Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WWYD - Found deceased mum's letters to my dad

109 replies

ThePastKnocks · 20/01/2023 21:12

My parents split when I was a child, my dad was pretty flakey then one year he just didn't turn up for me anymore. He's been like it on and off during my life. I've got to the point that we chat and I enjoy him visiting/meeting up as a family a few times a year but I tend to keep my expectations very low due to my childhood. He seems to be trying his best though and was supportive through the bereavement.

I'd just been looking for a document and found 5 files. The first one is red unlike the others so I took a quick peek thinking I'll have to sort through them later. From a quick glance, it's letters to my dad and then potentially some responses and maybe court stuff.

Should I read the file(s) - I don't know how many are about this.

AIBU - No
YANBU - Yes

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 21/01/2023 08:36

knittingaddict · 21/01/2023 08:14

The sil didn't burn the letters. The op of that post and her husband did. Shocking behaviour and no wonder the sil is so upset.

My mum died this year and we went through the house together and made joint decisions about what to keep and what to chuck. No letters were found unfortunately.

I think she was referring to the poster when she said sil.

knittingaddict · 21/01/2023 08:14

Terzani · 21/01/2023 08:01

This! These letters are part of OP's family history, a part of OP's inheritance. It is normal for all children to want to find more about their parents, to want to understand them better. A deceased mother isn't some stranger whose privacy is breached by a grieving child who misses her and wants to remember her and to know her better by reading and keeping anything written by her.
I have no idea why so many PPs are so obsessed with an hypothetical soap opera scenario, with OP risking to discover some sinister secrets or dirty laundry.
The most natural thing for children is to keep and cherish any memories left by their deceased parents. Not to reject and destroy them (or to ask friends to read them instead and summarise them!??) because some movies managed to scare young people into thinking that any letter or diary left by mum or granny has the potential to reveal that the deceased one was a monster.

As for that SIL deciding on her own to burn documents that pertain to someone else's family history... no words.

The sil didn't burn the letters. The op of that post and her husband did. Shocking behaviour and no wonder the sil is so upset.

My mum died this year and we went through the house together and made joint decisions about what to keep and what to chuck. No letters were found unfortunately.

Terzani · 21/01/2023 08:01

Ramblingnamechanger · 21/01/2023 05:54

Reading my parents letters was like therapy for me . I finally understood their relationship, their grief and why things were the way they were… I know this is not directly relevant here, but I found it a fascinating and compelling process.

This! These letters are part of OP's family history, a part of OP's inheritance. It is normal for all children to want to find more about their parents, to want to understand them better. A deceased mother isn't some stranger whose privacy is breached by a grieving child who misses her and wants to remember her and to know her better by reading and keeping anything written by her.
I have no idea why so many PPs are so obsessed with an hypothetical soap opera scenario, with OP risking to discover some sinister secrets or dirty laundry.
The most natural thing for children is to keep and cherish any memories left by their deceased parents. Not to reject and destroy them (or to ask friends to read them instead and summarise them!??) because some movies managed to scare young people into thinking that any letter or diary left by mum or granny has the potential to reveal that the deceased one was a monster.

As for that SIL deciding on her own to burn documents that pertain to someone else's family history... no words.

DanceMonkey19 · 21/01/2023 06:14

It's difficult. Trying to put myself in your shoes, I think I would want to read them. However, they can't be unseen after the event. Sometimes ignorance is bliss. I can't see what good could come of it, only bad. So I would ignore them for now. Sorry about your mum op Flowers

Ramblingnamechanger · 21/01/2023 05:54

Reading my parents letters was like therapy for me . I finally understood their relationship, their grief and why things were the way they were… I know this is not directly relevant here, but I found it a fascinating and compelling process.

Ramblingnamechanger · 21/01/2023 05:50

If your father were dead I don’t see a problem. As it is perhaps ask him for permission to read them/ give them to him/ extract anything you need for practical purposes ( wills, divorce papers, nationality birth death certs etc.

Emmamoo89 · 21/01/2023 04:40

Burn them. Not good idea to read them

Mummyoflittledragon · 21/01/2023 04:00

I think you need hang onto the correspondence until you’re ready to read it or let it go without regret.

Mummyoflittledragon · 21/01/2023 03:59

Blossomtoes · 21/01/2023 00:15

This. It takes a lot to shock me but this did. How incredibly high handed.

I agree. Absolutely disgusting.

JennyWI · 21/01/2023 02:59

read it! there may be somthing important in there for you to know, or mabye even somthing that would make you look at your father in a different light

knittingaddict · 21/01/2023 02:11

In the op's case I would return the letters to the father, who wrote them. I think that's the usual etiquette here. I wouldn't read them if one of the parties is still alive.

knittingaddict · 21/01/2023 02:08

Mum2jenny · 20/01/2023 21:21

We burned private letters we found between my dh’s dad and his wife and didn’t read them and we were crucified by dh’s ds.
And we’d do it again. She thought she should be able to read them and we thought it totally inappropriate.
And we do not ever speak to her again….

Ds = sister?

As a family historian I feel her pain. How was it your husband's place to make that decision on his own without giving her the option of keeping them? I'm actually appalled that you would do that.

OneFrenchEgg · 21/01/2023 01:53

Anne Frank's diary. Such a breach of confidence, I'm shocked how many people thinkm it's ok to read it.

  1. This is a different situation obviously Confused
  2. You don't know how I feel about the publication of her diary
sjpkgp1 · 21/01/2023 01:11

Soontobe60 · 20/01/2023 21:26

When my dad died, I found some letters my mum had written him when they divorced 20 years previously. I really wish I hadn’t read them.

When mum died last year, I found other letters in her belongings. I didn’t read them and threw them away straight away so I wouldn’t be tempted.

perhaps you could ask a friend to read them on your behalf?

I think @Soontobe60 has suggested a really good thing. Explain the dilemma to a good friend, ask them to read them, and ask them to summarise and recommend what you should do.

allswellthatends · 21/01/2023 01:03

Seriously? You may not have been adult but you were definitely part of the marriage snd are entitled to know what happened. As others have said, if you're not sure now just put them away for now. But never destroy family history!!

CharlotteRose90 · 21/01/2023 00:41

You know what I would read them. When I was younger I somehow found the divorce papers between my mum and dad. And read them. I’m actually glad i did as it showed my dad in a completely different light and the person he is today. Changed my opinion on him and I’ve never forgiven him

Scrumbleton · 21/01/2023 00:16

I recently shredded all the many many paper copies relating to my expensive, painful and toxic divorce ( more than a decade ago). I was afraid that my now adult DD would one day read them. They reflected some very bad behaviour on
both sides particularly ExH. To this day it's the worst divorce I've known of outside those in the papers. Though DD is practically NC with ExH I wouldn't want her to read what we both experienced. So no, please leave the past in the past and respect their privacy.

Blossomtoes · 21/01/2023 00:15

Delphinium20 · 20/01/2023 22:48

I'd have crucified you too. How dare you decide for your SIL what she can and cannot see belonging to her own deceased parents.

This. It takes a lot to shock me but this did. How incredibly high handed.

Member869894 · 21/01/2023 00:07

Please don't. When people are going through divorce or separation they are often at their very worst. My ex partner and i spent a year sending each other the most horrible vitriolic messages. We are both nice people and eventually managed to become relatively amicable but we really both did lose the plot when separating. I would hate my children to see them.

TellMeWhere · 21/01/2023 00:06

ThePastKnocks · 20/01/2023 23:50

The letters are from 20 odd years ago. He's always been funny about my mother being mentioned and even 20+ years after their divorce, my dad was so awkward with her at my wedding. She was trying to be overly nice, maybe he questioned her motives.

My mum died just before Covid so it's been a while but I feel that's probably impacted the grieving process. I've chucked lots out already. Today was a chance finding due to desperately needing something from my own paperwork I'd done around the time she died. Part of me thinks, at some point I have to read them or bin them. I can't keep them forever, can I?

I can't ask my dad though. Whether he says yes or no, he will burn bridges.

You seem to be treading on eggshells to ensure you don't upset the apple cart with your dad.

None of my business, but I'd question whether it's worth maintaining a relationship that is so precarious. It sounds exhausting.

I'm not of the opinion that children need to appease their parents.

MissHappiness · 20/01/2023 23:59

OneFrenchEgg · 20/01/2023 23:52

Wow. I'm really shocked at all the people feeling entitled to read private correspondence. I shall be getting the shredder out. I think it's shocking - if you weren't told or shown in their lifetime that's it.

Anne Frank's diary. Such a breach of confidence, I'm shocked how many people thinkm it's ok to read it.

MissHappiness · 20/01/2023 23:58

You can see from the answers here that people respond in different ways to new information from the past, potential timebombs really.

I have taken similar documents to a session with my counsellor after 2 different bereavements. The questions the counsellor asked helped me understand the emotions attached and the risks and potential benefits. Then I decided after I understood why I cared.

I agree with your DH's suggestion, and after all, he knows you better than we do, but if you haven't already got a therapist then that's a project in and of itself because it takes a while to build up the trust.

"I don't have many friends I see anymore"

That's a bit worrying. Have you a lot going on?

5YearsLeft · 20/01/2023 23:55

TellMeWhere · 20/01/2023 21:35

I know my mum has some lovely letters between my grandparents, from when they were separated due to war (nan was German).

Wouldn't dream of throwing them away. Certainly can't imagine setting them on fire! How horrible.

They have historical and sentimental value to me.

Guess it depends what you're expecting to find, but I'd give them a quick glance.

I think this is an interesting point. At what point DO things start to have a historical significance? If the private letters that the previous poster burned were 100 years old and between a great great grandmother and great great grandfather, would she still have burned them? If they’d been worth £1 million, would she have burned them? (Well, she’s being very self-righteous so far, so she might say yes, she still would have, but the answer is no).

Better yet, would she be here saying, “They were private letters between Mr and Mrs Winston Churchill. Of course I burned them all”?

It just seems such a ridiculous thing to do. If someone keeps pictures and letters and other cherished mementos, knowing their children will be going through their estate (unless they die suddenly), why would you BURN those memories of the foundation of your family? You might as well burn it all - the pictures, anything they wrote. It’s ALL private. A life is private. But then you die, and it’s over.

And yes, of course as several have pointed out, the decision should have been made by the letter writer’s two children, not her son and DIL.

Teaandtoast3 · 20/01/2023 23:54

I’m conflicted. One one hand I feel she kept them for a reason. On the other I feel it’s private even though it’s presumably largely about you.

I would shelve them for the moment and give yourself a good amount of time to think about it.

You may end up with more questions than answers.

fUNNYfACE36 · 20/01/2023 23:53

When we were clearing my d3ceased grandfather's stuff we came across a packet labelled 'to be burned on my death' .I have always thought that showed good foresight and maybe we should all think about labelling stuff?

Swipe left for the next trending thread