Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Exams are now virtual signalling?

146 replies

WarOfTheWolds · 20/01/2023 20:34

Details changed to protect identity, but in summary:

DS had an exam today, He's at college. The exam mark will go towards his final grade. He was tasked with answering questions on several case studies. One of the subjects of a case study was a person called Sam. Sam had they/them pronouns and Sam's sex was unclear.
DS has ASC and dyslexia. He's bright, but can tend towards rigid thinking. He said that he just kept on getting confused by the case study, having to re-read it several times to understand it because of the plural pronouns (other people were also involved in the case study, so a lot of pronouns flying about). DS also ended up editing his answers several times to try and make sure he got the pronouns right and consistent.
It seems that adding these pronouns to an exam question, when it was unnecessary to the case study
(a) was virtual signalling of woke-ness by the examiner
(b) likely to confuse students with issues like ASC and dyslexia and
(c) therefore be discriminatory towards some students - both in terms of understanding, and the extra time taken to check and re-write answers.
DS gets extra time in his exams, and usually doesn't need it all. Today he only just finished in time.

So, AIBU - inclusive pronouns are great and including them in exams is important because it raises visibility
or
YANBU - these pronouns are confusing and including them in exams is unnecessary and unhelpful for students with learning difficulties

(With thanks to the posters on my first thread attempt who pointed out my logic fail on the poll 😂🙏 )

OP posts:
Gilead · 21/01/2023 00:55

How lovely for you all. I’m sure with such a range of autism in the family you are quite aware that not everyone presents the same way …….
Reading the thread before you replied would have given you the answer to that…

DdraigGoch · 20/01/2023 23:57

Boomboom22 · 20/01/2023 23:35

The marker won't care what pronouns he uses in the answer

The marks come from application if knowledge to the scenario not whether the person is they etc. You say gender/ sex is not linked so he or she or they wouldn't affect the quality of the answer

The marker won't know that the OP's son spent five minutes rereading the question and wondering if he had missed another element.

DdraigGoch · 20/01/2023 23:56

WineDup · 20/01/2023 23:23

What I mean is that if those phrases HAD been said, nobody would have been claiming that they “misgendered” someone. And I’m sure that in 20 years time, “they” will become interchangeable with using gendered terms.

The next generation are far more comfortable with it than our generation (and the older ones)

Never mind misgendered, I'd be wondering if you'd miscounted.

If you had said "they are on holiday", my next question would have been "who has he gone with?"

MrsMikeDrop · 20/01/2023 23:36

JustFrustrated · 20/01/2023 21:16

YANBU.

At all.

Clear and unambiguous language is important.

Everyone, in all languages, understands that "they/them" denotes either plural or mixed sex groups.

Pro-nouns aren't important. Exam results are.

I'm sorry your son struggled. I would advise writing to the exam board and school. It won't do anything. But the more that write.... We may get heard.

YANBU at all. I agree that exam questions should be clear and they can donate plural etc. I have no learning difficulties and usually got very high marks. Even this might potentially confuse me. It sounds really dumb and unnecessary. Sorry your son struggled. I'm normally one of those people who would say to suck it up, but you are not BU at all!!

Boomboom22 · 20/01/2023 23:35

The marker won't care what pronouns he uses in the answer

The marks come from application if knowledge to the scenario not whether the person is they etc. You say gender/ sex is not linked so he or she or they wouldn't affect the quality of the answer

Judgyjudgy · 20/01/2023 23:33

YANBU

Rainbowshit · 20/01/2023 23:28

YANBU

SausageInCider · 20/01/2023 23:28

There is absolutely no way this is a new concept to a young person. Absolutely none.

Pearsandclocks · 20/01/2023 23:27

Yanbu

WineDup · 20/01/2023 23:23

DdraigGoch · 20/01/2023 23:17

No one used "they" to refer to a singular, known person.

"She is at the shops"
"He is on holiday"

Obviously I don't know the sex of your dog because we've never met, but I certainly knew the sex of my cat so "she had a tin of food".

What I mean is that if those phrases HAD been said, nobody would have been claiming that they “misgendered” someone. And I’m sure that in 20 years time, “they” will become interchangeable with using gendered terms.

The next generation are far more comfortable with it than our generation (and the older ones)

mumarooni · 20/01/2023 23:20

I think it depends whether that co tent has been taught and how it is examined. I teach a humanities/social science and we expect students to engage in case studies that include people who have radically different ideas about sex and gender (from all around the world) and to handle those differences with respect, interest and careful critical engagement too. Generally the idea is to be interested in difference rather than resistant to it, but also to think about what these different ideas do within society and where they come from. But we teach all that first, it doesn't come from nowhere on an exam...

DdraigGoch · 20/01/2023 23:17

WineDup · 20/01/2023 22:48

“They” is appropriate for anyone, and 5 years ago nobody would have batted an eyelid at being referred to as “they”

examples:
where is mum?
They are at the shops.

have you heard from Tom?
no, they are on holiday.

have you fed the dog?
they had a tin of dog food.

No one used "they" to refer to a singular, known person.

"She is at the shops"
"He is on holiday"

Obviously I don't know the sex of your dog because we've never met, but I certainly knew the sex of my cat so "she had a tin of food".

DdraigGoch · 20/01/2023 23:12

KickHimInTheCrotch · 20/01/2023 21:52

Perhaps it hadn't been taught specifically in that subject this year but it's normal language these days. It's on every TV show, podcast, news programme. There's no excuse for not understanding the use of they/them. My 11 yo gets it.

I don't know a single person in real life who would be referred to as anything other than the pronouns customarily associated with their biological sex.

I have never seen anyone on a TV show addressed as "they/them", nor on the news. The only occasions that I ever hear "they" or "them" written down or spoken aloud is in the context of a group of people, or a single unnamed person.

I'm hardly old and out of touch, I'm in my twenties.

WineDup · 20/01/2023 23:04

Zosime · 20/01/2023 22:57

where is mum?
They are at the shops.

Why would anyone say 'they are' to refer to a mother, rather than 'she is'? The speaker knows she's female and that there's only one of her.

Until recently, the only time I ever heard 'they' used to refer to a singular person was when the person's sex was unknown. 'Is there going to be a new person in Accounts?' 'Yes, they're starting on Monday.'

It’s not a phrase I’d use personally, but I would also not care if someone else did. Language changes over time, and I think this will become more normalised over time (similar to how we no longer use ableist, racist, or homophobic language)

Zosime · 20/01/2023 22:57

where is mum?
They are at the shops.

Why would anyone say 'they are' to refer to a mother, rather than 'she is'? The speaker knows she's female and that there's only one of her.

Until recently, the only time I ever heard 'they' used to refer to a singular person was when the person's sex was unknown. 'Is there going to be a new person in Accounts?' 'Yes, they're starting on Monday.'

FrangipaniBlue · 20/01/2023 22:56

*“They” is appropriate for anyone, and 5 years ago nobody would have batted an eyelid at being referred to as “they”

examples:
where is mum?
They are at the shops.

have you heard from Tom?
no, they are on holiday.

have you fed the dog?
they had a tin of dog food.*

At least one of those (possibly two) is grammatically incorrect so yes, lots of people would have batted an eyelid.

FrangipaniBlue · 20/01/2023 22:52

The OP quite clearly refers to her DS as he/him - these are obviously HIS chosen pronouns, why not use them?

Or does using a persons chosen pronouns so as not offend them, only work one way?

WineDup · 20/01/2023 22:48

FrangipaniBlue · 20/01/2023 22:43

The irony of berating the OP for grumbling and pointing out that people are entitled to chose their own pronouns, then going on to use incorrect pronouns for the OPs son.

A little deliberate perhaps?

“They” is appropriate for anyone, and 5 years ago nobody would have batted an eyelid at being referred to as “they”

examples:
where is mum?
They are at the shops.

have you heard from Tom?
no, they are on holiday.

have you fed the dog?
they had a tin of dog food.

FrangipaniBlue · 20/01/2023 22:43

KickHimInTheCrotch · 20/01/2023 21:25

YABU
It's "virtue" signalling not virtual.
No need to use the word "woke" in quite such a dismissive way.

People are entitled to use whatever pronouns they chose and this is now part of life. It's not going away. We can grumble on here about it being woke and "confusing" but our young people do need to get used to it and using these terms. Expect to see a lot more exams with gender neutral names and pronouns. It's a shame it was difficult for your DC but they will find they need to get their head around it sooner or later.

The irony of berating the OP for grumbling and pointing out that people are entitled to chose their own pronouns, then going on to use incorrect pronouns for the OPs son.

A little deliberate perhaps?

titchy · 20/01/2023 22:23

RampantIvy · 20/01/2023 21:56

It's a pity that a new pronoun can't be invented to describe a gender neutral person. As a grammar pedant, to me "they" is plural to describe more than one person.

As an aside how do they deal with this in countries that use masculine and feminine articles? In France for example? Did you know that Franch for vagina is masculine?

Zee and zeir are sometimes used.

IcakethereforeIam · 20/01/2023 22:20

New pronoun for nonbinary people? Meme. It's a word the young folk will already be familiar with. Encapsulates being both male, me, and female, me, as an harmonious hole, meme.

YANBU

NoBoatsOnSunday · 20/01/2023 22:17

It’s not as if using ‘they’ or ‘them’ to apply to an individual person is a new concept, it’s always been a feature of the English language.

People going exclusively by genderless pronouns seems to be a recent phenomenon.

Perhaps it was a poorly-phrased question in other respects but it’s hard to see the issue otherwise.

RampantIvy · 20/01/2023 21:56

It's a pity that a new pronoun can't be invented to describe a gender neutral person. As a grammar pedant, to me "they" is plural to describe more than one person.

As an aside how do they deal with this in countries that use masculine and feminine articles? In France for example? Did you know that Franch for vagina is masculine?

WarOfTheWolds · 20/01/2023 21:52

titchy · 20/01/2023 21:47

However, such case studies will have been taught and the language used will have been used and discussed in lessons before the exam. If this is not the case then op may just be able to cobble together a case for complaint.

That's a really big assumption there. Do you know OP and the college her dc goes to and all his tutors? And which exam it was? And what the question was?

No. Didn't think so.

I agree with inclusion. Wholeheartedly. I agree with having names in exams being as multicultural as possible. I agree that kids and young people must see people like them represented. But I do not agree that has to come at the expense of another group of young people, and to be honest it's pretty easy to make sure that those that have 'they' pronouns see themselves in exam paper questions and that ND people have an accessible paper.

People with your eloquence and clarity should be setting the exam papers @titchy!

OP posts:
WineDup · 20/01/2023 21:52

WarOfTheWolds · 20/01/2023 21:45

It crossed my mind, but no. Definitely not. The sex of the person was not relevant. The subject isn't sociology btw, it was just a ballpark topic area I gave for context.

How do you know though? Have you seen the marking scheme? It could be relevant outside sociology.

Swipe left for the next trending thread