a drip feed, I'm a bit frazzled and this has surprised me. It has come at a time when I thought I'd packed away my 'childhood dad' and any associated trauma but I've been reading a parenting book which suggested reflection on your own childhood and how it impacts us as parents. Now to find this, it could open up old feelings but it could help too.

DH has suggested reading them with a therapist but I'm wondering if I really need to know any more. Reflecting upon them both, they were toxic in their own ways.

OP posts:
Seeingadistance · 20/01/2023 21:58

I’m sorry for your loss and I can understand your curiosity about the letters and documents now that you have found them.

Your thread has reminded me that I should find and destroy any emails and documents between me and my ex when we were separating and divorcing, as I really wouldn’t want my DS to read them, especially after my death when I am no longer here to discuss them with him.

BatshitBanshee · 20/01/2023 21:55

I'd read them. I wouldn't have to think too hard about it either. But just remember three things:

  1. a relationship, broken or intact, is recounted by two points of view and not what actually happened. Don't get weighed down by any ins and outs that maybe in the letters. Whatever was going on, it doesn't matter now.

  2. you may read things about yourself as a child that may hurt to recount now. That is normal but you have to be comfortable with the possiblity you might be uncomfortable for a while after reading.

  3. people change and no one is perfect. If you get on with your dad now I'd try to hold onto that and not crucify him for what he did or didn't do in the past.

Thighdentitycrisis · 20/01/2023 21:45

Sorry for your loss OP
I might be missing the point but your mother has died and in her things are these letters written to your father?
then did he return them to her, or they were never posted? If the latter, then it’s like her diary isn’t it?

Christmasbaubleswithtinselon · 20/01/2023 21:45

@tillytown what on earth have I just read. Your actions were unforgivable. You had less say than your DH and Sister in law. They should have discussed it between them. What a fucking awful thing to do.

tillytown · 20/01/2023 21:43

saraclara · 20/01/2023 21:37

They weren't hers. They were private letters. If there are any letters from the early days of my relationship with my DH lurking somewhere and my kids doing then, I very much hope they will respect our privacy even though we're gone.

There'd be nothing steamy in them, but even so, they were never meant for anyone else's eyes.

They weren't yours either. Her and her brother should have decided what to do with them, you shouldn't have been involved at all.

Circumferences · 20/01/2023 21:39

If he cared enough to sort through the house himself he'd have found the correspondences himself.
He doesn't.
They're yours purely to check there's nothing amiss financially regarding her estate. Not snooping is it.

saraclara · 20/01/2023 21:37

leithreas · 20/01/2023 21:32

Fucking hell! The woman was grieving and upset that you burnt a connection to her mother and now you don't speak to her. I mean maybe it's the way you have phrased it but you come across as ice cold.

They weren't hers. They were private letters. If there are any letters from the early days of my relationship with my DH lurking somewhere and my kids doing then, I very much hope they will respect our privacy even though we're gone.

There'd be nothing steamy in them, but even so, they were never meant for anyone else's eyes.

TellMeWhere · 20/01/2023 21:37

ThePastKnocks · 20/01/2023 21:32

I'd had a quick look on the first page to see what was in it, quite ready to bin the folder at some point as she kept everything, even sticky notes from the early 90s. It pertains to me actually, it mentions my behaviour at that age and how I'd cried as I was missing him and didn't know if he'd forgotten me. I vaguely remember the tears and definitely remember him not turning up!

She never said a bad word about him so I think that was going to be her way of shedding some light on things in years to come if I wanted to know.

It's not love letters, more so from during and after their divorce.

In which case I'd hang on to them and maybe go through them when you feel better placed to read what's within.

ivykaty44 · 20/01/2023 21:36

What will you achieve by reading the letters?

what if there are things in those letters that Rob you of a dad as your feeling change. You’ve list your mum you may regret reading these letters

what about keeping the letters safe and sometime in the future reading them, possibly after other people have left this earth.

TellMeWhere · 20/01/2023 21:35

I know my mum has some lovely letters between my grandparents, from when they were separated due to war (nan was German).

Wouldn't dream of throwing them away. Certainly can't imagine setting them on fire! How horrible.

They have historical and sentimental value to me.

Guess it depends what you're expecting to find, but I'd give them a quick glance.

ThePastKnocks · 20/01/2023 21:32

I'd had a quick look on the first page to see what was in it, quite ready to bin the folder at some point as she kept everything, even sticky notes from the early 90s. It pertains to me actually, it mentions my behaviour at that age and how I'd cried as I was missing him and didn't know if he'd forgotten me. I vaguely remember the tears and definitely remember him not turning up!

She never said a bad word about him so I think that was going to be her way of shedding some light on things in years to come if I wanted to know.

It's not love letters, more so from during and after their divorce.

OP posts:
leithreas · 20/01/2023 21:32

Mum2jenny · 20/01/2023 21:21

We burned private letters we found between my dh’s dad and his wife and didn’t read them and we were crucified by dh’s ds.
And we’d do it again. She thought she should be able to read them and we thought it totally inappropriate.
And we do not ever speak to her again….

Fucking hell! The woman was grieving and upset that you burnt a connection to her mother and now you don't speak to her. I mean maybe it's the way you have phrased it but you come across as ice cold.

tillytown · 20/01/2023 21:31

I'd read them, but my parents suck so there is nothing I could read that would lower my opinion of them.

Zosime · 20/01/2023 21:31

perhaps you could ask a friend to read them on your behalf?

OP's father is still alive. It would be a shocking breach of his privacy to allow a stranger to read letters between him and his late wife.

OP, I think you should tell your father you have found these letters and ask what he would like you to do with them. If they were written to him, they belong to him.

JudgeRudy · 20/01/2023 21:28

Not quite the same but when clearing my uncles flat following his death I came across some love letters and some pretty dating court papers relating to his former marriage. My cousins (their children) are scattered so a lot fell to me. Once I realised what they were I put them in a sealed envelope and passed them on to my aunt (his ex) so she could chose what to do. I actually felt quite uncomfortable having accidentally them. Even though I didn't read them I saw certain phrases and got the general gist. Don't open Pandoras Box

NumberTheory · 20/01/2023 21:28

I would almost certainly read them. Whether you should or not I think depends a lot on you.

Are you very curious and likely to dwell on them if you don’t read them? How would you cope if you found evidence your dad or your mum were actually very different from the people you currently see them as?

Soontobe60 · 20/01/2023 21:26

When my dad died, I found some letters my mum had written him when they divorced 20 years previously. I really wish I hadn’t read them.

When mum died last year, I found other letters in her belongings. I didn’t read them and threw them away straight away so I wouldn’t be tempted.

perhaps you could ask a friend to read them on your behalf?

Motelschmotel · 20/01/2023 21:24

Mum2jenny · 20/01/2023 21:21

We burned private letters we found between my dh’s dad and his wife and didn’t read them and we were crucified by dh’s ds.
And we’d do it again. She thought she should be able to read them and we thought it totally inappropriate.
And we do not ever speak to her again….

That’s horrific! He was as much your DH’s sister’s father as your DH’s father, I’m assuming?

Appalling behaviour by you, it absolutely was not for you to decide.