Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

None of them had arm bands on

87 replies

Pooskidsonthefrock · 20/01/2023 21:01

We live abroad (originally from U.K.) went to a local swimming pool at a country club today, took Dd, 4 into the shallow pool with arm bands on.
A few British families there, all the children without arm bands, floats etc, some younger than Dd, most around age 4 too.
It made me feel a bit crappy that she can’t swim properly yet, I never realised so many kids her age can.
She had lessons when a baby, but then covid hit, my friends kids (her friends) can’t swim yet, am I missing something?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
welshweasel · 21/01/2023 07:52

My kids are 3 (nearly 4) and 6. The 6 year old went to a swimming party last weekend with his class, they all had to swim a length in front of the lifeguards before they were allowed on the inflatables etc as no adults in the pool. They can all swim well. My 3 year old does lessons with some of his friends. None of them can swim independently for more than a metre or so. They use pool noodles in lessons. On holiday we use a float jacket. I'm sure that if he carries on with lessons he'll be swimming well by 5 or 6. I think swimming independently at 4 is unusual but not unheard of.

Dramaalpacas · 21/01/2023 07:46

I got DD into lessons when she turned 4 (as before that I would have had to go in the pool with her and I had a small baby so it wouldn’t have been easy logistically). In the starter class she wore these round foam arm band things. She moved up quite quickly (I think a weeks pool holiday really helped!) and can now swim without armbands. Don’t worry OP, she can start to learn anytime and 4 isn’t unusual that she hasn’t started yet- the swimming pool parties where it would be embarrassing for her to be a non-swimmer don’t start till age 8ish.

Soapnotshowergel · 21/01/2023 07:42

I can still remember the pinch getting them blown up on my arm now - ouch! My dad used to take all three of us swimming on his own so I guess he needed us in arm bands so we didn't drown. I don't think I've seen many kids in armbands over the last few years.

We supervise a child each when we go. DD5 has lessons so we take a float for her and she does her practice or chucks herself in off the side.DD2 mostly walks up and down the pool steps so I just hold her hand.

Passportpondery · 21/01/2023 07:32

Most 4 were olds are not swimming well. However arm bands are a lot less popular now, especially in a shallow pool.

My 3 year old can swim 10m, she has never worn armbands. But I wouldn’t class her as a good swimmer, she still needs a lot of supervision. However if she fell into a swimming pool she could flip to her back and float, or get herself to the side for safety. That’s why we do lessons young, not for the distance swimming.

ChristmasKittens · 21/01/2023 07:29

We live somewhere where kids swim from birth and are swimming on their own quite young. We never use arm bands as it hinders their learning. Obviously we never leave them unattended or in danger either! But it is kind of the same idea as not having stabilisers on a bike. You have to unlearn how to swim/cycle without the aid otherwise.

londonrach · 21/01/2023 07:28

My DD is learning to swim at 6 and about average in her class. We were effected by covid. Arm bands are strongly no recommended. She has a vest but in the pool with swimming instructor using pool noodle. 4 is very young. Don't worry

rhowton · 21/01/2023 07:25

Being able to swim is important and should be prioritised. If you can afford £25 a month, get him swimming lessons as soon as possible.

Stravaig · 21/01/2023 07:22

Don't worry, at DD's age the most important thing is to enjoy the water and the different ways she can play in it. Specific strokes and technique can be learned at any age, and won't be retained without regular practice anyway.

I spent the first 5 years of my life in warm countries with outdoor swimming, and was chucked in a pool to see if I would float long before I could walk. I swam like a fish, all the strokes, including butterfly. Then we came to the UK and I didn't swim again until class lessons in secondary school. I pretty much had to (re)learn from scratch along with everyone else. I'm a very average adult swimmer, unless I'm doing a lot of it. What I do have though is a general happiness in water, any water, whether pool or loch or river or sea. Which opens the door to all sorts of water-based activities.

If your DD is learning joy and confidence in the water, it will last a lifetime, irrespective of ability or technique. If you're going pool swimming a lot, she'll quickly learn the official strokes - however a decent doggy paddle in a variety of outdoor settings is just as valuable!

RedHelenB · 21/01/2023 07:13

GlasgowGal82 · 20/01/2023 22:15

We never used arm bands because they get in the way of learning to swim properly. My five year old still can't swim because we've not been able to get him into lessons and he's not had enough pool time due to covid and our other commitments. I'd never put arm bands on him though. When we go to the pool he uses a pool noodle, a shark fin float and I just keep close to him to support him in the water.

All mine used armbands and could swim proper breaststroke by age 5. It really doesn't make that much of a difference in learning to swim if you use armbands or any other flotation device.

MrTumblesSpottyHag · 21/01/2023 07:10

Arm bands get in the way. Both of mine could swim at 4 but we prioritised swimming lessons over any other clubs- for us it's an essential life skill.
I don't even want to contemplate how much it has cost us over the years though 🫣. They started lessons as babies and apart from covid interruptions they've had a lesson every week since then and they're 7 and 10 now. I could probably have bought my own pool 😂

LaFemmeDamnee · 21/01/2023 07:02

Teateaandmoretea · 20/01/2023 22:03

Arm bands or not to arm bands is pretty meh imo. MN is rampantly into trends. Both of mine played around in arm bands when they were little and are now county level swimmers. It never ceases to amaze me how people on here get wound up about details early on then stop swimming lessons when they can still barely swim in stage 5 or so.

Your child is 4 as long as they are enjoying the water great. It’s a good age to start lessons and they will refuse the arm bands within months. What matters in terms of swimming is what you do later on.

Swim Stages don't seem to have much ti do with how well a child can actually swim. DD is at stage 5, which only requires you to swim 10m. Front crawl, breast and back stroke she can swim all day long. Brilliant stamina. But she can't progress until she's mastered the utterly ridiculous butterfly.

Mamaneedsadrink · 21/01/2023 07:01

Endlesssummer2022 · 21/01/2023 06:52

Neither of my DCs used armbands when learning to swim. DH is Australian and a big swimmer, he doesn’t believe armbands are helpful or necessary. In swimming class they use noodles or back floats.

Mine too, noodles or flutter board. DC been swimming since about 6 months old. They discourage arm bands

WonderingWanda · 21/01/2023 06:57

Try and take her to the pool yourself once a week and if you can get a woggle use that instead of bands. Let her build up her confidence of being able to swim about / float and she will just naturally get the hang of it and learn to move, jump in, get a wet face etc, then you can invest in swimming lessons to teach her the correct strokes.

Endlesssummer2022 · 21/01/2023 06:52

Neither of my DCs used armbands when learning to swim. DH is Australian and a big swimmer, he doesn’t believe armbands are helpful or necessary. In swimming class they use noodles or back floats.

Saturnsmoon · 21/01/2023 06:51

I think it’s a bit of a cultural thing. I grew up abroad, somewhere with a lot of water and most kids learn to swim at 3/4 there. I was late at the age of 6 however in the U.K. and other places I’ve lived 4 would be young to be swimming independently.

Oysterbabe · 21/01/2023 06:38

My two started swimming lessons together at 4 and 6, only half hour a week. Covid delayed. It's been 4 months and the 6 year old is doing great, can swim 5 metres, is fine under water and has already moved up a level. The 4 year old is coming along more slowly, still using a noodle. Neither have ever used arm bands.
They start swimming lessons at school in year 4 so I'd like them to both be confident swimmers by then as most of their friends do lessons. I never had lessons, am awful at swimming and always had a deep dread of swimming at school.

sanityisamyth · 21/01/2023 06:25

DS (now 9) has never used arm bands. He's had lessons since 6 weeks (mainly for water safety and confidence). It really worries me seeing young children in the pool with arm bands/inflatables on as if they fall in a pond/river etc they won't have a clue how to survive. At least in a pool with parents and lifeguards they are supervised and can be taught to swim properly and learn to star-float if they get into trouble.

PatchworkElmer · 21/01/2023 05:52

My DC has never worn armbands, they’re definitely less popular now I think. When they couldn’t swim at all we’d use a pool noodle or support them in the water.

Copperoliverbear · 21/01/2023 05:50

Book swimming lessons now. X

Smileandtheworldsmileswithyou · 21/01/2023 05:46

We live abroad and have a swimming pool so our eldest daughter could swim at 3 with no jacket or arm bands. Both my girls have had swimming lessons from 6 weeks (with a gap because of Covid). If we were in England maybe she would g need to be swimming by now, but I think the sooner the better.

MiddleParking · 21/01/2023 05:32

By ‘swim properly’ do you just mean not wearing armbands? My kids have both had swimming lessons since they were a few weeks old and my 3 year old can swim about a breadth unaided but I wouldn’t call it ‘swimming properly’ to the point I would move away from her even for a second and I can’t imagine I would when she’s 4 either. So I don’t think there’s loads of difference between a 4 year old next to their mum who’s wearing armbands and one who isn’t. Absolutely nothing to feel bad about. You’d need to hold her (or have her hold the side) to some extent in a deep pool and in a shallow pool you can’t even take your eyes off them for a second because if they fall over a small child can’t right themselves.

Heartshappedsunglasses · 21/01/2023 05:14

Oh no- it’s funny how these things just creep up on us. I prioritised swimming with mine and took my 6yr old last night, haven’t seen him for a few weeks and wow! He is better than me (not hard) , the just turned 4 ur old is just about doing a few strokes unsupported but mostly uses the woggle or fin in his class.
BUT can either of them use a pedal bike…. No! They just run around on balance bikes screaming at us if we try.I’ve given up again.
it can be so easy to compare but I’m sure you are doing a great job but that parent guilt is a right killer.

StClare101 · 21/01/2023 01:08

We are in Australia and I think even here a four year old with a floatie vest thing wouldn’t be completely unusual. My kids were swimming unassisted by three but my nephew is over four and still has a floatie despite having a pool in his backyard! His older sister was swimming by three but he’s a very cautious type of kid.

CombatBarbie · 21/01/2023 00:43

Youngest dd was born and brought up til age 4 in Europe, she has swam since age 2 albeit underwater for first year or so. Very common to let go but be very near them from what I saw at the pools.

Oakbeam · 21/01/2023 00:34

We never used arm bands because they get in the way of learning to swim properly

Same. I was taught to swim in the mid 1960s. We used floats.

Swipe left for the next trending thread