Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think school uniform has had its day

269 replies

Grumpybutfunny · 20/01/2023 20:33

Okay I'm northern like this poor kid, tho not that close to the Scottish border. Is it unreasonable to say, when schools start saying kids should wear an inappropriate coats, just because it is school uniform that its time for parents to fight back.

I've left for work at 7:30 and it has been minus 2-3 all week. When I'm scraping ice off the car, a kid shouldn't be walking to school in a summer fleece with a rain jacket over the top. I've been freezing in my duvet coat.

Uniforms were a great leveller, but in the age of social media they still see what kids are wearing outside of school or what car the parent does the school run in. Surely what's more important is that they are comfortable and warm.

www.chroniclelive.co.uk/news/north-east-news/jesmond-park-academys-uniform-policy-26016890

OP posts:
Teatime55 · 21/01/2023 11:46

I am a fan of uniform. In primary on non uniform days the clothes were frankly ridiculous, turning up in cycling shorts and crop tops in snow.

DD won’t wear a coat as there are no lockers anymore. The idea of carrying it puts her off. Hers is slightly flexible - but I hate blazers, they are ridiculous.

I have worked for a school trust that had that strict policy (including checking socks but I hear that’s been relaxed). I can see the benefit. Children would turn up in dirty/torn clothes and someone would just swop them without much of a fuss. Lots of the students/parents would have made non uniform an issue for sure.

leithreas · 21/01/2023 11:43

I'm in Ireland and my kids school uniform(secondary) is really relaxed. Trousers(no girls wear skirts even though you can, everyone wears trousers), polo shirt or shirt, jumper. Black trainers with no obvious branding and black or navy coat again no obvious branding, every kid pretty much without exception wears a black puffer jacket. Hair how you like, whatever colour you like, piercings or make up of you like.
For me it's a nice balance. They can still express themselves to a certain degree while being comfortable. They aren't all brand crazy though so don't really care what trainers or jacket they have.

FawnFrenchieMum · 21/01/2023 11:34

PuttingDownRoots · 20/01/2023 21:05

The Scout uniform is a thin shirt. Its not actually practical...

I agree that school uniform could be made more practical though. Warm jumpers (or hoodies/fleeces) rather than blazers and shirts for example.

Yes that’s what I meant. I’m not that close to scouts etc, but I meant like T-shirts, fleeces, cargo type trousers. Comfy and practical.

Cracklingfire1 · 21/01/2023 11:32

@EndersGame you do know it's not the teachers who make up uniform rules and fines for taking time off, right?

And ....Teachers are striking about conditions which will make life better for YOUR children.

Catswhisky · 21/01/2023 11:22

Our secondary school has strict uniform rules, blazer, skirt and pe kit all has to have the logo. I think someone priced the full uniform at £185 recently. This is in an average northern town with mixed incomes.

Having read the thread yesterday about the man dressing in girls school uniforms and hanging around outside schools I do think it’s time to change. As well as for the students comfort. A logo jumper and choice of joggers or smarter trousers would still be a school identifying uniform but would be both comfortable and difficult to sexualise by adults.

And sensible shoes or boots. No ballet flats in winter.

WishIwasElsa · 21/01/2023 11:21

Some schools need to take a long look at these policies they are enforcing. Teachers wearing warm coats taking a warm coat off a pupil who has been unwell enough to be hospitalised. Putting a child who is having chemo in isolation for having a shaved head - absolutely disgusting.

Wedonttalkaboutboris · 21/01/2023 11:17

I worked at JPA on supply a long, long time ago- back when it was called Heaton Manor. Ignore the pp saying it’s a wanky school. They’ve done a fantastic job of going from ‘inadequate’ to ‘good’ in a very short space of time. It was an extremely challenging school and I’m really pleased to see the turnaround they’ve achieved.

I think the strict uniform policy was probably a part of this. Anyone who’s worked in an inadequate school will know the lengths it can take to establish student (and parent!) compliance in order to then go onto revalue academic expectations. It’s definitely an accumulation of behaviours and the smallest things do matter. I remember one headteacher who used to quote- ‘you give them an inch and they’ll take a mile’. Now they’ve brought the kids into line and established a strong ethos, perhaps they’ll be able to relax it a little? I do strongly agree that a thin fleece and raincoat is nowhere near enough for the weather up here!

OoooohMatron · 21/01/2023 11:07

QuestionableMouse · 21/01/2023 11:04

I didn't, most because the tie was a sensory nightmare for me. I'm convinced I'd have done better in my exams if I'd been allowed to take them wearing clothing that I was comfortable in, not a horrible itchy wool skirt, shirt and tie.

I've already said I think ties and blazers are outdated. I still agree with a more relaxed uniform though.

QuestionableMouse · 21/01/2023 11:04

OoooohMatron · 21/01/2023 10:29

But kids who wear uniform also function perfectly well in school. Maybe in other countries kids are not as bothered about brand names etc I don't know. I remember at my non uniform primary school over 30 years ago getting the piss taken out of me for my crap trainers.

I didn't, most because the tie was a sensory nightmare for me. I'm convinced I'd have done better in my exams if I'd been allowed to take them wearing clothing that I was comfortable in, not a horrible itchy wool skirt, shirt and tie.

QuestionableMouse · 21/01/2023 11:01

HelpIcantfindaname · 20/01/2023 21:31

I think uniform has a place but it shouldn't extend to coats.
If a child needs a uniform coat for school, they also need a normal one for use outside of school... not everyone can afford 2 coats.
My kids are also at a school in the cold North East. Their coats don't have to have a school logo, but must be black. Their coats are not allowed to be seen in school - they must be removed before pupils enter the building & cannot be carried around school, coats must be put in a bag. With the amount of books they have to carry their coats don't fit in their bags. There is no jumper in their uniform, so the kids spend the day in a shirt & blazer, outside & inside, in winter & summer! It's ridiculous.

I genuinely don't know what the schools are thinking saying kids have to wear black coats when it's often dark at 3pm! It's so stupid. The entire thing is stupid.

I grew up in a village and had two miles to walk to the bus stop, part way along a rough farm track. I spent so much time in trouble for wearing boots (especially in the winter) rather than the stupid flimsy ballet flats the school wanted the girls to wear. No amount of explaining that I couldn't physically get to school in said flats made any difference - the school suggested I could wear boots to the bus then change (and carry muddy boots around in my school bag, with my books, packed lunch, pe kit and everything else I needed.)

No wonder so many kids hate school! Let them wear comfortable, practical clothes.

SoupAndSodaBread · 21/01/2023 11:00

No uniform*

SoupAndSodaBread · 21/01/2023 11:00

neverbeenskiing · 21/01/2023 10:12

We use PP money for things like counselling, breakfast clubs, activities, resources and equipment for PP students. We can't use it to buy "a good supply of everyday clothes" and shoes for every kid that needs them!

Wtf? I was responding to someone who said the school has purchased the child's uniform...which is a good supply of clothing. The only difference is that it can only be worn on school days, which wouldn't be the case if there was no money.

I used to process all the PP payments, so I know it is spent on counselling, breakfast, activities...and clothing

OoooohMatron · 21/01/2023 10:46

Patineur · 21/01/2023 10:34

They don't necessarily function perfectly well. Every year there are horror stories of idiotic schools that won't allow children to take off their blazers without permission even during heatwaves, and teachers wasting bloody hours checking on whether children are wearing the right shoes and socks. If children want to take the piss out of each other, they will do it just as much because they are wearing clothes they have grown out of or are worn out.

I agree uniform should be more relaxed. My sons primary is trousers/shorts, polo shirt and a sweatshirt which is practical and cheap to buy. DDs secondary is very strict on blazers, ties etc and I do think a polo shirt/sweatshirt would be better.

Plaidparty · 21/01/2023 10:46

CecilyP · 21/01/2023 08:21

Well that’s the problem with uniforms! You literally can’t please everyone. Though some aspects of uniforms please no one.

Yeah but I’d rather my kid looked smart and it pleased no one than they looked like they were in a jogging suit 5 days a week. it always looks so scruffy.

My daughter loves her uniform so the generalisation that no one likes aspects of it is widely overstated.

TheMoth · 21/01/2023 10:44

Whilst uniform does mitigate the obvious differences, there are a million ways of getting it 'wrong' as a teen, in the eyes of the kids who will judge you.
Wrong way of doing your hair.
Wrong style of shoes.
Wrong bag.
Wrong trainers for PE. I'm still haunted by that one. No mum, Nicks are not the same as Nike and yes, I was crucified for wearing them.

Bunnycat101 · 21/01/2023 10:43

I think business wear 6th form has always been ridiculous. The majority of those kids will go to university and slob around for 3 years. I honestly have never got the point.

Blazers are largely impractical especially when you have teachers making sweaty, smelly kids wear them in 30 degree heat.

I quite like our primary uniform but again think the lives of reception teachers would probably be much easier if they were sent in with clothes that didn’t have fiddly buttons etc. I have noticed a lot of the private schools near me seem to have tracksuits on the uniform for younger kids. They also have the super smart blazer but actually seem to be in the tracksuit more often than not. My children seem to manage fine in their own clothes at summer camps so not sure why it would be any different during the rest of the year.

CecilyP · 21/01/2023 10:35

Patineur · 21/01/2023 09:24

The government could do more to enforce it by, for example, making it part of Ofsted criteria. Academy chains would probably get much less keen on expensive uniform if it results in them getting a Requires Improvement grading.

Also it would be possible for a group of parents to take judicial review action, with parents entitled to legal aid fronting the claim. That could be interesting.

That would be interesting about a group of parents! I can’t see ofsted taking it on or giving requires improvement if other aspects of the school are good.

Patineur · 21/01/2023 10:34

OoooohMatron · 21/01/2023 10:29

But kids who wear uniform also function perfectly well in school. Maybe in other countries kids are not as bothered about brand names etc I don't know. I remember at my non uniform primary school over 30 years ago getting the piss taken out of me for my crap trainers.

They don't necessarily function perfectly well. Every year there are horror stories of idiotic schools that won't allow children to take off their blazers without permission even during heatwaves, and teachers wasting bloody hours checking on whether children are wearing the right shoes and socks. If children want to take the piss out of each other, they will do it just as much because they are wearing clothes they have grown out of or are worn out.

OoooohMatron · 21/01/2023 10:29

Patineur · 21/01/2023 10:23

What happens in other countries is entirely relevant to this topic. People always put forward arguments like this which demonstrably don't work when you look at countries with little or no school uniform where the children function perfectly well despite having to decide what to wear every day. If your argument doesn't stand up against that sort of comparison, it's time to acknowledge that it's a weak argument, not to moan about the comparison.

But kids who wear uniform also function perfectly well in school. Maybe in other countries kids are not as bothered about brand names etc I don't know. I remember at my non uniform primary school over 30 years ago getting the piss taken out of me for my crap trainers.

olivehater · 21/01/2023 10:28

School uniform is great. Mine wear mostly supermarket stuff apart from logo jumpers/ cardigans.
my 9 year old will only wear Nike at the weekends. Wouldn’t want to have to kit him out 7 days a week in it.

But do agree about the coat. Most schools don’t count the coat in their uniform policy. Sounds like a particularly wanky school.

Patineur · 21/01/2023 10:27

BlackFriday · 21/01/2023 10:18

I'd have more sympathy for that father in the article if the coat in question hadn't been electric blue, a opposed to the regulation black. And although I read it a few days ago, I seem to recall him talking about expense. Yet he'd bought his son a North Face jacket? They don't come cheap.
Loved the "sad face" picture!
Also, all the people beating their chests about poor freezing kids - we have to literally force ours to put on coats for break times and even then they take them off the minute they get out of our sight. Lots choose to wear shorts even in snow.
This has little to do with kids feeling the cold and more another way to have a go at schools - as evidenced by that ill-informed poster banging on about fines and strikes.

The point is, though, that the kid would presumably need a home coat anyway as the school coat is so useless and anyway, no kid would wear a school uniform coat when they don't have to.

As commented upthread, for safety reasons it makes much more sense for children to have light or brightly-coloured coats anyway.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 21/01/2023 10:26

I don’t think it’s uniforms as such, it’s what they are.

Why primary children can’t all be in tracksuit bottoms and a sweatshirt type jumper is beyond me

Patineur · 21/01/2023 10:25

OoooohMatron · 21/01/2023 10:16

On school holidays she's not with1000 other kids, potentially being judged so no 🙄

With no uniform, the kids don't judge each other, because the novelty factor isn't there. As people have said, they usually just settle into wearing whatever is comfortable, frequently just a mixture of jeans and sweatshirts.

Patineur · 21/01/2023 10:23

OoooohMatron · 21/01/2023 10:12

I think she's pretty typical to be honest. School uniform is a leveller, it takes away any doubt, it's just easier all round. Who cares what other countries do, why on these threads do we always look at other countries? I do think uniform should be more practical though, blazers and ties are outdated.

What happens in other countries is entirely relevant to this topic. People always put forward arguments like this which demonstrably don't work when you look at countries with little or no school uniform where the children function perfectly well despite having to decide what to wear every day. If your argument doesn't stand up against that sort of comparison, it's time to acknowledge that it's a weak argument, not to moan about the comparison.

BlackFriday · 21/01/2023 10:18

I'd have more sympathy for that father in the article if the coat in question hadn't been electric blue, a opposed to the regulation black. And although I read it a few days ago, I seem to recall him talking about expense. Yet he'd bought his son a North Face jacket? They don't come cheap.
Loved the "sad face" picture!
Also, all the people beating their chests about poor freezing kids - we have to literally force ours to put on coats for break times and even then they take them off the minute they get out of our sight. Lots choose to wear shorts even in snow.
This has little to do with kids feeling the cold and more another way to have a go at schools - as evidenced by that ill-informed poster banging on about fines and strikes.

Swipe left for the next trending thread